High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32346/2017dismissed

Gulzar Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-09-01Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul9 pages

! " #"$ %! &'

( ! )))) !" *"!+"$,- # -

"+( " ))))

!"." + (" (

$ " 01 2"!2 " 3$+ 4 + 2"

/ 2 ,(/

05(

+2 $" /" &$

/*4 " 2/- '/- "

($"67$"!89-

:. ", 4+) 6"( +" 9-$ " ;<-;5- ;0-;;-;0-;1-;<5-0--01-0-)'!22+//4+ / :/

+$,, 4 "

" <( :.

/" &$

/*4 "2/-'/67$"!859-=+":. +( "+#:$,, "

/ + '"

/. -"( +

+ 155: $<)*=++ = 4 : > + # //4 " > 4 " $ + $:=// + , "

/:"

!')1) )50 + " + "++ $

))

$/?" 4+ @+, " 4+-+

+ ,/

6@$/=@$"-&. -*A @$"-$"("@$" *("@$"9 ="

4 +=. " ++ $ $/?" 4+-=+ =" "".

4:$ >

> 4+ -+.

:/ >+ =.-:$ ,+ =-+6 9 =.

=#"- =++ >$"-+

)@+, 4+-$/?" 4+-$>+,-, 4+-'/>" 4+-&4" ( 4+ $"

/ 4+ ="

4+" +. (( + =. " + , "

/B++ >

+,=+.+.":/ > 4+ (4-+

(" > + 4 = " ,+ , "

/'$=++

, =-@+, " 4+:" >++ 4+ , "

= + 4:/ =&4" ( 4+:" >+""/ 4+

+, "

/ $/?" 4+($+ "$/

+-+ // " ":+A 4+C / $", //+, 4+", # C$":= ++ /: = "

+ 4+ ,$/?" 4++ ($// + :"

$ =+

+-+ +

, $ // + : # , /

, +" +/ +

" ,+ /4 ", + + ,= ++ " +((/ +@+, " 4++ + = + 4- " ,"

4+>/ //+$,:$/?" 4++ + = ++ >. "

4+"

: "

4+= $>+, 4++ + = + 4 + /: = = 4++ + ,= ++ 4 +/

4+>/'/>" 4++ + ,= ++> "( + " ( "

);) /4 +":/ =+"

4+>- " ,=+

+:/ "

4 $&4" ( 4+/ + 4 ="

=++/ + "

4++ #+ ,/ - + + , + 7

4" +$( 4+= : $ >+ = ++ 4-+(/ + "

4++

#$//.+ "+"

4+="

4"$"

/ 4++ + + "

4++ $/ " / = +

4 " 4+$ ".:.+ -+ -=+ = + / $", //- ,+" #+ 2+"@$"

@$/=@$"($ + + , + + ,= + 4 + "

4+ + $/ " , + =# //4" , +( '/>" 4+

:/. > 58) >. $:=// " ,+( >

$ + , =+ $, )02%)0= + > //+ ,- ="

"': >'$=++

" + . $-+. >+ , 2 #

( /-"': > / +$" : 4+ ,

+ "" + "

+ $" /

+" ")D+ $"B++ C"/ #

,+"-+. >+ , +2 # / ( /'/=+"+

$ + ,

/7, > +, >+

# /+ ( /"': > +://4 :.+ ++, # :+ +

$"" ++" (

4:=+ ( " )$/?" 4+ $ " 0-

)0) 0-0<-0!2 55-=+= = : 7, "4"

"4 "

("(" :.$/?" 4+-+

( = + +"

A$"

+ ("

+ "( " +," +( /

-:$ = > 4 +

- + ) "(

" < ( :.+*4 "-+( ")

="$,,

/ " $/ "+( " +"4$ ++

++:

,> / $ +" + ( "

$ 4 + ( " =+

+ =" $ / " 3$ ". + +"

( " ;), 4+-,/.-&4 " 4+-=+ " " , ",. +"> : / "-=3$ $(: $ + $ &4 " 4+=( + 4+:/

("$"

55 + // = . 155- ( (/=" 4 ++ $ ( " ; " / B+$/?" 4+ &= 4+="/ 4 ++ $

( " ;- +, ,-", 4+) , + , "

/-=+

+=: #+ 4+( -"$ >4 &= 4+ $/?" 4+ +. // = ", 4+

$/ " /+ , "

/ +/ // =/ 4= ++ , "

/* " A$"

="" # :.: ++("

=", # ++ ( /"': >/ 4

)5) = +$/?" 4+ &= 4+: $ = /.

' +$/?" 4+ &= 4+=",

//.7,

+ ( /=+"", 4+/ ++ ( /= + $+

"= + :"

+ A$"

+ (" <5-+ 4#((/

+ ( /

4 +( " +( /

$ 3$ ".=+"

= :"# + = /.

: $ (".

+ # //4- : + + (" + , ,( :.

4 A$"

+ " (" + 3$ ". "( "

1567$"!)19- ="( " ++ A$"

" #

:.", 4+ + "

4+>/ " $" = $ +

-=++ // = +" " ,+ , "

/=+

++ = # 4= ++ 4+( /. ,(/ A$"

="$

" :.

: ++(" + : (" " $/ " + ( " + "/ $( A$ 4, + 2 $"" "

!" # #$"%%& + ("

-*4 " : $ + //= , ,(/.: $+( "+, , +("

$ #

//+*4 " "3$ ((/.+ A$

/, + +,"

/# /:/ " $,, 4

/ "

$,"*4 "+

" $//. "$ ?+#

:" $4+ " + ,

$,, 4+

/ +/ :(/ +

)<) A$ 4," " '()

* " # #$"!

+*4 " + $/ $+("

$,, , +

/,"

,"/. +: ,, //4 = + + + :"

4 /. = = $(( " + //4 + -:$+, ,-+*4 "+ / > $ +//4 (/. ,$" +++((/

+ A$

/, + +/=((/

:/+" + , $,, +

+#+"

/" $/ "+( " ("$

+" + E 6$("9

/" $/ "+( "" ((/

:/ +

$, (" -: $ +(" +

$ ,"

/: "+*4 " $,, +( " /# 7"

4 " :. + *4 " =+ $,, 4+( "" $ ") F+ +(/ " 72B;8'- (. * 72B;8- (.

$((/,"."( "

72B;8 - (. G) ". "( " 72B58' %" , + #

-+ A$" .= - , .

" ,

$,". #

(( = +- :/ + + +//4

$"" A$"

+ $"# " 4+%$"+"+ ,

(" #+#"

. A$"

))

+ , . 2B (" # + + ((/

= , # :. +

: "!'/-=+

+="4 "

= +(+ -:$ $"+" => "$,, 4+

$ " ;1 !2 " +" #

= $/ ="" $,, 4 $ " + (" # +" "- " ,+#

/ :.+

=//

$, " - (" # ++" $

/ $,, +

$ " ;<8;58;08;;8;08;<58 08)'80180!2

4/.-//+

" $,, "

/ $ " + : #

-$,, //+

: $

"1H + ( " +# ((" + + 2 $" > 4 3$+ =//$,, 4 "

" 7"

( =" $ " 01 2"!2 ( +" : 4 (

(" # +2 2"

/!"

$" "+" "/ 4"

# +44"

# (".:.

4"# ( $ "

;2"!2

# 4

" + $:, , :. /"

$/ "+( "-+ 2 $"

" # =++ $,, 4 "

" $ " +//4 = ( :. /" &$

/ *4 " +

" : +//4 : "+ 2 $"

("(" # ;2"!2 012"!2(" #

+"( =" +

4+ 2 $" "

" $ +/ > -:$+, ,- =//)

)1) :/ + ("

(/ /=+ +"( =" "" + 2 $"$ " 012"!2+ :7"

4/.= +

$,( "" + - "" (

//4/ =+ ,, ""

4 A$

,, =+" +" A$"

4"//. 7"

=+" /("

4""3$ :3$+ -: $+.

" //4//.-#7 $/. "= + $A$"

=+"+ //4 -# +.+.">+ " #/$

(

+ " ".- $.

",> $ 4 +

+ ( ( ="$ "

012"!2="7,

":/ /:. I:/ (72 $" )'( &+% '#",+" =+/ $ " F+ // = 4("

(/,.: "/ + 7"

+"( ="

4+2 $") 69++( =" :" " +" (

(" # +2 "+" " +4"

# 44"

# (".J 69+ + $/ :7"

#".("

4/. ("# :$ ("

. $" " +"= $"+ A$

J 6;9+ + $/ :7"

4 +7(":"

/=4" . +"(" # +2 H (("/.- + ((" ("

", . # /:/ + ( " "# ( 3$ 4 + /4/ .

(" ("

. ,($4 "

" $,, 4

)) # = ;2"!24 + "

"( :.

+*4 "=+" +

+:$,, -+( " +#", .

/"# ( '$ +(" -+ ( "- " " 4

", .-+#

+(" ( > 43$+ =//$,, 4 "

" +( "=""3$ # /+", .

"# : "+ 2 $"-:$+." 4+=.((" +

+ 2 $"-+" "-= + $,> 4. :"# +,"

-("(

, ( "

/"# ( = + , + " ,+ " ( "

+ "

"-+"# ( +// :

, +4" $

/ # ! $ A# B++"(> 48"

K8 B++"( ":/ K8