High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9149/2022dismissed

Baldev Singh Sandhu v. Union Of India And Others

2022-05-30Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri14 pages

!"#"

$ % !&"#"

'! ()'

" *"*"*) ()'

" *+,**

!" #

$ !

%%%%% "*"*- .-/-01- 2"

" !&&' $ #( $ ) # $ $ * + ) # +, -.

/0 &/&& *

1 23, "

#( ) # ! (

# &

! #(

) # ! ! ! " !! (6 ! ( ! !

# 6

! 8 /'/9:/.9&/-0 ( ! "

!(! # ! ( ( "

# (6 !2 8 ; 7

" "

#( 1$

3-4.-01+"15.

$ 460.174. 28#9:*#"

;

( # ) # " (

1 $ ,$../- $;<+"'.- -4=1 5-0)4 "-

4. 28>>9*&?'@*4- A <44$ 1- ")4 "

+"1 1.+- 4. 289*8)7*9: -B4"'"

-$0 4. <+".- -40 '1 )4 "289&*:C"

< # ! "#

! !

2 # $ ! !" #

! ! !

" !

" !!

( ! $ $ !*$ ! $ = , -:'>* +-:'> , " (!

#! ! "

1 " # !

((! 71

! ( ( 1 " #" 1!

1 "

#2 &0 -0-:'> " !!

( # 2 # /> -/ &/-&*

1 2-, #

& !

# !

! ) # !

! "

# /3 /> &/-> *

1 2-', ! !

! >

! " ! ! !#

#( ! ( 7

# 7 !

"(# ( "

! (

! !

" ! #( ) # &.

-/ &/-0*

1 2.,

! (!

" #! ! 1 ( # ! !

" ! 6

! 8 '/9:/.9&/-0 "

( " "! (!

< (

;/ /:

&/-> "

(

! "

" # &/&-"7

#( ! ! ! ! @ " ! !

! ) #

( 7

! ! # ( !

#"7 (

) 2#7 " " @ #

8 $ ;9 9&//>2$ -& /0 &//> ! -;

*&, -;*-,*, $ ! -:.."

! -/: $" #( ! $ 8"? ! $ 8"?

" "7

$ !)1

# ) " !! ! "

( 7 "

! ! ( -::: " $ !

" #(

# !5 #( /- /0 -:::&.

/& &//> ) "

"!5 #( 2 *""

- 41%$0-

6 -%D$1141 3$ 41 "

! (2 ?"7 8"?

A&//;

0 3/ >&/92 &

@ 8 < 0 ( B

) A&//;

-. '> ///92 ;

) ?

3 "* , A&//;

30 &//92

) ?

- " * , A&//;

>> .>/92 >

) ?

* , A&//0 ; -& 00/92

# '

< 8 .03 D 8 7 $ ( ) 7 * , A ! !

-:::

&/ 3- >//92

C "

#( 9 7 ! 8# 7*! ( "

#( , A-:::

;0 ./ >'/92 .

) ?

& " -> " * , A&//0 0 >/ ///92 :

) ?

* ,;

" A-:::

- -. &;>92 -/

) ?

* ,>0

" A -:::

&//- &/ :. ./>92 --

) ?

* ,&

" A&//0 - .0 /0/92 -&

7 * , &3

-& " A-:::

-- :/ .0/ ) - &; 3- ::/92 .

! ! "

" ! #( ( 1 "7 ! ! ! ! " 1 '/ '/ -:/92 @ " ! !! !

7 !

# 7 "( ! # ! # !! "

" ! !!

/> -/ &/-&*

1 2-, -0 -:'> !$

: ! ! # " ! #(#

! #(! !5 /- /0 -:::-0 /0 &//>

) " " 7

( ! ( -.*&, *;, $ $ ! *$ !, -:'0* +-:'0 +,

( ! # ( ( !

# ! ! ;*-,* , -:'0 "

! !!

2 E 41%06%.- 56 -3 -5-1 4*.

1-0 *1 5.

*- .$23311 6 %3-E281%"92 .3 -;- 8 *1 10">C9"

# ! !! !

!)1?

/- /0 -:::

-0 /0 &//> #(#

! #( ! !5 # # ( #

" & >: 0; :&-92 7 "

! !"

# #1

/- /0 -:::-0 /0 &//> # # # # * 2," #

(

( !

C ( -.*&, -.*;, $$*$ !, -:'0 ( !

$ !)1 #

( ( !

# ! #(! ;*-,* , ;*-,* , ;*-,* , $$*$ !, -:'0 -/

( " "

!5 # # ; 30 0; &>392 "

" & >: 0; :&-92 " " 7

-- ( 6 ! ( 8

$ $ ! )1 " /& /:

&/-0*

1 2', ! " (6 ! ) # "

-/ &/-0 *

1 2.,2 E( 6

! ! 75

9>, /& /:

&/-0*

1 9',

(

! ! ! ( !

# $$ ! & 8 ! " -;

-/ &/-0

(D( ! !! !

> # "

&/ -/ &/-0 6 " #( !

# ! " ! ( 1 ! ! ! ( !

! "

) "

! # ;

)(

B ) 7 !

# # # ! !! ! ( ! ! !

1 $$

# !!2 !

! ! # ! ( # ! # ! ! ! (!

1 ( > $

! #" " !

! " 6

" !

! (

! ! (!

1 ( $$

" 1! ! " !2 !

8! F -&

) ) # ! ( !

! ;/ /:

&/-> "

# (

! !1 ( "

( "

# !5 -;

6# ( !

# #( 8 ; -- /& &/&-*

1 2:, !

# ! /3 /> &/->*

1 2-', "#( ! G $ )

2 E.- 5.4 B "

" ! G $

# #( !

( !!

B B B "2 @ (

- -:::

-0 &//>( !!

!)1? D

!! ($ ! )1 # ! !5 (

( !2!!

# "

" ( 7 "

! ! & >: 0; :&-92 "

( ! ! ( !! #( ! !! ! ! ! ! -;

*,*," -;*&, $

! -:.. "

H ! $

! ( ( !!

B B B

9 ( ( !2!!

! !

! ! ! ! -;*,*," -;

*&, $ ! -:.. "

" ! ! 5 !( #

( !!

( #(

2 " ( !2!!

#(! ! # ! -/: $" ! -;*, *," -;*&, $ ! -:.. "

H ! $

#( ! ( # !!

# #( $ # !

*B "

", ! G $

# 3 > &/-> $ ! !

# 1 !!

# ( (

*B "

", ! G $

# 3 > &/->F -0

##( ) # -:>!

" ;& # 1 ';" (#1 33!

! !

2 !

#( ! $ " " ("

2 ! "

" #

" ! !

! ( !

# ( ( !

# ! !

! !

! ! $ "-0/1 ,$3- *.- 3-+" (;0 $ F-;-

- <- -15.$ 424.

$5. 514 - -0- - 4. 8&9*#"

(" "

( ! ! *! ,"

"# " !#

" # ! " 7

# ! #( !

! ( ! "( ! !

!7 -3 # " 1 $ !,$../- $;<8$B -9

!7 (

! <

$ !

# #( $ #"

!-B4"

'" -$0 4. <8$B -9 ( # ! # !" ! #

!( !

! !

I ( "!5

( " " ! 5 # ! (!

" !!

! !! ( # !" ! -.

! '@*4- A <44$ 1- ")4 "

8$B -9"

(

! 1$

*4-46 -F-4.- +"","' -2:89*CC2 " ( !

! # !

<" 7

" ! $ 1! ! (

! ( ! ! $ ! ! !

1 ( " ! ! ! "

( (" # #! -:

4 ! ("

! !!

#" "

# (#( $ ) " ! # ## (

7 ! (

! ) #

( !

! ! #! !

& &/

1<- +1 <-0-<- *- 5-4.- 7 4. "* 1 1 -2 *C2 <

$ ) # (

" 2!

! ) 1$ !

!! ! ! # (!

( ! ! ! (

( # ! ! "

( (

" !!

( ( ! (!

(! &-

! *4-4- =6 1-- 4. +"

0-3-5- - 4. 28:9*2 # " 1$ "

1$ 1 11 -0 4 00 2,- -4-=- * +"'""+144-0 -289*" G 1$ B4'- -5 2 .

- .*4-4

- - B 4 -41 +"'.

$$6'1<-74. C*&2 ! "

(

" ! ! ! # ! ! 1 ( ! ! !( # !

! ( #( <

$ "!

)

! "

" ! 7

! ! # ! "

# (

) ! !! "7 #! !"

# #

7 )

#"#" ! "

! ! &;

( "

8"*"*)9 '-<&2 8+,**

9 A98 # A98