Rehmatulla And ORS v. Smt.Wahida And ORS
!"
#$#%&#'() *+ + "
%(,(-#'()+ + + "
./0'#'() ++ + "
#1203,//00('31#%$ ..#//0(3$ 4#%$,$ 235016'00('31#%$ #$.('#(3$
!
" # $
'
(
&' )' *)*(
+++
!"
# "
- /
*0 )1 &001
2 !
-.
&4 &* &00'
!
56 ! .
7
* 5 - '
.
8
" 7
:&1
** )4 &010 .
&( &* &01( /
&/
3 -
&( &* &01( ₹ '))));/
₹ 4)));/
&/%
.
₹ - *4)));/ -
') &* &014
' & ₹
&()));/ -
* ( 2 - -
*
-= . =
&
₹
&4)));/ *: )4 &014 -
.
-
*
₹ &))));/ -
') &* &014
' *
-
*/ > .
- 3 .
&
*: )4 &014
* (
.
*: )4 &014
* ( -
.
" ') &* &014 - < , 0 )) 4 ))
&/%
*& )* &01?
, - /
8
&( &* &01(
( .
- /
.
"
@
&/%
-
-
*
'
(
₹
*))));/
&/
!
.
.
.
<
- -
A .
.
.
&( &* &01(
2
B ! - '/( . ! . &014
4 &
. .
7 = -
.
2 * (
.
- -
* ( - .
= .
-
.
.
*: )? &014
C .
.
- - -
*: )? &014
.
*
2. . -
?
/
* (
:
C - > -
C * > - . .
D C2 '
> D C2 ( >
* ( - D C2 * ( >
D C2 * ( ?
>
D C2 * ( :
" < 2
" >&
>* 2 > >' -
"
>( " >4 -
>?
82 >9
>:
C -
<
2"
2>& ! 2>* " 2>' " 2>( 5
2>4 -
A< 2&
&) E -
"
&&
!
56 !
&4 &* &00'
/
8
&*
&4 &* &00'
&/%
2 !
5
*0 )1 &001 /
&'
/= . /
*0 )1 &001
2 !
&( # .
*0 )1 &001
2 !
-.
&4 &* &00'
!
56 !
-
2 !
"
2 !
&( & < " 2 > >'
A< & A< *
&( &* &01( -
&/%
/= 8
"
4&*
&( &* &01(
*: )4 &014 -
A< '
A< (
- < -
"
>( -
>
.
< >'
" - - < >( -
"
-
2 !
!
56 !
, 5
A< & A< (
.
-
5
.
.
&* &) &010 A< 2& .
- -
*/> .
.
&) )4 &000 A< 2'
A< 2( .
.
2 !
)& )( &00* A< .
!
*( && &00) A< .
)? )& &00*
! % A<
"
.
=
, -
.
&( &* &01( < 2 > " >'
< -
"
>( .
2 !
*0 )1 &001 - / -
&4 , .
*0 )1 &001
2 !
-.
&4 &* &00'
- !
56 ! - /
2 !
.
.
-
, . - -
&?
I have heard learned counsel for the parties besides going through the record.
&:
/ .
&( &* &01(
!
56 ! /
8; .9
&1 2
>
-
- .
*: )4 &014
* (
-
* - 3 .
&/%
&0 F
3 .
&* &) &0:0 8A< 2&9 .
*: )4 &014 8A< 2*9 -
. / 8 ; .9
.
3 .
.
*1 )0 &0:0 &* &) &0:0 .
-
- .
.
*: )4 &014
.
.
.
.
* (
.
.
*1 )0 &0:0
.
&* &) &0:0
< <
% 2>'
+ ;
- A< 2>/1
; .
&* &) &0:0 *)
<
"
" # = C .
3 .
, - 2>'
% "
2>( %
&) )4 &00)
*& ,
2 !
5
.
"
/*(1)/&00*
&) )4 &00)
!
7 56 !
)& )( &00( 5
7/
&) )4 &00) )& )( &00*
- .
.
** 5
!
56 ! .
>(/-
"
>'/ " >
.
>(/-
" /
5 - >(/-
"
=
.
- %
A< & A< *
.
*'
5 6 .
>'/ " 2 >
/
!
" #"
"
$ "
! ""
%
!
" $
! ' "
"
!
"
(
!
"
) *
$ " "
"
" *(
.
- 5
-
*4 ,
&/%
-<
/
5
&( &* &01( -
-= .
*?
E .
.
.
.
5 *:
7= .
<
(& - &0&1 28.
In view of the judgments passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pankajakshi (Dead) through Legal Representatives and others Vs. Chandrika and others (2016) 6 SCC 157, Randhir Kaur Vs. Prithvi Pal Singh and others (2019) 17 SCC 71 and Gurbachan Singh (dead) through LRs Vs. Gurcharan Singh (dead) through LRs and others (2023) SCC Online SC 875, questions of law are not required to be framed in second appeal before the Punjab and Haryana High Court whose jurisdiction is circumscribed by provisions of Section 41 of the Punjab Courts Act, 1918. 29.
. "
-
')
89 .
.
0%-1+ 7 + " 58
*
+ ,- *
" ,