← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20715/2021allowed

Gurbhej Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab

2021-05-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

-"P$$$$QJ$RSO$SQLS$%KI&R$KT$<IJM13$1JN$S1&G1J1$1R$ $ $ $ %S1JNQL1&S$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ %&'('(-"0!*$KT$-"-!$@KU'F$ $ $ $ $ $ $ N1RO$KT$NO%Q2QKJ$V$-09"*9-"-!$ L=A?6;>$2./56$4/E$4/+:6;A$ $ $ $ $ W<;:.:.+/;A8$ $ $ 7;A8=8$ 2:4:;$+,$<=/>4?$ $ $ $ $ $ $ W&;8X+/E;/:$ $ %K&1'$V$ SKJY3ZO$'&9$MI2RQ%O$1&IJ$'KJL1$ !"#$#%&'('

)"*'Y:6#1'<,/,&-:,3'45678,&#3'

97"'&-#'.#&:&:7%#"$*'

)"*'<,%5##.'<:%=-'>#7/3'>4?3'!2%@,A*'

)"*'\*'Y*'<*'\-#-,"3'45678,&#3'

97"'&-#'87J./,:%,%&*''

@<A;8;/B;$C4AD;E$:6A+=56$7.E;+$B+/,;A;/B;F9$ $ /"0%$#&%1/2$3'$4&"/56$ 0-#' .#&:&:7%#"$' ,"#' $##1:%=' "#=2/,"' A,:/' :%' 8,$#' IPL' Q7*HHF' 5,&#5' GG*EU*GEHF' "#=:$&#"#5' 2%5#"' <#8&:7%$' DFW;RRN;WHH;RGN;WEU;HSU;HRS;' HRF' P!K3' ,&' !7/:8#' <&,&:7%' 4@%,/,3' >:$&":8&' 4J":&$,"' ]L2",/^*' 0-#B' C#"#' ,""#$&#5'.2"$2,%&'&7':%6#$&:=,&:7%':%'&-#'$,:5'8":J:%,/'8,$#*' G*'

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

V#,"%#5'872%$#/'97"'&-#'87J./,:%,%&3'7%',56,%8#'1%7C/#5=#'79' /:$&:%=' 79' &-#' A,:/' .#&:&:7%3' ,..#,"$' ,%5' 7..7$#$' &-#' A,:/' ./#,' ,/7%=' C:&-' /#,"%#5' <&,&#' 872%$#/' C-7' ,/$7' 7..7$#$' =",%&' 79' ,%B' 87%8#$$:7%' &7' &-#' .#&:&:7%#"$*'

R*'

V#,"%#5' <&,&#' 872%$#/' ,"=2#$' &-,&' A7&-' &-#' .#&:&:7%#"$' -,5' 5#$&"7B#5'&-#'8"7.'7%'&-#'/,%5':%'[2#$&:7%'AB'2$:%=','&",8&7"',%5',"#',/$7' ,//#=#5'&7'-,6#'$&7/#%'&-#',=":82/&2",/',"&:8/#$'9"7J'/,%5',$'.,"&'79'&-#'J7A' 87%$&:&2&:%=',A72&'RE;WE'.#"$7%$*''

W*''

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

V#,"%#5'872%$#/'$2AJ:&$'&-,&'&-#"#':$'%7'$.#8:9:8'"7/#',&&":A2&#5'&7' &-#' .#&:&:7%#"$*' 4887"5:%=' &7' -:J3' &-#' 5:$.2&#' A#&C##%' &-#' .,"&:#$' :$' 8:6:/' :%' %,&2"#' ,%5' .#&:&:7%#"$' -,6#' 2%%#8#$$,":/B' A##%' 5",==#5' :%' 8":J:%,/' 8,$#*' 4887"5:%='&7'-:J3':%6#$&:=,&:7%'79'&-#'8,$#':$'76#"',%5'8-,//,%'-,$'A##%'9:/#53' A2&'&-#"#':$'%7'-#,5C,B':%'&-#'."78##5:%=$'52#'&7'K76:5MHF'.,%5#J:8',%5'&":,/' C://'&,1#'/7%='&:J#'&7'87%8/25#*'

N*'

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

O7&-' &-#' .#&:&:7%#"$' ,"#' $&,&#5' &7' A#' :%' 82$&75B' $:%8#' HG*ED*GEGH*''

S*'

X%' ,' K72"&' [2#"B3' /#,"%#5' <&,&#' 872%$#/' $2AJ:&$' &-,&' 8-,//,%' -,$' ,/"#,5B' A##%' 9:/#5' ,%5' :&' 8,%3' &-#"#97"#3' $,9#/B' A#' ."#$2J#5' &-,&' :%6#$&:=,&:7%':$'76#"*'0-#',//#=,&:7%$',=,:%$&'&-#'.#&:&:7%#"$'8,%'9:%,//B'A#' ,5@25:8,&#5' 7%/B' ,9&#"' &":,/' C-:8-' :$' 82""#%&/B' -#/5' 2.' 52#' &7' .,%5#J:8'

$8#%,":7*'0-#"#':$'%7'/:1#/:-775'79',%B'92"&-#"'-#,5C,B':%'&-#'&":,/',%5'&-#' 87%8/2$:7%' &-#"#79' C72/5' &,1#' &:J#' $:%8#' &-#' K72"&$' ,"#' C7"1:%=' 7%' "#$&":8&#5'92%8&:7%:%='52#'&7'K76:5MHF'.,%5#J:8*'' F*''

P%'&-#'."#J:$#3'P',J'79'&-#'7.:%:7%3'%7'2$#92/'.2".7$#'C72/5'A#' $#"6#5'AB'1##.:%='&-#'.#&:&:7%#"$':%',%B'92"&-#"'."#6#%&:6#'82$&75B*'' HE*'

0,1:%='C-7/#$7J#'6:#C'79'&-#'J,&&#"',%5'C:&-72&'#`."#$$:%=' ,%B'7.:%:7%'7%'&-#'J#":&$'79'&-#'8,$#3'A7&-'&-#'.#&:&:7%#"$',"#'7"5#"#5'&7'A#' "#/#,$#5' 7%' A,:/' 7%' &-#:"' 92"%:$-:%=' A,:/' A7%5$' ,%5' $2"#&B' A7%5$' &7' &-#' $,&:$9,8&:7%'79'87%8#"%#5'K-:#9'Z25:8:,/'),=:$&",&#;'>2&B'),=:$&",&#;P//,[2,' ),=:$&",&#3',$'&-#'8,$#'J,B'A#*''

HH*''

P&':$3'-7C#6#"3'J,5#'8/#,"'&-,&':%'8,$#'&-#'.#&:&:7%#"$',"#'972%5' :%67/6#5':%',%B'7&-#"'8,$#'79'$:J:/,"'%,&2"#'C-:/#'7%'A,:/3'&-#'."7$#82&:7%' $-,//'A#',&'/:A#"&B'&7'$##1'8,%8#//,&:7%'79'-:$'A,:/*'' '1G$-0H$-"-!$ $ $ $ $ @1&IJ$'KJL1F$ <-,/:%:'

MINLO$ $ !

!"#$"#%&'(#)*+,-.%#)'/,#0&1& & 2#'.3/& !"#$"#%&%#(/%$)45#&1& & & 2#'.3/& & &