← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3802/1998dismissed

(O&M) Ram Singh Etc. v. Bachhittar Singh Etc

2016-12-20Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

Ramesh Kumar 2016.12.22 16:57

 

       

 !

 "# !$%   $&

&'&&&()! $**)+ ,-.

'/"," &&&0011 23 ""'/"," &&& 04 &

&'&&&$!)  !!*+ ,-.

'/"," &&&0011 23 564'/"," &&& 04  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&



-& '/"'"#45# "0011 ""001& -&17"01#'458" -& "/01#45# "04& 99999 *)+%,' "4 "1140 48/31 4001 /&()! $**)4$!)  !!*"

 :31845154" ""001&

'&()! $**)/341"513 &$%$$*)*14;"'/"4"2& '/"4 "<  +"  4    ;'3  &$<.#  8" =  118/  1 3/" ="04>01" 1184 >  

  

 



      

      

 



   ! "! !"!# !#"!#!#!"$!

# !"

!"%!"! "!##!# !#%!

! !

 ! !#!#$! #  &   '

  $!



(

) *

+ !#

*   ,   - .



 

       !

 %$  

$" 

  

 &

)

)

    

%$" /



& 



 "





 

  ) 



)  )  

 

     )

   '   )'

   

&''

 ))

)     )'

       ))     

    &     '



0 "3&($($*)* '&$!)  !!*+" ;'3& ." 14" '/"4"/ 564'/"4"#8" =443401 "43"43/"118/41 >  



  



                   

  )1 1 1+  

+ "$

  $            "$

   "   &   &   '

 $! 

(

)

*

!+

* 2,-  3 &#



& )

4



# $%$ 

  5)

 6,    

          )  

    )

        )' '



   &'' ))

) 

     )   ) 



           &  '          '

 

 

  &       &       

  ' 

0

 "031"13/""43#" 3>> '/"1 4"41""= 80"0?"3

& -& '/"'"#143100/ "1 0011 ""0013

4"04>0134 3&$1 /" 41"0 ""="4 03"4"" 1'/"#-3?"'/" '/"

0"0/ 44$@&$$&$*)A4#"#"4   >"# 8"  4    "  0011>01  "3

188"38  1&"64>""0 "01831=4034"018 1=/& 3"3

4" "3"04>01 8  1"3 18"5 44 34 "0/ 44$@&$$&$*)A#8"" 1=/44 ?814/4" 01"4&#"0"414=? "  0    "  05  "    "      "  0 / 44$@&$$&$*)A&"814=0033 "  634/   4  4  44  &%&$*@  +B&C.&  "   4 3 " 14"6 4"=$*@ >@(&

/ 13

4"" "634/ 44# 0?"3

8/511" "4/" "00=84 = '/"#8"83554 =3#  1=# '/"#-3?"'/"# 1'/"47 ??'/"& 7 ??'/" 44 31 "=$*@ &"44 "5 1 441:38"08"3"5/"0="1 44& 10 ?4D3/"#"#4/ "3>4&"3/""8/  /"> "# 3" 814"6 4#"  "  "534&"050 "4311= "8&300"#1430" 44431143 01 2 3455-31 2 3, 6

  272 8/

3  2 3455% 331  2 3,

/3"1430"44431143 =" 5= 31$ 2953 455 :.-72,*%3 /;

4"0100  1&#?"&$A$"4 11"" '/"&1#1=$ /"14"4 11""#8""04"403"414 ?"&$A$& 3"3

4""" '/"44 "=$*)!4"0#"3/""414=4"0# 3 /4  "  1  0    8/  54  8/  44  $@&$$&$*)A +B& A.#8""" ?4 ="3 18# "3#"00"43 #8""1/ 05=&300"#1430 AC " 36

E4  4   -31  //  "   01  4   01

8 0&"4/"3 18#"3#3 1" =184#"#1 1 >4&  3" 3

4 "  331=" "   " 0011# 1=#-3?"'/"4 1'/"44=>> =4818="3 1" &"=14 11 0141 / 3"&"3## 8 3/""" "B34& "0011"4 41/8""8"148"" "  0    "  1  "=  =&  5    001  / &( *> !! 34 4A$ 31 @ 814 '&()!

$**)01/4"45"0011F "4

"" ""4B0415/ "4-3?"'/"#  1'/"4 '/"1/105 /"&'" /5" 0=/4543/"1 &"148" "3"-&001 /&$%%@!> !$%

54/34"05 4A$ 31 @  // 4"44154"118/43  > .0=0144A& &$*@ +B3>$.G

. 4"=$*A*>C!+B3> .G4 .40= 3& !A@+B3>(& "3#" /11/1=4 05= 40=  118/001&

  #  -&1  7"01#  14  '  31 4  =  -& "  /01#  45#  0/  "  04 3

4""634/ 4401=3 1" =18&"444 4"8"0"01:3 ?"&$A$4#"#"84 /4"1

6 44&"8 0331= 8"/40 4"=$*@ &#"0114 4 "> "D68?"3

&7"8 46&" 148""3B&C#444 &%&$*@ # 8""4"3 > ;(         $"

7!

(        

/

8 

   5$7# ,

     :;

<< 5

$   8

8 9 



  &

&' 3)8 = > 8 ?86)) 

98?>8-  # $% @+ ):=  ): =+ ):"=5 )73 )7 ) 

(

)

*

+  *   2 ,  -   :#=  1    7 3  ) 7   )  7  (*

+ * 2 , -   (  3 )7 ) 7(*

+ * 2, -  ,    

  

 

      ) #1)1 "

1 

 &

      $#      

9$"$!#   

  / 7    &  

  ' 

   

  % *    )    '    &  

:?86))  98  ?@>8  - =    

 6     

  

;  

 >

     

 2 

    

 

 

  '

 )

 

)   &      8  ,   59 59     !!!!!

 

 !!!!!! 

!!!

!!!!!!!   !!!!!!

/& !!!

A

5 " 9

A

5 !!!

&

    # &

   !!!

 

 



 8 A

!!

8 A

%  

 

 !!

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB *   C 

'    8   ' ? $% : =  7!?>80   031    "   4  4#  -&7"01

34"/3 4""41="B" "01">8014 3/(C

/"  8A 84 47"8&*C#7"3&$ )

47"3  "$*A*>C!"B$D%"""

"1443 =54&"41=

4 4634$D%" "63&"148" "3"6 4"=$*) >)(+B& .#8""

"867"8& $!&#13 &A#11" 1/ "5 "8 >"4684"11/40 44$@&$$&$*)A8 /1&5"/ 41=

 104804#"#:34/& 300"#""1430"44431143

=" 311"1 3

455$321 2 3 :35,    272 68& 3"3

4"""3#4B&* ($&@&$*@%"  3/"4#8""="51 45=  >8&11" ""4"#"#/3 -&'" 8 =4014/4#"#1 1 >4&  31#-&'"3

4""304 1=41#"#"8 81=4" 04$@&$$&$*)A&"8"44> 0011&$#8""414"8 1/8"44 &$#C#%4@5/4/$*%A0#8""14$*@ 4&""3 18"551?4" 4 4#"#"4/3 1& H"/4"3#"3

4""41"

3/"8"/4"?"3

 4"# 3 44""/30"4634"3

8"" '&()! $**)/&  "5  "4  " 14 31 "0 4 / "3/""48"" 14"58""  4"3

-&'"##"4+B&C.

4"8=0&#8//$D%" "& 01 = 6  &$  "8  14   "1 44&$#C#%4@#"/4""01 1=  6  8  4  >"      7"  &$A$  4  "5  

   8""8/ 44& "?

5=#01 = 6&$4"3 > ;*  &

&

   !  !    )

   * ' 

' ) *   )  

)  %$ 

$" * 

)

' 

 &  6)

   

 %$"   

       

 

   

  

               

 

        

* ' 

'

 ) *

 '   )  '   

)  

  '   !   )

 ;  )   &

& 

0 ' 1"01= A &"8"0 3

8"/4"053444 &%&$*@ &5" 6 4    "  =  $*@ >@(  1=  1  "  "#  8""  ?" 3

40&7"8 6&"634/ 1430

=-&'"8314300"58" 311"634/   1 3

<5 55 , 8"" "14" " "0"?"8#"0"554 04"?"8 "6444"53 4#"00=8314  4468"011"> "&"30 3///"8""0 "14 4 "&"150/0"$C4 $%" 634/ 4"3 > #  9  '  

     &'         

  &    )  &   '

   

 ?  '

)   '

: =   '     

      & '      

!

 7 *& '  &       '  ' !

 

&     '  

 >

 ! 7 

 )    ! 

  '  )   



 '  

   '*  !

   &

&' )&

     )     '   &'' &  !



 ' &'

 

   

 &')   '&'

 6 !   

    

 ! 7        



 

    D

 !   

    '     ' 

&  

 ! 7 8! '

       &  )   

      

  *       )    

 '      ) !           6





&  



     '&

     & 

  

           '





         '

  

   '   6 !

   

 

 )     '





/     )E      

  !    '  )  



'





      

     '         

 ' 6

  

    !  

 



      '    



 ) &   

   

'

   )         '    

 : =   '   

   )  & '7 ! ; & 

  

 

 "" 

*  9  '6      





  

 





F! G""*  &' ! !4

   

! &

  '

)

'    &        ' '

 

  

 D    



  

 ')



  

   A )     

'    '

  

 



&&

   &  

)     

  

 

G 11""5 ? ="3 18 8"14/"3& 45  =  8=    441  54  4  "  0 6 44"634/ 831401/"

6="43  3/"4"5 4 ="

 3 18&51-&&$%%@!> !$%1=014 43 #8""14=4# 3"="5  0544 ?4& "11/4440#" 6/" 010="="403"4"""68"0 4 4"8 #"3#51418&"6 4 "=$*)(>)A# ?"83

4?"33

"5

/5#8""#44#11/4"5 04#"3#" 4/54 ="3 18 430"004 54&"403" 31# 3"?"8  "6#":30104&

"//#4448"" 4/  44  =  "  "  3  18#  8""    4  30 001443 =54&

43& 00144 4& - 1=:3,6   *)+%

153 '(-.& +3:35>2 ?5

 @5?

+3:3 :=!

@5?