Gurpal Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR









 

 





!
 

 

 

      !"  

 

#$%&#'()*+,-.
*$+(.*&$/$-

" #
$"
$%&'
(%)"
' *"+
,+
"
'
- "
$"
.
 /+
 
,
 "/+
% .0 $"
 ".
1'")+
,
"
)-/ 2"-  
 $+(.*&$/$-0+1#$)2
'
-
% "
1
3!

'


") /
"%" '
0
/
"
4%' *


 !

!

6
"*"
% "

1 
7 3+7 7+73

'
  /

8"
'"
9'
 9:+

/ 1
' +
"
' 
 
//
 /
-" *
" '"")+

'
0

)-") ;
""

!

!+
'
-"
<"
"

--"

0"
'
"/
%"=//4
$*"+
"
* *
'"
) 
"">

 '
* % 

'
)-")

)-/ 
'"+
"-"

%/ $*"

/+
' 

?

!+
'
0
",+
<'" +
 '
0 
'
'
)-")
"",


0<
'
-"

* % + ,/% "@+
<'%
 @
"
"
% %
 /% 
 

'"
") /

 - *
* 
')
'
%/)
)+
0.,
 
*/


/*/
@)


" / '
/
 /
A<

"4%"
 /@

 %"
'
--/


',

*' <'
'
'"
.%

-"
'"
"*'

-"-"@+
"*'

/
 
/0"@
 '"
"*'
%"

')
0@
'
/*/
@)
'
,/
-%
"
'

 /
0<
<
-"+
', *
/"
," 
"
'
/
""+
/ '") @
"
'
@

%'
 
0/%
")

*,

'
-"
 /
'"
-%
0@
)-")+

%"+
) *
<'
"
/*/  

<//
<,"+
'
") /
-%


"/@
"" ')/,

 /@
<
-"

'
-%

")

'"
-+
 

'
") /

 


'"

 
 
,
%-

'
@

/"*
'""+
'
/<
-""0
-% ') +
,"
-% ')  
'
B")
-% ') +
 /% *
'
- /@
"
") /

<,"
)"
 
'
,/
-%
"
 "2
 /
 <
-"
" ")
')/,
 
") /
-
'""+
'
/*/ @)
-/@
)-"

"/,
'
 /
0<
<
-">
<'
'
 &

 %" *
'
'
,"
)-

-%
4%
@

/"*
 ) )C
%
//
'
"



"/,
'
 /
0<
<

0@ -% *


"
'""+
,
'
") /
/<

"4%"

*,
%
"*"
 '
<'

'
-"

-%
* C *
'
-" -/
 /@+
'
 

/*/
1@)
/
-",
"
"* C *
'
)-")
0<
<

 
") /
-%
1
7
"




B-"
-",

'
"*"
'  
 /@
-",
"
)-% *
%" *
'
"/+
0%
-") )-% *
,

--//
"
", /
*
<,"
0@

,"@
%" 
-+
1
7
"





0
'
/
"-"@>
<'"
' "* 


)-")
0<
'
-"
',>
"/@>

0   
'

"/
 /@

'
 
-""0
% "
'
 

/

'"
"

/
)"
 
-""0
%
 
,

'  
B *

'
 
<
)  
"

")
)

)+
)& '
B *
 

0
/*'"
"
" * 
 
, <
)/

-"
  
"
0 *
"* 

,<

'

/*/
, ) 
'


 
"4%"
'

"
/& *
0@ 
1
7
"




"* 
'
)-")
0<
'
-"

-%
%

)   @

'
-"%"
-""0
"
") /
"/>
'
"/
%"



0 -")

",/
0@ 
'
-
-""0
% "
'
-"%"
 
'


"
 ,& *
1
3!
"


0@
'
*'
%"
%+

0",
0,+
'
<'

 /@
-"

'
") -%
<%/

/<@
0
% 

") 

") /
"/

,<

' - +
/ 
"
%0/
>
'"
 %
<%/
',
/
4%
'
@
 /"*
'""
'
 
))
0@
-" 
 ,/,

*,"


"

) "
"
4%" *
/
-<"
"
<'/
B" *

-<"




0
-")

0
)-")
A&<+
,
'
 
 ,/,  /@
<
-",
-" +
0%
"/ *
-",@

'""
"
 ,/, % *
   /
/

/
"
% *
   /
/

-"-"@
0@
B )) 
'"

/

/>



0
-")

0
)-")
B- '
0,)  
*",
 +
'"

,"@
"
'
//
'"
 '%/
0
-")

0
)-")
0@
'
%"
1 
'
-"

 0"
'
%"+
*
<%/
 ,/,
'
 %

'
-"

-%+ '""

'
%"


-")
'
)

0
)-")
'
'
-" <%/
 

-/@
"&
%-
'
%"

 %"
'
4%/

%
0@ %0," *
'
) "

") /
.%
 


,"

'
 "
 ) "

") /
.%

"
'
C

/"


-
'
"& * 

0
-/@
%-
%"

%0,"
'
.%
@)
1

<%/ /<@
0

'
 "

.%
/>
'
'
)-")
0<
'
-" 
"* C
 
'
C
")
)"
 
))

'
 /
 '
@)

) "

.%+

/+
4%
'
 +
<''
'  "

@


-")

0
)-")
 90/
'
1%-")
%"
'
)-/@
/"
'
/*/
-


"* C *
)-") *

'



1 *'
;
1

% .0


'"+

83:

8") /:
637+
 
'
0",

% "#2
D65
'
-
'
)"*
")
'
0,
%

0 %))"
'%#
'
-<"

'
*'
%"

4%' *

") -" *
"

"
)-/ 

B"


 '" 
.%"


 
 
" 
")
'
-<"
*,


") /
%"
"

)-% *
'
 
% "
1
7

'

 '"  -<"


<
-/ %
<'

%"@
/)
0%

'
 0
B"

"
<'
'
*%/ 
 *"

%'
-<"

,C>
8:

%"
'
 

.%
"
8:

-", 
0%

' -"

 @
%"

<'

-<"

4%'
'
") -" *
"
)-/ 
"

)@
0
B"
<'"
'  "
 
,)
',
/
'"
-%
<%/
- 
 
 
"%) 

'

 

*"@

0 -""0
<,"+
0"
B"

%'
-<"+
'
*'
%" )%
',
%
"*"

'
%"
 
*",@

'
")
 % 
"%
 

) /
-",@
"
 
/&
)%""+ "-+
@+




0
 */@
4%'
,
'%*'
'
,) "
,)9
)/@
 
'
 "
',
/
'
-%
1%'

 
"

-",
 %"
 
',
"%
)-

@ 1)/"/@+
 @
)-")
0<
'
,)
 
 "


"/

'
 
% "
-/
%
/&
", 
 ""%-

"
'
 
))
0@
-%0/
", 
<'/ <"& *

'
-@
>



-",
"
 @
0
"

4%' *
") /
-" *
 ,/, *
%'
 
%
' ") /

', *
,"<'/) */@
 
-")  */@
,/ /,%"
 

" 
 *
"
'
-%"-

4%' *+ -"%/"/@
'
 
" *
")
))"/+
 /+ )" /+
,/+
-" "'-
"
%'
/&
"  
"
'
 " *
%

)") @
"/ *

<"@+

"
'
)/@ -%
<'"
'
<" *

0//@
-",
"
-" /
 %" 
'
-"
',
"/,
'"
 "
-%

'
*"@
 +
*'
%"
)@
4%'
") /
-" *



,<+ 0%

'
)-")
0<
'
 "
 
,)+
' -0/@

 ,

")
 
0/&
 
  %
 ") /

<%/
-%
%

*"
--" 
-".%


B")
 .%
<%/
0
%

')
0@

4%' *
' ") /

-
%//
 
)-/
/) 
 
)-") <'
'
,)

'"
<"+
'
*'
%"
)%
 "

<''"

<%/
0
% "
"
 ""@

'
 "

.%
   %
<'
'
") /
-" *
"
  %

'
") -" *
<%/
 )% 

0%

-"

/<
- /) 
 
)-")
0<
'
,)
 
<" *"
 <''"

%"
'
 

.%+


--"-"
'
") 

-%


 
 

'
 <"

'
0,
4% 8:



"),+
'
*'
%"
'//
0
<//
<'

.%"
 4%'
'
") /
-" *E
'
-" 



//
 @ 

'
B- 
 ,* 0,
 +

,<

'
"-"

%/
$*"

/+
'  
?

!
)

-%"% 

'
""

!

!
-
0@
' %"+
'
%"
/
'

%%/
-%"-
<%/
0
",
0@
&- *
' -" *
/,

<//
0

'
 "

.%+

'
/) 
"' 0<
'
-"

-
" */@+
'
-" 
-

//<

 !
 !

6
"*"
% "
1 
7 3+7 7+73

 

/
1

' +
"
' 
/ *
<'
//
 /
-" *
" '"")

'"0@
4%'
4%
'
-" 
- " 1$+(.*&$/$-2  +,4*





 ! F''"
-& *
=
" 
#


F''"
-"0/
#