Rattan Singh v. State Of Haryana




   
  

   !

 



        


   "  #$"

 %
""%


&' (

"&)'*+,+-(% .*/+(0& "&1'*+/ &+(+2% .*/+( 0&(*2(( & "&%+3'*4+&5+

    

   *2(( &*+'6  /(65(*7&('64,0& *+/ .88((00 7 !9
+ ' ( ( &.'82482&' 8 (0&0/8 (*'

&045'(+((*+44.+( '+.+ '((*2(( &+& (*+( :



**++7.*(*40(**+ 0*'+7.*(&;

 ;4+,&8+4+,(*6+ ( ( ,* ' + *',0,& (+( *8 +4+&8*+6 &+'65*&72 ,**(*8(*&; ;

4+,0(*824+ ( (&/ + 27'*(*2(( &7(0 (**7'+ &'7(*+7.*(&; ;4+, *'(&50(*2&'7( *+'6 '722&(65 <;

&8+4+*&*7'6+ + 8(*&; ;4+,65+22+& .+' <;  <;9&'2(/45   76(  0&   /(  7 &  %(  !9 
  (* '(+(8 (0(*/(8+6/8 ( ''700 ( 7.*
(* 2&' (+'*&'(+(8 (*+'6 '722&(65*&*7'6+ +'

,44+'(*,00(*2(( &,** +('(*+((*824+ ( (*+6/'+,( '''+&/&=+47'( '7&(*+((* 2(( &' /( *  &+'  0&  (*  '+  ,( '''  *+/ .  2' +.+ '( (* 2(( & *+' 6  '7.*(  ( 6 '(+64'* 65 (* 2(( &652&7 .0 /  &&('(+64'* 8(5   +4'  8+  +  +((82(  (  2&/  *'    65  2&7 .  *'

+(( + &.'(&>; + >+8  .<; 72% .*% 4(&(5  2+&(8 (  &  ,*  2&7  25  0  +(( +  &.'(&0&(*+( :



>;  +( .(*+(2&' 0 (*2(( &,+'8+&3 (*00 (*+(+(+  '(+(

4+/*+'6 (+3 65*8/ +7.*(&0(*2(( &+ *& 0+(*&; ;4+,*+/+22+&+'0 ,( '''('722&((* 2(( &<;$+3*8*+ *+''(+64'*(*+(2(( &*+ .  /44+.&&,*&*,+'2'(+ (*+(**+'6

0+4'45824+( +7 (02  50/4+ &8 +4+'' <(*(*+'''(+ 04+& 7 '40&(*2(( &
*+/  .   (*&7.*  (*  78 ('  0  0   >*6(  ;  '  + 824+ ( '((7(  ?

2&&((*+(07&&  *'+824+ (,+'0465(*2(( &+.+ '(*'' %7 4 ,0%*+37 (+4++ +7.*(&; ;4+,&8+4+7 '9 !9 !

?+  +  9
 2&7'+4 0 (*824+ (  +('  (*+(  *  *+  4/44  +44.+(  +.+ '(  (*  +6/  '+ 2&' ',*+& <' (*2&' (+'0*+/ .+''+74(*8 ,(*  +  '(3  +   +4'  '

+(*  +  '78  0  '!?

@;  0&8  (*

 2(( &*'+824+ (''700 ( 7.*( +((*  8(5,(*(*,0' + +7.*(&; ;4+,,0(*+(2&&( (*+(0  (>*6(;'+250&&7 & 74  04 '7(0&&/&56&7.*(65(*2(( &4+8 .(*+( 2(( &*+27&*+'  ' (* +80*'' ) 178+& *',0+ (*+(*,+' ((4((*&/&508+(7& +87 (0  '*'+'7( *+6 04 (*5+&

 *'78 (' +((*+((*/44(.+( '2  .6(,

(*2+&('*+(( + &.'(&>; +4''*,'*'2&'  +(+'(+ (24+
(''700 ( 7.*(&+(76(72 (* '(&527(0&(*65(*+7.*(&; ;4+,/ (*&,'('(8 50 (*2&'7(&>' ( '2& 0 + (*8+4+00(* 2&'7(&>+ 4'&4+( 0(*2(( &' + ,0'

+22+& (45  2&6+64  *  2(( &  +  8245  0  4(&(5 2+&(8 (*+/ .+&4&6 +''+74(65(*2&'7(&>+  (*& <' (*2&' (+'
 (*+/+ 5*'(+( (+&&/ +(+ 47' (*+(2(( &*+'6 0+4'45824+( (*+' (*+((*2&'7( +. 5*+'0+4('(+64'*(**+&. !9
65 '*+,076(
 /,  0  (*  0+('  +   &78'(+ '  0  (*  +'  /( &&'2+''65(*7&('64,+&*&65'(+' *2(( &'&&(6+A7((./ .(*6 0(076(

(( '+44,   

  !

'