High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/844/2002allowed

Stephen v. State Ofpb.

2024-11-04Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel15 pages

#$%$!

'(('

)*%

+& ,- +'

+ -

"#$ %$ &&''

( ))*++)),, " - !

"#$ %$ &&''

( ))./0)),, "

3! 41 5 66666 + -

5$#)7 $" 8$ ' && '! % '" 2 $77$ 14"27 $% $# $ " $" $% " "

/,+,,! & " 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2!

' "

$ ( $., $% ,,! 4& $2 %$ "14"

$ &$4 $ 7 %$7 : $;<!

" " .,<///! 2 " 4" $ ;0;! ;00! ;,0! ;+ $% :( $'

$ 3$ 9 ! ' "

! 41 5

$% &$4 5 % 7 8 $ 8 4" $% = ::! 8 5"4" 59 4" 8

$ $7&'

$ 7 9 4" & 2 $! $ /,</// 5$4 *,, # 2 $% ;,<///! 7 ''"

% '& ''9 "

%$7"

7 4" & " 5 "$"

9 ! %$7 8 8 5$42 5

$7 $8#! $

# 2 0>.,</// 5$4 ,, ! 7 $77 "

" 59 $47 2 4'& $ ? '47 47 & $&

"@ 5' "

' # 2 5

" 4

" $ 7 2 4" & &$ 5' %$

" 7 7 $% " 8 # 2 $& $% ); 8 ; $4 $ 7" 8$ &$ 4"! 7'9 & 7 4" " 4 $) 4"! 8 $ "

%4 $% $77$ $ 8 & ( 2 4" $ ;00>;+ " ;,0 $% :( 8 % 7" 2 4" & ! 8

' 2 4" $ ;00 8 " $% $ ;+ $% :(! 8 % 7" 2 4" 4 + ' "

$ ' $ 4"2! % 4'7 $ $% '!

'" 5$ 4" 24 '9 $% & #

2 % 7" 2 7 " $# " 4" & $ 4"2$ 2$$4 7& $7 %$ ; 9 ! 8 % $% ,,,>)!

"% 4' $% & 97 $% % ! $ %4 4"2$ 2$$4

7& $7 %$ 0 7$ 4" $ ;00>;+ $% :( 8

%4 $# " " " $ 2$$4 7& $7 %$ ; 9 !

% $% !,,,>)A "

"% 4' $% & 97 $% % ! $ %4 4"2$ 2$$4 7& $7 %$ 0 7$ 4" ;,0 $% :( $ 8 $"" $ 4 $4'9 $8#! 4" 4 8 $# " " " $ 2$$4 7& $7 %$ ; 9 ! 8 % $% ,,,>)A "

"% 4' $% & 97 $% % ! $ %4 4"2$ 2$$4

7& $7 %$ 0 7$ 4" $ ;00>;+ $% :( < $ $# &$ % '" & && ' 2 $# $! " 5$ && ' % '" 59 7 # 5 4& $2 %$ "14"

$ 0

$# !

24" $ 5 '% $% 5$ &&'' !

4 $! 7&42" 14"27 $% $# $ " $" $% & " 2 7 $ 4 5' 5 2 $ 9 $ # " ""4" $ $" $% : 24" $ # " ""4" 59 &$4 $ &$# ''2" 5"4 $ $% 7 59 4" $ ''2" " $% " 4 !

24" 8

" 4B&'

" "' 9 '$"2 2 $% : 59 $7&'

% ''2"

" $% 5"4 $ $%

$" &$4 $ $9! 5 2 $$ " 4&! 8 $4 9 45 !

$ 5'

# 5' C)! 8 $ 8 B 7 " 59 &$4 $ $ &$# ''2"

" $% 5"4 $!

$ 5'

# 5'!

7 8 $"" 59 &$'

0 $% (( $ ,.,.///! 8 ''2"

" $$

&' $ /,</// : 24" ! & $7&'

! # 7! % 5 2 ''2"'9 5"4" 59 4" $ /,<///!

4" $ ;,</// $8#! $ $7&'

2 " 8 '$"2" 59 7 $ % 7 '9 775 : & 8 '$"2" $'9 % # 7 $77 " 4

" $ .,</// : 24" 7! & 7"

' # "! 8

# 2 $& $ $% ); 8 7 $% " ! 8 ''2" 5"4 $ 59 4" $4" 14 * " 9 & $ 4 ! &2 9 $% " " $ 5 54" $ 4" &$ 5 '% $% 4") &&'' 4 !

457 " $ & % $# 54" $

7! B& %$ ''2 $ $7& " # 7 " 4"

& 7 $% ''2" 5"4 $ $% 7 4 !

$# $ ''9 5 "

' 8 " % $% : 457 " ''2" 4

" $ $% 8$2'9 5 '

" 4&$ 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2! 7 $ 5 &$#"

$$ 8 &$# $ $% ' 8 : %4 457 " $ $% ''2" 4

" $ $% # 7 "$ $ 7 $4 9 2 &&'' . $ $ 9! ' " ($4'

# 7'9 $&&$" 457 $ 7 " $ 5 '% $% &&'' : 24" % "

2 2 # 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 5 " 4&$ # " " 7 ' "4'9

&$#" $ $" $% ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 " ' 8 #9 & $% 7 4'9 "

2 " ' "' 9 '$"2 : B4 ' $%% $ 5 $4" '

5 ''9 " $ 5 7 " $' 5 %$ $8 $4 $% &$4 $ &$& B&' %$ "' 9" $"

2 $% 7 $% C)! 8 $ 8 9) $ 4" &$ 5"4 7 :77"

'9 % 8 "!

'% '' 2 " 4" % $ 7$ " %!

$""

7 8 &$'

&$)7$7 &$ $% 7 &$# 8 &2 7 $% 4

"! "

&2 9 ' " $ 4"

& ! 5$ $4 %$7 4

" $ '$ C 457 $! ' " ($4' & 9" %$ "

7 ' $% 5$ && ' * :

# " ' " $4' %$ & "

# 2$ $42 $" %4''9 / : $" $ $ 4 $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :(!

475 4&$ &$4 $ $ &$# 8 5"4" 59 4" &$ 8 7 9 5 $7&''"! $ $8 $ 5 '

'9 7 9 5 $7&''"! $ 7 9 9 &$ 2 8 ''! $ $" 7 9 5 %$"

$ "4" $ ''

$4 &$ '$$

$ # " ""4" 59 &$4 $! 2"

$% $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :( $ ''9 '

&4 ' $%

7$ $% C); " C)+ & $% 7! 7 7&'9 ' 9 "

" $ 9)8 4" &

8 9 " 42 9 7 $ $8 7 8 7 $'9 % " ' "9 '% $7 4 ! 7 $% # $ 5 2 $ $% &$4 $ $ % $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :( $" &$4 $D $ &$# 2 % 7" 2 4"

4" $ ;00 7 '9 4&$ 7 $% C)!

-8 ' ! 75 9 $8#! &4 ' $%

7 "$ $ & $% " $% $4 E4 % "&$" 59

7 "&$" 8 5$ 4" 8 # 7 2$ 2 $ $$ $ /,</// 5$4 *,, %4 "&$" #9 B " 9!

8 $ ' #D $4! %$7 8

4" % 7$ " 7 $ $8 "

$77 " 4

" '

7" 8 $ &$'

$ ,.,./// $ 2

7 $"" :%

8 $ 5 5'

#"!

4" $

# '' 2 $ $ $4" /,0/// "

$ B&' $ $ 8 8 " 4 ' ,.,./// $ 2

7 $"" 8 &$'

$)B 7 " %4 "

"&$ $ 8 " "

$ $ 475 $ 7 $% $$ 4" 59 4" $ 8 9 7 '$ # " $4 $% 7 54 "

$ "

'$ % 2 "

4" 5 2 8 # 7 $ 9$ "

'9 # " &$'

$ $ 2

7 $"" % '" $ "

'$ 9 $ $ 8

&$7&"

7 $ "

'9 # &$'

$ $ 2

7 $""

7 % ' & $% 7$ )F 7$ $%

" '' %4 !

8 $ 5 5'

#"!

7$9 '' "$ $ %9 2"

$% $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :( &

7$9! 7! 8 $ 8 7 1$ 7 $% 2! 8 7&'9 $7& 9 4" $ $$ $ "&$" 2 "

2 9 '7 $% %$ $ " B " 59 4" &$ 4&$ 7! $ $ $ 4 $%% $% 5"4 $ "

$ ;0 $% :( 4 ! 7$9 $% C) $% $ '& $ $% &$4 $ , ' "

$ ' $ 4"2! 8

' ""'

4" 8 '

9 4" $ ;00 $% :(! '

" 4&$ % 7! % 4 2 $ $7! "

'$" 5$4

5"4 $ 59 4" $ & ! C); " C)+ $8#!

% "

2 4" 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 $ 4 5' % $% & $% &$4 $! 7 4" $ $7 $ ;,</// "

$77 " 4

" $ $% 0,</// $8#! "4

& $"! 8 # 7 8 '

# % ''2" 4! $ $7&'

8 7 " $ 9$ 59 7 $ % 7 '9 775 4" &$ $ $'9

! 9 $ 45'

# 5'

47 7 7 " 7 2 %$7 $7 %$7

/,</// 4 ' ;,<///! " $ $7&'

2 " 8 7 " 59 % 7 '9 775 $ &$'

2 "

&& " 7 5 5"4" 59 4" &$

$ B&" 7 8'' % 7 '9 775 8$4'"

$ # 9 $ 2 4" &$ 8

' # 7 8 '' '

# 4 ' $% 7$ $% C); " C)+! & $% 7! $8 9 "

" $ "&$ 5$4 4" $7&''

7 $ &%$7 7 2 8

7 4 ! "&$ $ $% 8 % '' $ $% 5'

E4 7 $ $ 4 $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :(

'' 9 "&$" 8 4"! & ! $$ 8 9 # 7 8 &$7 $ 7 9 54 "

" '% 4"

9) ''2 $ 2 4"

2 "

''2" % ' &$7 $ 7 9 7 " $

$ $4 "$ $!

9 7 ! $ 4 $%% 4" $ ;00 $% :( '

5 &' " 59 ' "

$ '

$ 4"2 $ $ ,0 $% :"

# " $ $'"

! 4" 8 8 7 $ /,<///!

%$! 9 # $ B&'

4" 8 47 9 $$

# 7 % '4 $ %4 4 B&' $! '' 5 &47" 4" $ + $% :"

# " &$4 B # 4 $8#! % "

2 4" 59

' "

$ ' $ 4"2

2 "

& '& 5'9 8$2 %$ 8$ $

! $ &$4 $ # $ # ' 5' $ $" $% : E4 $ 8 '$"2" 59 % $% 7 % " $"! $ 48$ 9 # " ""4" 59 &$4 $ $ &$# 4" 8 8

7 $ /,</// ; 9 $ # ' & $% C).! "$$ 8 $ $"4" &$)7$7 $%

$) B 7 $! "&$" 7 $% &$)7$7 $ .,</// ,, !

%$4" " $& $ $% 5$4 $ ; 8 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2! 8

' " '

2 8

& $% '" 7 "

" % / " 9 % 5"4 $ 59 4" % # " 9! $" 8 "!

4 7 "

7 " $% $" 8 $% 5"4 $ $& $ $% "$$ 5$4 & $" $% &2 9!

7 " &&$B 7 '9 8$ 8 ! 8 &" 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 4&&$ $'4 $ $% / " 9 &2 9 : 79 $ "" $& $! &47& $ $ " 8 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 $ 4 5' 7 8 7 2 $ $% /,</// " $77 "

" $ $% 0,</// 4 ! 7 "

" 8

" 9 $% ''2" 5"4 $! " % "

2 4" 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 "

" / " 9 % 5"4 8$2 '' %4 !

' 4' $% ' 14 &4"

&$4 $ &$# 2 4" 59$"

$ 5' "$45 " 5% $% "$45!

% 9!

$% &$4 $ '' 2$ $ 4" : # 8 $% 47 !

&2 9 $% 7 $4 "$8 $% "$45 $ $% &$4 $ E4 #$'#7 $% 4"

& ! & ''9 # 8 $% % "&$" 59 & $% " " ! & $ $ & $4! 9 " $ $8'"2 $% # 2 9 ' $ 8 4"! & + $8 $7 2 $ $"

2 % 7" 2 4" & 4" $ ;,0 $% :( "

$# 4" " $ &$4 $ '

" 4&$ 4

" $ '% 5

" 59 " " $ 7 &$# 24 ' $% 4" 4

" $ ?B@! '$2 8 & 7 "8

$5$$ ?B;@ " 3$#7 $ B& &$!

$& "8 4

" $ $ 5 $77$ 8

$5$$ ?B;@ # 5 &"

59 &$4 $ $" # '" 4" &$ 5' %$ 4

" 4

" $ " & 7 "8 2 $5$$ $% " " 8 $#" 59 &$'

! # " $#9 77$ B " B - $#9 77$ 8 8 " 59 $ 34"# " ( 1 " 2 8 $8#! 2 8 $ $#9 77$ 8 $ B 7 " 59 &$4 $ 8 ! # $42

9 8 " 8 9 8 2 # 4& 4 9

59 $ ' 45'

$4 $ # " 7 " "

/*,,, 4 ' $% $ 5$$ $% " " # 7 ?B ;@!

" 4&$ & 7 $% "8 2 $% 7 7 54" '9 ' 7 $ 5 7" $5$$ $% 7 59 9 7

"$47! &$ 9" $5$$ $% " "!

&& '9 " # 5'9 54"' $% $7 '$$

"8 & & ! # 5'9 $ %$7 $7 $ $5$$ "

&'" $2 ! 8 $# &'" $ 8

"$ $ 5 7! ' ! $'' $! $ 451 $# % & &

54"' $% & & 5 7! ' " $'' $ $% 7! 54 ' '9 # 5' 7 5 &4 $

& & 59 7

42 '$ $% 4 2 $# $ ' B 7 '

8 $

& 2 '' 47 $4 "$8 $% "$45 8 2 " $ &' 4 '

9 $% & & 5 4 & 7 "8 2 $% " " # 7 $ %%$ 5 7 " 59 # 2 2 $%% $% $ $'' 9 '

5' " 4 " & 7 "8 2 $% 7 %$7

$''2 $ 9 $ 4 $4 8 "8 2 $% # 7 8$4'"

# 5 '9 # ' 5' < $ $% 4

" $ ?B@ 41 5

' 24 2 &$"4"

5'$8! % ' 7 $ 2'

24 2 G

5 &4 ' $%

" $ 7 9 ' ' $ ' $# 5 54" $ 4"! & !

" $ $4'" $ 4 57 $8 " 7 %$ $77 2 4

" $42 $7 8$2%4' 5 54"

$ 4" & ! 54 $ " ' $% 9 4 8$2 # 5 "

#4'2" $ $ 5'

($4 $ 7&$ $% " 8$2%4' $8 " 2 $ " 57 7 $4 $ # $77 2 4

" $ & &

$ $%

($4 ! $42 8$2%4' 4

" $ 5 7&4" $ 4"! & ! 54 7 $"

$ % 7 '9 775 $% " " # 7 $4'" 5

" 4 7$!

7 $" '%

&$ 5' %$ " ! " $ $ ' '' 5 " %$ 7 : $ " & 5' $ 8 8$2 8 $77 " 59 4"! & ! 8 7 &$4 4'9 "

5'9 % '" $ &$# ''2" 8$2%4' $% 4"!

& ! 8

&$7&" 7 $ $77 4

" : # 8 $% $ $% 4

" $ '

" 4&$ 59 &$4 $!

' '9 5$ $4 4" $ 5 ""'" 8 9 '

9 $8 " 57 $77 2 4

" 59 7 $D5' 4&7 ($4!

!! '" 4"

# #$

%& !

%& '

(

# # (

!)*

!) *H . ' "

$ ' $ 4"2!

7&42"

14"27!

'" $ 5 '% $% 4" 422 $ 8 7 " $ & $% " " # 7 8 # 2 B4 '

' $ 8 $7 5$9! 2$ &2 ! " 8 " $ 7 9 5$9!

54 "4 $ $51 $ 59 7 $77 " 4

"! %$! $4

%" $ 4" $ &$# " % " "

'$ 7 $% " 5$9

% "

2 59 ' "

$ '

$ 4"2 4%% %$7 & '& 5' $4 '2 '

% 7 9 $D5' 4&7 ($4!

$% " "#

$%"&'

% "()

)*!

'" 4" +

, $

% .$

$ !

$ / $

% .$

$ $

0 $

$ H * $ % 4" 4 7 $"!

5 $# " 8 " $% $ ;+ $% :( 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2 4" $ ;00 $% :( $D5' 4&7 ($4!

$% + % " +

'-.

(( '" 4" G+1 (

$ 2 $

3!"

$ - 4

3!" $

$ $ -

'9 $ 2$4" &&'' )4 7 8 59 C) $ /,</// 8 7 " 4" & $ $$!

$ 5 '" 24 '9 $% 9 $77$ $! 7$$ 5 $% 9 $%% 5 2 "

#4'2" 7 $% C) $ '

5'! ' "9 5 '"

2 &$ $ $%

14"27 .! 7'9 ''2" & $% 4 7 8 4" & " 7 "$ $!

9 7 ! %4'% '' E4 7 $% 2 $% $77$ $ 4" $ ;+ $% :( : $ $% &$4 $ C) $# " 9 $# $ 58 & ! 4 7 " # 7

&$4 $ % '" $ ""4 9 # " $ & $% 4 7 $% $77$ $ 8 4" & 5"4 $% 7 /

E4' $ 79 5$# % "

2! 5$ $% 5$#) 7 $" && ' ( ) ./0) $% ,, " ( ) *++) $% ,,! 59 ''$8" .! 7&42" 14"27 $% $# $ " $" $% " " /,+,,! & " 59 ' "

$ ' $ 4"2! ' "

$ ( $., $% ,,!

"! " &&'' 5$ 5$#)7 $"

( '

&& ' E4 " $% 2 % 7" 2 7 , "

2 &&'

$?@!

% 9! '' '$ " "

&$"

$% $"

2'9

/+ -0

$#75 ,+! ,+ 0 &

2> $" I>$ &$ 5' I>$