High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12441/2000allowed

M/S Tej Alloys Ltd v. Punjab State Electricity Board And ANR

2019-04-30Mr. Justice Raj Shekhar Attri17 pages

"# $

%"&'(&)# &# *&"+# !

," "

!"#$

%&'()$ %)* ) )

#"- #(%.

#(+/&0 .)&01#+,

"# "1#+#," "

%)* ) )+% 2 + 3# ,

+& '" )+&"/ "/ +

#&" % & 42567555 8""9 :2; &" + &)) ,&" "/ %,, "&# '

8""9 :7; % ' + #," " 3+#' & &" 1 420440<47: +& '" #& &/& " + ,

"# &1# #.

"/ + )# )"% " 1 + ,

"# 1# + ,# %/%02==6%"02===+,

"#+&1%#+#%/+&3# 1 ,#+ '

"##& "

"/+#," "1# )"") "/+)# %,,+ 1&)#,#

7 + ,

"# & ,%' )

) ,&" ")#,#& %" #+ ,&"

)02=<> #%"&" " %) "1%#"&) ")2==4 &" &"%1&)%##

"/ #)&## "/" + &"%1&)%# "/ &) .

0 + ,

"# +& &" )# )"") " '&# "/ " (:2< + )"") &") " & 1 7555 ?@ 1# + %"&' (& )# &# 81# '#.

A+ &# B;0 &" & )" %" # +

,#.

"1"

&")# )02=25+,

"#&+& +& #/%&# ,& & + )# '

#& ' + &# 1#

+ )# # & + 1&)# ,#

1 + ,

"# +& '" "& ' + &# 0 1# 3+ )+ + ,

"# ,& #" + #," '

1 & "& "

"/ + )# # &" "%# +& # & " "3#C "/)"

"+&# "+ "+1%2==60 + %##" #&"1# # "

& #&"1# # 8 ; %"

1 +

# "/ #D% # " & + 1&)# ,#

1 + ,

"# ')& 1) . &" )% " #)# &)%& )"% " 1 )# ." +%/+ + &# 3& &3&# +& + %"

1 + # "/ #D% # "3& 1) .0 )+&"/ +& "%"02==="# # ).#+ &0+&# +#%/+#," "7 % #&" % 4>2E & 425675558""9 :2;#.

"/+)"% "1+ ,

"# 1# + "+ 1 %/%0 2==6 %"0 2=== &" #& & &" 1 420440<47:"/3 ++ #&" % 0#," ""7 #& &%,, "&#'

8""9 :7;1#+& & %"&" /&.2< &

+ ,

"# , + & %"0 1& "/ 3+ )+ 3&

" +&+)# )"") "1+,

"#3 ' &' ' )"") 3 +% &" 1%#+# " ) //# . &/& " +

%&") 1 #&" % & 42567555 8""9 :2; &" %,, "&# '

8""9 :7;0 + ,

"# +& 1 + "&" ,

" 4 + ,#

"&# &/0 + %#0 &1# +&# "/ + ,

"#"2F5=75550 % " )1 "+#," "&" /#&" &1 )"") "1)# )%,,%')+)"

+&+,

"# , <5G1+& %" " ,%3 ++ %"&'

(&)# &# '1#2<227555+ %#1%#+# #) +&

" )& + & %" " , 3 + " + ,%& ,# 0 +

&+&&" &% & )&.&)& + , 3& & F

,"' "/#. 0+#," "&,,&# &" 1 + # #," + #," " #& ,#

"&# %'

" & 3 & )" + 3# ,

" " # + #," " &

+& )# )"") "'&# "/))%" (:2<3&&") " ' " +,#

1+,

"#1##%""

"/1+1%#"&)+ %"

"& "+,#

1+,

"#')& 1) ."2<5E2==6 % & &/ 1 '9 &" &)%& )"% " )% " ' #)# "+ #" "

& "3&#) . 1# +,

"#.

# & 2<5E2==6+&+ %"

3& & &/ "2<5E2==6 &" +& "3 %"

)&"" ' &##&"/

& &" 3& #D% +& %,, 1 )# ' & #) ))# "/0 + )# )%,,3&,#.

#)'+#," ".

"44 & 2<5E2==603+ )+3&1 "'+%"

#"/ "#)")#" ,##,# & 54562==6#)# '+11 &1+&# &" % /" '+#,#"& .1+,

"#0 3& "

" +& +#& "/)% "'&C" % & &/1 %"

$ # & 4# %/%02==60+#," "&C +,

"# +#/ + & &/ %"

#,& # #,%#)+&&"3"+#," " "&#

" # & 2>42===+,

"# "42&#)+02===0 ,

"# "

& +&# #1#&"3 %"

+&'",&) &" +& +&"'"#) . &" +%,, #+&&%# + ,&)+ 1 + %"

" 25+ ,# 02=== 1# +"3 %"

3& ,#.

'+,

"#0+& 3& '+#," "1#

+ &'&" 3& "& &+ "7<+%"02===+)# '

1#+,# 1# %/%02==6%"02===+& '#.

' &C "/ + &.#&/ 1 )"% " 1# ,#) "/ +# "+ # ' &C "/ ")" #& "+&)%&)"% "&#)# %# "/+ )##,"

"/ "+ 1 + ,#.

% &#0 3+ )+.# # + #," "1%#+#& +&&1#+ "&& "1"3 %"

3&1%" +&+#+&'"&%'&"

& ")#& "+)"% "1 )# '+,

"# ") ,&# "3 ++'

#& ?, "/ " .

3+#D% # "1(&#/%& "E42720+&))%"1+ ,

"# 3# .#+&% &" .

# # & 42 %/%0 7555 8""9%# :2;0&%,, "&#'

1 420440<47:3&#. %," +,

"##D% # "/,& "3 + "2< &+#," "&

+&+& %"1 2<0E50555:+& '" , '+,

"# "25227555&" +& ") , &")3 ++# #,& '+ %#0 +)# )"") "3&" )"") < " # 0+#," " "

+ ##," '

1#+ & ")+&"/ "/+ %"

1+)# #+#," " C+&" +& %"

&,&#&%"

&" "&,&#1+

# "/D% "+#," "%'

+& 1+# &"1&% " + %"

0+""+ %"

')+&"/ &" +# " " )+&"/+)# #%)+0+#," "%'

+&+)# #)% "'& +&.') 1) .+ #," ")") +& ")&+ %"

/ & &/ 0+"+ "#/)"% )&""')##)#)# "+ #&" +%,, +)"% # +#' )"") # %,, #)"22?$ " 1# #%""

"/ + 1&)# # %)+ ,# 0 + %,, &' '

" "+#&.#&/'& &" &#"+'

'#.

3 &" .#:+&% &,#+ "#%) "1+&# > +,

"#+&1 #, )& "# #& "/+&" &C"

" + 3# ,

" " &

"0 + ,

"# %'

+& %# "/ +

,% ,# 0+#," "+& '"'

"/+,

"#"&.#&/ '& &,#,#.

%)"% " E 1# )" # "/ + &" 1 + # .& ,&# 0 + 3# ,

"3&&

1##/%&#+&# "/"2=257552&" + "#

# #3& #) )"

"% 6 + )%" 1# + ,

"# +& '" +&# &" 3 + + & &") + )%# +& /" +#%/+ + #)# # (%. # (+/& +& %#/ "'+&11+,

"#+& %"

&,&#&" ,&#)1+

# "/D% "&" &" 1) "+& 3 &11)+)##)" 1 + )# # #& "/ +& # %," + ,#.

" 1 ) " 7>8>; 1 + ) &" &#/% +& 3 +% / "/ + ,% & % )& 1# + )# )& ",)#0 3& " ," + #," " #& & %,, "&# '

"/ + )"% )+&#/ 1# + ,# + # # & " 1) . +& ,&) # &")%,".&# %% / "'%#+ &#/% " = +&

1&)%&,

+&+ %"

"+,#

1+,

"#')& 1) ."2<5E2==6&" + "3%"

3& "& &+ "7<5>2===%# "/+ ,# 0+ )# 3&' "/%,, #)+,#

1+,

"#&" & %,, "&# '

8""9 :7; 3& %'D%" #& #.

"/ + )# )+&#/1#+,# 1# %/%02==6%"02===

25 ")&#" )+&%#,#.

"&)"& "

") "7> 82;0 87; &" 8>; 1 + "

&" )# )0 2=25 8 ") #,& ' + )# )0 7554; + & ,#.

#&1 & %" #-

" #$

' ((((

) ((((

* ((((

+ ,!

(

, $

$ , #$

$ $ -

. (((( +(

(

22 (%':) " 82; ) " 7> 1 + ) ,#.

+& + D%&"

1 )# %,, + )"% # ' &)#& " '

&"1&)##) #&" 3+#+)"% # #0+ )" '%" %,,& #01#3+ )++ )" &#D% #+)"% # / .+

&)%# &" "# "&"&/# "1#+ #+#1@+# + # %,, '+ )"0%':) "87;

,& %%," + )"C,+ # "3#C "/# #&" 1%#+# ,%&+&

")&1&" 1&%0+)"% #3 "' &',&1#++ #1 + #1#&"/&+ 1&%)"

"% 27 (%':) " 8>; 1 ) " 7> ,#.

+& " )& 1 &"

,% # 11#") & 3++# &" # #.

)&' # "0 +

&#3 ' ) '&")# )&",)# +#1+,&# & '# &,,#&)+ + )# )& ",)# ' 3& 1 &" &,, )& " @+#+",)#1 " +&+ #+&)& '1%") "&0+ +&

&+& %"1"#/%,, +)"% # %# "/+ ,# 1 1) &" +& . )+&#/ 1# + & 1# & ,# " 9) "/ 9 "++%':) "1%#+#,#.

+&+#/ #1 #)# )"% " +& ' + )")% . ,#1 1 + )# )"% '+)"% #0 "+&'")1&"1#&% 0)

24 " + '&)C/#%" 0 + 1 # % 3+ )+ #D% # #

"& & 3++# %"

& ,&# &" ,&#) 1 +

# "/D% " 2F %##" #&"1# # 8; & .

) +& % 1# + #&"1# & "1)# ))%##"1# &+ /+#.&% "&,#,# "& )%##" & 3# .&% ,"

& #&"1# # 8 ; # .&/ #&"1# #)".#++ /+.&%1.&/ "3.&/+ )# )& .

) &# "

& % 1# )"") "/ + )# )&

"#% " + &%# "/ "#% " + .

) # %) + .&/&" )%##"1# + /+.&%& &.&%+&+ &%# "/

"#% "0 %)+ &0 &

# &" . # )&" & &%# + )%##"&" .&/+#3 .#&#/ .

)3 '#D% # 1#+ & ,%#,03+ )+ ",#&) )&' 2< + %&3++# "

&#&"1# #8 ; ' #/&# && #)& %,1#)" #& "'1#+(%,# %#

82==6;7(<=E+ (%,# %#+ &%" #- 0.

% $ !

1 2

$ ! 1 2

2 4 #! !

23 #3 5 63

' ) !

73 5 13 ' #3 ! 23 8 9 4

23 #3 23 63

23#3 $ !

#3 $

& ! !

;;;7

! ! ( ! !

! $

;;;

;

! ! #3

! ! !

;;;

;7 3 ! #3!

3 #3 3 $ !

$ 1 2 ! + <

( ! . / 3

! = 2> + % / " +& '" 13 ' + /+ %# 1 ++& /&#+ "

752F++& /&#+2FE"D%"0 +# " + & " + "/ +& &" "

& ,&# 1 +

# "/ D% "0 " + &'") 1 3+ )+ + D%&"

1 )# )"% )&""' &%#

2E 30+)" &,)3+ )+&# 1#)" #& & 3++# + #," " 3# % " % "/ & %,, "&# '

+%## "/+# ,#.

%" #%':) "8>;1) 7>1+)# )02=25 26 + % & &" ' + (%,# %# "

2=66(%,# %#E21# " "/+&%#,#.

"0+(%,# %#+ - 0> $ $

( (

$ ! ?

& / /+ <

! @

$ + $

;

/ + ?+ 4

! !&

+ !

$ $

4 ! /A= 3&1%#+#+ '+(%,# %#+&- '

$ !$ !&

/ 1 2 + ! !

+ !

( !

( ( 3

5 ! 1 2

= 2= + & " 1 #&"

"/ +& '" & , " + /+ %# ) " " )& ! "

/8 >:> ?&#"&&C& 7E=H #

!!$ ! /8 >>* 4 .>% "

& $ '

( ;;> *828 $

8; 75

# + #%#" 1 ' + #," "0 '.

%+& +# "&/& "1& ,# "/3 ++ %"

"1 &" 1#&% ' + ,

"# " 1&# & + # "/ D% " )")#" &+#0 3&+,

"#3+'#%/+ +" )1+ #," ""2<5E2==6+&+ %"

+& ') 1) .&" 3&"#)# "/+)##)"#/)"% /& "0#)# +3+&

3&+,

"#03++& ,%#)+& &"3 %"

03+ )+&1# )+)C "/3& "& " ,#

'+#," ""7<5>2=== +#1#0 "+ %& "0+#," "3#"% "#& "/& %,, "&# '

3 +% / "/ + ,% & % )& 1# + )# )&",)# 72 '1& #+#," "0+# &"),&) '+ " + ##,%,"(& /%& &'" ) +#," "+&. # %," (& /%& " E4272 1 ( % 1 + .#+&% "/ 1 + &))%" 1# + ,# 1# %/%0 2==6 %"0 2=== #+ ,%#,0+#.&"(& /%& "E4271+ ( 8& 9 "+ᶃ &'" ) ,#.

- 0.'

/CDE?3+B3F5/22FEB35+3+85FEBC C+5+237+ 5

!$ $ .'

C? 4

3 !

! G@+ .'

! !

$ ( $

$ !& 77 ,#%& 1 + &'. #/%& " +3 +& (&

/%& " E427 &,, )&' " #,) 1 ",#& .0 & , # '%#" #(& /%& "E4272,#.

1#)+&#/ "/)"% # " + '& 1 )"% " ,&#" 1# 3 &# &1# "&& " 1 ,#,##I)##)J #+ #/%& &,, )&'3+#+)# )

# & & &" : 0 & , # '%#" &" " #)# "/ &" )"% " "&,, )&' " +)&1 & #0 3+ )+ & ' #)# "/%" #:)"% "#9))"% "1"#/%,, 0 & + %& "+,#")&"+ #/&# ,&#&/#&,+71+

"&#(%'

" "+3# "& "1 '+#," "

&'" ) - 0 3 23@#3

@ $

* D >>: 23@#3 ( = 74 %)+0 + # &") ,&) ' + #," " " (&

/%& " E4272 9,& " + %&") 1 %,, "&# '

3+#'&

"& &" 3&#& 0 &

,&) &" #. '#) 7F

1#") +& '" & ' + ,

"# " + '#.& " 1 + (%,# %# "

! ) *++ ,' -,-* 8755<; F(47E- 0.

% H3 ? !

A 3 !

$ $ ,2 !

, :

/ ! ! / + 8

>* (

$ . ? /

8 *. $ %

$ !

> %

? !

! ! !

3 ? ! +

(

$ % ! !

(

1!$!

(

3 ? $

! $ = 7< #. ' " ) +& %':) " 8>; 1 ) " 7> ,#.

+&&"&,, )& "1# )

"/+ ,%# 11#")'+ )# )&",)#)&"'%'

'A +#,&#B3.#0#)# +3 +& " + ,#" )& " +# 1 + 3 ,&# +& 1 &" &,, )& " 1# & % )& " 1 + ,% &# 1# + )# )& ",)#0."+%/+ 3&," +#1+3,&# &,,#&)+ +

7> + &,)+&'"&C")&#1'1+ /+%#1 ?&#"&&C& "#

2==2 .

%#&FE7

"/+&,,&1 '+)# &# &/& " + % / " 1 + &#" ( "/ % / " ! "

/8 >:> ?&#"&&C&7E=0 3&+ '& .

"")+&13- 0.

B! !

+ + 4

! ? ? /

! 4 ! $ 4

+ $ ! & &

(4- ! !

! $

+ ? ? /

5 ! $

! $ !

< $

? ? / ?

$ $ 4 ! $ ! $ $!

+ $ ! $ $

! $

E 4 $

+ F

5 ! !

! "

+ ? + / > ;

/ !

? / = 7E & D% + &'. )% "0 + 3# ,

&3 +

,%/" #&" % & 42675558""9 :2;&" &)) ,&" "/ %,, "&# '

8""9 :7;0 +&.

"/ '" % +%/ "/+ &#& % )& 1# +)# )&",)#&&

3" %" # ) " 7>8>; 1 + )# )0 2=250 &# + '

/&&" &#'

#&#&" &#)"D%"& +#," "&#

#) #1%" + & %" 1 2<E5 &C+ , ' + ,

"# &"/ 3 + & #& 1 "# 3+ )+ + )+&#/ 1# + 1&% "/)% # 76 "

"0 3 ' ," + #," " &C#)%#+,#.

"1) "7>8>;1+)12=25# &" +# )+&"

,#.

%" # + )# )0 75540 3+ )+ )& " 1#) %# "/ + ," ") 1 + 3# ,

" " 7>+ &0 75540&" "+&'& 0+#," " &#& &%,, "&#'

0 1 &"0%" #+&3

, %)* ) )- $

& %& .$ % & @ " I %8 " I @B