High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2074/1999dismissed

M/S Parkash Industries, Ahmedgarh, Malerkotla v. Market Committee, Ahmedgarh, Malerkotla

2015-01-07Mr. Justice S.S. Saron18 pages

#$%&'()% * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +( % #% /2% (3/4' #% 2 00/ (3/%'++,, %'((5#%&.. #$ #,, * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +( '#%&../ '.(0%' * ++,, -%) #$26 #,, * +( '#%&../ '.(0%' * ++,, -%) #$%0(70 * +( #$%1,2)',6).% * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +(

'#%&../20%)% * ++,, -%) #$ ,%(0 * +( '#%&../ '.(0%' * ++,, -%) #$2'% 8%0%+% * +(

#$ %)#,)%2'&% * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +( '#%&../ '.(0%' * ++,, -%) #$64, (%,#,, * +( #$2'%)%0 0#,, * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +(

#$1)9. #,, * ++,, -%) '#%&../ '.(0%' * +(

'#%&../ '.(0%'/ * ++,, -%) #$' ,#,, * +( '#%&../ '.(0%'/ * ++,, -%) #$ %)#,)%2'&% * +( '#%&../ '.(0%'/ * ++,, -%) #$2'%. #,, * +( '#%&../ '.(0%'/ * ++,, -%) #$ )%#, 2 * +(

!:''% +%%,,++%.7;,,4('8)(0.<

;%%%(' +%%%<

:''%'8)(0.'),(;%+%('0< !

" '%(%',,(+%.(;)'4

0),%2( ++,.,(;7'((0'8)(0. ((%4'%;7',.%'.)+7;,)(% ' )8; )%, 3,+. =)( / !>?@ 4 ( A'%% %%%('B((C#%&..DE(.%0)' 8)(0. ( (%/ 4'%;7 ' ) ,( ;7 ' +, (+)0 '

,.%'.)+7;,)(%' )%,3,+. =)( / !>?@ 4% (.( A'%% %%%( B' +,5 (,%DE2');''++,..8)%( ,. % ' .) +7;, )(% ' )8; )%, 3,+. /!>?@/'%%/'.%&)+%'%00'% 43%/%',7%%/'%&%. @F !>>> )8; )%, 3,+. / !>?@ A% '% B' DE .+,,374'34,%%)%,(3,+./)0. 0%),)%,+%()/.+%3,'(,%(+)%'% 0%),)%,+%()(+%3(%%,%,0%),)%,+%() ())%,,.2 ' .

+,) )8; )%, 3,+. %(/ 4'% 2 " .+ ,37 (5 3,%.;%+0%),)%,+%()/;)0'%,('( .%&%'%,3+%3%0,,7(%()(% G#$%&'(#)*+,$ %-."($#/,#$($0$(,"12+-#%,..0$(+#C A!E'23%..7/;7/%9%0+4% %%((+%%.

%(;7 % )(%' /;,'')8; )%,3,+.

%( 999 999 +34%,./''+/$(, ++CA!E2);8'%),.()(% ' /'%',,;,3(%'+)%+' /( 3,%.;/'%%)+%3%7')(%(%)+/ %+ ' 0%),)%, +%()/ ;)0' % ,( % ;)0' % +%0'(.%&%H %3(('9+0%),)%,+%();%)0'% +%0 ',, ; ,3;, %+ 7 % 4''(,3%7'0%),)%,+%();)0'%,(),,7 .(

E',3()(%);5A!E',,;+(;7'(,% )'.%.7;+%%;(()'+%%%/.7 ;++(%(0(;7' %(';',H %3(( ' ' ;)%( ' ',, ; +( ;7 ' (,%;7((0'+)%'+%%3%;,;7'.%.' 9 +)%'% ' 0%),)%, +%() % ' 0( +%( % .))%() E'%%%,3()(%);5A!E',,;%3%;, %%%,(%3)I 43%/ ' 4 .((3( )8; F !>>F/ 4'')8; )%,3,+.A .(.E /!>> A%'%B' .

(( DE4(/4'%;7);5A E4);)(/4'% );5A E4%(2"' 2);5A E 2"' %()(% GA E7(,%,+7'.)',3()(%);5 A!E/'',,/(('.);,;,+7 %'.)()%.'.'%0'+% +%).%.'((),I ' ,37 )(% ' 4 ',,0( ;7 ' (,% ;% ' )% ;7 47 4% + ' ( 4% + 4% (.(;7')% > !>> 8)(0.%+%(#$2);;'' '(%6.,'6).%-2)8; '% !

>> )8;( %7 "> A= E '%%/ ' ,,%/ 20%)% +( %(% % %3%7'.)%%%,(%3) 00%3(0 '(%(%/'+,5(,%,(3,)0'2)8; ( ' ,,% ( %( 4') .+,(0 ' #%& ..+%7((/4''4(((3(8)(0.((% (( !> F!>>!A95 E %(%0 ' ' +, ',, +7 ' %)%, (3,+. )( .) 0' ', 7%,7 ,,. J), .) ..0 %. 3.;%/ !>>! ' +, ,.

K +70'.),,.%0),%,7/;)'(()( '+,+7%'%!?L+%).4'%.' (70%(;7'0')%'4%+.(;3 /'%%/'+,,('+%)',,00')(;7 '#%&..,.0%'%)%,(3,+.)(.) % , ' 0%)( ' '% +%3 '%0 % ' )8; )%,3,+.=)( /!>?@2/'(.(', '%0%%.())),/(%2 !' )8; 0%),)%#%&%() /!>K!4)(%'+)%+' '((,('%0%'%!?L+%). '%)%,(3,+.

)(.)'%%/')030%+% ++,4,( '4%./',0'4%+',,00 '3%,37%)%,(3,+.)(.)4(.((,' ''+,'+(3,,.)0',,.( '4'+,+7%(.0'% !?L+%).%.'('740%(;7'0')%4 ,%(''((,(,.%'%!?L +%).%.'+%3'% /!>@? '%,)%('8)(0.((%((!@ @!>>@ A95> 5! E3(4'''%,%),(;7'+,4(%( ',(0 ' '% +%3 ' #%& ..

), ' ' (('%0%'.)%)%,(3,+.)(' %,)%,(')%'%++,0'8)(0.((% (( !@ @!>>@ A95> 5! E/ '% ++,, )% 3( 8)(0.

!>>?A95!! 5!

E',('((.. ,( 0 % ' %)%, (3,+. )( .) %

@ 0 ' ( 8)(0. ( (%/ ' %, )% (%( ' ) 3( 8)(0.((%((!! ?!>>?',(0''%+%3 ' #%& .. ),/ ' (( .. '%0 %(,7(+7.%)%,(3,+.)(.) 43%/++,0'(8)(0.((%/'%

++,,)%4',%,70)+'8)(0.%+%(2627,- 2)8;!>>!1 @FK( % -#%&../ 2+!>??21 !FF/4'%';',(''%;747 (.0;4%((%.'+%32 '%

')/'8)(0.((%'%,)%4(() (.(2,,00%3(/'+,(++,

')/%0).%(;7',%(),%' ++,, ( ; 9.( ' +%3) 8)(0. ( (% (( !@ @!>>@ A95> 5! E +( ;7 ' %, )% ( ' ' %

++,, )% (( "

!>>? A95!! 5!

E ',(0 ' #%& .. ,( %3% % ' .) %)%, (3,+.)(+%%8)('(%0).;,% '%''%(%)(%',,0')4'',,% ((

K!>>"%3%%)+'%)%,(3,+.)(.) %%%,(%3)=%.'+,(0/'%,)%'(%.(' ,,40) G! :''% ' .+)0( %(% ((

K!>>" ,,%/ %20%)%,,0,/),,(3(%'%(,( '+,<

:''%'+,,('8)+%7(%<

:''% ' ) ' +, .;, ' +%%.<

F :''%'+,'),'+% )< " :''%'+,++(;7'4(() ,'+%)< K :''%');(%%3)(%2 !' )8; 0%),)%%()#%& < @

+%), ' 8)(0. ( (% ' ,0' ' ) %.( '4 ' ,7 J) 4'' 4 9.( 4 %0%(0 ' 3,(7'%3%7+%(0(;7',,%'+% ++,/ ' ',,0 ( %(% +( ;7 ' #%& .. !

!>>" ,.0 .) /FK/>@ $5 2 ' ' #%& .. 4 );8 .% ',,0 ' +%3))/'+%(0(;7'#%&..%3%' .)%'%)%,(3,+.)(;(;;%%(;7 %8)(/'%(7) '3 '%( ,%( ), % ' ++,, ' ,,40 );,J),4;''++,

! " #$%& ! '

" #$&%( )

! '

" #$&%( * + )+"

! " # $%& ! " ,-. $$.

! !

/ ! + )+" 0 1(2

> 2 '% /!>@?('B)%D,)( %;), ( %;%% ( ' B(;D . 7 ,;,7 % %()..7(,)((;+7;,&(/;)( ,)(8)(0.(;2 '% .+4%')% ,,4%'%,3+%3'% %()(% G5+ (,($(,#C' /),'9'%4%J)%C AEG)%I,)(%;),(%;%%H 99 99 AEG(;I.7,;,7%%()..7( ,)((;+7;,&(/;)(,)(8)(0.(;H 999 999 999 !2+- /0-$$%''2(,$+-+#$CA!E7+%(0%' %3%7 7 (; % (.0 % 7 +%(0 4'' ,.

% % %+ 7 (; % (.0 ,%(7 +( .(/')%.7/'&/,,4%'+%,( '(;%(.0%'+%.&0)',./' .7 ;/ % 9(0 ' )%% % %/ % ' 4',%+%',,40+%(/'7C AE '+%(0%,(;+7;,;73%) 4%%).%./'/%.'( 4''(;+7;,'()' +%(0H A;E ' +%(0 ( %, 7 )' (;/ '/ %.'(.('%0%(4% 03 ;7 ' +% ,( % ' +% .&0 ' ,.'+%,;,'%4,,;,.

(/ '()'+%(0H %3(('4'%'.)'(;%(.0 ';%+(;%')'+%(0/% ',,;,,4()(%'%'+%(%)' %+7. 99 99 E'0'C AE',,++,7%,C AE 7 (; % (.0 )+ 4'' % +7;,%0'/;73%)70%.

AE 7 (; % (.0 )+ 4'' +7. % ;%%(/ ;7 3%) 9+% 0%.H A;E',,C AE '.+%3%;,%'('% ;,, 9'0/ +%.%7 % 'J)/ ((0;,%). /!??!H% AE ' +%3 ), %(% ' =% 2'(),'(3,%()%/!> ?H AE',,.+4%')%4%(%)+%I '9+%B)%D((2 AE'%

9')3 (/ ;) ,)3 ( '%%/ 4''9+%B)%D(,)(%;),( %;%%/ 4,,,)(,,)'%/4'%.+(8)('%0'' +%,)(0'J)8)(,%;),%')'%9%0' )%7+4%2 A!E'% .+4%)%,,4 %'+%,('(;%(.0%9(0' )%%%%'+%(0%,(;+7;,;73%) G4%%).I%.'4%%)./. ,)AE2 A!E'( /(.'+%3%/ ;)4,,,)(')%7,37 1%( ), % ' +,5(,% %%%( 20,

'8)(0.,'0')%%+%(( '%- #$,.(%.1( !>@>,'

('' +%3 ' % ++,7 ,7 3,)%7 ' (;% ( %(% ( ' +7. (; 9% ,0,3 +4%

%.(',,40+% G!

**%.,,7/'%%+%37/'.59 ('% (%0'9%+(03(' .+,7.+;,'%4)'+%3/4),(;

)%+%0.7.(++,7'% )'4),( ++%')%)%7%(%%,;,7/'' .)%)%7%(%.)+7'+,7'4,,,,4 %5.+,'% ((3% '7+.7.(/'% ,7++,4''(;% (%(%%,'+%(;73,)%7(4'' %,%(;7'9%10,3+4%'2 4.+%%5.+,4')%7,;,7/ ' ' )% ' +,7 .) , ; ' ) % . ,,()4'',%,7(,4')'J)''%7 % .7 .

( ;( ,7 %), %, ( ' % ;9((3%,&'+%I ( ( ' ' %, ' ,%( ), % ' +,5(,% ' ( 8)(0. (3 ' %0). %( ' %(8)(0.%'+%3,.%)(%' %+,(% /!?

>.,);,0%4''%+% 03 ;7 ' ' ' %+% ;( .% + % ' % ' %.,,7 ' +%3 ' . 9 ( '% +%3('9%+(03('+,7.+;,

)' ,/' ;%(;4%%). 4'''+%'24,,'+7%;)(/'J) 4''%J)%(%(''+';9.(;7 ')%.734/'9+%4%%).2 ' % 4,,,)(,7'3,)%7'+%/;), )4''%,;,7'+7+7'.)%9/ '.7;'4%(B4%%).D'3;039), %+%/4''%3'+)%+.% (, ' .+0',;,7+7 ')/.'+'%.2 '%

/' %(9%0')%7+4%,37%%)%,(3,+.

.) ,( % 9(0 ' )%% % % 4%M)!%.(;3 ' %)%, (3,+. )( .) 4 .+( 4' ' )8; )%,3,+.=)( /!>?@4(',0,7)'

4',,0(;%')%(=),, '')%#$ 2);;'' '(% 6.,' 6).%D A)+%E )+',( ' 3% ' )'4%+%/)4''.%'+,'+% ++,/4%0%(%.%(%%++7..+()(% ' %( 4 ) ' %% %(%/ ' #%& .. ),( %3% ' .) %. ' +, 2.4' .,% J) ' ; 9.( ;7 ' D;, 2)+%. )% 8)(0. %+%( ( ), % 3%510, - ( '%A !!E?2!K!/4'%',,40'%J)4% %( G! +%7 4' ( .+,7 4' ' )% %(% ; +%.( % ' ; ' 4 4%0 5 .+,<

:''% ' )), +%7 ; .+( ;7 47 %) % (+%3 ,0. () % .% ' )%7%< (

:''% ' )% '),( %.3 ,, 3 % .+,704''8)(0.')%<I 9.0 ' ( J)/ 4 ',( ' & (30'44%0('4'3%;+%''(% ),('3'(;7.+,704''8)(0..);(0%0(( +('8)(0.5%(%(,,4(;%(;7'8)(0.5 (;%')%;%3()(% G!F>,(+%+,,4'&(30' 44%0,)%(0%0,,;'+%73,(;7

;%)%(,7%5.+,/'%4,,,47;3 %5.+,/(+%%0))0'.)+4' ,,&(+,('%'3'%(;)'7 &4''(';4,,%.4''. !" :'3% ; +% ' '( % ),( '3 '( ;7 .+,70 4' ' 8)(0. .) ; (0%0( ( +( ' 8)(0.5%(% ( ,,4( ; %( ;7 ' 8)(0.5 (;%'';)(()7(;,0')%/ ' ; ,&( %. ' + ' %(% , ' (+%3 ;7 % (,7 ),,7 %)(/ ' %(% ;%7%.,%'9')%)(.)I 9.0'+%+,8)%'./')%',(' )8)%;','%%'%.7 %+%+%7'%0')(.,+%+,8)%J)7 (0(';;%3()(% G!"

8)%'.G')8)%;', '%/%'%.7%+%+%7'%0' )(., +%+, 8) % J)7 ( 0( I ((.7;,;,G34''((%0'; 4%0(%I ( G3 ')0' ' .7 '3 %3( NO ',7 ' % I A0 3 , &*) " )

)& / $$$/ (/

E !"> 8) %'. ; ' );8 %)/ ( ((++%'()(.,+%+,'%'7%)),,7 ,&(0'%/(%)%J),7;()+''%7 )8) %'. 43%/ ,')0' )8) %'. %%%(%%0%((0%)(%%)/+%'+.% )% %0%( +%%J)/ % )),,7 '% ; %) 4') )8) %'. (( ' )8) %;','%%'%.7% +%+%7 '% 0 ' )(., +%+, 8) % J)7(0( +%%'(''%3( ;/(')8),7%'(%';4),(; )8)8)%'.+%)%4'''(% .7%;4''8)(J)7;,0'%

!F 999 999 !K :.7(('%)()8)%'./,04' 3%,+/'3;34(4'%%'40+%5) ( +5) ' %.% / ;. );3 ,4 A% ..,4E%0''')%4,,(%H;)',%/ 4''+%%;%')%(7$./%.+,7 +0./%),(+%3/%)8)%'. ' '%/ ' 8)%( ' )% ,3, ( ( 8) (+((.);%(,74,((/'%44,,;,,40 ')%D4+%/,04'.(,7/(8) 999 999 !?@')%'%(8)(0.,;%3('' (%%)%(/'%%.,%, 03%)2)'%%,,(;7'+%3 '% !?

>%!>@? 999 999 !> 4''+%)/4;%3( 3 "

4 5- 6 5 , )77 $ 0.*&')%'),(;%),(+%(%)%,0 ',,J),%(%+(+)%)'%. %(%+(;7')%2)'9+%(%.7;%7 '& ' %0 %( .0 ' ,0 )% ' %, %..)%('3((8)(.% !>! 4' ' +%+, J)7/ 8) ( 0( )(0'),()%'',0,+%;)(;7 ',07.%')%'),(3%+%.,0 +%+),,0,7;7;)0',0,+%';)(()7 ')%)%'('7(7.+;)',0, +%.);3,7)%;((')%.)

)%''% 4%0),/))'%(%)8)0%7;7';) '+%')%47)%;'(7.+ %, / 4'' ' %+( % ' (( ' )%%(%(%(('., ',0,+%(0')% 4),( ; ),,7 8)( 3 .+0 +)3 4'% ,0, +%';;)('),(;+%.()'8)(, +%%%0)(%3(0%)8)+%')%.)

3,7 ()%0 %)(),/ )%)+),) ( (' ,0 !> ')%D(3)%.);)%'3%7 0 8) ( % %. ' )% 4', %(%0 8) .) (++%0.++%'(++%+%%,( .+ ; %(%( %(% ()%0 (' ,0 ' ;8 ( %) .0 ' + %) ; '3(%.+,'(),')%(++%0.++%' (,04''I '((5#%&..),(%,P'.) ;)%%3')%;)'4%+,( ;7'(,%2'#%&..),(%,P'.) %)%, (3,+.

)(/ 4 (+%3( ; %%( ;7 ) 2)';';%(;7'+,'%%/'+,5(,% %;)(%))';'((5#%&..'30 %('.)'%0'%(%+(;7')% #$2);'''(%6.,'6).%DA)+%E')/'+7. % ' .) .%& () ( +( ' +% %)')9(+%%0%7%',7 .'(.+0'.%&..J)'(., '4%+4''/'%4%.+%0%3%7' ')/ ' #%& ..

,( %3% % 3 ' ;'% ++,;,'%J) %+'%();,J),4/,%(),% '+,5(,%'3'.,7%0)('%);5A E 2"' %%+3/'%%/'(.(%)('% % , 4,, ; );8 +7. % )++% )' %0).%,+,()+#$)%;',;, ()%3 1(- .2,%7 %( '% !

2 !K@/4'%

!K '+%3%,7(7.2.,,2,( ,,%7 ()%,(%&0 /!>> 4%9.(',(''+%3 )' %++,;,'0%.9)(+%%'. ' ( 4 ',( ' )' ( '3 7 %%+3 ' )(%(%4)(;);3,4%0 ,.'0'%%%(,7(+7.%)0 3)%')++,%(%%+(0,;,7.+(';)7% ' %( 8)(0./ ' D;, 2)+%. )% ' 9.(%,%8)(0.Q,20'-2%7A FE?2 !/4'%4',(''+%).+0%%+3+% ++,;, (,%%7 ) :''% ' +%3 (,%%7/ %0%(.);'(');%'%''%. 9+,%7

0%,,7+()++,7;3).%,%)+(); '.0'+%3) Q,20'DA)+%E/'D;, 2)+%.)%;%3()(% G!F'+%).+0%%+3+%++,;, (,%%7)**(%.0/'%%/')% ' /%0%(.);'(');%'%''%. 4 D9+,D%,% /4),(;4');8), %)( %%+3 9+,%7 0%,,7 +( )++,7;3).%,%)+();'.0 '+%3) 4,,,('))%3%.%,7 (,%%7 ' +%3) ,4 %%+3 +% 0%,,7 ((** .(0 .7;+)%,7(,%%7,% .0+%3'+%+, 4''4,%(7.+,

,%%7.(.')%4,,'3%%+3 A;(/++FK?5FK>EI '%/4''%%J)%(;9.(' ')/4''%4,,+%%%+3%/%AE0%,+ (+)%34')HAE'%.(7)0';++,(HAE'%.%

@ ',4H(A3E4'4',0,)%.+,(6+0 34'%(%/(''+%3);5A E% 9+,%7)++,7;3).%++7.%% (,7( +7. ' (,% ( .& ' +7./ ' #%& .. )(% ' ),( ; %( ',+, %3%0 ' .).+;,'./4'')0';)++,( 4');5A E4%( 3 ' ,0)0 );5 A E .& ,% ' ++,;, %%+3 ' +%( (), ;% % % ' .(.',;,7'(,%+7%%4'', +7'.),3()(%);5A!

E(+7' %',,;+7;,,7%+4+7;,2,,)%'%/' ,;,7+7%.'((),'4,,,)('(),3 +%%%);5A E '%0).',7'.)%)%,(3,+.)( ()(+7;,%'%);5A E);8,37 %;+(+%3(%,'.+;, (, 4' ' .) ,3( )(% );5 A!E '%%/ )' +%3(,%%7%9+,%7.(.(4),(;++,;, '.

),3(3+%%%);5A E2 "' 34 ' ;3 ()/ '30 4%( ,, ' '% );,J),43)%'((C#%&../ ((7.%'++,+%%%(;7'+,5(,%(+)0 ' ,37 % J),7/ ' %0),% ( ++, ,( ;7 ' +,5(,% % (.

#%&..',,00'8)(0.((%0(',. %%,,4((')(.( 6 !

7 -.,