← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3950/1998dismissed

(O&M) Rajinder Singh And ANR. v. Bachan Singh And ORS

2025-09-23Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal8 pages



      





 

  



 

    



 

 

  !

" #   $!

 

 !" #$!%

'

'

 )"%"*+"

* '

,

- !% &"'

' " 

 ....

#   $!

 %    +"   

 &

 

 "

  )  (%

" -

      )#



 1%  2 &'  3

   



  



4' 5"%"'

   )#

6% 2 &2 1% %%

'3

 





"

   7 %( #' 

%((  

%0 "0

 

 ) 

  "%

(8%

)#+- &"'!/



!%

'5" )#

%(( +-

9

("

("

&5%

"9

" "

("

 +"% 5 

)#

%0%

 %( &

) %

0

+- &""

"8%

+- &""

9  &%

4%

5 %

5 "

)( &

) %

)#%

6



':%  3

'3

 

0



5 %

"#

 % %

"%

 :

0  "  

&  "  

%'  "  (

5% &  %  5  0   8" " +- 

%

, 

;<( '% (( = >  <(%, %

5" " 

%(() 0 "

 % -

%

"9

(?"

% "%

=>  8"





# => ; 8" "%

0

) % " 

0=>1  8"

%(("



%

(% " 

% = >1 @ 8" " +- 

4%

, 

;=>1

7.  %( ;

%5 

%

 " &0

'

6% 2 &   "%

((%

& 

%, '

  && % "  -

       '  

/

 (%

' 5"%" 5

5  %0&

-

 )#

@ && %

  ' " 

) (%

 +" 

 5  

0%

 (  " &   

 

 4 

&"  5 6  

5  B%%

   &0

"

  &

"  (

'%



 - )

C

'

 ( 

)



 !

; " - )6  '4



 !

66(  % "% &

)0

-

"! 06 "  (

            

   '(

5 )#

% "  (! "



     #    

$

 %

 

         

 "& $ #% &

-

'

B

5% B% 

)( 0  A

)0%

:% 

%) %

DE9F)#%&

&

 

 

(%

&

 0%

-    8%

 %  #  

 %  (   ( 0 

 %%

C( 

 

"&

5

"   '5%

%((  % 

%

 

)  (%

&  +" 

 :%   

  6  5   B% 

# 

" 

%(( 

 ) "      )# 

/

  %  (% 

"  0

  "

 "

  ) 0

"6 )

5(  

"  % 

)#C

F) 96 ' ( ) *     +  *, -    ./ 

0  % ,  " 

/

)0%

" %

&

(% 0% #% "(%

& 



+"

5  %&"

5

% )#

# (0



5

%

(0

&) 

( 

/

"' " 

5

"0

 % B% 

) 0

) *

# %0%

 <"

&

&" "(%

  " 

(

#  +"

5

(% "  

/

  (  

& 

 

"   #  0

"% " %

(+-

" 05

E91G

  %

5% 

/

 

 

 

 

"   #  (  0

' 

 )

5

%((



 

&

)%

%%

(>  ; (6

(6%

    66 

(   % %   ( 

 - %   

 ) " 5 &

%((C

 

  

"  -

(  ! 0  6 (  <

 % ( ) *      '5" % "

  

 



  !"##$%$$&  '   (' )



')*

    

   +

, %

) 

-( .  *   )/

0

1&2) 

  , 

 *   

) 2

 

  -

   

* 





* 









*  **

* 

 * '

   .

 

/

0

1#) 

-(    



)   ,  *  



) ,



 *

    * 

   )







* *  .

 *     )  ) 

*

,

     -

 )



*





, 3 @  

"(% "

5

 )

 "    )( "%6 %%

 ) "

%

DE91GF  , 5'

 %

E91;%0  # (0

5% " &

" %

(+-

%

0 

(0

 &

&% " %



( 

%&"

'

  

" % " 

')

% 

"% " %

(+-

(8%

"% (

 !

' # (0

E91G% %

%

&E91G( 0

' "(%

& 

:% 

 B% 

)

A

%

%((

"&

" 0%"

%% % 0

+"

 :%   

  6  "

  

 (

5% &  %%

  +"   % 

 

(  (   %  

" 

+- &"  +")B

%(( %  &%

 8%

)  %)  &

 5 %   ; +"8%

& ( &%  

" %)5"



5%

 &  +"0 &% (

 

 %)

 

5 @ > "

&5%



)   

" %  %

( 0

&  8%

0

 &

&  #"

&)  "

"

'5"%"+- &"

&

& 4 < %

%(

  (8%

%

%% % 0

"

<

0%



+-

!% &"9  &%

( 

/

'5"%"

%E9"%)% 1"

&) "# 4

E9"%)%

"

(50

" %

(+-

0%  &%

+"

 %&"

)

 B% 

) &% ) "% 0



)

5% " &

<  

  '  +-  !% &"  %  4  "

  9  &%  8%

"   '% "# '"& 



&

 %)

"+-



'5"

% %)

5

) "%0

)

"

" &%

) %

")B

%((5

&

&% 6  5% "(

&5%

%

)   

" %  %

&

( " 0 '%

0%

 

 % &

( 0+- &"

%((% &% " 0#% @4

"

 %

3

 % "# 4

 "%0'"

%% +-    #

#'5"  '

" 

%((%

% 

 5  

 % &  % " 

&  5% "  +-  !% &"  5" 

5  % &5% "+- !%&"

("% %( '+-

!% &"9

)#5 (  &%

0

 

&%

"%"%

'5"

5  % &  5% "  "%0 

 "% 

 5   %&"

# 

 )   %%

'  5"  %  % 

 

%((  5  

% &5% "+- &"%

5 

)

 +- &" : " 0 '

& " &%

" %)'5"



5%

5 &<

 

 #% % 5  "

(

((

'5"%"+- &"5 &

&  60

#' 

"  % 0

    %%  

 



) ) & % 

E9 

5 (

% "%% % 0





 

'

%(("

(

% "%%

  "' " %

 

 ( % "5

 

-

' "'(%

0 %

" 

'

" 0% %0%  

&0%



'%(

#'

%



# <<,1E338A  2H13E 4!



Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No