← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1994/1999allowed

Kalawati Etc. v. Roor Mal Etc.

2018-07-26Mr. Justice Amit Rawal12 pages





       

 !" #$% $&

'&$(()$(((* +,- '.&/ 0+12 &&&33

 42

+12 &&& 35 &

'&6%7)$(((* +,-

&&&33

 42 '.&/ 0+12 &&& 35 6&

'&6$$#$(((* +,- '.&,8+12 &&&33

 42 '.&/ 0+12 &&& 35



 !"#$% &'

#'&("

2

,2&'9, "58"

2133

 '&$(()$(((+ 2235&$+  '&6$$#+6%7)$(((& ,2&42529':1"582 ,2&

'12."58"

2133

 '&6%7)$(((+2 235&6 '&6$$#$(((+2 235&$ '&$(()$(((& 2133

 '&6$$#$(((& ;;;;; '&(")$ 1  252    .  1

 53    12  :

2  '5

*

33 &$(()"6$$#56%7)$(((1.22:  59 58 '

&( 6$(%< 5='.&/ 0+12 42 '2+12>&

'&$(()$(((1? 5?1 33

@ :15:2525?1A0233

 2  &)5 2:55&)?535 '.&8"

012 '&6$$#$(((1?32225?1  : 12 55&7". "1:088@@815:  &6&  2  A "  12    1  3   5  3252@@2   55&7"1558551 3232B  12&

'&6%7)$(((1? 5?1 55 &) "012?15:12 2252:.

 8 255&)18?2825?A0233

 2 1? 2 .&

@/ 058 51 " .:

5 2532.9 ? :12521 

2  $ 25"  2

 *C& (-"  012?  .

  8@@8 121 5? ::8058 21 282.132.1802  58"254

:/13 2"1 2

"2,152:21 0023:2

 2  5.325D10&$ <"

D1&$%$"$%$E$5$%$E . 2:$7#D $ .2 5$E625 121 5.325D10&$6)"D1&$(). 2:$ D $#.2 238 &'1C325 (&!&$(<7&2A * 55-"11213 ?::32328 '$ 15 '

"$(7!*212"$(7!- .5

+

1.

&25:

".

12?2:&!!655 $&%&$(<7025?1 B 02?

1.202225 1

2"01"5?8"51. 8 21282.& 0

:5155&) 2522 011313 821 3232":

2  A     ?.    33   52  '  $)7    1  2.

25 251 2'

?8 ,:2"2

"01" 12.5325:1513232"1082" 21 33 05.55

& 5&$6@'255 02 .512502 D&5&) 532 02.D:32 .2?92:25:.? "

 @5&55513 ? : 1255 8&05110535?812/2D '

5 '.0 #$(&5&7 53202.5 25  1  2  A "  12    1  3   5  12  3252@@ 2"2285.32.*C& $-"012?1?.02 31 32321C1 12& '1320282"12 22.51 

0:  @ =$- F1123 2021  5  ?:12'.&851252 

22555$%& &$(<(5252

2 35$%&(&$(<(2

: "

585G  - F1123 2 5. 2 5?

1'1D""10.

1G

 6F11255&7'.&1:08 



12'.&8 :013 ""01 G  )- F11255&)

2. 535'.& "01G  7F112       ?5         @952   232G  !- F112       3     1  32  2.    .?

G  <- F112  55  &)      3    1    3232""01G  %- F112  55  &)     5  2  .32 G  (-

 &>

" 3321285"C.5 F@$12 A 5 F@  :1?2':1" 2D'12 && 3"58"2

5?2 :12255 .C& $C& $)5122 51 85&    1  12  15"  55  C.5    .     0". "F@$ "F@  .2':1"F@6,1?2

255F@)12.3 & 1?185?2 :1225"12 2 2525  1  5:       &$    )  :  1  3   5 55&758 255&)55251 . 55&)"1? 2 ."?252:.

 12231 3232 ?8& 0328 33 ?2:&$%$(()?1  / 058"&&"13 56%($(()?1  :

12 55 &7 02 5&1A0233

 232



0533 &$%? 31 5:15: &)8 2 55&)1 5:1.?5358?

28251

,

5:12 28@@8152012:251.  12 2 .0 3&1C"12 33 "5?8"18? 5& ,2&'9, " 25  "232:33



'&$(()$(((5235&$5  '&6$$#5 6%7)    $((("   ?.5  1   :  01  1  2.5  33 "

33 ?2:&6($6@$((( 52 252)$

 < 1 ? ?.53 225.

12 2: 25"

&&"  12    235  &)@  2  ,    23    1  3232 552.112 2: 2551233 ?2:

&<!)<@$(((23 :225.

8 2185"

1? .5? 2313232125 ?1.2.1 2 12 2: 25582 $(<!"012

@55&)15?10? 2: 25" 55  85&  

 1  2.5  5 .  2  32   5.?

5? D5259 51.2"2" 32     1  2.5  5 .2  85"    5     22?



155&)08115 528512231 120:

15.1 2 12 2: 25512215325 01112?82 1 55"0112 52..

 ?2:&<%6&42 $(<! 28 51 15? 10? 2: 25"1 2 12&11 2? 0 18?55252:15: &)1 5:55 &)?535801 :111 5

5852.8&

-

0C5515355C&71? 328522551? 5258585. 55  !&)&$(()"  122"  1  : 2  C&    C&7    1 2.553553 :& 2? 018 

  :25  5 .  C& (  5  C& $#"  &&"  1  252  55 %& &$(<<5$%&(&$(<(128  12"012

.

 0251.2A "12133

@3 & 5&)1

:512.5.

?2128   2&1

2$258525255 %& &$(<<295 1 .55&)?

0

05 585?21 

2"0125:.11

:55355 0552:52&5&) 533 ?2 1

2"01105.58525255$%&(&$(<(*C& $#- 51221.5 & ,2C1?15 .1?32 ? D5&81328118?.3 501& 2: .32.1?3 5225"C32313 5"122"1 2? 02:1 :513 55&7& 12 2?55:2:2 8 255&) 5311 2 . 52 252%

! ?1  55&)0 3"1 "15:18?2:1 @5 ?1A0233

 2&

2  2"  ,2&  42529  ':1  2  ,2&

  '12."

25  2133

 '&6%7)$((("235&$  '&$(()$(((5235&6 '&6$$#$((( ?.51?11 2? 0 22 1 555&)

.

?5358&@2:215355"32 328' )<1 :2?:2 52 29:1.&382 C&H234

:/13 1051 02&5.5 "20 ?5558"1 "53 ?815 ?3285&15 .012122 55"122"0 5.?

8532328'(#585 &1252128  22B 9 5  25  ?  D5    ? 1  2 2  2  59 5    1  8

2823  5512:1 2?

5?55 &)8@@853&  &<012:25131 3232 0155&)1 ?5558 21 @ 55&)"01115?22501?1A0233

  2&321328 252< "2 2 0.

2 01 12?: 2 ."122"15:1 2 20232  : 59 5& 0C551155 85" :1? 5225?13 "? D5 13 8508 ?

1.0112 18  0 35:&C3 1.21.3 :011C32 =5 5 :>2013210501.255

850

51 259 51 & 32182. '&6$$#$((("?11 2 ? 018..5

: 53282 D:1 .32.C& $:5?3252@@213 5

/

0

55&7"012?1323253 0:25? 1251C1 12& 15 5328153 1 :011212 2 12 2: 251251 3232 ?1.&C&753550"1 "2:55?25 5 .5.3 23132328&

18 .2?

 5328?1:85"122"2:1

"12 .0295& 181251 25  2132"33251 332?D"2251 2? 051801122 5.21 ?.,2&'9, " 25  21 33

 '&$(()$(((519 5:.5521  2 ? 01C2 ?

?@51

0:

2:

@ $-

2  ,   5    328  53    32  5 . C&7I - 55 85"55?8"&&".

 128 2 2: 252.1125 0

1.

1.1 ?B 85 10511323201111252. 2: 25 0535&8182 "1.15? 10? 2: 25&320115? 535 528122.1 2 12"

 .1?2.153532I 6- 122 2.1.1221222 8 15?32852252.328'7#  1 5  85      ? 1  :8:  5  D:



2.I )- 23 1? 5?1  2?

:

12.55 ."1 "5.33232 

0  1  5 .    ?  D    225  ?  0   55  85    2:25  5 .  22   32 .32 180'))1

9?A5

8 I 7- '.3 1?D?55&7012:25 112? 2.1 2 12 2:

25&

" 1:$61?535"1 1

5183 5225..2 "&&"5 

22132110 

535?8"

?

12215518?? 5 13 ?:8I !- '$ $(7!?

  5  .1121.2322?512& 21 D?28"'$ 251 @ =$ &      0

001

 2

   30  

 3041  252       .:  :  2 :"1.?"1

?52.5 25  01  1  2

    322  5  50 12 52

$&@ 012"110225:2 32225&

 &@F121 .?25:21 .2"11232225011022 5:25&

6&@F121212 5?32225   1  12  52 

  $  2 

   1  D

5

.

 &> <- 180C325?1A0233

 2 :@515:12 2

0:1  .55&)1? 2 .5 

222 13220 :1I %- 11 2? 0225 05?1 5:

55&)?5358I (- 53551?32852501

0 2:255 .512.02 2B 25?322.532328'!5

535,"$(7!&832 .3 52 '$!15 535,"$(7!

?5208 255&)5355 0 2:25& 21D?28"'$!25 1 @ =- 60231

 0  3  103 

2 31   3  

31

4 F182    5 . 2:25 52 021.?:2 325 5  ?2     2  3 232:    225   53.55:5?132:8:51 32  D:  1  1 5    53"  1   2  1

32 .11531?.5.3  0113281  5   53285&> $#- C& (5C& $#5:1

25 1

218? 5? "0121 5:8@@853"

2 "02821

:5 ?55&)5"122"1.? D5



259 51 I $$-  5 01.2C1?5 .5 5301328019 5:.2525 13  &7  8912 9

 

 390  :00  ;231 3<2

 390)'./-,  5 ?"1 2"2 215?2.:1 ? B  001 55:133 ?

8012 555

5 ?8 25 5:1J?

'

32. 2 



            

   012132320112801 328'(<*$- "328')$1

9? 2 "$($%0

533 2133 && '0

5? 5 52'$## 58  25 25512

5?01 2.:1 ? B  0&1  1J?

'

32.  21 5115!"# !     $ "

 %



&'     

(

  33 ? ' (<*$- 22 0""1328')$ 1

9? 2"$($%15?225?D& 21D?28"

12 83219 5:.8 25 5:1J?

 '

32. 2 D9D1J* 32-251 @ =   

          

         !!         

    "        

  

     # $   %  &  

   $) * +,- ./ , 0 -  



     

 ' (  )* + ),-.

=)* /   

  )0

  &       

      &         



  &      ,    2     

*

 

     3           &       4  

 

  4       

 3       1!   5

 

 4   , 0              $  4 

     

 

 

 

 4   ,60     ),)   4     &       4   

      6,0   5

 

 4   ,60   &                

  4 

     

 

  &     

 4       6*)7   &       4 " 

    )0

  &       4        

             

     3                       6*)   &       4 4       6*)7 8      

   

                 

  3   

 

      9           ,*7   &   &    7   8   ,*:     

  

   &                  . 122"552.1 ? B 

001 55:133 "2.5&

2125?8" '&$(()$(((

05"

012 '&6$$#56%7)$(((25.5&' 13  525&21?3232525: & $<*-)*5/   '&(" 209 $%=># (9390?1 @0

 ;0@

(939 3A

;0@