High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/22/2026dismissed

Sukhbir And Others v. Rajesh Kadyan And Another

2026-03-18Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

% ,#!%$ %$<B3 F5 !/11%"

?<C<B --!66,"# --!66,"# --!66,"# --!66,"#

!-%"2!"#

!!"# $% 14*,!"%"'24%/,#! #&!,--!66,"# @@@@ ' ' ' ' () * +,*%$- !!"#.!/0#1%"!/%"

"2--!,6'/&,66!"9!&,7!!"6 6,12 #%#&!% 2! 2, ,#!2A<<B,"2<C<B -,!27*#&!6!, "!2141602 29! 3!"1% 1411% "5' ,"1-,# ,"2 #&! 6!, "!2 221#1%",6 1# 1/# 029!' ,"1- -,#' ! !7*#&!C 2-, #*%7:!/#1%"- !

!-!/#14!6*+&!

!$! !2,##&!1"#,"/!%$,--!66, ,"# +! !2181!2 () 1 1!$6* #,#1"9' 7,!2 %" ,9 !!

!8!"# #% !66 2,#!2 <<=< <B' !-%"2!"#% $16!2,01#$% -%!1%"7*+ +,*%$-!/1$1/-! $% 8,"/!;0, 07:!/#- %-! #* *,9,1"#&14!"2% D !-%"2!"# %'+&%%+"!2#&!- %-! #* *1" ;0!#1%"'7,!2 %", !91#! !2 !61";01&8!"#2 2!!22,#!2?<<E!.!/0#!2 27* &1 $,#&! &! ,$% !8!"#1%"!2 01# +, $16!2 7* !-%"2!"# %2!/ !! &%6 62! ,9,1"# !-%"2 !"#%%"<=<A<A,"2#& &!,8!+,,66%+!21"&1$,4 4%0 412! :0298!"# ,"2 2!/ !! 2,#!2 <<= 7 7* #&! 6!, "!2 1416 029! 3!"

"1% 1411%"5 ,"1-, ,#&!%-! ,#14!-, ##&! !%$1!

!.# ,/#!2&! !0"2!

? , !;0!6 #% 8* ,7%4! 2 21/01%" $1"21"9' 01# %$ -6,1"

"#1$$ 0/ //!!2,"21&! !7*2!/ !!2+1#&/ /%#!/ !!$% -%!1%"7*+,* ,*%$ -!

!/1$1/ -! $% 8,"/! %" #&! 7,1 %$ $ ,9 !!8!"# #% !66 2,#!2 <<= <B

!.!

!/0#!27*2!$!"2,"#1"$,4%0 %$- -6,1"#1$$1" !-!/#%$#&!/%"# 0/ /#!2 &%0 0! $066* 2!#,16!2 1" #&! &!,2"%#! ! %$ #&! -6,1"# 1 -,!2 1" $,4%0 0 %$ -6,1 ,1"#1$$ ,"2 ,9,1"# 2!$!"2,"# !$!

$!"2,"# 1 21 !/#!2 #% 9!# ,$$!/#!2 2 #&! ,6!

!2!!2;0,#&!01#- %-! #*1"$,4% %0 %$-6,1"#1$$+1#&1",-! 1%2%$#& & !! 8%"

%"#&$ %8-,1"9%$#&!2!/ !!$,16 161"9+&1/&-6,1"#1$$1,#617! #*#% % 9!# ,6!2!!2!.!/0#!2+1#&#&!1"#! 4 4!"#1%"%$#&!%0 # 0 #&! ',2!/ / !! $% -! 8,"!"#1":0"/#1%",6%-, !21"$,4%0 %$-6,1"#1$$+&! !7* * #&! 2!$!

$!"2,"#1 !# ,1"!2$ %8,61!",#1"

"9'8% #9,91"9% / !,#1"9,"*/&, , 9! %4!

! #&! 01# - %-! #* ,"2 !661"9 #&! 01# - %-! #* #% ,"*%"! !./ /!-# -6,1 ,1"#1$$ !/ !! &!!# 7! - !-, !2 , ,//% 21"96* ,"2 $16! 7! /%"19"!2 2 #% !/% % 2 %%8,$#! 20!/%8-61,"/! ""

""%0"/!21"%-!"/%0 # ,# #!2 <<= 3,/&,",5 1416029!3 14"5

,"1-,#' % <CC C= %# 7*8 #!

661.#!!"3B5 1.#!!"3B5 1.#!!"3B5 1.#!!"3B5-,9!%$#&1:0 8! 0298!"#&,4!7!!"/&!/H!2F19 9"!2 3,/&,",5 1416029!3 14"5

,"1-,#' % <CC 41 1"9&'#!"%9 ,-&! C=J ,64 (C) , !2 #&! !0-%"' !-%"2!"# % - !$! !2 !.!/0#1%" ,--61/,# #1%" %B %$ < = #1#6!2 G ,:!& ,2*," 062!!-I %%" #&! !,$#! ' 7!#&!C 2-, #*#%#&!:0298!"#, ,--!66,"#&! !1"

"+&16!/6,181"9#&!8!64!#%7 2!/ !!2,#!2 <<=-,!21"$,4%0 %$ !- -%"2!"#%'$16!2%7:!/#1%"1"

1"#! ,61,%"#&!9 %0 0"2#&,# !-%"2!"#%+,"

"%##&!!./6014!%+"! %$#&! 01# - %-! #* 1" ;0 0!#1%" ,# #&! #18! %$ -,1"9 9 %$ :0298!"# ,"2 2!/ !! 2, ,#!2 <<= (C) # +, -6!,2!2 #&,# #&! !91# #! !2 !61";01&8!"# 2!!2 2, ,#!2 ?<<E7* !1&,"23$,#&! %$-6,1"#1$$,"

"22!$!"2,"#5+,,,16!21" 1416 01#%===%$ <A2,#!2C<<=<A+1#&,- - ,*! #&,##&!,8!,6%"9+1#& /%"!;0!"#1,6 8 80#,#1%" 7! 2!/6, !2 166!9,6' "

"066 ,"2 4%12 &! ,12 01# + +, 21-%!2 %$ 7, !2 %" #&! /%8- %81! 7!#+!

!!" #&! -, #1! 7!$% ! #&! 6!, "

"!2

!121"9 $$1/!

! ',16* %H2,6,#' ,"1-,#& &!01#+,2!/ !!2' !06#,"#6*'

!61";01&8!"# 2!!2 2,#!2 ?<<E ,"2 #& &! 80#,#1%" 7,!2 #&! !0-%" + +! ! /,"/!66!2&!% %-! ,#14!-, #%$#&!% 2! 2,#!

!2<A<A-,!27*#&!, ,16*

%H2,6,#' ,"

"1-,#1!.# ,/#!2&! !0"2!

> !

!!"#

6,1"#1$$1"-! %",1#!

!27*&%941"2! ,61H'24%/,#! #!27*&%&,"1"9&'24%/,#! !$!"2,"#1"-! %",1# 2! 2,#!2<A<A 2! 2,#!2<A<A 2! 2,#!2<A<A 2! 2,#!2<A<A ":%1"# !;0!#'$16!#,H H!"0-1",16* %H2,6,# 6,1"# "#1$$ ,"2 2#&!2!$!"2,"#, !7 %#&! 6,1"# "#1$$$16!2#&!- !!"#01#/&,66!"9 91"9 ,61!",#1%"%$,"/!# ,6- %-! #*7* *#&!1 $,#&! &!1&,"21"$,4% % %$ &1 %" 2!$!"2,"# 062!!- 19"% 1"9 #&! !.1#1"9 19&# %$ &1 %#&! #& & !! %"

" 1! #&! -6,1"#1$$ &! !61";01 &8!"# 2!!2 7!, 1"9 % B= 2, 2,#!2 ? <<E !91#! !2+1#&#&!%$$1/! ! %$07 !91# , ' ,"1-,#1"$,4% % %$ 2!$!

$!"2,"#1/&,66!"9!2 #,#!8!"#%$#&!2!$!"2 2,"# !/% 2!2+&! !1"&!,281##!2 2 #&! /6,1 18%$&17 %#&! 0H&71 ' , 2!!

!-,"2, 2!!-&!2!$!"2,"##, #,#!2 #&,# ,#&!&,"%%7:!/#1%"1$#&! !61";0 01&8!"#2!!27!, 1"9%B=2, 2,#!2 ? <<E1/,"/!6!2 "#&!7,1% %$#&!/%8- %81!'#&!01#121-% %!2 %$ 7 7* #&1 ,+, 2 %$ ,16* %H 2,6 6,# !61";01&8!"# 2!!2 7!, 1"9

!61";01&8!"# 2!!2 7!, 1"9

!61";01&8!"# 2!!2 7!, 1"9 % % % % B= B= B= B= =2,#!2?

=2,#!2?

=2,#!2?<<E,"21#80#,#1% <<E,"21#80#,#1% <<E,"21#80#,#1% <<E,"21#80#,#1% %"1/,"/!6!2 %"1/,"/!6!2 %"1/,"/!6!2 %"1/,"/!6!2 %-* %$ #&! % 2! 7! !"# #% #&! 07 !91# , ' ,"1-,# # $% 8,H ,H1"9"%#!%"#&!/%-*%$#&!1"# 0 08!"#/%"#,1"!21"&17%%H#&! $,/# %$1 1#/,"/!66,#1%"1"#! 8%$!/#1%" C%$#&!-!/1$1/ !61!$/#'BC C 2D 35 !121"9 $$1 ,16* %H2,6,#' ,"

<A< $1/! ' "1-,# <AJ (C) # + +, 0781##!2 #&,# 1" #&! 01# $% -%!1%" 7* +,* %$ -!/ /1$1/ -! $% 8,"/!' !

!-%"2!"# %D2!/ !! &%62! 212 "%# - %4! &1 !,21"! , +1661"9"!#%- -! $% 8&1-, #%$,9 !!8!"##% !662,#!2<<=<B',0/&'

:0298!"#,"22!

!/ !!2,#!2<<=-,!21 1"$,4%0 %$ !-%"2!"#%7! !# ,12!

(E) &!

!,$% !,12%7:!/#1%" ,1!27* *#&!,--!66,"#+! !/%"#!#!2 7* !-%"2!"# % &! 6!, "!2 .!/0#1"9 % %0 # 412! % 2! 2,#!2 A<< <B 2181!2#&%!

!%7:!/#1%"99 1!4!2#&! !%$' 1 #--!,6+,$16!2'+& &1/& +,,6%2181 !2412!% 2! 2,#!2<C<B B-,!27*#&!6!, "!2221#1% %",6 1# 1/#029!'

,"1-,#/08 1 #--!66,#!%0 0 # (=) 8- -09"1"9#&!,$% !,12% 2! -, ,!27*#&!6!, "!2%0 #7!6% %+' 6!, "!2 /%0"!6 6 $% #&! ,--!66,"# 0781# # #&,# 1" #! 8 %$ #&! +!66 !## #6!2 +'C 2-, #*%7:!/#1%"/%062"%# - 1"/1-6!%$6,+ &,4!7!!"2181!2088, 16* *, #&!6!, "!2%0 0 #7!6%+%09&##%&,4!$ ,8!2 2-!/1$1/10!+1#& !-!/##% 8! 1#%$%7:!/#1 1%" ,1!27*#&!,--!66,"#'#&0 0#&!18-09"!2% 2! +! !61, ,76! #%7!!#,12! (=)

!, , "!2 /%0"!6 ,6% 0781# #&, ,# #&! % 2! -,!2 7* #&! 6!, "

"!2

1 #--!66,#! %0 #+,+&%66*"%"-!,H1"9'

'6,/H1"9,"*:021/1,6 !,%"1"9, 0"0#,1",76!1"

"6,+',0/&#&!- !!"#,--!,6 6+,#%7!,66%+!27*!##1"9, 12! #&!18-09"!2% 2! 35 (B) &, ,4!&!, 26!, "!2/%0"!6$% #& &!,--!66,"#,"29%"!#& %09& -,-! 7%%H,8 80",76!#%$1"207#,"/!1"#&!

!07811%"8,2!%"7!&,6$%$ ,--!66,"# (A) " #&! - !!"# /,!' #&! 01# - - %-! #* +, !61";01&!2 7* 2!/!,!2$,#&! 1"$,4%0 %$%"!%$&1%"1 ! !-%"2!"#%412! !91#!

! !2 !61";01&8!"# 2!!2 7!, 1"9 %B= 2,#!2 ?

?<<E +&1/& +, $%66%+!2 7* !"# * %$ 80#,#1 1%" 7,!2 #&! !0-%" " #! 8 #&! !%$' !-%"2!"# % +& &16! /6,181"9 &18!

6$ #% 7! #&! !./6014! %+"! 1 1" -%!1%" %$ #&! 01# - %-!

! #* !"#! !21"#%,", ,9 !!8!"##%!662,#!2<<=< <B+1#& !-%"2!"#%,!2 2%" #&! ,12 ,9 !!8 8!"# #% !66' !-%"2!"# % $1 16!2 01# $% -%!1%" 7* +,* * %$

-!/1$1/-! $% 8 8,"/! , +!66,$% -! 8,"!"# # 1":0"/#1%" !$6!/#!2 $ %8 !/% 2'#&!01# #+,$16!2%"<=<A<A,"2# #&!,8!+,2!/ !!21"$,4%0 %$ !-%"2!"#% %"<<=%+!4! '1"# #&!8!,"+&16!'%#&! 6!9,6&!1 %$ 2!/!,!2 !1 &,"2 - !$! !2 , 01# $% 2!/ /6, ,#1%" ,9,1"# !-%"2!"# % %' ,,161"9#&!4,6 6121#*%$#&! !61";01&8!"#2!!

2'+&! !1"7%#&#&!-, #1!!"#!

! !2 1"#%,!##6!8!"

"#,"27*41 #0!#&! !%$'#&! !61"

";01&8!"#2!!22,#!2?<< <E ,"2#&!80#,#1%"

"7,!2#&! !0-%"+! !!#,12 2!7*#&!6!, "!2 !121"9 $$1/ /! ' ,16* %H 2, ,6,#' ,"1-,# % /%"4!"1!"/!' !6!4,"# 2,#! ,"2 !4!"# 1" #,706,#!2$% 8, , !!.# ,/#!2&! !0"2!

?<<E

!61";01&8!"# 2!!2 +, 3$,#&! %$ -6,1"#1$$ ,"2 2!

!-%"2!"# % 34!"2% 5 +1#& !-%"2!"#%34!"2!

01# $% 2!/6, ,#1%" $16!2 7 !-%"2!"# % 34!"2% 5 !61";01&8!"#2!!22,#!2 A 01# $% -!/1$1/ -! $% 8 !-%"2!"#%34!"2!!5,9 01# $% 2!/6, ,#1%" $16!2 7 7,!2%"/%"!"#914!"7* !

01# $% -!/1$1/ -! $% 8 34!"2!!52!/ !!2,9,1"# ! !.!/0#!2 7* 2!/!,!2 !1 &, !$!"2,"#5 1" $,4%0 %$ !-%"2 2!"# <<=<B !"#! !2 1"#% ," ,9 !!8!"# #% !!D-0 /&,! 5 7* #&! ,--!66,"#D%7:!/#% ,9,1 !66 C<<=<A 1"# 5 - ,*1"9 $% !##1"9 ,12! ?<<E %$ <=D<B<A<A 8,"/! ,"2 -%!1%" $16!2 7* 9,1"# !-%"2!"#%34!"2% 5 7* #&! ,--!66,"#D%7:!/#% 2!/ <A<A !!2 !-%"2!"#%34!"2!!5 8,"/! $16!2 7* !-%"2!"# <<= % -%"2!"#%34!"2% 5 (?) -- -, !"#6*,"2!412!"#6*'#&!,--!

66,"#,"2 !-%"2!"#%,/#!2 21" /%6601%"+1#&!

!,/&%#&! $% 9!##1"9#&! !61";0 01&8!"#2!!22,#!2?<<E E#% 7! 2!/6, !2 , 166!9,6' "066 ,"2 4%12 1" % 2! #% 2!$!,# #&! 19&# %$ !-%"2 2!"# %D2!/ !!&%6 62! ! #1"!"#6*'1"#&!01#- !$ $! !27*#&!,--!66,"#' !-%"2 2!"# %2!/ !!&%6 62! +, 18-6!,2!2 , -, #* , ,"2 #&! - %/!!21"9 +! ! /, 1!2 7!&1"2&17,/H ,"2+1#&%0#!4!"1"$% 81"9&18 8,7%0##&!,8!

() " #&! 914!" $,/#' +&! !1" #&! ,- --!66,"#D%7:!/#% ,"2 !-%"2 2!"# %+! !/6%!

!6* !6,#!2#%!,/&%#&! 7!1"9$, ,816*8!87! '"%$0 #&! !412!

"/! +, !;01 !2$% #&!-0 -%!%$ !/% 21"9,"*$ $1"21"9;0,#&!1 /%66014!7!&,4 41% ,#&!,8!+, !412!"#,"2%741%0%"#&!$, ,/!%$1# 0 #&! 8% !'#&!/%660 1%" 7!#+!!" #&! ,-- -!66,"#D%7:!/#% ,"2 !-%"2!

!"# % /," 7! 2 ,+" !4!" $ %8 #&!1 -,#!"# ,"2 2 6,#!"# /%"20/#K #&!* &,41"9 9 9%# #&! !61";01&8!"# 2!!2 2, ,#!2 ?<<E7!1"

"92!/6, !2'166!9,6'"066,"24%1 128! !6*7*%$$! 1"9#&!1 /%" !"# 7!$% !#&!,16* * %H2,6,#,"2#&,##%%1"#&! ,7!"/!%$#&!2!/ !!&%62! % ! #&," #&,#' , 0 01# $% 2!/6, ,#1%" +, $16!2 7 * #&! ,--!66,"#D%7:!/#% ,9,1 1"# !-%"2!"# % %"6* ,$#! #&! $161"9 %$ 01# $ $% -%!1%" 7* +,* %$ -!/ /1$1/ -! $% 8,"/!7* !-%"2!"#%34!"2!!5,9,1"

"# !-%"2!"#%34!"2% 5 (<) " 0/& /1 /08#,"/!' #&! ,--!

!66,"# 7!1"9 &,"2 1" 96%4! + +1#& !-%"2!"# % 2!! 4!2 "% 2!#,16!2 # 1,6 #% #&!1 /,0! 7* #&! 6!, "!2 %0 0 # 66* 7* +,* %$ C 2 -, #* %7:!/# 7!6%+' !-!/1,6 #1%" 1" #&! !.!/0#1%" ,--61/,# #1%" - !$! !27* ! -%"2!"#%'+&%+,'1"$,/#'

'7!1"92!$ ,02!27*#&!,--!66, ,"# !"# 2!7#% //% 21"96*' #&! C 2 2 -, #* %7:!/#1%" % ,1!2 7* ,"2 #&! :0298!

,--!66,"#7!1"9 9$ 14%6%0'#&! !+,"%"!!2%$ $ $ ,81"910!1"#&1 !9, 2 ()

#&! '"%8! 1#/,"7!$%0"21" #&!07811%"8,2!%"7!&,6$ $%$ #&! ,--!66,"# #&,# !-%"2!"# %D2!/ !! & &%62! +, "%# ,76! #% - %4! &1 !,21"! ,"2 + +1661"9"! #% -! $% 8 &1 -, # # %$ ,9 !!8!"# #% !66 1" ;0!# #1%" 7!$% !#&!6!, "

!2 1,6%0 #%0/&-6!,/, ,"7!-! 81##!2#%7! !,91#,#!2 27* 2-, #*%7:!/#% ',##&1#,9!'

#&!,--!66,"#DC ',#&!,8!#,"22!#! 81"!2 21" $,4%0 %$ !-%"

"2!"#%D2!/ !!&%62! 7*#&!

!6!, "!2 1,6%0 #,##&!#18!

!%$ -,1"9%$:0298 8!"#,"22!/ !!2,#!2<< =1"&1$,4%0

() "4 41!+%$21/01%"8,2!&! !1", ,7%4!'#&!$1"21"9 !/% 2!27* 6!, "!2 %0 # 7!6%+ 7!1"9 7,!2 %" - %-! ,-- !/1,#1%" %$ -6!,21"9 ,"2 8,#! 1,6 ,4,16,7 76! %" !/% 2' #&! ! 7!1"9 "% % 166!9,61#* % -! 4! 1#* +1#& 18-09"!2% 2!

'"%1"#! $! !"/!1/,66!2$% %"!;0!"#6*'#&!- !!"#.!/0# #1%" !/%"2--!,6' 1&! !7*2181!2 (C)

"21"9,--61/,#1%"35'1$,"*&,66 ,6%#,"221-%!2%$ 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 , /& , /& , /& , /&?

?'< '< '< '<B #1H L& L& &!#&! -!,H1"9D !,%"!2 ! &!#&! !-% #,76! ! D% D%