← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3916/1998dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Raja Ram

2025-11-03Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal13 pages



   



 

     !



"#"$%"& '(!)!)*

$'('+(,"& '()!!)* 

 



     



 



 



     



!



 



     



 - . !



/ 0.

   ! ! "#$%1( # ! "& '& 

! (&

)& 





!

&+

& 

%1( #

/ 0.

-





   .



#  ,  /-

0    -1-2

 & 

    %

,

 

   3 45  

       ,  



 

  

  #

 



 & & 6  ,#,

- -

7& #





  , 

 

  





 .  

   

  

 







 

  

 

   &  # , 





        /-

0     & 



,   ,     



   & 

 8 ,  &  ,,

   



,    .



 6

    

 

,  .,







  

,

  

 , 

&   #

   

 

   





 & ,, 



& 

 





&  8  ,   

  &   *

   

            ,



   

 



,   









 .  . ,

 

:

  ;   &  



 



-:

<= -112  

 " 

> & ( -:=-:?@-:2 ,:< <?

-11=;9- <= -11? #



#   

 



<2 <= -11= 

&> %> "& 5A

 &  (

=<<=<1=-- ,-2 <?

-119#

 &  

,&

 



  /-

0    -1-2 #

 

 

8



 



#,  

*   

       

  & 

:

-

 ,

  

 

,, ,



&   & 

  

,

  ,

  ,#

  &

   , 

,  

 7 

    

      



&





  

 



#        

*



/

        &    

   , 

  

 #

,



 

  

#

 

*

,  





# 3*

 

) ( 22;;-?%2<5-?

%2<5-2%2<59:%2<59/%2<59B%2<5

/< ) 

 (

#*

 " 

# 

 ,,,

-1B2C-1?2  

, -9 B<  

  ;

'  

 ,, 

   &  



   6 



 8 0 # 

 ) D ,,



&

 #





    #,           





/ -

E  & ,

    ,  #



  



  

,  2<0  , # ,

 



 ,,

/

F



  

 (

-





 ,

 ,, 

 

    

 G  0   +  E          

*

#

,, 





&

#

,  , 

        &    

   , 

  

 #

,



 

  

#

 

*

,  





# 3*

 

) ( 22;;=%2<5-B %2<5-=%2<521;;--%?-959<%?-95

:1 )/! 

 (

## 

 ;

'# ;

) ,

-1B2C -1?2

 ' ) #  & 

 

  ,,  #

    

        &  

(

$#   









,

&

 &  ;

   

# 

#



&  

    .

 (

#

-1B2   

        #

     *

>  ,

-1=<=-

-12B2=

,& 

 ,,    

) D  ,,   

 

,  &      &  ,  #



# &  



 ,,    <1 <?

-119 

      







-

E  & ,



  

 

  ,     #

  

       

   

  

 #

2<0  ,    ,

 

 F



  

 



 ;

'# ;

) ,

-1B2C-1?2 

 &  ;

     



,

&

#   

 

 &  

9:

</ -1=B 

&



 #

,  ,   

=         &    

   , 

  

 #

,



 

  

#

 

*

,  





# 3'

   , ) # 



   ,(    ,

-1B2

-1?2 '



,

 

 

 ,,,  & 

 ,, 

     &   

,

-1B2

 

 ) ( 1?;;/%2<5B%2<5

5

?%9<52%B<5

9:) 



(

#*

 "   7 ,

&

 ,, &  

91 <B -119  



,,

)   

&

 #











 

 ,,

,



= -

E  & ,

    ,  #

  

       

         ,  2<0  , 8 ,

 

=

F



  

 (

-



& 8 

 

 



4

?

  ; ,,  ,         

   

.  ,, 

   

 # 

, &  , 

  

&  

E  ,  

  

        

    ,

 

 ,  #     ,

  

 

    #  

 #

 

-

 

  ,,     

    

 ,       

      

  8 

 IF00

 ,,   

, 



 IF0"

:

  

 

 IF0"

/

   , # , 

2<  IF0"

 

  IF0"

=  

'

    #  ,,     6

   

  

& 

 &  E



,

   ,

 

&>

%> "& 5A

  

 #

  &3            

     

 

    4    &    

  

 

;     

    "  > # # #   

& 

#   

 

*  &

 3                      

    



 



  

         

      

 



  



  

A  

 D 

 

  

   # #

( # &

 

  

#        #   6   ,    ,  .      

-<

7 &

    

    #

  & 

,

# 

 

 J



 K    

    

                  

 

I --

 

 ,    #

  ,#

0     

  /-

0    -1-2  -<<0  

  



 

 

 2(62726#81

"2& 98$'+:8 .# 2(& '98"$# /;# 82(&$162 2(& '98"$#4

)  *5,  #  





 ,<1$'&1

#1(,"

&","2#"& 98$'+:8 81# . /;# 2=

2$62#8 2(& '98"$#4

)   5 2(& 29"(&"$ 2(& '98"$# /;# 2$'7 2(& '98"$#4 )  ,23"

  

# # 

,  

 6 ,# 6

,

-9

   

  #, 





  ;  



 K %#



 ,#5,





   

&

)

 K 

 

.   9=

   +  -1?9%

,



3

 -1?945 ( &

 

#

#



  



&  

 ,,

 

  929"

'> 2$?2(2 %!

1#8 2=

98$'+:8 .#4 ) 

(.1("



& .

 ,#            !

 "#   $%" 

        

                           

     &&



  

 '&

 ()*) 

 +,"--.   "--/ 0 12* #        3 4 #'              !

 "#   $%"

 

     

  





      



 

   

    !

   .                

6           

7 ( 

  &

8 9 :  0 1 

 

     

    

   !

 "#   $%" ' &&

  

  

      

        



         '    

  

       

!

 $$  &



     



!

 "#  $%" 

 

  

 ' 7  (       ;

   

  

  

     

!

 &

          96  &  <    =     >* $%. !&  -#$   9  )     !   (    >*  $#/  !&  $."  >     

 

 

       

!

&



    &&



 

 3 0 1' &&



 

   

 

         



 

                 

     

     ;

 

?

01' &&  



 

        

   % 

   !

&



     

              7   (   

   3 4>      

  

 

                       

   

  



   

          &&

     

    

       &  &

  

             

 '5  





&   (   !

&

< !

)  2 >* $#$!&%,     

    

          &   ;



 



 ' 

        

    9  ):    0 1     



    (      !

 ( 0>9):  1     



  )6& :  #%> """3>* $.-2& -/

  

  

   



   6

       &

 

   

        



   

 '

      &

        '  !



                    



           

  

     &

 5       

  ' 

     4 -:

7

  

  

# 

K9  

8

 

; ,,,



 7 

 ,,



 &

E 99

 ,-1?9





&    

   &  .& 

 



, #   ,,  

8

K   

 

  #







  D        

,   #

.     #

# 7& #

,

 %5  &       

-/





%5 

, 

   

 ,  



  

  #

( ,

 

 , & #

, 



-B





 

  .





    ,  

   

  ,     ,

            

  #

 ,     





/ 0.

)!!)*

 2+$2% '$'9 Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No