High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/823/2006dismissed

Jagjit Kumar v. State Of Pb. And ORS.

2020-01-31Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"#

$# %#! &$!'(#

) $#

# *##& (+,- #()#

,"# !# (!#+,.+$!'

& /0+,- ##)*

2#03+((#( (0& (

/& (+!45* 66#( !#&78+76+77875$# #/($0& 9##0'3 !0 #50+9(#)!#

, )# ( -# ( )#! 66 ")0 !"# (":;

$,##/(,&5 &- !"# (#####(5- #<5

#"$0&9#+/(#(((/## (3

'-00 22' ( ()!#(- ';8 ';(##)-03=(((#)##'3("

2(!#+#-00 9#=6 66+ 2(!#(

0(/(")#0/#>=(3'! 6) "

(")0 !"#0 /(&"& ( #((%$#>(/# #"-00 ()!#=/((3"!+(3/((3'/#(!""

" "00""=(3'#-#(0 (( "3(3'((';+/(#"/# ) # '#(=(> ' ##!+(3">/( (')!00(';+#!003((3'(=(( ")0 !"#0 /(&"& (/-00 2 2' ((##(#" ';(3! (2(>#/(!!"'#)0/(0!#/ (##!# 22' (4#"=/((3#( #"+(3/(3'03 (';=(3"#( #!(00((#3#0! ()3/# )!!#=(3(#"?!

(-#& (+&#)((-00 22'# # (")'3(#)#+ (3#((#"//)## ()!!##= (3()# (0& ( (#& (+ #.)!##- , , #!0!#)#" ' /& (.!

'(()#/#> ()0 0-#"(#( /# )! ( (

3 ( # "00 " )!!'/' " )> ")3'0/#03 #'3 ,# (")0+'(!( )#-/(((#(>00((3'/( )!!' @(3/#> #(';(3' ! /( ( ' ))#( 9/-#+ #)'0 .!#'(& (/##3 ("#)(!)'!( #)#-'!!0 ,# (")0(3 (!#0 0>(()# @(")0( !("##/(( 5- #+/(/( ()0)#3/)#0 !3 @(5- #())(#"'0/!( "(")0#!A()0+( '/((#"045/# # @(5- #/ () )#)##!

()0()0 -00 ()!#-00 22' ( 9>) #2 (> /(!!"'#+ 00#+ 0-)0- #-#3"":;

$2 ,)> /0> )-#-#3"":;

,)0'0

(0A!#"/0>)-#-#3 "":;

$ B';!#>) ((3'/#> )0)-"":;

$:# #-00 22' (+ /(# ( '; ( (3' -00 ()!#/#>)-#-#3"":; $4 )#

7 #" ("0 :;"# :;

$B7<: / #- @( 5-

# ## " / ,# ")0 - (##"0+(00 !/)#)# 0(!#

)#(00(!# !0 # 50+9(#)!#+(!))0)!"#0!)( (00(!#)#-!#&8# $ C# !0 #50+9(#)!# ( (# #!#&76<778<75$/0 00(!+(# ((!#(+/((+ (3)0 !030"#0 !# ( !# -+ ( )#! ( ;""3-/+(0/((#!#

$B")0 !"#))#(" :;

$,"'#()0 $B 2(!#0##'#( -# -'3(")0 !"#"#0) )#- -#! "" '3 ("

$B &(- !"# )#- )()3 (#)'> :;

$B<, $B7 .-# !"# )#--#!!"+/(#$BD2 & @ #)#-('0 ###:;

$BD<, '0&- !"# (" ##$B" !# ("##$B8

&()#!00!-) ")0))#!+(-()#!/0'3!# ## D

&" ! /# ## !# &

D # $ /(( ( ! /(0 3 ( #"

#!"))# ("!'"((3/# ('003-0-( 5-+!;"# !0'#& ( B (#& (B

,#(# # !"+0##0 #- (!#(!#&778<75$76<75$

@()#-)#(! "#!00/

# & '

( %)

( ) )

* + %

,+ %

!" %%

-.--/-011

% %

& % !234 %

'%%

%% % %

" % 6

& % 8 %%

% $

(

%!2. #%

% %

% )

33943!& 3.-43!&

@(3/#!#

"# 778<75$ #!")#"#/"((

76<7 #!")#"#3#)3 <(!0(#+ !#(# !# # #! ")#" # )#3(

2((/####!!##03

#-+ ( !<- ( )### ))0 '# ( !# &+ /(( / 00/ '3 0# & ! +9(#)!#+#!003(! "- ##) (!/#(3/# A!((# #" ("

@()#" #"!0'30#& ! +9(#)!#0!#( /#!# &# * $#" 0!

B((#765$ # ( "!E ## & 76 5$ ! " #$ %# # !&! '( % # )*+)((#,-#& ).+/ 0!((3'

'>""0 00( #3 "0 "&76 5$

B((# (# 3 //((( !##E 4#" ( ## " ! ( (# / 3/ ( !##

B(( )#! )#)#3E *)#! )#)#3 0 #/ -# # ()#! 0"((3' !0 ' 03 )#! )#! ")3 '; ( !# -( ()#!3"#A! (0'03(!

B((# $B

2(!# #!!0 /E @( ) $B

2(!#/#!/#(3#( 0 # - )# * 7D(! "

B((# (# ) ##'# (E &"& (+%$#>(.#>(+ ?!(-# & (+ &#)( .!#'( & ( /# " "#0/+/(!0(#/ 0 ('!(-0-"( ! 9/-#+ ("

/;"'3()#!# ( # -# # / #/ ()#!

B((# ( )#! #3 " ")#''0 !!#0E @()#!#3!#0'0 '!(!#003 / 3 "(+ (3 !003 " ( "( >/

/00((3/#.- # 0>03()#!(3 300 0(A! "" "# #" '3 ("

' .- #-+(/(( ")0'#'! ("

B((# ( 0#3 " ( ")0 $B !# #"#"E 4#"(0# - )#* +0!/ #/(0#3"( ")0 !# #"

6 #")#3 +#(#("/ !#!/#(3

B((#(# 03 ")0 ( ( ("0 :;"#E @( ( > )0 6 66 , )# ( ("0 :;"# #)# :;

$B7<: ( ")0/##-( 66#0)"# ( / "( @(# / ;)0/(3(")0 /# ""03

@(##+ ( )'03 ")# /( ( ")0 !0 ' #!0 !+ /(( 0 #/ -# # ()#!

B((# ( -#))#'"# )#''0 ( )#! -#E ## ( " ")0$B !"# $B 2(!# - !'3(! -#+ / '#- ( )'03 !0 ' #!0 ! (((3'" ((- !0/(#")#)# #)#! ("+ )#- "(" >)("/#"")(#

@(")00

#-'3!(! ")'3 0#& ! +9(#)!#())#((!#'3/3 0 ()##-)+/((/! #)+/()!))#(#!

(!0

5(-(#0#!0#()#'

(#!

((##

4##3##+&68# $ ' #)#! !# 68 00 ###;#)/##-

@(9 (!##3& ! "300#;" (##3)# '#3###"0!# ! /( # ( 00 !# # ( )!#) 3 0#("0(##+0 03#)#)#3 3 +###+###)+( # !0#33)# !(##!#+"3+/( 00 #!(##+#((;!3# ##'!)+(!"+((' #0'0#(/') (;"( ## :;)0 ,00 #/((#:;!-# !0+ /((#;# # 0#))00!#+(00' "'##(& ! #()!#)( !'6

@()/##-##'3!' (00' ;# #0 3 #0!#3 ## ) 3 ))0+A!#3+#0#(#)#

5))0!#(('"'33)# (# ( 9 ( !# # ( & ! + !#(# ))0'3(")#(00'#'3((# ("

C#!0#(#)* (### ! "

'3-2((!#/(#/'#-(9 ( !#;#))00##-0)/#!#& 7 '

#& 76 ") #-#( A!0##'3(#0!#-!#())00#) /((#03/(!'"#())0

@(! "###'3("/

# $

%%!&$'!'()$ /(# /

'#-((9 (!#(!0#))#(- #( ##"(#0!#;))#-"## !

5((0##0!#()(! " -/(!)#)#0303 (!0!0) ))03 !!" &-#0-00)(00!( ")0/#-#0> #+/((/!0(--#03 ("#( B(#(! ")'30# & ! +9(#)!#/00#+'!))#)#))#0 ))#-###)#0/ @(# 00 03##"3(# @(! "#03#'##3# (0)#)0#"0! 53# ##/('3) (#-)

4 "#(#-)+(" "#

*#3#"'(A!###

/0 2# 1% %

#(! 2(- #3 & (2!

1% %

#$4

(2!