← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/16/2022dismissed

Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/S Sangrur Industrial Corporation Ltd. And Another

2022-05-10Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi10 pages

 

    

    

  !"#"$%&'&

($) *+

, --.-

"$/ 0 

1#+ $2-(-$0(# -"

3-.-

"$/ 0&$-    %  4/ & + + +  4/ & +++        ++5&  

 !

"   

#$#%%#%&

!'  (

) "   "

*++

*

,  - !       ./  0*    &$$1 !' *2  "      -     %3#4%#&5     !'     6   * * "  ! +

  !

 *2

& +'    "

+  

 

- 

  

- 

  

 +'    - 

!-   7    +  !-   "  "'+   ' '+   +' *      

  

  +'-   +  

   ('  '+    +         '  ,

8  "&$$. 9      &$$.:,  

     4

' ""  "



"+    

    !'*2- -+ -

  ! !'*2 ; 

 -  +     

  

<"

+ =

!-       -  !'*29;:

 +'    +!    -  %&3%##4            +    !'    

+'""

!'  -   +'      ./  ' "  "  + " - - "  +  +'    

"+ 

+

6   * 

 (  ( + ,

 !* "          -      

  +     +  

(+ %##19   

- ( %##1: 6   "+&4&%%#&.!    

 !'   +' -  -    + "  -    %&3%##4

!'  -  + -

,

'6   * 

 

+  +

(+ %##1 + 

- 7 *2    ;  

      "+    &4&%%#&.



!' (

) " ! >?!

 > "*

   &44%#&5

 67%114 %#&/ >?!> "*

 "+&4&%%#&.

!'

 (

) "  ' -         !  * 7!

 

!+  .##/%#&5-  -   "  

 

+  ,(    *   

    -   

.4#531.#< .##/%#&5"-     %&35@ - +' - &5%#&5   A   ""

  !'      -     *2         ./  0*    &$$1 + " "  - -   +    !   +

  !'   + " "+%/#%%#%& 8      *      *2     "

    

                    +< + 

     %9:304  %##1 

!- "'   

 +< !'

*

!- 9  *  *2

 

  * +<  +'    (  * + +'    '

+ '   - +'-  

  '        304  :    *

!--

 +  + +'!

 

 !'

 + +' 

 

!+ !'*2!

     !- +

 " 

        ;,   *   

  

*

!-"

  +!

 !

  !'

 "   !'+ " - " "   !   '   ,-     +  

< +  +'- -   +      !-   ,  -   '   "

      *

 !-             ' "    9*       , :      ,     ('  '+    &$$.<( %##1  !' '+

+   B  *   + " 6 ;   "

  - !  =+    ./  *    -    C67& ..3"!

"$  -  #

"$2  #"0 -*"

- 3  , -0   



 





        





 









  

    

   





  







    



 

 

 



 

  !





   

 







 



    









 





"

 

 



 



 "

#  

   

 



  

  



    $



 

  !





 



"     



 













 



    

  



$

"





  

 

   

  

  

   



 











 





 

 







 









%

& "





  

 









  



  

  



 











   



 

 











   



$

"

    











   





    



 



 

 



 



 

 

 "  



&

  

 





 

    



  





    



&

$ 

 









#



 

    



  









 

  



    







  

 

 

    '







(



"  

  



 





  

 

 

    '  



  ! 



  



        

 "

 

  )*

  +$  



 

"   

  

  '  $

 



 

 

 

   

   #





  (



"   





 

  



"   

  

  '  

  





" 

  



    



 

  









    

  



  





 

  

 







  

" 

  



  

  

  



 %

& "





 

  





   

   

  



 

   

 

  "  7 =+    +  -  -

  

!  9%:  ./  -  !

 '"

 +  

! 

9:9!:

!

  9%: "

   

!  %  ./

 ,         *2      - +   '    - "       +      "

,     

" - -  



!'



  -      35  4& 

&$$1    -      -  !

  +  ' 

 ' + 

    *2 !    +  +

 

' 

   ( %##1  -   

    "

+ + <  +'   +

 +' -  + ,    + "   (     %##1    < +   +'  "   

"

    "

 D#.<&1<&%<##%54 

! +,8  -    &49/:

* 

  '    8   *         "

    

+ <  +'    

 

      '+ -             -    

+  "      ''+,-   "

  !  '

  !'*  !',(

 9 B         !'  *  "

  + +'



 '+-    -   

+  "  ''+     

- -!'>E!=*

   1# (-* $!;

*3 # $0$0(!

-# < / 0&<#&## =+

3 !

-"!"

> -0 $0

$ ;

-8+7+'!+-    !" 







" 

    

"

  

  

       



  " 

 ,-,./











 



  

 



  



 









    





 "     

     

B    +   

! "   !'*2  '   

 



  '  (   +! " !

'   +   &1 (  : ,- !  "   - !'

  >?!    =  *

   +

  

) # ;

$  <#&  (-"

==($"!

"$=.

$>/ 0 $0 $ ;

-::7+79'<"? <"?

;

#!.

 "$

- - $!

*>(- #($0 -# !

"$67  ;

-*"

-

"$ !

     

    C



0 

 #









 

 

   

 "        

     



     

 









 

 

 

   

- 0         0   

 

 

" 

    











  



   



'

 1

   

 

 

 









  

 







 



  

  



 

" "   



 ."  









 

 



  

 

"   " 

!

 



 

 

 

 

 

   

      "



  



 



!

  "  #    

    . 

 



     



 





  

   

 

 

 

 

  

    

 

   

  





     



 





 

 





   



       

  F +   - ! 

& &+;

;5+;

- #+ !@-@ -# / 06A -#(#&&&+ !(-"

"

#  /"="

0 7 "<"3568:5+(.- = (-  $0"

 

"$ 3  "2;, >#  ( ;-"

>    $0"

 <#&   = $

"$  $0"

 / ''+!

''7  -   !

          -          !

  !'  

"  

  "  -  ! "' "

+   ./9%:  0*     &$$1  ,    *

 -   +

( %##1D     +     ./9%:%    !  !+     -     "   "  ! "

 

 

!+ !' * + +'- '

  !   

 

 -  -   +   +- 

 

! *2G - !  -  ' 

 

!+ !'*2  7 +!

 !      !- "'

 +'!  >?! =  *

    *      4//%4//.    %#&1 1#  +;

$ "

$0(!

-# / 0 $0 ;

-#<#&## =+

3 !

-"!"

> -0 $0

;

-#   , (''+  -  '

  +   ++ +    %..&$$%   +   !   

+  !  

   6

 - 

 "!    

 ./  !' * + +'

"       "   -     %&3%##4  

  !'          (

) " &4&%%#&. - - "  !     !-    +    !

 - 

 !'*2- 

  "  &4&%%#&.!  *

    "  "

  - " +!

'

 ' '+ !'   +'!

   

   -  

  +             +  -  

          !  -   ' " ! 



 +,   ' !'!    - - ! ' 

' 

  +  '



 -   ' ' '+-   !'

, !   !'-   

   +! '

 

 -  

 

 +'-  



   + " !   !'  

  - 

!'

,(*'- - 

 6 ,   -       +   

         -  !'>E!E=*

-   +       +

 ++ + +    >5 '

"#$#$%&$'

()%$& $* +$&),

"#$#$%%$ %-$ +$&),