High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1078/2004disposed of

Bimla And ORS v. Prem Singh An Dors

2015-08-12Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg14 pages

!" #"$%&%' ( %)* '#+& ,,"** '!& -"+&.& +")/%'01 '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

/)!/ ) 2 .+ ,,"** '! -"+&.& +")/%'01 '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

&1 '% '#!1"+& ,,"** '!& -"+&.& +")/%'01 '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

&1 '% '#!1"+&

,,"** '!& -"+&.& 03%+/1 +) '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /)!%)3 '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.&

5 !% '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /)!&1'% '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /' 2 ,+ '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& 2+%&1' "-% '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& 1*2 .+ '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /)!%)* '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /)!/ '!&1"-% '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& + 1) "-% '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /.) ' '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& 11 4. ) '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

( 1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& /.+"&12.) + '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!& +"&"'!7 +/1 +) 8#-$ !" + +9&1 5"*8#-$ !" +!1" ,,"** '!& +""!./%'018#-$ !" ++"&,'#"'! +2 1* : !8#-$ !" + 4 &!1 ' #: 5&

1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+ ,,"** '!& -"+&.& / ) 2 .+ '#!1"+& "&,'#"'!&

! "# ! ;1"!1"+",+!"+& <$ *":&, ,"+&) 53" **:"#! &""!1"4.#0)"'!=

3"+"

"++"#!!1"",+!"+&+'!= 6;1"!1"+!1"4.#0)"'!&1.*#3"+",+!"#%'!1"%0"&!= +"&"'!7 +/1"+ '8#-$ !" +!1" ,,"** '!&

&%),*"/1%2 #5 '8#-$ !" +!1" ,,"** '!

&%'

66 +/1 +) 8#-$ !" + +9&1 5"*8#-$ !" +!1" ,,"** '!& 6 +""!./%'018#-$ !" ++"&,'#"'!& '#> +2 1* : !8#-$ !" + 4 &!1 ' #: 5& + ,,"** '!&%'? !?? '# ++"&,'#"'!@ 4 &!1 ' #: 5&%'+") %'%'0 ,," *& "# !$

A%#"!1%&4.#0)"'!8%'!"'#!#%&,&" ? ! ?? ,+"

"++"#35 4 &!1 ' 4, !1%0 ) '#

'# 6 '#66 #%+"$!"#35$* %) '!& + "'1 '$")"'! $),"'& !%' 0 %'&!!1": +## !"# > 6, &&"# 35 &""' 1 .#1 +58 !+$$%#"'!* %)&+%3.' *81%: '%

1" $!& +"3"%'0! 9"' +)

!%& **"0"# !1 ! ' >>> '.) ' +&1 # : & #+%-%'0 4"", 3" +%'0 +"0%&!+ !%'@ @

1 -%'0) '5!1"+,"+&'&&%!!%'0%'!1"4"", '#: &0%'0 +)1%: '%!: +#&.%8%"!: +#&<1 +.8:1"'!1" 4"",+" $1"#'" +.+0 !!'%* %**& ! #%&! '$" ! 3.!9) : 5

+)!+.$9.'%'81%: '%!: +#&<1 +.8 3.& 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) %'&1+!

"'#%'03.&3"%'0#+%-"'35+"&,'#"'! +")/%'01+ &1*5 '#'"0*%0"'!*5 '# ! 1%01&,""#$ )" +)!1"&%#"

<1 +. '#1%!!1"4"",$ .&%'0&"+%.&%'4.+%"&!!1"$$., '!&1"+" !"+ 1%! ! 3" +%'0+"0%&!+ !%'?B ?8:1%$1: & **:%'0!1"

& %#4"",1"& %#4"",: & ! )#"+ !"&,""# '#!1"3.&$ )"'!1" :+'0&%#" '#1%!!1"4"",3" +%'0+"0%&!+ !%' @

8 & +"&.*!

:1%$1&%C$$., '!& !1"4"",#%"# !!1"&,!#."!%'4.+%"&&! )+!") "C )%' !%' ' !1" #" # 3#%"& :"+" #'" ?

: & +"$+#"# 0 %'&!+"&,'#"'!.'#"+/"$!%'& >866 '#6 @ !1"

'.) ' +&1 #: & 0"#

5" +&'!1"# !" $$%#"'! '#: & " +'%'0& B@,"+)'!1%"& B@ && * +5 &#+%-"+ '#&6 B@ 35 #%'0 !1" 0+%$.*!.+" :+9 1"+"

+"8 $* %) ,"!%!%' + 0+ '!

$),"'& !%' & 8 8 B@1 &3""' %*"#

/%)%* +*581*2 .+ 0"#( 5" +&$* %)"#&8 8 B@ & $),"'& !%'+"0 +#%'0%'4.+%"&&.

"+"#351"+ %3%+/1 +) 8%'4.+"# $* %)"# $),"'& !%' & 8 8 B@/.+"&12.) +$* %) '!$* %)"# &8( 8 B@ :%!1 +"0 +# ! # ) 0" ! 1%& 4"", 3" +%'0 +"0%&!+ !%' @

5 , !% '#!1"+&1 -"$* %)"#$),"'& !%'!!1" !.'" & 8 8 B@:%!1+"0 +#!#" !1 1"+1.&3 '# '%*2.) + 0"# 5" +&%'!1" $$%#"'!8:1: &" +'%'0&? B@,)/)!/ ) 2 .+:%#: '0 1 + %*"#$* %),"!%!%'#."!#" !1 1"+1.&3 '# '0 1 +$* %)%'0$),"'& !%'!!1"!.'" &(8 8 B@ &1": & " +'%'0& 8 B@,"+)'!1/ '!&1 "!$1 # %*"# $* %),"!%!%'

$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &( 8 8 B@#."!!1"#" !1 1"+1.&3 '# / 00 + *%'!1" $$%#"'!%'D."&!%' '# !!1 !!%)"1": &! 9%'0& * +5 &8 @ 8 B@,"+)'!1%) * '#!1"+&1 # %*"#$* %),"!%!%'

$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' & 8 8 B@#."!!1"#" !1 1"+1.&3 '# -%2.) + 0"#6 5" +&+ 1) "-%"!$1 # %*"# $* %),"!%!%'

$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &(8 8 B@#."!!1"#" !1 1"+1.&3 '# )%: &:1: & 0"#

5" +& !!1 !!%)"/ ) 2 .+1 # %*"#$* %) ,"!%!%'$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &(8 8 B@#."!!1"%'4.+%"&&.

"+"# 351"+%'!1" $$%#"'!%'D."&!%' /.) '1 # %*"# $* %),"!%!%'

$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &(8 8 B@#."!!1"%'4.+%"&&.

"+"#35 1"+%'!1" $$%#"'!%'D."&!%'/)!2+%&1 ' "-%1 # %*"# $* %) ,"!%!%'$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &6 8 8 B@#."!!1"#" !1 1"+ 1.&3 '# .9"&1 0"# 3.! 5" +&%)31 # %*"# $* %),"!%!%'

$* %)%'0$),"'& !%' &68 8 B@#."!!1"%'4.+%"&&.

"+"#351"+

%'!1" $$%#"'!%'D."&!%' 6 1" +"&,'#"'!& ,,&"# ** !1" 3-" )"'!%'"# $* %) ,"!%!%'&35: 5 &", + !":+%!!"'&! !")"'!& "&,'#"'!'&.+ '$" ), '5 *&,,&"#!1"$* %),"!%!%'& ",*%$ !%'&!!1":+%!!"'&! !")"'!&:"+" %*"#+)!1"

,*" #%'0& !1", +!%"&8 **:%'0%&&."&:"+" + )"#7@ ;1"!1"+ $$%#"'!!9,* $"' >>>: &3"$ .&"

+ &1 '#'"0*%0"'!#+%-%'0 +"&,'#"'!:1%*" #+%-%'03.&@ @B &%!&"

"$!=

;1"!1"+!1","!%!%'"+& +""'!%!*"#!+"$"%-" '5 $),"'& !%'8% &1:).$1 '# +):1)= 6 ;1"!1"+!1","!%!%'%&'!) %'! %' 3*"%'!1" ,+"&"'! +)= ;1"!1"+!1"-"1%$*"&%'-*-"#%'!1" $$%#"'! :"+"3"%'0#+%-"':%!1.!- *%# '#"

"$!%-" #+%-%'0*%$"'$"&8% &%!&"

"$!= ( "*%"

? 1", +!%"&1 -"*"#!1"%++"&,"$!%-""-%#"'$"'!1" +"& %# %&&."&1"+%3.' * !"+ ,,+ %& * !1""-%#"'$"8 : +#"#!1" ).'!

$),"'& !%'&!!1"+"&,"$!%-"$* %) '!&

""*%'0#%&& !%& %"#:%!1!1"%),.0'"#: +#8?

! ?? 1 -" 3""' ,+"

"++"# 35 4 &!1 ' 4, !1 %0 ) '#

'# 6 '#66 #%+"$!"#35$* %) '!& +"'1 '$")"'! $),"'& !%'

1 -"1" +#*" +'"#$.'&"* +!1", +!%"& '#1 -"0'"

!1+.01!1"+"$+#& !1"$ &":%!1!1"%+ 3*" &&%&! '$" %

> > 1" ,,"** '!&1 &$1 **"'0"#!1": +#'!1" **:%'0!: 0+.'#&7@

1 !#"$" &"#B%'4.+"#:"+"!+ -"**%'0%'"", @ @

1" $$%#"'!1 &! 9"',* $":%!1 !1"& %#"", '#.& 4 &!1 ' #: 5&3" +%'0 +"0%&!+ !%'@ @@ 3"%'0#+%-"'35 +"&,'#"'!+")/%'01=

"0 +#%'0E. '!.) $),"'& !%' !%&&.3)%!!"#!1 ! $$+#%'0!!1"$ &" !1"$* %) '!&3.& 3" +%'0+"0%&!+ !%'@ @@ 1"+"%'

!"+)"'!%'"# &

"'#%'0 3.&1%!4"", '#!1"+"

!"+1%! 3" +%'0+"0%&!+ !%'@?@

1"+"%'

!"++"

"++"# &@ !%&&.3)%!!"#!1 !%!%& $ &"

$'!+%3.!+5'"0*%0"'$"%':1%$1!1"#+%-"+ 4"", '##+%-"+

1 -"$'!+%3.!"#!!1" $$%#"'! '# &&.$1:1*" !1"*% 3%*%!5$ ''!3"

&!"'"# 0 %'&!!1":'"+ '##+%-"+

"'#%'03.& 1 -"$ +"

.**5$'&%#"+"#!1"& %#&.3)%&&%'3.!#'! %'# '5 +$"%'!1 !&.3)%&&%' &,"+ %'#%'035!1"*" +'"#+%3.' * '#"-%#"'$"'!1" +"$+#8!1" $$%#"'!1 &! 9"',* $"#."!+ &1 '#'"0*%0"'!#+%-%'0

"'#%'03.&1"#+%-"+ 4"", '##+%-"+ +"'! ! .*!

'# & &.$1 !1" +0.)"'!& #- '$"# 35 !1" *" +'"# $.'&"* + !1"

,,"** '!&@1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+$ ''! 3" $$",!"# 6 1"&"$'#,%'!! 9"'35!1"$.'&"* +!1" ,,"** '!&%& +"0 +#%'0D. '!.) $),"'& !%':"-"+8 +)!1","+.& * !1" %*"8 %!%&+"-" *"#!1 !!1" ).'! $),"'& !%'$ ''!3"& %#!3"'

1%01"+&%#"+)!1""-%#"'$"'!1" %*"8%!%&+"-" *"#!1 !%!%&'!1"

*:"+&%#"'''" !1"$ &"&8 ).'!+"0 +#%'0 .!.+",+&,"$!.&8*&& $'&+!%.)8*&& *-" '#

"$!%'"!$1 &3""'! 9"'%'! $$.'! 1"%'$)" !1"#"$" &"#1 & *&'!3""'! 9"''1%01"+&%#" !1"+,%'!1 &3""'.+0"#3"

+")"35!1"$.'&"* +!1"

,,"** '!&@1" 4 &!1 ' 45 !1 +%- 1 '%0 ) '# '!1"+/8%' !1"&"$%+$.)&! '$"&8!1" ,," *&? !?? +":%!1.! '5 )"+%! '#!1"& )"&! '##%&)%&&"# &&'()

( 1%& ,," *1 &3""'#%+"$!"#35:%#: '#)%'+# .01!"+ '# &' #"$" &"# ) 2.) + + "'1 '$")"'! $),"'& !%' "$" &"# )2.) +: & 0"#6 5" +&1"$* %) '!&1 # **"0"#1%& %'$)" && 8 B@,"+)'!1%"& B@ && * +535:+9%'0 & #+%-"+ '#&? B@,"+)'!1 +) 0+%$.*!.+")" '&1"+%3.' *1 & ! 9"'!1"%'$)" #"$" &"# && B@,"+)'!1B6+# ).'!1 &3""'

#"#.$!"#%'+"&,"$! ,"+&' *"C,"'&"& '#).*!%,*%"+ 1 &3""'

,,*%"# ? / + &!1"%'$)" !1"#"$" &"# && B@,"+ ''.)8 ! 9"'35!1"+%3.' *%'!1"5" +>>>%&$'$"+'"#8%')5-%":!1 !#"& '!$ ** + '5%'!"+ "+"'$"( F ).'!1 &!3" ##"#%'+"&,"$!

.!.+",+&,"$!.& /8%'!1%&) ''"+8 !1"%'$)" !1"#"$" &"# !"+ ##%'0( F%'+"&,"$! .!.+",+&,"$!.&$)"&!& B@,"+)'!1 1"+" +"!1+""$* %) '!& '# &&.$1!1"#","'#"'$51 &!3"$ *$.* !"# 35#"#.$!%'0B6+#%'+"&,"$! ,"+&' *"C,"'&"&/835#"#.$!%'0B6+#%'

+"&,"$! ,"+&' *"C,"'&"&8!1")'!1*5#","'#"'$5$)"&!& B@ 1" 5" +*5 #","'#"'$5 $)"& ! & 8? B@ 2"",%'0 %' -%": !1"

.!1+%!5*%(+)(,'+*((-.%/'+0102')/3 +(-0&+%+&+(%3- (-.-+

454313)5$!1").*!%,*%"+ ,,*%$ 3*" !!1" 0"

6 %& /835 ,,*5%'0!1 !).*!%,*%"+8!1" ).'! $),"'& !%'

$)"&!&68?

8 B@&.) & 8 B@&! '#& **:"#%'+"&,"$!

"C,"'&"&'* &!+%!"& '#!+ '&,+! !%''!1"+&.) & (8 B@&! '#& **:"#' $$.'! $'&+!%.) '# &.) & (8 B@&! '#& **:"# ' $$.'! *&& *-" '#

"$!%'!!1")%'+&/8%'!1%&) ''"+8 !1" $* %) '!& +" 1"*# "'!%!*"# ! $* %) &8 8 B@ 1" "'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **$ ++5%'!"+"&!G (F, +)!1"# !" $* %),"!%!%'!%** , 5)"'!1"*% 3%*%!5!, 5!1" "'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **3"!1"& )" & +#"+"#35!1"+%3.' *:)%'+&).&!1 -"3"$)") 4+&8&.!

!1""'1 '$"# ).'!8( F ).'!&1 **3", %#!!1":%#: '#!1" +") %'%'0 ).'!&1 **3"&1 +"#35!1"+") %'%'0$* %) '!&%'"D. * &1 +"& 1" ,," *&! '#&#%&,&"# $$+#%'0*5 &&'()

1%& ,," * 1 & 3""' #%+"$!"# 35 :%#: '# !: )%'+ $1%*#+"' #"$" &"# '.) ' +&1 # +"'1 '$")"'! $),"'& !%' "$" &"# '.) ' +&1 #: & 0"#

5" +& !!1"!%)" $$%#"'!%& %'$)": & **"0"#!3"& 8 B@,"+)'!13.!!1"+%3.' *1 &! 9"'

1%&%'$)" &&( B@,"+)'!1B6+# ).'!1 &3""'#"#.$!"# %' +"&,"$! ,"+&' *"C,"'&"& '#).*!%,*%"+ : & ,,*%"#:"-"+8

!1" +%3.' * 1 & '! ! 9"' %'! $$.'! !1" !1"+ $!+& *%9" .'"+ * "C,"'&"&8*&& $'&+!%.)8*&& *-" '#

"$!%'"!$/8!1" ).'!

$),"'& !%'+"D.%+"&!3"+"@$ *$.* !"# > 1" %'$)" !1"#"$" &"# &#+%-"+1 #3""'! 9"' & &( B@,"+)'!1%'!1"5" +>>> &1": &

5" +& 0" !!1 !!%)" /8( F ).'!1 &!3" ##"#%'+"&,"$! .!.+",+&,"$!.&1.&8!1"

%'$)" !1"#"$" &"#%&! 9"' &&

( B@,"+)'!1 !"+ ##%'0( F%'

+"&,"$! .!.+",+&,"$!.&B6+# ).'!1 &!3"#"#.$!"#%'+"&,"$! 1%& ,"+&' *"C,"'&"& &1"1 #!1+""!1"+ )%*5)")3"+&1"#","'#"'$5 $)"& ! &( B@,"+ )'!1 1" 5" +*5 #","'#"'$5 $)"& ! & 8 B@/9"",%'0%' -%":!1" .!1+%!5 *%(+)(,'+*( (-. %/'+0102')/3 +(-0&+%+&+(%3-(-.-+

454313)5 $ !1").*!%,*%"+ ,,*%$ 3*" !!1" 0"

%& /8 ,,*5%'0!1 !

).*!%,*%"+8!1" ).'! $),"'& !%'$)"&!&68 8 B@&.)

& 8 B@ &! '#& **:"# %' +"&,"$! "C,"'&"& ' * &! +%!"& '# !+ '&,+! !%''!1"+&.) & (8 B@&! '#& **:"#' $$.'!

$'&+!%.) '# '!1"+&.) & (8 B@&! '#& **:"#' $$.'!

*&& *-" '#

"$!%'!!1")%'+&/8%'!1%&) ''"+8!1"$* %) '!& +"1"*#"'!%!*"#!$* %)&68 8 B@1""'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **$ ++5 %'!"+"&!G (F, +) !1"# !" $* %),"!%!%'!%**, 5)"'!1"

*% 3%*%!5!, 5!1""'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **3"!1"& )" &+#"+"#35!1" +%3.' *:)%'+&1 -"3"$)") 4+8&.! !1""'1 '$"# ).'!

( F ).'!&1 **3", %#!!1":%#: '#!1"+") %'%'0 ).'!&1 **3" &1 +"#35!1"+") %'%'0$* %) '!&%'"D. *&1 +"&

1" ,," *&! '#&#%&,&"# $$+#%'0*5 &&'()

;%#:%&!1"$* %) '!%'!1%&$ &" '0 1 +#"$" &"#: & ( 5" +& 0" !!1"!%)" $$%#"'! '# &&.$1 &.) &8( 8 B@ : & **:"#!!1"$* %) '!1"$* %) '!1 & **"0"#!1 !1": &" +'%'0 & 8 B@,"+)'!13.!1%&%'$)"1 &3""'! 9"' &&( B@,"+ )'!1 2"",%'0%'-%": .!1+%!5 (6'0/(-.%/'+010(673+3-8/ (-.%/'+0+'&+%'.3-

454313)5&(8' $(F ).'!1 & !3" ##"#%'+"&,"$! .!.+",+&,"$!.&/835 ##%'0(F8)'!1*5 %'$)" '0 1 +$)"&!&

(B@,"+)'!1/835#"#.$!%'0B6+# %' +"&,"$! ,"+&' * "C,"'&"&8 !1" )'!1*5 #","'#"'$5 $)"& ! &( B@ '#5" +*5#","'#"'$5$)"&!&68 B@&,"+ .!1+%!5 *%(+)(,'+*((-.%/'+0102')/3 +(-0&+%+&+(%3-(-.-+

454313)5$!1").*!%,*%"+ ,,*%$ 3*" !!1" 0" ( %&> /835 ,,*5%'0!1 !).*!%,*%"+8!1" ).'! $),"'& !%'$)"& ! &8 8 B@&.) & 8 B@&! '#& **:"#%'+"&,"$! "C,"'&"& '* &!+%!"& '#!+ '&,+! !%''!1"+&.) & (8 B@&! '#& **:"# ' $$.'! $'&+!%.) /8%'!1%&) ''"+8!1"$* %) '!& +"1"*# "'!%!*"#!&8 8 B@1""'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **$ ++5%'!"+"&!G (F , +)!1"# !" $* %),"!%!%'!%**, 5)"'!1"*% 3%*%!5!, 5!1" "'1 '$"# ).'!&1 **3"!1"& )" & +#"+"# 35!1"+%3.' * : )%'+&1 -"3"$)") 4+8&.! !1""'1 '$"# ).'!( F ).'!

&1 **3", %#!!1":%#: '#!1"+") %'%'0 ).'!&1 **3"&1 +"#35!1"

+") %'%'0$* %) '!&%'"D. *&1 +"&

1" ,," *&! '#&#%&,&"# $$+#%'0*5

6 $,5 !1%&4.#0)"'!3"&"'!!!1"!+% *.+! +&!+%$!

$),*% '$" 4"# !5

:8:0% $