← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/522/1998allowed

Bhuru v. Chandgi Ram Andors

2016-07-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages



    



 !""#$%$&'()(*    

  

 

     

 +' ,-

     

  



 

 



!

 

"





!   

 ###     $%&  '

! (   ) )

  !

* !

 

  $+&   !  ! ( 



(  !  



  )    

 ! %, 

 !

  !     -%./

+/.0%12. 



 

   '  

 ( 3

 !3

 ! 

 

 ! %10..*)   !

 ! 

!! 

  

        

   

+..4%151 ' 

  ( (6 7 

    "

   

 +0.2%12% ("

    %1 0..*)

   

 ! +/,50.*)  

      %*0  )  

  (

' 

(    ( ! +0.1%12%

$,&  

  "

    

+0.2%12%  (

8  6 )99 -

 "

  

,%.0%12/

   !  !  

 

 ! : ;(      

     <  !      

    

 .0.,%12, $/&  

!!)

  

    (  !   !  

 



 )     ! )         !

  

+%1,50.*)     !      

 +0.2%12%

     (0..*)

  ! 



= 

 

   

   !    

  )       =

   !!

      !   

!!    

   

!!  

'  !  

 

   !

 (   

 ! 

!   

   

 

!!

 

!!(   (     



 ! !  !          !  (       !     !   

 (  

    !



  !

 (   

 !

  

 

(

         

$0&  8 !

)

 

    : 

 

       

!+%/,50.*)

  !    ) (  !   )  

 

!! 

 !

!

   

   ' 

 !   

!!  

 ( 

  



 

   

 (      

       

    

 =   $4&  !

 !   

   



  !

   )

                                                          !  " 

      #$ % $5&           

   '

      "

  

 .4.1%11/  

   

!!  (         

  !

  

 !

!          

!!

 

(

    !  

+0.2%12%  

 ! )  '   ! )   ( 



  +0.1%12% 

)  !   

  (    $2&  8 !

)

 ( !    >  

 "

  ! 

 >  

    

  "

   

 %,.+%112   ( !!   "

   ! 

   '

      

  

  

  ( !  $1&  9

 

 !    



      $%.&  

  (

    

 !

)

 ! (

  ! )  ( )   

 

 "

   

 +0.2%12%    ( ( 6  7  

        -%./ ! %12. '   

  "

?<@1*+   !

  

)

& "

 

  "

         '   "   

       (    

   $ )#**+'     $!,#*       -

 +# '           .  #*) )/ & 

            

                  

 "  

 &        % $%%&  

!!

 



      

 (0..*):   =    +%1,50.*)   ! %10..*)  

   

 +/,50.*)

    A

 +%1,50.*)  

 

  +%/,50.*)

  ! 

 !0..*)

    ( 

 9 

 ( 

 

 8@%

   =    +%0..*)

   

 B  C

"

D (   +/,50.*)

    :   

         

      (0..*) $%+&   !   



) !

 

 !

 

 !!

  !   )  



    !

            

   

!  ) !    -%./!%12.

 +0.2%12%   ( 

   (  ! 

  !"

  -%./!%12. 

    

         +0.2%12%

      @1*+ 

 

  



     )

  !  

!

      



 





!"    '   !

!

 

  "

(  

 '   

 

(    !"

?<@1*+

 $%,&   !7

 "

          

 ! "

!  ! = 



 !!

  

( !

 :   !  

 %..  !   ! (

 = 

    0   ! 

  

  

   

 

 

( !      

  B D  BD !

 %..B%D  -   

  =  (

 = 

 (  !   ' 

! 

(   

(     



(         (

= 

>     

  (   (  

    <E      

  % $%/&  '  (

 =   !

 

 ( !          )      #*/ )/     

   

   "

    12    

   "

         

  (    (     %

$%0&  9 

       



     >  !

  

 

  

+0.2%12%

!   

 

(

  (     

   ( !    

  9    

   )

! 

  ( !    

 2!   !

    )

3              

   2     

   "

            

            

   1 2         

     3"    2  

                 4 5  2% $%4&  

  "

 

 +0.2%12%      )   

 <(  @1*+ 8  

 !

 <   "

 !



 "

 

 +0.2%12% '    "

   

!!  

   ,%.0%12/

 !   

      : ;(   <   9             

   "



 +0.2%12%  

(

 (  

 <   !   A /% +5

$%5&  

  !

  < E1   

 "

F =     

    )      !

)

 =        ! 



     '                !  =

!



!  !

! "

  

(

(      

 

  

(  ! (  

     =  ( 

   <  

!  >     " "  # $!%  

&& ' ('

 &)

   

* !+&, $%2&     

 !   

 

  "'- 

+. / (0 +* 

  )    =          

     !<    '  

  ! )  (  ! !

     ) 

     !<   

!

  !A +. %/

( 

    

  G  ;       

<  ! A  +.   %/ 9       

 (  !  

!

  (   (

   !(   

     (  <  

$%1&  >    !    H 

 

 

     

!          !<   



  

!!

  !   '      (  "

  )   (         9!     



   !A +. %/

  

    !!

!        

  !<      

 

      =

(   

      

 ! 

  = 

!A +. %/

(

   

     

   

     

!!

  !    $+.&  :

    !   "

 9  !

 

    

   

    <

  



    

          (        !  9

   ! 

            

 (   

    ! )

! <

     =  (       !< 

  !   "

 (  !

!

       <

 = 

          

 (     $+%&  >    !    

     !- "   1%2

 !.

9

!    

     ("



(



   (      

 (   <    9 

("

!



    (   (      !   "

 '  

( 

   !   

( !

       )

 ! <

  

       (       

        ( !

!





! (   

 "

  

     $++&  >    !    

     8   !  !% "  ,**/,0(/(%03&. 



 !           )     

 !< (      '  

"



     (   

  "

 '     

<



( ( !  

 

   

 '   "

   (

 !  

        (

* ! & '%% "  !%

+ !.** "  "

    4   "  

 ! ,*+ /#0   "       '



) ! & /#0

 4  

 !,+      



 !

    !!

 

 $+,&    )    

 

A  +.   %/    ?<       "     ("

!

 (      

          



(

,! "

( )  

%15, $+/&    !        

(

 

   (       

< !   )    !

      !  9   

 !



    

  

   (     9

 !   

    

   !     9

! 

  (   =

9

 



      

  =   (   

 ! 

    A  /%   +5    ( !    

   9        

   

 (

 

  !

 

 

  

    $+0&  A  /%   +,*+,)*+0  

   

       !     

   !    

 !

  



     

(  

' 

!

 ! ( ! 

 !   



   * 

  

      !     

 !  

      

( 

        ( ! 



(  

 !A /% +,  !   

 !     

      

    

 

        

  ) 

         '  

    A /% +,

 ! A  /%   +0    

     

!   

 !     

     

 !

        

     

 

  



    

       !  

             (   (  (   

  $+4&   "

  

    !

   !

 (!! 



 : ;(  <

  "   !



 (  

    

  









   (  ( !   

  

+0.2%12%   



 !

  "

  )     

 +0.2%12% ?<@1*+

  !



 

!     =  A

 !    



 ( 

!     

  

     $+5&   

  ( "

 < 

       ! 

 !A /%  +,*+,)*+0

 

    

      

     ( 

  (

!



  !

  

  ( ( 

  

      

 



    (

 

  '   

 ( 

  

     

!   

  

(    

      %2.5+.%4