Ranjit Singh v. State Of Punjab



  
        
     

!

"#$#%& '( ( 



   


  
&

 )* (+
 +  +



 

  !"#$  %#&'((#

 ) "*  &( '*!"#$   +

----- +  +

, ( .

&((%('((#%#, (%(!,*&'((#/(&0 !#

 ((0##%
# 12!

!.3 1415!$(#1.61267.682#%  $#($0 ! *$&##'($, $$ .982 &( %,(0 %!# : ;#*  #($ (# (!&/  (($ <!&( 

(%* (0&% $ 0(0%# $#! & &
#%&($ 

(#,(0 &( $#%< )&"((0& /&#& !'#!&  #.3 1415  ,#43=4

 /&&/   !(0 

#%'#($ #%%($(  !'!%#'

#(0!* #&, (#% ('>#%%0(",*

( ,#$ &'((#/  ''&!! !%# &('#(#=44 0

#% #(/ $#"!

(&$ #%&'#$(#& ' # ,#"> (#!

$#"*&?(('%#(@ ! (0#%$# ! !%#

#%& $$!/'%# ! !%&("(0 (# )'

=

!

&$#!& ,'!$ %*

%  &'($('0#"(0& 0  #%, (( $   !# $ !#$#"*#%$#

$( ? (*#%$#

$#$! &'($(' (!!#/,*& A#(& #% :#&!

( B  ("

 ;CA#%&(D 141=AA <(A=21 "

 /&(& A#& &!&  0 #%, (# $$##%!! *(( $ #, (!#,%!

!$(#>=3#%& $ 0("&( ' ("#%$(#5=7> /&($&( ''($ ,##%%$!&$

&(0 !(( #"

# (#&& & #;, ' (&$ #%: 

!#&"

 #% E0 ; '$( < " ((#CA( D# 8727#%141=!$(!!# .5 141= !:
,(  ) &"

 #%!(& ; 141=AA(A..49 F!!&,%(#%, (#& $$! /&#& !,($ !%#

'(#!#%

#1>=*  !&( / ()*# )$#(! ,(

& ,#"> (#!,%(& ,0(",*#,"(0& '##0!

($ (#0 * ((  (& #'$(#%!

 (0& 0  !!($>1.#%&A#((#  !($& ( (# & $#((# '($(' #"(!& #* 0#$# (!! $(#>=3#%& $

 !!((## ,#" ( $*'##$!"!($(&$  #%  : #& 

/        #%  A&& (&0 &  G   ;  A(   ''

# 588=61412 & #,"!& (0##% $(#=3#% $/(#, , %#$#(!(0&$ #% 



$$!%#, ( ($# /(& $#!((#& &'#$(#/#!' %#  *$# '(##%(

& ,#"> (#!$ & #;, ' &!& '' /&#/ ,(0'#$!%# ,(0('#(##%$#

$( ? (*#% $#($, $ / (!

%#, (("(/#%&($ (#%# '(#!#%.9 #&

( ( *( #&$ ( (&$ #%: ! 

( "

A  #%"(0 (#;C1411D.4AA2.'##0!($ (#

!(#!( ! *0 0!& (##%& A##% !( /&($&$#(!!&$#$ ''# $&#/ !, ( /(&'$# "  $  ($!(0$(#=3 $ & A# #% !(  F'! & #'((#&  $(# 5=7#% &A(

#$!A#! .93=H/&($&?(( ( & $$!#, 0!# ((%&( (#$#$!!/(&('$(%(!'(#!I/#! ''*($& 

&$ #%:

( & B

"  #%
+ & ;

A( '' # 59..#%1412 /(&0 !#$#"*#%$#

$(

? (*#% $#($, $& $$#!!

&,%(#%, (#& $$!("(/#%'##0!($ (#%#

'(#!#%41*  !48 #&#%& $$!

.4

&( ( ,%(& , )( #& '' ( <

# .2799>1412(! :

, &( B, &(  " & #%E 0 ; !(&$ #%:

&# " A& !(0 &;A(

'' # 5831#%1412

..

&$ #%:

 ++

G 6& #%E 0 ;< CA D# =11.#%141= &,%(#%, (& , $$#!!,*

- & #  $$! /&#/ %#!(& '#(##%..2,##%'&!* ,*#,"(0& >

D &'((#/ ($#!*%# '(#!#%#*  !&

#&J ,D &("(0 (#(& $ / $# ' !$& 0>&& !

,%(! ,$& 0/*#,%

!J $D &$#$(##%( /#! )# ( J !D &'((#& !#$( $!

  "(/  #%  ,#" (#!  '"

((0  % $#  (  &   , #,"!,*& & &(, (

$# '( $#%$(#>=3#% $

.1

( ( * (&$ #%: #!

B,& *#!

6 & #%E0 ;< CAD# .13886141= & A##%!( %%#!!&,%(#%, (#& $$! /&#/ %#!( '#(##%.4 444 #%$#!('&#'&   !/ ($#!*%# '(#!

#%# ! & %*  ,*$#(!(0& $#$(##%( /#! )#0 ( .=

' #%$#!&#/& (&'$  %##/(0  &"

% $#/&($& ?(!#, )(#$#(! (# %#

!$((#> (D &'((#(  !*($#!*%# '(#!#%

#41 * J ((D &(#$( $!#%&'((#J (((D &( ( )(0'

$ #/ '

$ ##% /" '#$(#/( #*#& ,F

(!#% J ("D &!(##%'((#(+!($( #$)>'(#()*# " *%''#J

"D &(#&(0#$#!#&#/& (% !#, ( & '((# 

*  

'  /(&  &  "(!$  #  (%$  & /(J "(D &(#&(0#$#!#&#/& (% !#, ( & '((#/(#$#>#' 6'

($('

(&(

.5

&'$  &'($('#% / (!!#/,*& #;, ' A#(&$ #%:  

" #%   !&

#&; C14.8D=AA11  "

 /&((& ,#,"!& K

%!

   '#   #%  $(   +('!$  (  &  ' '(#  #% (#$$  (0&,*& '#(,("!#,(#$(%#! 0(* #/" & ( $(#$( //& "# & ,'

$!#  $$!/(&0 !## '$(%($#%%$,& (

#&

 !!##! $%# &%!

 '# ('$ #%#&#%%$ L #&( '# % $#%#$( +('!$( &0 #%, ((&0  !'(0 '#(+ (#(

'(##( $#$(#&# C/&($&"F'(##

*/(&#D(

F$'(# %# * # #%&, ($'($(' '' #& " ,#(0&#%/(&&& # ! #'# ,(0 ($ ! !%##0'(#! &(!##!# *0##!##$(

+('!$####$(* &(#!#,& &0 #!( #% (((*&!($(##%&+!0$#(!(0 $ ,"# & F$(#%+!($( !($(#& ,$($ $(,!,* 0 ,#% !$((#!!,*&(A# !,*"* (0&A#(&$#* L #$$ (# *&( $(*#(#'$/&&!*(0, (# 

$$!'#(&(0&&(0#!##&% $ !(&$($  $#%

$ M

 .2

&'($(' (!!#/,*& #;,&' A##% !( (&$ #%: ! 

( A  #%"(0 (#

!  #&;  C1411D  .4  AA  2.    #  "

  (  &(  $     &

,#" (#!$  (& ,#,"!& K& #%$#"($(#( $( $ (!( ( ,*

*#/  '' #& &(% $#/(0& #& (!#%&A#/&(!$(!(0&, ( ''($ (#( 0 ("  A#!#&()& &'#(,((*#% $#"($(#,(0 #  (* , ( ''($ (#/(& "#,!$(!!($* $# *#0

'($(' E$ # (F'$#(! (##% , ( ''($ (# /&($&(# '(("( /(&& #% '#(, !+!($ (#,*/ *#%(

& $# *  (

 $?( /(&$#(!$#!*/#!, $ #%0 " (+($M

.7

$*  (  &  $   #%  : '

  

 

(       #% A&& (0 &; 1412AA(A=11 &

& #,"!& K(%  $$!(#0 %( "!($ %($ (##% (F#"* (+ (  !( '(# & !%((* ($#!,  (!& &((0&#& " '!*( !($1.#%&A#((# & ,(%(0!M &  #,#,"!,*& A# #%!( (& ,#" (#!$ & K! * , !%#& $$! F *, !%#&"($(  %#!( #$(* !%#&$!(,((*#%# +($* /&($&("

!

!0 &

#%&(A###  &A( #$!A#!'#"(!

*##%#&!0#( #!#& $ '#$!%%($(*M

.3

&%# #$(!

%& &(A#($#$(##%&, ($

!  %!

   '($('  #%  /  &   (0&  #  '!*  (   (   '

  #%

.

 # ,  % (  !  +  '#$!  &(!  !  ($  1.  #%  & A#((##%!(

&($#((# (0&$ #,!(!#& $$!



!,* #;,'F$#(K /(!(0&" #%

+ , !#&M 1415AA(A5=25

.8

%  &  $  ("  %%$  #%    &  ,#" (#!  % $# ("#"!(&( $  ( )(#$#(! (# ( !# $#$(# &'((#((!%#&,%(#%, (  !& &''((# !"#, #/!

.9

$$#!(0* /(&#$#

(0 *&(0#& (#%&  &''((#(&,* //0 !

&'((#(&,*#!!# , !#, (#%(&(0'# ,#! !*,#!CD#&  (% $(##% !( A# #/"& ,#" (!$#$(#& , ,+$#%##/(0$#!((#> C(D   &  '((#  &   #  !($*  #  (!($* 

)  * (!$  & #'# (# *'# $? (!/(&& % $#%&$  # #!( !&( #!($#$&% $#& A### *#& &#(* C((D & &'((#& &( #%F$(##%,#! %(& & !!#&A#$#$! !& #(%*&$& 0(

!!#&( A# (&%( !$((##%&( J C(((D & &'((#& # "!( /(&#'(#' ((# #%&( A#

1+  +

2

 '( ( 
 E&&' )(06 #!

L6# E&&'# , L6#