← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1864/1999allowed

State Of Haryana And ORS v. Chander Singh Ex Constable No.

2017-12-06Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri22 pages

     

  

 

  

 !

!

"#$

%& '

()* +,- 

   



....

// 001#(2 '242    * 5. 6 .+,7

.....

 2/"#!

#(  $ 86 .

       

    



    



   

* 

6 

 



   !

 

"

 #"

 

 





 $% $& '(((

 * +  !!

 

,-

.

 /



 



 01 $& '((%

"

+ 2+ *3   !!

 

, .

)  

)



  



" 

4





"

+ 



05 $1 '((0 !'3

 

+  8 +83

 '9 $' '((&

  '0 $' '((9

*  :  

  #     8*:83

*  

    8*83  "

)

) 

-



""/



" /

""



""/ 

:





 ""



  

'% $& '(1;

/"

 * + " 

 / 

  

"" 

 <

)

 / 

'' $& '(('

/ "

" "

 

/""

 /





"

"

"

 =   / 

 "

!



 



""! "

  

""   " # > )













)

  



?"

"  ) ) 



 " 7  /



   



*  !



"  / 



"  ) 

"

+

 

 

 

 )

9

  +









@

  ) 

""

 

*

  /

" "

 "

 A

  : ) ) 

7

 /   6A @

B ) 





  



""



 >!)





""   " # > 



)



!7

  /

" 



  6A @

:

 )  "A "       B ) 



  

)

  :

 )  A

" "

"

/"

"

)

  



  



 



"

" "

 ) 



 )  

 )

*: 

  "





  

" 

& @ ) 



)

  



  /

!

3 E 

  + 05 $1 '((0



" 

"" " ""

F @

 3 E 

  

 



 F @* 3 E   !)F @* 3

#"

"

 "



E'

) 

""/    



!

!'

*  05 $1 '((0

!0 @

* :  '9 $' '((& !& @

*   '0 $' '((9 !9

G  &$ $5 '((9 !5

  !;

  !1

>/"

@   !

 7



  #   @

  +

*E'

) 

""/    

 

!

'3 67 *!'

H $; '0 '(('

03 67 *!0 



""  $; '0 '(('

&3 67 *!& G

   $; '0 '(('

93 67 *!9 G

/ $; '0 '(('

53 67 *!5  ! '% $' '((0 ;3 67 *!;

6A  &$ $& '((0

13 67 *!1 /

  09 $; '((0 %3 67 *!% H

 '; $1 '((0 (3 67 *!(



 )  09 $; '((0

: '$3 *!'$ *  05 $1 '((0 ''3 *!''

@

* :  * '9 $' '((& '03 *!'0 @

*   * '0 $' '((9

G   /"   H '

" 



 2  +3

/""





"

 "

 

 

G    "



)

 /













  /



: H 0   

 

   !

 )



E"  : H &

  )



 05 $1 '((0



" 0' '0 '((9

 >





 '$$

G   '(;&  " )  " 





 !

 ?"

"    





 01 $& '((% 



 





 

-



" /

"

 ';

 



 >

 



  

)  ") )



 



 >!)

/"

 #" '; 0



)

 #"

" 



  

'(((2'3 #  +  501 ;"#2(1&0

1#& '

 #<) 32.

(1(

"= 1'>1#1

/"

 

" 

;

 

  

G

"











-

 " "" 



 



 / "



 /



!



" 

)"  #"

@ 

"

 "



 )



)  /

"

';

  

 -

 "



" 





 " 

   4

  

3 '

#!

'

 #<) 32.

(1(

"= 1'>1#1

() '2.* 0$'92'3    D  5;'

%  

"

)



 

""













)  A

!

2'3 E /



   











-

 /"



!







-

"  " ""  F

(









  

  

) #" '(&9

"

 

 3  8#"

'(&983 

/



   

'0

2=

'%;'3

#" '; '

'; 0 2'3

)" & B 0$'1

"

 3 ) " 







 

/

!

,40

. 4()"' ?

!

/4# 2)% #(2.

2'3 H

"

 ""

 ""

 /

  "



 

  

"

) 

 "



  > /  H & ;



 )"/





 >!

D4G6

'

& ;

 H *

  :    )!

: 

  )!

:    )"

 )"

'

*

 

# >

 

& 



* 6



 

  

A 

7  '5   

;

67

 

   *  ""

7  '5 

* %  ""

7  '$ 

 

*    (  ""

7  ;



:  '$  ""

7  & 

)!: 

2&3 -

 

 " 

,

 .

 ""





  >





 8  ""

""



<

 

@40

.+

2% 2210

.+

 *  ""

 "

 





 "







 )"

"  

"

:

> 

    ""

"



.



#" '; '

 "

" 

    #" 6 / 

 

"  ""

" 



 B  

   / "



)/ 



"23





 

   

2'(1$3  %1; # G 4 "

= ?

: 2'((03  0(( >

* = 

* 

@



4 

  23 /

"  )

 )

 B

7

 #" 2)3 23

 

"

  2

"3 #" 0$';

"  )

 )

 "

 "   

A  /""

""/





4









"  )

 )

  #"

'(&9B 



" 

)

/""

"





D



"  -

  "" 7  



)













)

"



'$



 

'% $' '((0 *53

"   /"



    +

 

  

/> +

 "

 

>

   **# H ''

'' $& '(('

' 5$  )   

A" 

)

  **# H '( '' $& '(('

1 $$ 



 <

)







0;5  

&5

  



   

'3 '' $& '(('

'& $1 '(('

2'0&  

,

3B 03 '& $1 '(('

'1 '$ '(('

(;

 ;



'$

3B

&3 05 '$ '(('

$( '0 '(('

3B :

)

""



 

   "

)

   :  E"

 @

  +



6A @

)   &$ $& '((0 *!;3



 /



  "A

D



/

  09 $; '((0 *!13

" / 



)



)   09 $; '((0 *!(3 " 

 



" "





"

" /

 









'; $1 '((0 *!%3

 

" "

 / & 

 

B )

 

"

"B 

 





 

?"

"

 >

 

 !/  /



6A @

 /

 





 "





 2  +3

 05 $1 '((0 !'3

"

, )

).

, )" 

.

 

"  )

)

"

/

)  









 )



  



"  "

)

"



,



"

".

 *



 ,/ .

''





!'&



 

"  " "



)

 /













  /



 "   "

"A /"

 <    G 4/ 

" 

 

!

1'19$ ,-



"     "



)  "

 /

: '(%&













  /





"

 "

"A /"

 <   

" " 4/ .

G -

 / )



 

 

)

"



 '% $& '(1;



  05 $1 '((0



" ';

 



>  / 



  A

) 

") B )



 



 >

+ ) G -

 >



#" '; 0

#"

'(&9

 " 



  # ) 

 2 3

 

" 

" -

 /  / 

 >!) 

!

  6A @

B )

 /

)  A



A" 6A @





 

!

 /" )   &$ $& '((0 *!;3

 """

  "A

"



6 " 



  "  05 $1 '((0

 >







" 



/ 

!

,D 6A @

/ # >  

*E * +  4   

"" # > 05 $0 '((0 D *E

>

"

 @  *

 

   >

"



4

"

"





 @  *

  

)



D  *E   

)

@  *

 

  



)





  )

 "



#

  *E

"B *E!'

 ")     "

#

+   4  *E!0 *  =

:   /

9 2

3

*E!& * I <  :   I "/

/

 

"

7

6A

.

,:



   

"



6A @

:

 /



6A @

:



 



/

 

"



 "

:



 

"



)



 /

  09 $; '((0

" /





6A @





) 

)   



   #

  H &;' +



" 0; $; '((0

"  '5  

" " /

  )

" 

" " /

 

 H 151 D '; $1 '((0 

"   D  H 9(9 +  

"

 / "

 

  / & 



 / 7

   ""

4

"  )  / " /

  

  

  ""

 

 @

 :

   

E  

*E



6A @

 /

 

 " 



"

"   

*E 



)

""

: 





"

  & *E *E!'

")  /



 ""



"   

"

'9 $1 '(('

$( $% '(('

 >!) "

D *E 

#  



 ""





"

 

  / )  /

*E!0 *  =



" ) > 







" '(('

 >!) 

"



" 

"" # > 4

"

 *E

"



   

 

 *E  



  *E

" A 7





"

*E!& * I <    

"





'& $% '(('

$' '$ '(('

09 '$ '(('

$0 '' '(('

/"" 

"

"

" " ">



   

"  



" /  '& $1 '(('

  "

  +

: >

  '' $& '(('

 

 > 

  '' $& '(('

 

 / "

  +

>

 



  



 



"" # >

")

" > 



"" # >





  / *E!'

/ 

#   ) "

4  

"



"" # > /"  ) " 







   *E 

 



)

: )

"  " ""

 )  " ""

/"  

"



""

 

+

" "      + )

" 







)  

"

"



 



  

"

  + H

"

" 7



E 

"

  



*E 



/"

"

)

"    )" )

 )



   "

)

)

)" 

.

 '0

)

 



 /

 

/""





 



 "

 

/ 



6 -







/ A  &$ $& '((0 *!;3

" 

!'&



 

!

1'19 ,

 A  &$ $& '((0



   J    

 + 67) '

267 *!'$3 05 $1 '((0 ) 

 A 



    /  



 > )  

 

*E!'

") 

  



"" # > ) 



"



  

* I

 7

*E!&   

A )



" /  

 



()1( ( %1>* ()

1// 001#( !

&1''

!

='"%

0  ( #< 2"%

%1( ' 10 =1(2 ='"% ()

#A4 '>

== 'B

""



""

     67 *'

*'0 / "

  !



 

     " ) *E!'



    "



D 

"  / -



!'% ) 



 >!) 

-

/

) 

 " ""  )



'&







"  -





) 

 > !

 #" '; 0B / 

"

  /"

 

"    ""

"





/""

" 



 )  "

 #" ( '%

#"

'(&9

 /  

A "  A



!

@40

.

 ( ' #< #2 "# 2'3 H/ 



  "



  

!

/

 



" A " 

/!

    "









 )B

& C)"

"%/402"' 0> '

( '

!

4#!

'

24&'40

+ 1=( '

"%/0 ( #< (C #(> = D

> 1'28 A410 => #< 'D

/ 







 



   

" 

8  B

23 / 



 



   " 

8 

 







 /   



!

   

    ""



" /



!

  



H!



  

)"  

  







  /





  

 "



   







 

#2/ ("' # '10 "= "0

 /





   "%/402"' 0> '

( '

1#> "0

== '* 

)" :   

  /

" (C #(>= D

> 1'28 A410 => #< 'D * / 





/ 

""  /""

"



 .



#" ( '%    )

"  " A " 

 



)

"



!A



/""

" 

/

"

"" 



" 

)"  #" ( '%203

D



"  -

  #" ( '%203

'9

6







-

  



 A

   05 $1 '((0 )  6A @

 



  #" '; 02'3  

 ""

 "

 





 "







 )"

"  

"

""

  #" )





  ) /"

 



 "A /"

 

 "

 >

 "



 7

"   

#" '; 0 /"



  )

  ) )



  *



 /  



)

)

  





)"

/""

 

 

) 

"





#" '; 0

#"

6 / /""

"  ">

  )

 / 

7

 

>



 " ""

 

/""





 



" 



 '0 $' '((9 !&3



 

!

,

    



  

 /



'(%&







 

) >







+, D  7 

 





 /



  

) 



  0;5 





)" .

'5

H )



 # )  2



 



)



&99 



" 

G " 4

 

 '1  

 )





#" ( '% / 





"

"



"

"

 3 '

#!

'

 #<).*

 2 "  )

"

"









#" ( '% / 



   



!''

/

!

1'1<'1/) ,I  / 

""  :

 



 

 """

 



 

" 



>

 "





 /"





H " ) ) 

 

 "

  ) 



 '$  



 "

 

+

   #" '; 0 "

 

 

 

"

 " /"



 

 

 ""

/  

:

" /

" 

 

 ) 



)  7 

/



  )".

 

 

"



23 /



#" ( '% /

 /"





 

"  /  A "

';

D  ) "

"

""

>



"<  





D  "

)23

"  ""

  







" "

)"

 "  ) 

8)"     



!;

 

2'((03     59

(1(

"= 4#F1&

() '2 32.

1%  #<) ;"#2(1&0

!

,D

"

"

 A

  "

7  )

 "

 



.

D







-

++  /"



"   /

#" ( '%

#"

'(&9

: 

 



#" '; 0 2'3

 

) 

#" ( '%





 

"  B 

" )



 #" ( '% /  /""





'1 : /

)



""/





 $% $& '(((

-

 





 01 $& '((%

  

4

  ""

 /



   

 

%& '

()*+,-  E >  



J H

E #   J H