High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13240/2005allowed

Saraswati Sugar Mills Ltd v. State Of Haryana Etc

2024-08-27Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth5 pages

@D>7DEF !"#!, "%AB'9'7

))?&' G! "%!

6' !"#

%"1!

G!("%&!%

!!% ' %&!!( "$ )*&+", ' -./ %01 )*&+", !#"

%& ' ' % 1 !1

' CCC

' 1! (! "%!

1 )!& 1 ! 1"

, .! %" ,! %& 1!

",!!& %0 !& % #"

))!0!& + ") "% "#.)! 7 "# 1!

.%2 3") ! ").)!*45:#"

1 1"

;1!.)!*45<=' ' 6 &!%" ,!& !&''7* 8 ))

& !,!& "1"

. " 1!$(!% )$3!%" 8 8("!&"% ,,".%"## ).

" # )! %.%&!

.)!7"# 1!.)!*45'

))!0!& .)!7 "#1!.)!*45( "+ &!&# # ) %0 %3.1!

!,! ("# % "#8.,1) ("

" %"# 8!*1!(! "%!

8 ))

) 3)! "

(!% , "% % !

8 "#!, "% 5 "# 1!

.%2 3 ") ! "),*479:#"

;1! ,*479<=' >' ?

%!&,".%!)#"

1!(! "% %!

.38 1 1!1"

%" ,!

!&"%

"%0# , %& %# , &.38 !&

!0.)

)$',!

# , ! %1 !0

)"( "&.,!& %& () ,!&"% !, ,"

&3!#"

!1 ".

1 ,11

)"3!!%.(() !& )"%0 1 1! !()$ .3 38 !& " 1! !("%&!% !# #)!, %0 1 1! (!

"& !%& %0 0 # "8!

,1 !!/*1!

# )!& %1!.

.3!H.!% !!/' ?

%!&,".%!).38 1 1 1! .)! )"&"!%"( "+ &!

,.)

8 8! 1 % 1 ,1 1! .

!H.

!& " 3! # )!&'

*1! .38 1 !+!% #* ( !.8 8!&1 1! !"3!

# )!& 1 % "

"%! !!/ #!

1! ,"%,!

%!& !!/ "+!

* 1!% "" 1!

(! "%!

,"8() !& 11! 8!' ?

%!&,".%!)1 /!%."

"1!"

8(.0%!&%%!I.

7 & !& 4''7* " .38 1 1! ,"%,!

%!& !("%&!%D

* &"! %" &!%$ 1! # , "# 1 + %0 0

!,! +!&1!

%3.1!1 "32!, ,!&"1!8!1"& &"(!&3$

%.38 %0

%"1! %!

&"# # + %0# )!& 1! '!'#''5'

'7"1!!(.$ %&

"8 88 "%!

I, !* ' 32!, %0 " 1! (! "%!

, "%"#1 + + %0.38 !& "1! %!

&"# #

*1 1! !("%&!%1 +!( ",!!&!& &" 8("!(!% )$ %!

8"# # !, "%5 "#1!,*479 %&(!% )$"

"#'*E5*5D

8("!&' ?

%!&,".%!)1 /!%.

."1!"

( !& % ((!

)

! %""* 1!"32!, "%

!&3$1!(!

"%!

!2!,!&"% ,,".% "#1!# ,1 1! %1 &3!!%# )!& "1! %!

&"# #

' 7' ?

%!&,".%!)#"

1! !.

.38 1 (!

.)!

!H.

!& "3!# )!&,"% !% )$3!#"

! 1!

&!(

!,".

.)&%"1 +!3!!%8 &!3$1!

!(! "%!

%# ) %01!

:>=

%"1!

!## ,!

' 1!(!%

)$*1!

!#"

!*1 01)$3!!% 8("!&' E' @ @!1 +!,"% &!

!&1!.38 "%' 5' )""/ 1!1"

.!%" ,!

!#)!,1 1!(! "%!

0!& "# % %" 1 + %0 # )!& % % !

8 "# .)! 7 "# 1!

.)!*45'

*1!

! %" ))!0 %)!+!))!& %1!(! "%!

%1!1"

, .!%" ,!"#1 + %0# )!& !!/ /)$ %"1!!(.$

& "# ' "1 1! %&

"8 88 "%!

!)) 1!((!) )) !.1"

$&"%"&!%$1!

# ,1 1!

!# )!&3$1 '.)!7"#1!

.)!*45*( "+ &! .%&!

AD (

B' ((" ! " H."! !

!, "% 5 "# 1! ,* 479*

1 ,1 &

.%&!

AD # #$%

)

& &

( (

:7=

* &

9' !, "%3"#1!,*479*& &!# %!1!8!

%"#;,"% < < '!'1!

' "81!(!

. )"#1!

! &( "+ + "%* ((

!%1 1!!

!!%,!"#1!!% !( "+ "% 1 1! "

* ",,.( !

8 0!

# ,"

$ 1 )) 8 ,"

!, ,,".

.%"#1!( "&., "% %& )!"

"#8") ! %&#.

% 1

% %1!

,.)

8"1! ")) '.38 "%"# %"1!

!(.$ I,

1" .

!& * , %%" % %$ $8 %%!

3! !&"3!

!"#%"%D# ) %0"# %' 1!

,"%,!

%!&# ## ,!

1" &!(

8!%

)## ,!

!H.

!& " !%& 1! % " 1!

1" 1! .) 8 ! ## ,!

% 8"#1! ,'%$"## , 1"(!

8 &.$.%&!

1 .(!

"## ,!

* , %%" 3!

& " 3! .% .1"

-!& " , ,,!( 1! %& #.

%8 1! 8!"1!.(!

"## ,!

'% ,,".%"#.,1 ) (!"%1!

"# 1!

% "## ,!

* 1! (! "%!

8 ) )), %%" 3! 1!)&) 3)!#"

# ) %0"# !!/ /)$ %' 4' "

!"+!

* 1! (!% )$ % !

"#!, "% 5 %" ,!&

3"+!* #"

1! ,"%

+!% "% "# 1! ( "+ + "% "# 1!, %& %" #"

.38 %0"# # %"

"%0"## , ,!'#1! %,".)&%"1 +!

3!!%# )!&*

".)&1 +!.%&!

""&1! 8 8(" "%"#(!% )$' * "1!

! ".)&%"# %& ! 1!

! 1!(!% )$, %3! 8("!& 8!

!)$3!, .

.! !!% " .3"

& % !"## ,! %&%"

& !,)$"1!

'@! )"# %&1

%!+!

+!&

:E=

1 %$1"

.!%" ,!#"

+ %0# )!& %" 1! ))!0!&)$

"%0

.1"

$' ' %+ !

!"*1!"

( !&3$1!

%& 1!((!

!)) !.1"

! #".%& " 3 3! %" . 3)! % )

' 1!

,, & %0)$H.

1!&' 1!

"% ))"

!& %1! ! & 8' ' ))(!%& %08 ,' (() , "%

)" %&& ("!&"#'

B'9'7

2!1

'@1!1!

/ %0 "%!&J '@1!1!

!("

3)!J A !" A !"