High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/919/2021dismissed

Executive Engineer v. M/S Rock Drill Project Pvt. Ltd. And Another

2021-10-26Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill5 pages

!" # $%&%!' ( $!) * +, -. , / /, .0, /

11 22 . *&3&

40 5 // . / .... &1!'# '&

-. , / /, .0, /

11 22 . *&3&

40 5 // . / .... &1!'# '&

-. , / /, .0, /

11 22 . *&3&

40 5 // . / .... &1!'# '& ( 7/ 0 0 /0 // * & '(

'#8%* 0%'98, ##2 , *:

"!* 8

;;;

/0 //,

8%& !*# * &8 22 #%&1!& !" !& , , + !" , 2& %'<!2< &%=%2 * %&&3 ) > ' 8 & = 1

*% " "

$& ' $ && *: "!* #?3#%$ %!' !" 8 $ * 8 8* '# *& > * "2!

# ): 8 '& "!* 1*!<%&%!' !" 2 :%'9 !" #%"" * ' & > 2%' &41%1 & ): * '$82 && $8'!2!9: & > * $

& %& # %2 # %' 8 '# * #!$3= '& ) *%'9 #%"" * ' $!& 22 8 8* '# *& > * 22! # ! 8 * &1!'# ' @ "%*= 22! # >!*A > & ! ) $!=12 # %'

%= )!3'# = '' *

&1!'# ' @ $!=1 " * $!=12 %!' !"

)!3 BC !" 8 >!*A & #2: 2 "

8 & = %'$!=12 , "!* > ' !" "

: !3 12 ' '! ) %'9 &3112% # ): 8

%&13 *!& ) > ' 8 1 '# ' *)%* !* > 11!%' # %'

8 8* = *&

!* 8 & A !" $!'< '% '$ , "

$& * ) %'9 D* $ # "*!=

2 %=& * %& # ): 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ': > * (

! > %< !"" 8 1 '

2: %=1!& # !' % 2!'9>%8 $%!' !

D $3 8 ) '$ >!*A 8*!398 !8 * 9 '$: 3'# * 2 3&

'# 6

!* 1 := ' !" % =& ! ) 1 %# & 1 * E *

%%% !* 1 := ' !" & $3*%:

=!3' # #3$ # "*!= < *%!3& $$!3'

)%22&

%< !* 1 := ' !" %'$!=12 "%'

2 )%22

!* 1 := ' !" FC $!'* $!* 1*!"% !" ) '$ >!*A

<% !* 1 := ' !" %' * & 8 * !" FC 1 * ''3= & 1 * *)%* %!' $ !' 8 $2 %= * %& #

!3' * $2 %=& > * * %& # ): 8 1* & '

'& %& ! ) '! # &%=%2 * %&&3 & > * %'<!2< # %'

22 8 8* = *&

*)%* !* >8%2 * ? $%'9 8 $!3' * $2 %= $!'$23# # 8 '%* >!*A $!32# '! ) $!=12 # ): 8 $!=1 ': !'

$$!3' !" "

: !3 12 '! ) %'9 "3*'%&8 # ): 8 1* & '

$$!*#%'92:, $2 %= =!3', & %& %2 #, > *# # ): 8 *)%* !* %' 8 8* & 1

*#& !" < ' #

99*% < # 8 * "*!=, '& "%2 # 1 %%!'& 3'# * 0 $%!' 6 !" 8 *)%* %!'

'# !'$%2% %!' $, + "!* & %'9 &%# *# # + G G %'

22 8 8* = *& *' # ##%%!'

2 %&*%$ 3#9 , =)

<%# %=139' # # $%&%!' # # B !' $!'&%# *%'9 8 "

$& '# $%*$3=& '$ & #%&=%&& # 8 1 %%!'& 99*% < # 8 * "*!=, 1* & '

2& 8 ) ' "%2 #

6 *' # $!3'& 2 "!* 8 ' 8 & < 8 = '2:

*93 # 8 *' # ##%%!'

2 %&*%$ 3#9 8 & 9*!&&2: ** # !' "

$& '# %' 2 > %' #%&=%&&%'9 8

2& "%2 # ): 8 '&, & % %& !11!& # !

22 2!9%$, 8 %' $ & 2 : !3 12 & '! = %2 )2 ! 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ':, % > & &%22 )2 ! $!=12 !< * BC !" >!*A 22! # ! % *' # $!3'& 2 >8%2 * " **%'9 ! 2 3& F !"

8 $!'* $ 9* = ' &3)=%& 8 $!'* $!* > & * H3%* # ! < *%": 8 >

)2 ) *%'9 $ $%:

'# !8 * 9 !18:&%$ 2 $!'#%%!'& ) "!* '# *%'9 '# '!

&3)& H3 ' 1 := '& !" # > *%'9, 1%2 "!3'# %!' $ >!32# ) = # !' 8

$$!3'

%& $!' '# # 8 8%& %' %& 2" %'#%$ & 8 : !3 12 ' > & =

%2 )2 ! 8 $!'* $!* #3 ! >8%$8 $!'* $!* > )2 ! $ **: !3 !< * BC !" 8 >!*A %' H3 &%!'

!'* $!*, % %& &3)=% #, 8 & *% # !

#!1 8%& '!< 2 = 8!# ! >*%992 !3 !" %& !)2%9 %!'& '# # 2 : 8 = 11 22 ' 8 # !

) * D* $!& & 8 >!*A 8 # ! ) $!=12 # ):

22!= ' !" 8 & = !

'!8 * $!'* $!* %&, 83&, 1* : # 8 8 & 2& ) 22!> #

*#, 2 *' # $!3'& 2 "!* 8 '# 8 < 9!' 8*!398 8 "%2 & > 22 & &!= !" 8 * $!*# >8%$8 > & 1*!#3$ # %' !3* !# :

22!= ' !" 8* '# *& ! 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ': %& = * !"

* $!*# & %& *%&%'9 !" 8 #%&13 ) > ' 8 1 %& )!*' !3 "*!= 8 * $!*# 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ': $!=12 # 11*!D%= 2: BC !" >!*A 22! # ! %, 8!> < *, >!*A > & '! $!=12 # '# > & 2 " %' ) > '

01 $%"%$ $ & !"

8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ': %& 8 $!=12 %!' !"

22! # >!*A > & '! 1!&&%)2 #3 ! '!'&3112: !" "

: !3 12 ' >8 * & % %& 8 $ & !" 8 ' 8 %& !'2:

$%$ #!1 # ): 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ': ! >*%992 !3 !" %& 2% )%2%:

3$8 &* && 8 & ) ' 2 %# ): 2 *' # $!3'& 2 "!* 8 ' !' 8 "

$ 8 BC !" >!*A > & $!=12 # ): * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 '# % $!32# '! 8 < ) ' #!'

>%8!3 11*!< # 2 : !3 12 !> < *, #! '! "%'# ': = *% %' 8%&

*93= '

& %& *%982: !)& *< # ): 8 *)%* !* & > 22 & 2 *' # ##%%!'

%&*%$ 3#9 , =) 11*!< # 2 : !3 12 ' > & $2 *2: '!

* !"

3*8 *=!* , =%'3 & !" = %'9 8 2# 3'# * 8 8 %*= '&8%1 !" 8 031 *%' '#%'9 '9%' * !' 6 6 + $2 *2: * < 2 8 11*!< # 2 : !3 ' > & ' < * 8 '# # !< * ! 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 %2 !" 8 I 9* = '

>%& &$!1 '# ) '$ >!*A >8%$8 %& ! ) $!=12 #J $!312 # >%8 8 * = *A&

& = '%!' # %' 8 = %'9 8 2# !' 6 6 + = $2 * = '%!' 8

2%9'= ' !" 8 & > * 2%' %& ! ) # $%# # >%8%' > A '# "%'

2 1 := ' =

" * $!=12 %!' !" 8 & %# >!*A %& * 2 < ' ! '! 8

$!1: !" =%'3 & !"

8%& = %'9 > * 1*!#3$ # %' !3* 8 %= !"

*93= '& %& !11!& # !

$!==!' & '& 8 %" BC !" 8 >!*A $!32# 8 < ) ' $!=12 # ): 8 * &1!'# ' @ $!=1 ':, >8: * & !" % $!32# '! ) $!=12 #, %" " : !3 ' > & &3112% # ! % &!

& ! '&3* "2!> "*!= !' '# ! 8 !8 * 0%=%2 *2:, !8 * $2 %=& * 9 *#%'9 8 1 * *

'# & $3*%:

=!3' $ < ) ' $!** $2:

22!> # *' # ##%%!'

2 %&*%$ 3#9 8 & "3*8 * $!** $2: !)& *< # 8

?3*%&#%$%!' 3'# * 0 $%!' 6 !" 8 *)%* %!'

'# !'$%2% %!' $, %& 2%=% # '#

*# $ ' ) & &%# !' 8 9*!3'#& * 2 %# #!>' 3'# * 8 $ 0 $%!' 6

!" 8 *)%* %!'

'# !'$%2% %!' $ * #& & 3'# *( I

*)%* *# = : ) & &%# ): 8 !3* !'2: %"K

8 1 *: = A%'9 8 112%$ %!' "3*'%&8 & 1*!!" 8 K

*: > & 3'# * &!= %'$ $%:, !*

*)%* %!'

9* = ' %& '! < 2%# 3'# * 8 2 > !

>8%$8 8 1 *% & 8 < &3)? $ # % !*, "

%2%'9 ': %'#%$ %!' 8 * !', 3'# * 8 2 > "!* 8 %= ) %'9 %' "!*$ L !*

%%% 8 1 *: = A%'9 8 112%$ %!' > & '! 9%< ' 1*!1 * '!%$ !" 8 11!%'= ' !"

*)%* !* !* !" 8 *)%* 1*!$ #%'9& !* > & !8 *>%& 3'

)2 ! 1* & ' 8%& $ & L !*

%< *)%* *# # 2& >%8 #%&13 '! $!' =12 # ):

!* '! "

22%'9 >%8%' 8 *=& !" 8 &3)=%&&%!' !

*)%* %!', !* %

F $!'

%'& # $%&%!'& !' = *& ) :!'# 8 &$!1 !" 8 &3)=%&&%!' !

*)%* %!'( *!<%# # 8 , %" 8 # $%&%!'& !' = *& &3)=% # !

*)%* %!' $ ' ) & 1 # "*!= 8!& '! &! &3)=% #, !'2: 8 !" 8 *)%* *# >8%$8 $!'

%'& # $%&%!'& !' = *& '!

&3)=% # !

*)%* %!' = : ) & &%# L !*

8 $!=1!&%%!' !" 8 *)%* 2 *%)3'

2 !* 8 *)%* 1*!$ #3* > & '! %'

$$!*# '$ >%8 8 9* = ' !" 8 1 *% &, 3'2 && &3$8 9* = ' > & %' $!'"2%$ >%8 1*!<%&%!' !" 8%& "*!= >8%$8 8 1 *% & $ ''! # *!9 , !*, "

%2%'9 &3$8 9* = ', & '! %'

$$!*# '$ >%8 8%& *L !*

) 8 !3* "%'#& 8 K

8 &3)? $= * !" 8 #%&13 %& '! $ )2 !" & 2 = '

*)%* %!' 3'# * 8 2 > "!* 8 %= ) %'9 %' "!*$ , !*

*)%* *# %& %' $!'"2%$ >%8 8 13)2%$ 1!2%$: !"

'#%

*' # $!3'& 2 "!* 8 ' 8 & "

%2 # ! 1!%' !3 ': 9*!3'# >8 &! < *, >8%$8 $ 22& "!* ': %' *" * '$ "!* & %'9 &%# *# # + G G !* # $%&%!' # # B 1 && # ): 8 2 *' # ##%%!'

2 %&*%$ 3#9 , =)

! !8 * *93= '& 8 < ) '

##* && #

22 8 )!< & %# 2& * , $$!*#%'92:, #%&=%&& #

/%& %22

$!) * +, 3#9 Rts M8 8 * &1 A%'94* &!' # (

&4!

M8 8 * * 1!* )2 (

&4!