← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9390/2022dismissed

Rubal Chaudhary v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-03-03Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal13 pages



        

 !"#!$%&%"'())*  

 

    

  

  







!"

   $  %    

   

&&!'"

()%   )      %     

  

!"# &    $ % 

+ 

 '

 "&

, )% 

     ( +,

) - -,

- .

/001, %+   

2 2#

.

3

1, %+   

!"

4

!"# &

.

 1, %+  .

, 5 %1, %+   

&&!'"

.

,6)1, %+   

 "&

. 0.)1/,31

 .

7  .61

, %+8 . 031, %+1 .

() .01, %+  .

% .01, %+    99/

.

(81, %+    

!"

   *

2 2#

 -,.) /0

&

   +

   1  %    8         

 6 +      %%      )           +

 : 0+%+ 8+ 1+ 

8  CWP93902022.

;  )  , +

! 

"

9 0)  +   

 +

+  +           <)  ,  8     



   9   9  + /%   < 99/        =    99/     %   &*> #&2   !

#?

#&2 &&<),  ;  +  ! ) +)

    % +)

9  % 1=+8 +  8+    - Essential Qualifications:  

    

  







  !

"##    $ !%  &   !

'   

!

 !

#!  !

# 

  #   

  

(!)'  

*+

 ,     ( -

;     %    <), )8+

  @ + + + +  8  8+  +   + ,

 +   + 1   @ ++ +    + +     )8  +  

  ;   

6+    +       )            = @ +8+ =+

'

.

/001, %+  %'   %)2  A @ +  )8 +

  @ ++ +7 )8%)@ + 8 0)8+

+ )B  8 0  +

+ )B      )   8))  #1###>  8  + +1)  1     ) + 8 )    )B  118%) =@ + 1    )1   @ ++ +7 18% 1  +  =+ +   + % + +   8 ) 6+

;8 @ ++ +7 8+ +  0+ + 99/ 9+ +99/1      @ +8 7  8    +   1 8% 1@ +8 +

+ )B%

!

.

3

  %' "&)12"# '312"#4 8  %) /%3  1 8% 1+  &/% 3   ;   

     

&#??

##?    ++         +    + 

=/%) =+1 =  =/% 8  )  )   )   %   =     /%3   +  +     /% &

/% 3  1 = 8  +  8 ;        &!

#!

&2"2+ 

; 3% 8)   8+%    

'

#&!

"

.

      .

 ,6  )1  , %+       %' "&)441*2'324"# %)@ + 7 )  @ +8+

+ )B ; @ +7 +)  + %   =  +      %  8 0  8    +

+   )B>+ 10 )    ; 8  ) / +  +

+    ;1 @ + +

+  

?

      +              8 =   @ ++ +)8+ 

 + 8+8  +



  )8+

+ +  ; 8 %)2  A7 @ + @ +8+

+ )B  + + 8+

9

  +  % 1++   +   8+

+ +  ,+  %)

/%3   << 7++    )  ) 8  /%

 

9%  )     +

&#

:

  % 1% +  8

=   ) 3    /% 8 =

 ) << 7   /% ,  +  + =+1    8  =     %       A  @ +   3% >+

+ )B>+>0 )  >)  >

>+ >@    )  +   ,   %)@ + + 

18 =  %@ +  ))+   & %  +  + 8+  =    8+

 9+) +

%      )    +      

   

     %  %  +   + 9 %   %  +      +  +  +               ++     &   

     %     + 83.1 Documents to be uploaded with Application Form (MANDATORY]  )  "

.  

/  #  0   ,    "

  

1



     

)  "

)"!"/!"!.2)!.)!.),!.),!

%%!2

  1  *  

  

 1  (  # 

"

  



#

  3 )  

"

  

#

  

!#'   4 #  



 1  (  # 

"

  



#

  5

)    



" 6

)    

" 7 )  

  #   1

 8  



 1  * 

# #' 3.2 Scrutiny of Documents:

9



 # 1 





 

  &

 

  

 #  

#

  

 



*



   & 

     1  

8

 

 #      # 



# !   

*

  !  

1

*



  

  '

  

 #  !# - &&

:

          =+   +       % 8  +1% +  8 )6++ +8)+ -   3    /%C   )  ) << 7  /%C   %8  A@ +3% >+

+  )B>+>0 )   >)  >

>+ >@  ) + C %  %  )+ %  %  + +  +=+

;+  8     =   @ + + +1  8% 1    @ +  + +       )8 +

+ +    +   + +

 % +) +  %   + 8+    +  +  &

9  1   7 @ + + +    @ ++ + +)))  8+

+ )B  + ++ @

 % + +  ; 1 8    @ ++ +7     @ ++ + 8    +

+   )B   ;  ))       %     ) 9 

@ +7

9 = @ + 3%  )B +

+ )B ;@ + 

=  8 + )  >)  >) + 9   +@ ++ +    8 +

+ )B   )B8       ) )   )  %  / + + 

&

& 9  "&)12"#'312"#4. 

  8)/) 3   /% %) )  3  &/% + )  +   3% 1+  +  ) =+  )  =+1      %)  =  /%1    8      + +

 +  %    )           + 

                % 1 %  ) =+ + 

; +    8 $ 5 %8 +  *?D

0<< +  &

9  "&)441*2'324"#1      @ +  + +       %    ;  8   %) @ ++ +7

; 8 %)@ +801 3% >+

+ )B8 + ) + 



 +    E@ +7 8

% 9

 % 18+) +  @ + 8 +  )B 8 + )8 )) + E@ + ++)<8      @ + 8 0) )B  )

&

, 6 )7+,@ K. Manjusree v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2008) 3 SCC 512 8  )  8    +)  

+    +     8    +   +            

 ; %@ +6 )   -  :  1   



1

 



  

  ### #' 

  1 ;

### #'    



/   ( "

     < )  =





&& &

 



/#  

"##



  

   ;

  

   *

1  

### #' 

 1

#   



# 



  

    

 >   

5: ??

 ??

  1 1   3? ??5 1 

### #'  1

#   

&  1 ;     

8 ### #'    1 

 

  

 

1

#    1 1 #

 1 #   



#



#

1 

1   

# #*



    

   "  &       

£.5. Ramachandra Iyer v. Union of India, Umesh Chandra Shukla v. Union of India, and Durgacharan Misra v. State of Orissa.

FFF FFF 37 ;

% " 1    8   ### #' 

 

    

  1    1 1   

1 

     1

#  

   

  /

% " 

>    3? ??5

/#  

"##

   

 

    

1

#    1    

  8 ### #'    1 1  



# 

  1 1   1

 *

 *

  ;  

 

  % "  

 

 

###

 

#'    1 # #* -

9  GAnkita Thakur and others Vs. H.P. Staff Selection Commission and others9 2023 SCC OnLine SC 14721    = + )-

 >    

  

 *

8   

 





    #



 @



8       *

    



  #

     

"  ;

" 1 

   

  

 *

8     





    #   1  

 *

  

      1   

     &  1 

  

#

1

* 

 

 

 

 '





#

 

 

#

2 

 



8       *

 

    

"    

*

       8   #

 

8 



  

   

  

+

- ,7+8Tej Prakash Pathak v. High Court of Rajasthan9, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3184, % $.6     ) +  +   +

+  + + ;  - 76    1





1

#A

76 >  #   ## #



   

   

 1  

    B

76 . *

   

 

   

##

 #   



#1



 #    

 > 

#  

     1     



 >  

#  .    



#*



 > 

    



1 



8 /  

5

"     

4*  B

763 ;

  K. Manjusree K. Manjusree v. State of A.P., (2008) 3 SCC 512  1

 1     1 

  )* " ,1 CState of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3 SCC 220 )* " ,1 [State of Haryana v.

Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3 SCC 220]  1 

 

 #

 1  D ,+

[K. Manjusree v. State of A.P., (2008) 3 SCC 512]  1 

 

 

  ;

1  

 1   

  B

765 >  

*  *+



 >  #





 

 * 

 #        

 

 

      4 #  !4* 

  

 

*+

 

  B

766 .

 > 

   





*



 

*

*  

#  

 * (1  1

 

4

     #  

   #

 

B

767  



    *

   #   ;

) 

    #  

 * 

 #



   

    (1     

 

) 

    #  

 * 

 # 

 1 

$

   

 - &*

,++ + 6 )  % +   )+    +

+     +   +  +  +)  )

+   

 

 +  %    > % 

 +   

8 %+ ;

 +  % ++

+  ,   %  +)+  

+

+ + +  8 H+

6  8 %  ++   

+% )  =% &'

9+ -  9  

2 2#

1         @ + + +7 8+8 % ; =@ ++ +1  18   +   + ; @ +

+ ++   %8

 % 

 9



!"

 

!"# &1

8  )  /)     3       /%  8     

 % 1         /%     8  %) /)       &/% 9%8 + 6 ) 1 =+     +  1  )   ) 1 +  +    ;      ) +  3%  ;  +   +  %  9 3%   +8 + +  % 

 + @  ) 1+     6 )        ;     %8    +  6 )   +  + 

=+ +   % 8 9 8 % 1++  %  +    /%3   )  ) ++ 

 9

 &&!'"  "&   

1       8 )@ +7

 ;  %+ ) 8 ) =@ + )+

&!

;  1  )+  )1  +  ) 

08 $ 5 %  I%  6 ,  0  ) 1+  +    /%) 0 '#D 9 %  1 =   /%

.

.61

, %++

   I%  8  /)   /%1 +    *?D 0)

I% +    '#D 0   /%  ;%  +  1    +  0 /% 9

+1@ A/) A     ++  I%  

+% 0

&"

980% +  )1  +             %          ++ )   

&?

 )+   

'

  (,3.J,7,,< % (I/3E

  >0) 5

   5