Gurmit Singh v. Punjab State And ORS
!"#$%"&'('#)*++,
* -.
+ /
!"
!"
#$
%%%% /
0+
.
' "
"
"() && &**+ ,- (& &**- # . / ."!# 0 # # !
,
# .
2# " " 0 0 '3 " ! " (+ &, &*41 0 5" 6"! # 7 0 !
". 0 #0 " " 5" 6" ! .
3 #&*-+
5" #833 0 #" !,+ (+ &*-+# 5"
" 6 5 .
9 ! !
5" #833 ! : 3 "
: # "
!" # 3 " " !" 0 "
0 " # 5" " 6 5 # "# ! 0 ! " " # ! ! ! .!!"0
"&; 1&& . 3 < 0 0
!""
!""
#$%
!"' ( % ) ;
6 " ' " " 0 3 0 # " 5"
#833
" " 0! # " #
" ! ! "" "0 .!!" "
" 0!
". 0"
" " !" # " 0 #
" " 5" #833 "" ! # "!" !" # " ." " # 30 " #
"!" " = 0
)
3 ! " "
3 " . "" !" # # -
: 00 "
0 !" # ' &1 &, &*4- () () &*-+ 0 0 0 3 " ". " # >
. " "# ! !" ". 0 ? !" ! 0 0 8 ' " !"
# / . . / . ! 1 &48 .!!" 33 0 "
! " ! ;
,1 ?" " !" " " :# !" @! 0 !" " . 0 A " . @# ! / &**;B "# . / . "# ! " # .
! 0 " ! 1 &4 ! % *+
,
# -.
/
/
&
/
2
42
/
2
*+
,
#
"
#$%
-1
,
(
6
/
/
57
-1
!/
-1
!/
-1 #
&
1 -1
,
&
8 7 0
/
-1
2
2 6
2
2
/
4
/
/
/
9 /
-1
:2
/
/
#$% . 0 "
0
-1 0 &
;
&
-1
<
*3 /
9 /
/
/
* -+ 9 /
& &
2
/
1
-61
% / /
/ & &
2
6/
-61
&
/
/
,
# . 0 "
0
-1
+
9 /
&
/
-1 /
/2
9 /
&
4
,
/
7 0
#
9 /
&
/
,
9 /
/
,
/
#
9 /
/
9 /
0
# -17=
-+1
(
2
57
-1
>
-
/
2
/
-" )
/ ) /
/
1
-1
42
22 2
4
/
)
&'() )) *
*% -1
"#$
2
/
42
/
9 /
/
#/
&
*% -1
"#$
5
+
2
/
4
/
/
/
9 /
) <
+ )
,- . / )0
0
+
=2
/
??( ,
=
@
-
A"$=@B1
/
"#$ -=6
@ 1
??( , "#$ -=6
@ 1
/
2
/
"$=@
&
<
/
, 2/
? C /
*
2
-1 "#$
/
&
2
/ #/
42
&/
9 / <
6
2
/
<
/
<
2
/
<
12 "
3
((
'4. 5 /
!
% 2
2
2 /&
2 <
, 2/
5
$ +22
/
2
22
,
&
, 2/
1 6 7
8
.
9 ..
' . &1 6 7
$8
. 9 .. ' .5 / :
#
;!*
(
5 -$##
* 1
( <
% 2 /&
/
2
& /
//
2
&
/ # 3 &
/4 % 2
/ /
*
4
& /
/
/
2
/
/
2
4
/
2
&
&
4
/&
% 2 /
$
+
A
B 2
/
&
/
/
+
<
% 2 +0#<=
/
DE9#
2
/
&
4
//
/
2 //
&
&
/
)
$ +22
&
2
2
/
2
4
/
F &
2
/
,
&
#
@
,
$ +22
/4
/)
:
@
7 < ( + 1 5
;#/0
::
&2
#
@ , 2/
"( ( < " 5 %8"
; # ) (
;
9 /
#/
/
?
/ /
<
, 2/
5
/&
2 &
/
/
4
$
<
2
9 /
/
/ /
/
? < G2
/
9 /
/
<
"( ( " &/ ; :0
9 /
/
/
&
9 /
2
/
& / G
4
$
/
&
/
? E
9 /
@& 2
&
9 /
&
6 <
9 /
/
&
< 9 /
/
/
?
/ /
2
9 /
2
<
/ /
& & 2
)
(
/
$/ &
<
&
4
<
2
0
3
*
/
,
/
?
#
0
2
2
/
&
&
0
4 2
2& < /
2
?? -+ 6
"*1
)
< , 2/
/
/
2
/ /
2
=
$ !
!
/+ )
, % < (5 8% 0
( <
/
, 2/
#*
@ >
" / )0
0
,
,
H ' /
% /
H/
# ?
/
$
+
42
4
/
'
#
'
C
2
/
????
, ?
???
/
,
#
'
#// ?
???
??
/ ?
?(???
/
< /
, 2/
?
??
&2
< , 2/
( ? / )0
/
0
2
?(? -+ 6
"* ????
-+ 6
"*1
&
,
$ # H ' /
C
/ 42
9 /
,
H
/
/
&
/
&
@
#
>
" < 9
5 . ; , 2/
&
&
2
I " $2 %
H
I " $2 %B -
1
42
4
/
8
I " $2 %B -
1
G
/
/ I " $2 %B -
1 6
J
J / )
< ( ::!
( ? - . / )0
' @
?
%$ :
!
( ?
. !
<
/
, 2/
( H $2 @
/
D
/
&
@
# B>)
" <
-5 . ;C
/
I " $2 %
2&
/
/
J
J
+22
/
H
/
0
?(?
2
$2 @
,
/
$ !
/
*#
&
&
&
/
/
0
?(? &
?
!! !5
< =(
,
,
/ 0
2
G
/
2
2 /
&
&
&
/
<
? H
& 2 & /
/
2
??(
$2 @
)
6) &(
$ !0 ! 1 &48 " ! # 0 A " . @# ! / &**;B . " !" # ' # ! " " :# !" 0 # !" 0 0 ! "# "
5 :# !"
0" # " 0 "
"" " ""## !" # ' " # &&
/
" . ' #!" 0 5" #
" "" # ' " ! # < " 0 0 &,
"" # !0 ! " 0 "# . / . # ' " !" &1 &, &*4-() () &*-+ # &1
6 "# "" "" "0 " 0 (; """# &;
5" "" #
&+
" #
++, C /
# '
F'
F'