← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/31453/2017disposed of

New Nehal Pesticides And ANR. v. Rehal Agro Chemicals

2022-12-06Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages

202 (2 cases)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH (1) CRM-M-31453-2017(O&M) NEW NEHAL PESTICIDES, VILLAGE BAKSHIWALA, TEHSIL AND DISTRICT PATIALA THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR BIKRAM SINGH AND ANOTHER

...Petitioners

Versus

REHAL AGRO CHEMICALS, NABHA ROAD, BHADSON DISTRICT PATIALA THROUG ITS PARTNER GURPREET SINGH

...Respondent

(2) CRM-M-31640-2017 (O&M) DATE OF DECISION: 06.12.2022 NEW NEHAL PESTICIDES, VILLAGE BAKSHIWALA, TEHSIL AND DISTRICT PATIALA THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR BIKRAM SINGH AND ANOTHER

...Petitioners

Versus

REHAL AGRO CHEMICALS, NABHA ROAD, BHADSON DISTRICT PATIALA THROUG ITS PARTNER GURPREET SINGH

...Respondent

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :

Mr. Bikram Choudhary, Advocate for Mr. Hardeep Singh, Advocate for the petitioner(s) (in both the cases).

Mr. Vikas Mehsempuri, Advocate for the respondent.

HARSH BUNGER, J.

   

              

  

   

                  

          !    !

   "  #        $%& %$'( )   "   *"  *       

    +!,-(. ''/.$'    

 

    +!,-(. '' .$'   "  $'%& %$'"    +  0 ( 1+0(2 

     $&%$ %$3( )  /    *"   

  +0(         

  

         %3%  %$4 ( )  

    

"  *"    *    

       $%& %$' ( )     $&%$ %$3 ( )   /  "  * (

5 "

 6                   7 

 ( ! 

 

 

   +0(

       

    

       

 

                 



     

               

     "     

  %$%  %$   /$%/ %$'  %$%  %$'  /$%/ %$3 0          

      

  

 

*      

   8$ 9 :  " *     *" 

 

 "           *"   !    +%%%%$/    '%3 %$'     7 %"%%"%%%.

 !   +%%%%$     &%3 %$'  

    7 "%%"%%%.

   ;<=! 6 #" 

"       

 

 ( +'% %%%%4 %33&4 ;  "  

        "       -    $4% %$'  $&% %$'"    * (           - "     

     

    3% %$'   "      

*        

  :  *" 

   

 

 +0("       ( 

  

#  

      $%& %$' ( )      

  *   5

-  0!

"

"         $/  +0("    

,       $%& %$'

  *   5

 -   0 !

" 

"  

     > 

             

                  !

  "#$"%&#  "% %% %%%'( )  &       *   *  *  *     &+%,"%&# )  " *   -   . /          "$%,"%&# )  0 *                )  1 2               !

 *     *           /   

 *  

& 3  4 5         ) 

&'

-                 

     ' &0,   6 

  &,,&                 

   7     

   +&%"%&#         * 5-

'8  *  *.  

 " 

  

         "      +0(          " *

  * 

 

:

   $&%$ %$3( )  /        $%& %$'( )   

     +0("         $&%$ %$3 ( )   /"        

   

 *   * * 

           !   (

 5 "

 ;  "                  %3%  %$4 ( ) 



 * (

5 "

 

                *  

   ! ?

                                $%& %$' ( )  

 * 5

-  0!

"

" 

   %3%  %$4( ) 



 * (

 5 "

"    *   "    0     

# 

   "     *      $/     +0 (                  *    :     "  

    )     " 

   ( *"    *      $&%$ %$3( )  /     * 

"           *    

 ( )  $"    +0( ,      "

                          

  *  

*     @          $%& %$' ( )   

  *   5

 -   0 !

"

"

                   



    )       !@$ A   "

   7 

 ( ! 

     *   "      



 

   

 >     













      

 !"

  #  #  #  #!#!$%$ $%$ $%$ $%$!& & & &'   ( 

) !"

  #  #  #  #!#!$% $% $% $%!& & & &'

  *   +,  

     +  

-

- . - 

 -

.

/0



  1 *     &) "

  #  #  #  #!#!$%$ $%$ $%$ $%$!& & & &'     ()"

 #  #  #  #!#!$% $% $% $%!& & & &' $ $ +,  *  ,2, 

   ) +

  

2  2

+

"

  ' % % 3

, + 0          *!@$

A   "

    7 

 ( ! 

   

 

B)!@$.( 

       "   

 !      

    +0(0    

 

      

    

   

        " 

        $%& %$'  

 "          $&%$ %$30 )   

 7 

! 

*               !           :   "      

* 

 *    ( *"  *  

     0     

     

      

#           *

           

* 7 

!     > 9 4         &,9"%&#        *          !

  !

             4                     *       (  *           *                   *  

            /          *          *   

 * *           *     (    :' &0,  6              *         

            ;*       !

   

            *               &,9"%&#             <  &% 4      &9&"%&$        *                    *   (                   * <             &,9"%&#          (  *    - 

           !

    *       *     *                       <         '   *   

   <              <       /       &9&"%&$              <     

           <  &&

 *        

                       *    <            5.

( 

     )   

 * 7 

!                $%& %$' ( )           :      "             :         

      "    

      

    B)!

        *!@$ A  

"

  7 

(! 

 

 B)!@$.( 0   

  

          " -  "  "       

  

                    0



        "   -    

*    

    C       ;2     !         

 ! "  #

$ $%  "    > $       4                                 *     /      !

           *   

  &  '  '  ( )   *#

$   $% 

+

$ '  / *  *      =       !

        *   *        *              *      *> /        

            

     ?@       A   *              * 

  * *          A  4 B 

                        2    !

   *                                .

?)   @ ( 

    $%& %$'( )  

 *   5

 -   0 !

" 

"         

!  #      



   

 " 

       

   C               $&%$ %$3( )  /  "   

" !                                   $%& %$'( )     +0("  *"    

 * 

!     $&%$ %$3( )  /          +      ( *" 0    *                      *   

 ." *"

    (  *       

              December 06, 2022 (HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No Whether reportable:

Yes/No