High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32449/2016dismissed

S.K. Bahl v. State Of Punjab

2016-11-21Mr. Justice Krishna Murari13 pages

!!"#$#%&'!()!* +

,-./ 0 ! # #%!* 1$ , ! 2%3) 0 !$4%5!% & 67 ,,

*!$!% & *1#8*(.25.*#+,*5'" !9# . *,,#//+5'" !+* .!4! # #%!* .!4! # #%!*.$$2:. .!;2$.#%:*5!*5 !52/<+

4$$!5)<,4!"#/2* + 24%:*#%"$! =5 !5,!4 !()!* +

2%5!*,!" #%$ + >+ ?+= +>

+ %5,!" #% @ A @5A *!5 9# . ,!" #% @A .! *!'!% #% **24 #% " *!:#$ !*!5 /#"! , #% 1#:#/%"! 2*!2+ 725.#%+ 5#$(#$$#%: .! 44/#" #%2%5!*,!" #%* 4*<#%:*5#$".*:! .!4! # #%!* %5 * "//#%: 24% .! 4*$!"2 #% :!%"< 5(# * 5!%< .! :!%2#%!%!$$ .! 5"2(!% $ (!% #%!5 #% .! 44/#" #% #/!5 )< .! 4! # #%!* //!:#%: . .! $2)3!" ( !* .! "*#(#%/ 4*$!"2 #% #$

(!*!/< "$! "#'#/ % 2*! %5 .! .$ )!!% *!:#$ !*!5 9# .2 "%$#5!*#%: '*#2$ #(4* % "#*"2($ %"!$ %5 5"2(!% $ "2(!% $+ "4#!$ 9.#". .'! )!!% 44!%5!5 $ %%!B2*!$ 9# . .! 44/#" #%+%54*<!*9$(5! . 4*$!"2 #%:!%"<(<)!"//!5 24% 5(# .!$#55"2(!% $%5%"%$#5!* #%$#55"2(!% $+ .!""2$!5(<)!5#$".*:!5 .!//9#%:5"2(!% $*!$2:. )!5(# !5*5!%#!5&

#$% & # '( )(* +,

0-.

- -.

1+ ( 2/ 3(*

-.-

-0-

(

( 6

* -

-4-

-4 -

-*.-

5 -

/ - ( --

. " "

/ -

/ -- " .0-

. "

/ -.

-*-

/ -0

" "

/ -* (

-4

---

/ -5 $

/ '

/ -

/ - 3 8

-- 0

/ .

*-- 0 2 9 :2

/ . 3 " 3 33" 2 3 9 :2

3 ;

/ C .! *!/!'%"< * 5(#$$#)#/# < .! *!$#5 5"2(!% $ * .!#*"%%!" #%9# . .!//!: #%$#% #$% #(4* % $ .!"$!#$ 4*!".*:!$ :!9.!% .!".//%.$/*!5<)!!%#/!5)< .!4*$!"2 #% 7!*%!5$!%#*"2%$!/* .!4! # #%!*.$4/"!5*!/#%"!% .!325:(!% .#$2* #%

!"# #$

% !& + ?= @ A @*/A#%9.#". 4*!".*:!$ :!%""2$!5#%"*#(#%/ "$!*:!*<.54/"!5%*!"*5"!* #%5"2(!% $*)!#%:"%$#5!*!5 4*!".*:! $ :! 8#%: #% "%$#5!* #% .! 4*'#$#%$ $ "# !5 #% ,!" #%* #%"% !B ,!" #%* +# 9$.!/5 . % ""2$!5.$: *#:. 4*52"!5"2(!% $%5"//24% .!4*$!"2 #% 5(# * 5!%< .! :!%2#%!%!$$ .! 5"2(!% $ 8#%: #% "%$#5!* #% .!$"4!,!" #%%5,!" #%* +# 9$.!/5 $//9$&

' 8 "3 3 ! " "" 3 "

" "

2 " !

2 <

"" "< ; 3 "

3 "

" 3

3 "" !

2 "

3 "

3 8"

2 "

2 2 " 0 ; 2 3"

3 "

!"#$% &'$%( &$"' "

" -03 ; 33""3 ! " "

" !2 3

" " 2

" 8

3 >

< 9 )"*% +

,-%" **-./*!0$"(, "

" -. 3

! <

32 2 "" " "

," =

2 / 2

3 "

" -03 2 <2

3""

3 " " 3

3 "

3 ""

2 "" " " "

3 " 2 " " "

3 "

" -0

; 2 ! " /

" " "

" 3 !

" ? !

3 !

" " 3"

2 2 " 3 ! 3 3"

8 " 3 33

3 2 3

( 3 < " @ "

3 33

" -03

" !

3 " " 2

3 "

" 2 " 2 2 " " 3

3 " 3

3 "" "

" -.3 3 32 A !* (8#%: )'! $#5 )$!*' #%$+ .! ""2$!5 9$ 4!*(# !5 4*52"! 4*!".*:! $ :! .! 5"2(!% $+ 2* .!* 5#*!" #%: . .! /#$ .!$! 5"2(!% $ 92/5 )! .%5!5 '!* .! 4*$!"2 #%: 4/!5!*%5 . .!92/5)!:#'!%%44* 2%# < !$ )/#$."% " 9# . .!#%'!$ #: #%::!%"<%5 .!"(4/#%% *9# %!$$!$#%*5!* 5(# * 5!%< .! :!%2#%!%!$$ !". $2". 5"2(!% %5 92/5 % .'! .! !!" 5! !*(#%#%: .!;2!$ #%*!/!'%"<!".5"2(!% .!4*! ".*:!$ :!* %<$2)$!;2!% $ :! *1#8*(.25.*#+/!*%!5$!%#*"2%$!/* .!4! # #%!* /$*!/#!524% .!325:(!% !/.##:.2* #%)$$ "# #$ *++

>@>A @*/A

+9.!*!#%"!* #%5"2(!% $) #%!5)< .! ""2$!52%5!* " 9!*!% 4!*(# !5 )!4/"!5%*!"*5 .! #(!

, .!*#%: % .! 4#% ".*:! *!/<#%: 24% - . !/$- ! " 0 & # !

$- !+

+./5#%: . # "%% )!$#5$% )$/2 !4*4$# #% . 2%5!*%"#*"2($ %"!$"% .!2* /8#% .! ( !*#/4*52"!5)< .!5!!%"! .! #(!*(#%:".*:!$+ .2:. .#$ $.2/5 )! 5%! #% '!*< **! "$!$+ 9.!*! $2". ( !*#/ "%'#%"#%:/< !$ )/#$. . .!9./!4*$!"2 #%'!*$#%#$ //<)$2*5+4*!4$ !*2$* "%"" !5 ! /$ 4/"!5 *!/#%"! % .! 325:(!% 5.< *5!$. #:. 2* #% 1 "2 3! "

2!/ "# / " # #$

> @A D= +9.!*!#% .!*5!**(#%:".*:!$:#%$ .!""2$!5.5)!!% $! $#5!*!;2#*#%: .!2* /8#% .!5"2(!% $4/"!5%*!"*5)< .!""2$!5 .'! .!*5 /!*%!5 $!%#* "2%$!/ * .! 4! # #%!* %5 "%$#5!*!5 .! "% !% #% . .! 5"2(!% $+ "4#!$ 9.#". .'! )!!% 4/"!5 % *!"*5 $ %%!B2*!$ $.2/5 )! 4!*(# !5 )! 5(# !5E 5!%#!5 )< .! 4*$!"2 #% :!%"< %5 .! ""2$!5 $.2/5 )! 5#$".*:!5.!5! #/$ .!//!: #%$:#%$ .!4! # #%!*+$4!* .!

%5 .! ( !*#/ *(#%: 4* .! *!4* 2%5!* ,!" #% = @A * *! % (2". *!/!'%"! )2 # #$ $2#"#!% )$!*'! . .! //!: #%:#%$ .!4! # #%!*#$ . .!"%%#'!59# . .!*"""2$!5 %5 .5 5!/#)!* !/< $!% /$! *!4* 9# . (/#5! #% !% #% *!:*5#%: "%$ *2" #% % .! $# ! 9.#". *!$2/ !5 #% .! 9#'#%: .! %% "%$ *2" #%!! .! %)B<#% .!<!*

.! 4! # #%!* .5 !*/#!* #/!5 4! # #% * ;2$.#%: .! 4*"!!5#%:$)2 $#54! # #%)!*#%:

9$5#$(#$$!5 $9# .5*9%%4*#/?+

9# ./#)!* < .!4! # #%!* *#$!// .! 4/!$ %44*4*# !$ :!#%"/25#%: .!$ :!"%$#5!* #%".*:!$ , * $ .! "% !% #% /!*%!5 $!%#* "2%$!/ * .! 4! # #%!* . 4*'#$#%$ ,!" #% * !%)/#%: % ""2$!5 4*52"! 5"2(!% $ * 5(#$$#% * 5!%#/ #$ "%"!*%!5+ #$ ""!4 )/! $ ,!" #%* //$2%5!*.4 !*FF5!/#%:9# . .!!'#5!%"!#% #%;2#*!$%5 *#/$ *!5$$//9$&

" -0 BC -.- #+--.-.1*" -1 *D E

3 2 3 2 " "" " 3

2 " " "" " 2

3 " "" 3 2 "

3 """

- 3"

2 "3 "

2 2 %!

. E

3 "

2 !

33 3

C 2-" "

" 2 !

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

!4""$!@$24*A.5.!/5 . %""2$!5"%)!4!*(# !5 4*52"!5"2(!% $ 4*!".*:!$ :! .!4!B2* #% -. !/$- !4""$!@$24*A.$.!/5 . #%**! "$!$ 2* "% /8 #% .! ( !*#/ )< .! 5!!%"! # .! ( !*#/ "%'#%"#%:/< 5!(%$ * ! . .! 9./! 4*$!"2 #% '!*$#% #$ //< )$2*5+4*!4$ !*2$*"%"" !5+)2 .!4!B2* #%# #$

5!"" "$6$ ! . #23 2+@

>A ,> ?.$.!/5 . .! #(! *(#%:".*:!$* .! #(! 8#%:":%#H%"!+ .!""2$!5"%% )!4!*(# !5 4*52"!%<( !*#/$ .! *#/2* .$%32*#$5#" #%

//9 .! ""2$!5 4*52"! %< 5"2(!% .! $ :! *(#%: ".*:!$ )2 %/< !B"!4 #% "*'!5 2 9$ . # #$ #:. 2* #% .! !B!*"#$! 49!*$ 2%5!* ,!" #% ? * %5 * #"/! .! %$ # 2 #% %5#+ 9.#". "% #% .! #% !*!$ 32$ #"!+ 4!*(# .! 4*52" #%5"2(!% $## #$%!"!$$*< 4*!'!% .!)2$!%<2* * .!*9#$! $!"2*!!%5$32$ #"!%'#!9 .!325:(!% #%$6$ ! . #2 3 24" "$! @$24*A+ 9.#". 9$ 5!/#'!*!5 #% .! <!*

>+ .! 325:(!%

!4" "$! @$24*A $ %5$ '!**2/!5 $ $2". .! *!/#%"! .!"2%$!/* .!4! # #%!*%

!4""$!@$24*A* 4*52" #%%5"%$#5!* #%5"2(!% $ 4*!".*:!$ :!+#$(#$4/"!5 % .!325:(!% !/.##:.2* #%)$$ 4""$!@$24*A+ .!* # .!*2/#%:$6$ ! . #23 24""$!@$24*A.$)!!%44*!% /< #:%*!5+ 9.#/!4!*(# #%: .!"%$#5!* #% "!* #%5"2(!% $ ) #%!5 2%5!* )< .!""2$!5 .! #(!.!*#%:".*:!

"#%: .!5##"2/ <#% .!/#:. .!325:(!% #%$6$ ! . #2 3 24" "$! @$24*A+ * 1#8*( .25.*#+ ,!%#* 5'" ! 44!*#%:%)!./ .!4! # #%!*.$(5##!5.#$4*<!*%5*!;2!$ !5 . .!4*<!* .!4! # #%!*#% .!44/#" #%#/!5)!*! .! *#/2* (<)!""!4 !5%/< .!!B !% 4!*(# #%: .!5(#$$#%%55!%#/ 5"2(!% $ %%!B2*!$ )2 .! $#5 5"2(!% $ (< % )! "%$#5!*!5 .!4*!".*:!$ :!*5#$".*:#%: .!""2$!5 .'!"*!2//<"%$#5!*!5 .!$#5"% !% #%%5( .! 4#%#% . .!5"2(!% $9.#".*!$2:. )!42 * .2%5!*,!" #%

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

!4" "$! @$24*A "%% )! //9!5 $ .! 5"2(!% $ .5 )!!% 4!*(# !5 #% .! $#5 "$!+ )! 4*52"!5+ * 5(#$$#% %5 5!%#/ )< !%)/#%: .! #%'!$ #: #%: :!%"< !$ )/#$. "% " 9# . .!"(4/#%% * .!9# %!$$!$#%*5!* 5(# *5!%< .! :!%2#%!%!$$ .!5"2(!% $'!%#% . "$!*!;2!$ *"%$#5!* #% .$!5"2(!% $*5#$".*:! .!""2$!59$% $4!"##"//<*5!*!5 9#//% )!2 4/"! )$!*'! . "2%$!/* .!4! # #%!*.$/$ 4/"!5*!/#%"!%2 "2$!12$! "# #$

% !& +

@ A

@*/A

=% .!$#5"$!#%"% !B .!4*'#$#%$,!" #% * +9$4!*(# !5 )!4*52"!5*5(#$$#%*5!%#/ $ :!9.!% .!4*$!"2 #%9# %!$$!$.5)!!%!B(#%!5%5 .!""2$!5

.5)!!%5!%#!5%44* 2%# < 4*52"! .!5"2(!% $2%5!*,!" #% * *5(#$$#%E5!%#/ .!" $ .!$#5"$!*!)$/2 !/<5#$ #%:2#$.)/!%5 .! * # .!325:(!% #$% 44/#")/!$ .!44/#" #%2%5!*,!" #% * 9$4!*(# !5 )!2 #/#H!5 .!$ :!5!!%"!!'#5!%"! !* *!"*5#%:$ !(!% $2%5!*,!" #% * % '#!9 .! )'! 5#$"2$$#% %5 .! 325:(!% $ "# !5 )< "2%$!/ * .! 4! # #%!* %5 8#%: #% "%$#5!* #% .! * # .! 325:(!% #% $6$ ! . #2 3 24" "$! @$24*A+ 5 % #%5 %< :*2%5 #% !*!*!#% .!*5!*4$$!5)< .! *#/2*

! # #%#$5#$(#$$!59!'!*+# #$)$!*'!5 . .!*#:. .!4! # #%!* "%*% .!$#55"2(!% $ .!4*$!"2 #%9# %!$$!$* ('!%44/#" #%2%5!*,!" #%* %5$!!8#%: .!)!%!# 4*52" #%*(/4*!B!"2 #% .!5"2(!% $% .!)$#$ .! 5(#$$#%$(5!*!:*5#%: .!5"2(!% $E/! !*$92/5)!"%$#5!*!5 9#///$)!4!% .! *#/2* *!/<24% .!5"2(!% $$2)3!" .!#*5(#$$#)#/# <% .!)$#$ .!$(!.'#%:)!!%5(# !5#%"*$$ !B(#% #%)<4*$!"2 #%9# %!$$!$ '!()!* +

@,A $%3< D.! .!*$4!8#%:E*!$%!5& !$E D.! .!* !4* )/!& !$E