← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20002/2024dismissed

Babu Ram v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2024-10-19Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel11 pages

     

   

   

  !$%&'(%)*+*&,-        01

   

        





  20% -34 

   23"5-33 36  %

  % & 77777 

 !"#

    

    )+&

  

 



8  9*-  

 !"

 #$ % %  &   &'()&(&  " #$* "   )+:3

$  -+;( 

     , ,- ,   .

 -

     !  

 "" 

 & $ /   

    <

  

*   "  #$-       -   

 / 

 

   

     

   

 

 !

"

!+

 %,,-- ./ -0%



#$

 

$  % % #        

 & & 

! 

$ 

' $ 

!



!&

  ! 

 &  ( ( !    

     $!   

   $!         

& 

  ) )   !* 

& *!1 #   

   21  

3   1  

4 

4 5  



$  #   6 #  & 

  

.-7/.

#  &  



&  # #  +   *3  $

  !+

      !*

   

& 

# #   $



& #

#     



   

# $  $

  $# 

   $#  

   

 

  

 * #  

!



 

  

 

$

#$

  $ 

 ! * 

& 

$ $ 

  *

 $

# #! # 

  4  !$

#  !

  $

!

$



 









 



8  # 

 &     !   











!

   

*



   

 #  

$ !    #  * 

   



 





& &  9 *

$ 

# 

 # 7$#





$ $ $  & 

 

 



 $

  

!*#    *



 &$     $



 $ $: $! ;$    !$









# $$  



(    

 

 : 

 *      $  

   #  $  

 $ 

  

& $ 

 

   & (   !

  

 

 

 $  /.

,!

  



$!  #

  # 

#

&$



# $(

  #    9    



%& $

  & (  9  &  

 

 

 $

 $

 $

$  < *#



$ $!  &   



 





#$

$! 





& 

 

 $

$  #

&   



&   

$ 

   



*# #

$ 

 $ 

  

 5  *     $ $  9 ! 8

  



 

& 

 



  

#$

$



!





  

  $

 $ 

#

&   

     

$  ! ( 

  

&

* 



$ 

 

 =   $!  7 1 

    2 1  

3   1  

4  4 5  

 > "/- -,

0

/ //.//?

*   14    " #$ =-/ 

     % & *

 >   

      

    "    

   

   3 "

"     -  4  " "  

 =      >         &1        " /   /

-      

 

 - " 

"   & &'

 

   $ 

       #   - .

 -     - ,    

&

      &'  - 

 "  *-     4 "

   4  =   

   % &:            "

 =   "  

"

:  / 

$ 

    

    % &:        "

/ / 

  &(-   4  "      

  &(;.

-    -    

4 -    <   

(+  ""  #$ $$ 

     

      

      /      

)

    

 " 8   "  #$ /

   

" 



/ .

-!"

 " #$  

"" 



 " 

 ) >            "  "  

         % &         /      < 

   &(;$ 

       

 / "

"

 

    % &- 

    "

  /  % % &

     #   - 

      % &          "   

       

  /   5- 

   

 

 

 '  4

     /

    % &  .

-      

   

     ; $ 4        

        4

   

   "  

   " #$" 

   "

 % &           /     < 

        5  " !"

# #$      

"   "     "     # #$

   

   #$   4 

&:

   

 

 "

"  ? 

  '    "/  / /

-/  



 - " 

"  & '

 -

2

- #      

&-  "     4"

< 

     $  



    - 

"       &'

    - "   4 / / 

/    4"

   < " 5  4   "

  !=  

 4-   / /

-  -    -/         4 5   4 

               

 4"  " "   -/    !"   < 4 4 .

-  " 

" 4 "

  

4    $ / 



  "    .

@     

   & '

#"$

 

 

  4 /

     . 

/; +  1 1  +

      

 

 #   &  

  $

  $  $ # $

## 





 

  

/;



&  

  





   !# 

 &  !    &  $   &

 +   1  +

 

 

 

/; +   1 +



&

)

  

   & ? #   -   "      .

@   

      

!"

# #"$ %$$ %!





  

  

   

;  ; @ 



 # 

   

!  



/;+1+! , 0 





 

$   $



&

& 

$*  ()' * *" !0 #$ . 0 *# ( (1

    ++ ,

+  -+

+ 





   

/; 

8 

 



,*1+ 9  A ( 

 

$

 







/;



 $

  



    

 

# &#

 &

 $

 #& 



?

 $ - 

"   =   &'

'

 

  5 .

@       4 A "

  "

 ./ "

( (0 !!   *   !4         

     )++

  -++  -  &'

 -

* 



 

  " 1 "  

4   

"        "   1 <     

 "

" 4"  5  

          

"     .

@       

  * %$$

%!

  *

& $       ? 

        / /  &    &(  

      4 "

                "  $     

   

#  - 

= / "

   

  

-   / 4   /

 4 :    3  

     - / 

  ( &(&   !  -      " 

% &

   



/-   < "    

$   -                   

 ;

  -         "    " " 

  /      &-   4 -  

=-          " 4  "        - 

   

 / 

 

      "

 /

  "  

&( &(& &)5  

   

  ?    % &  "/ 

/

?



=  - -   "

-    

              

     "

 5      

     

  " 4         5 &1 4    =  /       " 4  "   B    

    -  

    

   /    

 

 

   "

4 

 "   &( &(& &)$ /  

 "     @          

 $ !/ )9 * '

.!#

3!"

#"$ 6!   7

3887 8 3$ $$ 7 " 

"

/!'!

40 .! 

! 

 +  

5#5)

 -+ 4 /

   /.*

         

#   

    & 

    #  

 #

&

$ 

   

   >

 !   







$

 

 &   B  

$ $  



 #    

&$ 

! 



 9 

+

  $ #  

 8



&



  

$?

        - " " :

<

!      

 

        &  *        " 

    -  

=  -    "

- "

         "

    -  "

  " 

 

   

4    4   5 @         

"     -   / 

< "

"      )+&

 -  ."

   !   : 3 

 

  "    

 .

#""

0 0

 &!



 



+  4 /

 : 1

.C

  

8 

(   #



8



   #!

  

   !# 

-/+1+! +  

   



-/+1+! +

8

 

&  

  

 8

 

(   #

 &$ )



 # 

$ 



 # 

? 3   "

-     !  

     / - /    /     <

"  

4 /

 )+&  -

3  !

 

   

 

    

4 /  

"     "



)  ."     4   

 !"   

 " "

     )+& -



         < 

  "  /   4 /    



    

/     

   $    "- 

       

 .

@ @               8 ;0

!"

#"$  !$

.!:

5

!"

 -  4 /



   *   



 &  & &

 &

+



+  D*3

  A #

$ +    



(  

(

$ #

   //"  

 #

 

-/ +

# %# # &(



  

&! #&   #

  $# 

#    #  (   

&

   

$+

#

 



)  ! 

  

 

#

$   !  $ 

  

$



  (        

 &

(  &   $

 

 #     #  

  (  

 B 

 : * 





! &   $ 



   & 

    



  

  

   / B 

   :  * 

 



 !

$!

!



$ :

 

6   !

! ) $

  & 

 $ 

 

  

 

;"E F  +

 (   



  

#  &# 

;;E/ /F

+

 0 B  

& & 

 

   :* 



&

  

    







   B! 

   :*

6     

$

6



 !

  & 

  

 $        #

   



 

 

;;E/F + +



( ; B 

 

   :* 

  



  

$ $   

    # 





& & )



   



    " B  

 ( (        

 &

 +

    E

 #      F

 





#      &

   +

   !  &

   &

&  $ 

 B   



 $

#  

#     $ # #

  

& #  & 



# &#

   

&



  

.- B  &





#

 8           (   & &$  $

 #    

      %

+

#

)     

8$



   

#



 

  :* 

(

$   

  #



 $ )

+

#   ? $    -   

 /  

      @    .!:

:

5   *

'

- =

"  4 /   

       

 -   

 4 /    

=" !"

 #$  !      

 "  " 

 4

    ,  + 3 "- 

 

=" !"

 # #$ " % %  &   &'()&(&  "

 #$*  "  

)+:3



 $   - +;( 

      ,- ,     -   !    

"" 

-    3  4     1     

       4 

       

      #     



  -  / /-/ /    "   

 ( B  )

"   *-  -  

 



#

-&(&) C  ="1   1% C 

   1%