Sahab Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana

    

     



  !"#"$%&'&
 ((     )

*# + *#,# STATE OF HARYANA )& #-$.

/% $012 *&,# &(&3 * % *& ,24 $- 27(*&.8!

9"

*&*:,$4 $- 27.8!

 *-

*&& *&(

-("$;6 $$7..2& 7 *< & === &(&3 7&>+ ?
&

 "# 1 "$;

$ ,- * 6

*"$; 6*,;6 +".

$!"$;., 8".
@- /"!& & * < *"$

"$,$.

*( "$@ *&& &"# *;* "2

*& /"9".9 (

 "$"$!

 &
'.

.A&
&
7* ;"#

.,$.

*( "$#
@7
77@A7 7A7'7 A
7
   7
'7

 2"!

 (

<  $#"7 "# *"!

"# *& $

.#$ "!"$;6

*&
( 1("$;6

.<1

$;*

!$!

##"$ * "21< *."$

 $!6  8".

*.

*.

.&&
& &

. !,$# 2 !$

$.#

* & 9 $/"$

-2"!"

$, 1<6 *.

.6,#1 $.7

/$ !!,$    !2 "/ /  1< 6 * 6 # $

$ *

 6 *7 "$8

"$"$ "#!/-2

7!6 $6 #1

$ "2 .7 2"#2"5 2<

*".  7$,# ,2-,*-# 9,2. .1<5

-"$;-

*&1 6"$.1 *#&4

.!,$# 2 *

BC

*&* #,-$ !"#"$ $012 (,-*
  

       & 

!"#"$"$( $:

$.* 0#!

>#,-* ?"#* -*.,!

,$.

*% E? /"$; 1 !5 #    -*  !

7 1

# 6  * ,#  *  * ;*    1 "2 $ 9 ;*,$.#%6 -*"/ *<;*,$."#

"$#

.- *#$#"#8 *<# *",#"$828"$;.

-*

.-2 $$"$; "$96"!676,;

 "$ $!"

22##"#!

,# (

D!6 *G

 # !$.

*< ;*,$. "#

 -##"1"2"

<   *#$#

*"$;9"

9"

#&$ -* !6 "#

 !6

"$; $.."#6$ 2<"$.,!"$;.

2"8 *<  -*- <7 *;

*< * -,*-#  !6

"$;,#"$; #;

$,"$ ..!,/ &6 -,$"#6/ "#-,$"#6/

*/96"!6/

$<

*#& "#7$.,1 *,

$

!6 / <1 71,

#

 -,$"#6/  96"!6 < / < 1  2"

7 "  !$8"!

.7 2#1

*#,-$ "##, &6 7"$.

*/"$"$;

;* "271 *",#$ ##  !6 <  -,$"#6/ #6,2.1

$"$

"$& 6 ;* ** ,# 2 ;* "22"

#9"

6"$ ."#!*

&6 ;* *.

$"

2"#*

.7 2

71<

$.!"*!,/#

# 

!6- "!,2 *!

&,

7 *";6 "2 "# $  .

$"

. / 2< 1 ,#    #  !//,$"

"$#

BC

.&6 -*"/ *<-,*-# # 1 "2"$ !*"/"$ 2!

. "/-*"#$/ (

1,*.

$ 5

-"$;6"/7- $."$; 27

5

- .!$# *,!

"8 2<"$ !,# .< 

*

*!$8"!

"$7 ##,*

9"22#,1/"

 :,*"#."!

$. 1  "$

  * 6"# -*  "# * F,"* .& 6"#  "$ ,*!6 ("$;6 *#&+#&(


@A'( 
A@1#

9 /,$

"$#796"2 *"$;-

"$ *;* "2"$$$1 "2  */ *",#$ ## 

2"5 2"6.  . 2

"$; */:,#

$.6"#

*"$;9"

-*# !, "$9"

#& 6  /

$#,* "* 2  &6,;67 #- "#.

1< ";6 "$"

#"/-,;$ .*.

*7"$,*8"

97

"#$ !$8"$!"$;& ?36 ,$.

2-*"#$ *#

"$ ."$:

"2!,# .<

$"$.

"$"

*".7* "!2 
  $# "$"#8"2

.& *<- *#$7.

"$ .* **

.7"# #-

.< 27 "$"#%96

"#-##"12 -* & 6  #

. - *#$#& (

   9"

#*,$# 26,$.* .- .!,/ #$ 96"!6* "#-2 .1< -*# !, "$7"#82,/"$,#&6

2 /

 !$#".

$. "

 25#  ,#

-- #796 "$:

"276 "$"$:

"22$;

*". .

"$76 <1

$!$8"!

.& "#$

BC "$

 :,#

.#6,2.1 "$:

"2 * $"$.

"$"

*".&.,1 "$# -- #"# *",#$

*/#  .6,;

2## (

D!6 *7

71<"

2 7#6,2.$

*,# */ $2 *;"$; -- $1 "296 "#$# *",#!$

#-$.

.7 "  *

. $ 1 "27 9,2. "$

 9"

2*

*9"

8".

&3 .$

$<;.*

#$

"$ ."$!,# .<7

!/-2

"$8

$. "2"$;  !6 #6

&6"# 7"$

 (

 H +#&

>

?
(

A'76

.% I
& $ .

!"."$; 1 "2 --2"!

"$# $ "/-*

96"!6#6,2.!

"$2<1

$"$

"$1< !,* "# <"$!$!2,."$; 2&

2 <

*#7 $. "  . "# .

$"

. 1 "2 1,  "# ,2

2< !F,"

.7 96 9"22 * # / $< <

*#   6"#2"

#- "$!,# .<J#* "!2 
  $# "$7 96"!6"# /# #"!  22  ,$.

2*";6 #"$ ,* $# "$7$ 8"2

."$#,!6 J !,*#

6"# "#$  $2< *71, "

"#!

"$2< $ "/-*

*#"$.

!"."$;96

;* "2&$ -* #-$.

.<#- .

<#"$ !,# .<> ##

."$  6"#!,$

* ".

8"

?7

$*

#$96<6 #6,2.1 $"

.1 "2&.!

"$!

*!

. *  2$; - *". / $. ,- 2"5  *& 

*2 #"!5 $K#$8 2  9 #7 96 *;

 6"# -* ##"$ $ 6"# $  "$  "22 &I A? $ L"6 * ..

* (!

/K7

5"$; "$ !$#".

*",#$ ##  !6

BC D"/,/ #

   "/-*"#$/

 !,2. 1  "/-# "$!2,."$;

-- #9 "$:

"2 * *". /* $#"D/$ 6# #$

 - ##"$;  *.

*79 8"

9

 ,* *.

-- #-* 

2-*"#$ *#9,2.$ $<-,*-# & '?3 !$#!",# 

!6 9"

!$/"! #   6,;

 / ;$"

,.

& 3 2# !$#!",# 

.7" -*8 .7/ :

*."M !$/<  !,$ *<& 79 $$ 2# #";6

"$8

"$; $!<6

.<!/-2

."$8

!6 #6

"#

.< "2 .1 (- !"

2,.;

7 9 26"&6 "* -*  "$  !,# .< / < $  $ *< * ,* "$8

"$&3 8"

9

--

;*  1 "2- $."$; 2$# *"$;

!$."

"$#"$*.

22< --* $#"$ D-* .1< &N &

.!,$# 2 2#* #,-$ !"#"$ 


'
'7 $ 

$ 8#& (

   ,$:

17 !".

.$
&'&
'796"!69 ,$.

*( "$#77A7 A
 $.
  7"$96"!6

"$9 #"$828 ."$
 #$".

2!6 #1, 9 #*

.$* "21<

5"$;"$

!!,$

* 6 . 1

$ ;*

. 1 "2 "$ ";6  !

# 96

"$# 9  ".

2

 ! .  

"$

.<$* "27 9 1< ;"#

!& &  *!$ 72

...2& 7 *< 7$"$# *,!

"$# */

BC (#65H,/ *7!$

$.#

6,;6-

*&0#6,#1 $.9

*-

1, 5, $,/1 * 2"

"$#,* -2"!"

$.6"#

6,;6$ !!,$  !

*9 .  #.

!!,$    !!".

 #  /  !2 "/ * 1 # ,$.

"$#,*  -2"!"

#& 4

. (

 !,$# 27 69 *7 !$ "*/#

"$8

"$"#!/-2

7- </ $ !!,$  "$#,* !2 "/#9  *

* &7 !6 $ 6 # 1

$ -*

.7 6,;6 !6 <

 *

*"#"$!,# .<#"$!

&&
& A& 6 #,1/"##"$# 2

.!,$# 2 * #& '& ./"

.2<7 -

* & "#  9".9   .

. (

 "$7969

$,/1 * "$#,* -2"!"

$. .

#-"

 #, *"$; */ !

*7 6"# .

6 9 # #69$ # .,

!!".

& 9 *7 ! .7 ( 1 ("$;67 96 "#  !,#"$  

.(

 "$ $.96"# / 2#

(

 "$6 8"$;- <1< 22"$; */1,22!5!

96"2 *"."$; 9"

6 6"/7 96

 .

. "# #

 6  ."

. 96"2  ;"$;  (76

57"$ *7 *

5"$;

76

.<1

$*

$ 1 "2 8".

 *.

* .

. &&
& 

* & 6 # $

$<!2 "/,$.

2"

"$#,* -2"!"

#1<  *;* *

 /

$< * $#,* $< * 6*"

#7 # -

/ 1<2

.!,$# 2 *-

*&&  .,1

"$# *",#1, F, 96

6 (

 "$ !!".

2*$ !!,$  !

*."#

$.96

*-

*

BAC &9 #"$828 ."$ !//"##"$  9,2.1 #,1:

*  2&

*&7"# 9/ $76 #2# *6,#1 $.7.

 6 $< -* 8",# !*"/"$ 2 * !*. $. "# 1 6"$. 1 *# #"$!

&&
7 2 "# 2"5 2<

 !$#".

 !$!2,.

7 "$  !"*!,/#

#7 $ ,# ,2 -,*-#  9,2. 1  # . 1<

-"$; -

* &  1 6"$. 1 *#& !!*."$;2<7

"$ ,$.

( "$ @ *&& & "#
&  

* & /" "# *.

.$* "2.,*"$; $!<  2$6 * ,*$"#6"$; "2 1$. $. #,*

< 1$.  #

"# "$    2

2

O 6"

,."!"

2 ;"#

O, < ;"#

!$!

.7-*8".

.#6 "#$ F,"* ."$ $< *!

$. ,* *#,1:

* ,*$"#6"$; ,$.

5"$;1 2

2

#6 9"22$ -* ## ** "8 $< /,$  */ $<$#,* $<* $< 6*"

6 6 *6,#1 $.$ #"#  !!".

.,*"$; $!<   2& 

* & #6 22 2# !/-2< 9"

!$."

"$#!$

"$ ."$( "$A>? *&& &9 *7$ 6"$;#

"$ 18 #6 221

D-* ##"$ -"$"$$ / #  & A& 

229 ."$ .."* "$#& >&(&3 ? ,.;

&'&