High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1022/2023dismissed

Suresh Bala And Another v. Suresh Kumar

2023-12-12Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh7 pages

"## $%!&'("

&% ###))(("!

*%!$!

$%!&+$,% ###!) ! %!"

%#$%-&((. /

%&))(("!#

%# 0"12$). /

%&/ %%!) "# ! "

# 4&)%!"))(&!-" -0&))(("! "

5 "!&6$ 5,"! 7#7#7)!! -0& $%

(# / ( 8$ 5 %# /"#.8 "

## )!! -0& $%

"( !% 8$ 5.8 "

9&%-0 "$%%" "5!&/-"% 5 "! &))(("!"

&!$ -0%!) "$%!&+$,%

%!)

%,""

(% "!"

! 9& (&!$ -0& ))(("!

% (% " &

& 5%," !((

##:((5 -;$ !& "5&.&$!-"

))((" < #9 &%5% !$ )% )%0 ! (!"

$,""

- "

"5 "&))(("!.9! # 4&-% !

%!) "%&$%!&+$,%

%!)

##:

9& &9!;$ !& "5& " / $%

%!) "9 &%5%

!$ )% )%0#4&! !& "5& %&;$

5%," !(("

))(("!%9

$5&%

! !& "5&#4& (!( "9!!# ..="

!& "5& % / !#.:.=!%"!, "0 ,%!) "& ,

! !((# 4& / (!$ -0%!) "$%!&9! "! -0 ))(("!"

&0 9% "!,"# ># ))(("! !)% / (!$ &(("5 "5&/( 0

%! 5%," !(( ##:# 4& ! / ( !$ 9!

"! -0%!) "9& 9% "!,"# # '

&& / (!$ !9% ( -0&(%" % ( $% "

/ (!$ ( $%!&+$,%*!#$%!&'( %!#9! % - % !( !# "&)( "5!

)% !.

(( 9 "5 !!$!9%

%, # ?&&% & )( "

! " ( %

% !)

##:!$-6,%

&!$ ( "59 & "!@$" (%(

)%,"" "6$" %!% " "5 & "

"! , ( " "5 & !$ )% )%0 !

)%0

%A #?&&%&)( "

&!"

( $!!"

(&)%!"!$ A #?&&%&)( "

&!"

, & $%9 &("

!A >#?&&%&)( "

!! ) , ( "5&)%!"!$ -0 & ! ""

$A #?&&%&)( "

&! "(

,% ( !

,& $%A :#( :# B" % /& !!.%!) "$%!&+$,%!))

" 9 "!!- ;!?"

;, " ?, &%.! "5 9 "!!

##: C;#.? <%!&+$,%.

5 !%0(%19& ) %5% "5%5 !%

!((

C;#.?>6!&<,-% %.9& & !! 5"$%! "C;#> - "5 !9 "!!#?D& "5&(!

) %5% "55%," !(( C;#- "5 !!% -#(!

$ & !%5 !% " " "5&%(/" "%09 &%5%

%! !((#?:$%!& +$,%.,)*"

%)% / &!,)))%! "9& &&5%,"

!(( "@$! "9!!% - #(!

/ %(/""%0

& !%5 !% %5% "5!(

!,)))%! "@$! "#!) "$%!&+$,%(!

$,"!C;# C;#. )0

85 !& "5&

%1# #

"& &%&"

. $"!(

%&))(("!;, " ? $%!&'(.?$%"

%.? $-&!&"

$,"!

C;#?='. %1"

%1# 7# %&% "5- && $"!(

%)% !.&(%" % ( $%, "($!

"&5%," ##: ! 5"$ "

$," 9& & 9! ;$ -0 85 !& "5& " / $%

%!) "

% ( !( "

!# ..= $

9& & !#.:.=9%) !%"!, "0-0&/"

&/"

$%&% "($ &%!) "9!(90!% 0"

9 (( "5

%, & ! )%

& "% "

"!@$"(0 & !$

% !)

##:# # ?& (&!$ -0&))(("!9! !&0

( /& % "# # 4&))(! -0))(("!5 "!&6$ 5,""

7#7#7 9% (!

-0 ,, " 6$ 5,"

> ## )!! -0& $%

"( !% 8$ 5.8 "

# ' "5 55% / . & )%!" ))( &! -" -0 & ))(("!# # B&/&% $"!(

%&)% !# # 4& $"!())% "5 "-&(

&))(("! "%( !$-, ! & 5%," !(( C;# 9! "/% ;$ -0 85 !& &$!-"

))(("< #"

))(("< #. $% "5& !( , "

&!, !"

-% "5&! 5"$%!

!&! !/ " , ! , "0

? ? #B ! $%&% ""

&5%," !(( C;# ! 1"

$,""

!%/! !!

# )%0% !, &&)%!"))(-(( 9 &!$ -0%!)

%!)

"%-! "C;#!& $( -

9& (&!$ -0&))(("!!1 "5! "5!

!((C;#- >#

" & &% &"

. & $"!( ))% "5 " -&(

%!) "=/ %.9& (!$)) % "5& ,)$5" 6$ 5,"!

!&&;$

!((C;# ##:&!

-" $((0)% / "&% -0 !! "59 "!!",(0?,

&%# B ! $%&% ""

$," C;# ! %5 !%

$,""

!%5 !% " ! $((0)% / -0? %5 !% "(%1# 4&!,)/"

%$%!&+$,%9& ())% "5 "9 "!!- ;!?:

)% / "%" &!,)))%)$%&! !&

%&)$%)

!((C;##B ! $%&%!$-, && ,

&! 5%,"85 !&% / %"!, "0 %&!#.:.= $

(!(

!# ..="

%5 ;

%;$

!( 9!7#:#:"

%!) ))% "&

$-5 !%% "%" ( "59 &-("!(

"& #B ! $%&% ""

&&% !"

& "5 "& % /&5%," !((C;# ! 1

$,"#4&

$"!(

%&%!) "&! $%&% ""

&& % "@$! &!(% 0-" $((0! !

#4&% ( $%% 5&(0 &!$

-0&%!) ""

&!$ -0))(("!#B ! $%&%

&&% !"

((5( 0/" "&6$ 5," ## )!! -0& $%

"( !% 8$ 5.8 "

# B&/ % &!$-, !!

"!, -0 $"!(

%& )% !# :# D% ,&)%$!(

&/ "( -0&%!) " "

%, / / !!.&;$

!((C;# !"

! $((0)% / #?, &%)% / !;$ "- "5 "

! "59 "!!#E"

$- (0.5%," !((C;# !%5 !%

$,""

$,9 &%5% !%5 !% "&!-")% / -0 ? <%!&+$,%5 !%0(%1 "&

$-5 !%% "%" ?D& "5&. $,"?% %(!

) %5% "5C;#9& & 9!0) -0& ,& "!"

!&#4&

$,"9% %(!

$ %5 !% " " "5%(/""%0C;#?=%5% "5;$

! !((#4&! !((9!;$ "!,) ))%! 9& & 9% )$%&! , !,) /"

% $%!& +$,% 9&

))% "&9 "!!- ;!?:"

&)% / %(/""%0

& !

%5 !%C;#?:='#C/".%!) "$%!&+$,%9& ())% "5 "& 9 "!!- ; ) 9 &%5%

!((C;#

: 9& & -%! & ! ! 5"$%!# $%&% ) & 85 !& ##: "

& %!) " %, " )%!" " &

$- 5 !%% " 7#:#: ( "5 9 & -(" !( "

% & )$%) !

%5 !%

!( "&-! !

5%," ##:"

&(!

$ )0

%5 !% (5("

C;# ##: !!$ -0& , &))(("!!& 9 "5% "!!

9 (( "5"!!

%,& !)%

"%# # %-$&

%! / ".$%!&'())% "& 9 "!!- ;!?"

! ,)(0! &&%&$!-"

!&"/%

!( - $&((5 !(( &%#?$%"

% )

&&!$ ("

9! 9" ) !!!! !&9& &!! " ? $-&!& ) &&

1!$ ("

"- ,85 !& "& 0%"

!! (($( / "5&! ("

7# 4& )(

& ))(("! ! & 5%," !((

##:C;# !"

-% "5! 5"$%!

!&"

&&!

$," ! 1"

$!# 9/%. " % !-( !&& % " ))(("! ( ;, ""0&"

9% "5;)% " % !& 9& C;# !"

-% "5! 5"$%!

!&#B(!

))%!&"

,)( " 9!/%(

5 !& %))(("!- "5& !(5(& %!9 &%5%

& ((5

%5%0 ,, -0 & %!) "# D$%&%. "

%( -( / "&!-"( -0&))(("! /&&5%," !(( C;# !"

5"$ "

$,"# # B"&( 5&

&- / !$!!

".B

"0 ((5( 0 "

%, 0 "&6$ 5,"!"

%!)!! -0- && $%!-( 9# < @$!

(9.,$&(!!"0!$-!" (@$!

(9% !! "&

)%!"!#'

&& $%!-( 9&/% "$%%" "5!

!9%%" "5"

"% %"-0& ! $%# # "!@$"(0.&)%!"))( !&%-0 - "5

,% !#"

"5))( "!. "0.(!

#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%1 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*23% %(/0