← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/19068/2022dismissed

Heavent Sudhir Malhotra v. Shree Naina Plastics Inc Khata Baddi

2024-07-24Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat23 pages

  

 ! " #    " 

$% &'

&('

"

")) * +,-, + 

     

   

  & '

-

&('



     

   

  &$'

+

&('



     

   

  &+'

- 

&('



     

   

  &%'

-

&('



     

   

 

& '

+%

&('



     

   

  &-'

 +

&('



     

   

  & '

 

&('

  

   

   

   *.!/, 0,0,01 2   

  

   

 

 ! 

 "



!  # $%   "

&  

 !&  #   ,0,01 2  3,&45'

' (

      

  ##  )*      +,'-).*,/)//  67089)459 4:,094 ) 5)19!);3+,'-'0'#/)//   67089)459 4:,094) 5)19 !);3 +,'-'1-   67089)459 4:,

$ 094) 5)19!);3 +,'-)0.#/)//  67089)459 4:,094) 5) 19!);3 +,'-)0)#/)//  67089)4 59 4  :,  094  )  5)    19  !);3 +  ,'-'12  #  /)// 67  089)4 59 4 :,  094 )  5)    19  !);3 +  ,''.'1  #  /)// 67089)459 4:,094) 5)19 !);  +,'...#/)//   6:) 09<=:, 094) 5)19!);!3  ##       4  #

#  # ""

 # !+,'-).*,/)//  67089)459 4:,094) 5);, / ( #     1*/ + +

 5 3  

!

! '*6*. 

/-)-/)'*  7094) 5),:,>5

 !74= 4)7/)?) 94;& 8 ,'%  !!   )'')/)'*$ 8 ,/% +   #  &

   

   ' +  + 

"5    " !! #

   '6*#   " ! '**'$ # " #

99 .% #  5 "!

 5 3  

 )1)'/)//$ 8 ,.% +

!

  60/  '*')/)'-  67089)459 4:,094

+ ) 5), $ 8 ,2%

"5    #   "

!

  6 :         

   " #  #     !5

   ;!5!5; < :( 4   

:

!

     5

       #+!  '-2.

  ;!   

#

!

     5=(=4>   ;!5 

    "5  ;! #

   #  !#0'))--6161;, 5" "5                  



  #   "

 5    3      ,!5 # # !       



  #     "

 5         

 3 

    #       #  ! $ 8 ,'%    ,!5 

5 #    ! $ 8 ,'%( 

5

  "

 ;  

? 

 5#   , !5

  )'')/)'*$ 8 ,/% 

+          !!          

     (       "#      

  +    '')0/)'-  !

 "   

  #  5#  !#') ! 

%     5!     /  #') ! 

+  :      "!

   

+ # &

+ 

"5            +  60/;/)'-    '*')/)'-         !!  $ 8 ,/%5# 





"5  +  

+   #

    #     !  $ 8   ,'%  =        #  '*')/)'-"#   + 

  #   # 5#!  6)) 5=

    "#   + )6

      #  

                  #   # 5#   

 "

!

  # "5 + #

    &

  + 

    )1)'/)//  

   $ 8 ,.%:     #  "!

 "   !5

+      1*/+ + 3  

!

! $ 8 ,'% !5" 8!

 !

 1 :         #   "!

      

 +  5   $+%

"       

  #     @

           '0  #  

  5 A 5+ /)'.$ # " #

 @9   A%      

!       #   $%      +!5: (

" $ # "

#

 @9/A%

  /2)0/)'*: 

    B

! C"   !  +        !  # 0B  19)3   58) 

) 5 

4  ) 5  5C<

  84)  /,  :,  0:

5C<

84)/, 94D 0 5)0+ E   ! !# ##

# +  @"

     

!     # $%     #  #@

 # +  @"  

    '0# +  2 :     #  "!

 +:(

 5     

  )1)*/)// 

!! 

!    -.$'%$%# +   (   # 

!

! 

! !    -.# +      #  

  " 



!! 

!

  

"

 #  

 # -.# +   

   '6* #    "         

"  "  

5 ! $ 8 ,'% 

-     "   ;  

    ! 

!  "

#   . :     #  !5



  !"  !       

  #    "         ;!5  #    # "  >5  ! "!  ! $ 8 ,'%   

#

 "  #        #   5    5  "        !!   5   " 0 >      #    "!

           #   "5        #   # !##(

+ 

  "#  

+  # " " 

   

!5

 

+  :   

   */+ +  (   "#  

 '')0/)'- 

 "  

 # " " ( 

   #   "# 

+  

 # + #  5#') !  # 5   # !')/"5

+ (

+ 

 

+ 

## !  # "5



 #)'5  ! ! # 



!

  "#   + + 

   !!  $ 8 ,/%     #

 "#   + 



   !5

  )1)'/)//$ 8 ,.%   #   # 5#6)) 5 #                    

!

   #  :   #  "!

 

  /*)0/)//       !   + 

   

  !( !



 !

  "# 

+ 

 5  3    /*)0/)// &

 

 ' + 

"5     !

 D



!

 +,1)6*0#/)// 

 67089)459 4:,094) 5)

94 B)) ;3 

+     # 

,  "5" # ,                  

     !" #    $   % !

%!&% #      !'  #

       (  ( 

     )  ( !*  #$       (      !  "             

   



!%+!&% ,            (       (-       ( (.!

% /            /  !  *   0$     



(  (  /   0 ( (   (1     !  *  $          ) 0!'  #1      ( $      

 ( (      (     0  ( (   (1    0         

 0 ( (    (( 1     & !%!&% ,!

," (                      0   ( 2 

(!

%"  #   3

# // 4   4.$3$3 +5%%3&% ,  /         

    ( 2   (!  *        &&!%,!&%& #4      .!

% /.!& /!   4     ( 2  (  %+

  (       (  !*# (  

 

   4            (  !

*    (            &!%+!&%&&     

!%5!&%&&(  

(  

!%+!&%&&   &!%+!&%&&!!           

!%+!&%&& (   (

$    ) 

-  ! &6666

6666

"      & !%7!&%&& $               !*1    % !%+!&%&&!     & !%7!&%&&$      1  (  % 

!& !%7!&%&&$   

      (    !

*  #  0  & 4 !8!4!#                     & !%7!&%&&    $     / /1  ( 

%  

      !           

  1 

!%5!&%&&#

     )           ( 

   #$     -     % !%+!&%&& 

!%+!&%&&!  '  #      ( 

!%5!&%&& % !%+!&%&&  

!%+!&%&&  

 ( $  !'  #  

!%+!&%&&!  91        )   



   0  

-!  *   )            &7!%+!&%&&  #      4      ( $            $    (         (    :! * :   #   "!

         #         "       !   #  "5

! 



   5"

!



+ "5 A

  -  # ! )-)//)/6 ; 

!   "#  &

 

 '+ + 

 "5    !

  

!    

     5  #  

"#  

+   /2)1/)//   #  5   -2$'% 

 0$/%#5 A 5+    

"!  

  )1)*/)// +:(

@

  #  E   +  

 @"  #      5         #      #          A"5 

   

5  !#  ')) ')'# +    #   

"#  

+    '6*#  !5 "5 :   #  "!

 

 

)-)//)/6 + #&

 

 '++ 

!

 

  #     

5   #  5= "! #  "    



  ""

!

 5



   ') :   #  #  "!

  "# # -.# +  "8    # # # 

    # 5 A 5+ /)'.

  " ! '-*/  5

##  "          

##      (      #    

   '-#+     

 

# 5 ;3 



!

 

      '6*#  =

  

   

 !  "#   

  + !"

 

$ ''         

       "5   

 #    



  # 5 '/    

! 5   "5      " ##   +:(

 5     

  )1)*/)// 

!! 

!    -.$'%$%# +    # 

!! 

!

!       -.  #     +           #    

  " 

  ! 

!

  

"

 +3 5  

   '6*#     !!  $ 8 ,/%  ""3 

+ #

+   # 5!

     "5   #   '6 ( C"  !+ 



  8 # '1-. ')'# +  ! #6 , 94F  94:,099!4 94B 4)7/)?); $/)/'%.

  !+ +/2*  # ,  7!;   

 7

   #    (             7  (#           

     (- !*   (-( 

+ 1   

      : (-   

!*  :#   #   1      (:#    (  !  #   1    :    (        



  (    :

    1                    0        !  </ #     ,5   %     4  """8 """         #  1 #  #(:   7!

7!

!666666666666

7!&!      ( #      #  

 !*     

  (    :

(!" :                    =   $ 0 > /<!! 4 (*<!# &% & 445+   +%, ?  -?

!

4 " <!#&% ,7 44 ,&  &%&3&% !

*#     @  ) (#            (  

( ( !

7!

!;   -1 

    

#  

%  

   #  

     (                              (        ( #         (#    #  7#  ,5#    % !  #   

   (  (  !

*#                #        (     #      (              (            #/       ( !:

'1 !      C"    !  +        B9$  %

 #

 "  ! !A

9$  %"   

,  +!A!.

 /   /   



  ,5  %     

  (# 1#B &5!;    ,5  % #         

#       

 

    (         

 !;    8 """#

 3        (  (!C   # 

  #  (

         

        

  

(  8 """!

 

 #    

       

     (    (    

!  *          (  

 %     !

&5!

! 

   ((    ( #   (  #               -      #     

      (  D           !*(-4         

            1 ( 

   (#   

  !'  #      #

    ((     ( 

!

 

(   ( E(    !"       

%    #     ( ( !:

*(  #  1#  !

'  #          (         (    

 1 0              (  3F3  2 !: '2    #      C"    !  +  



  !  5   ! # FC18?4

- 9C9C? G:, 84)? ) 4B 4) 

) /,3 +&'04)?)5 H $& ',,,&4)?)5'  # ,  7!  *         C  4    G C  4    4             4       !

*              4  ( #         H!"!           !

5!;           0       !" # (    

">4  /        (/ (

    #    



H!"!!;  (          (  

H!"!        (# 



( /  / 

     !;       

   H!"!      !*  

 !  

    (





H!"!!"   

     (     (!*  / !

+!" (    ">4    

   

  1    (              1   !H(    ">4     ( (  (# ( 0    I!* (   (     0    8     $   D         #   !*   

 ( (  !;   /    (

  

   

   !" #  

!  (  !

!;  (    

    

$ D   (   !

;  (    

 H!"!                      

    !*    (  (     ( #   !

*       (  !*

    

(  #

   (    



 

  0  ( 

(0  

H!"!

#  (:! '.  # !       3  3      )0)./)'*  #  #  3                  @

   = 

  # @

  

 '0# +  

!   # 

  +:(

  /2)0/)'* #

@

   #  ! "!  -# !        

 @

 #   ;!5 A #

5 5"  ##

# !5     3    # !       #   5        #   3   



# ! A 

#    5

5 B 5 "# ##!!

    '6*#  (  

!   

 #  !

 '0  # !  C"  !+     !" #B

! 

" !

 57

 AF

+   7 A  F= 5

  

  +  #        ! 

 

#  

    !#!

# # "





   3 # 5   +       5



      5  3

 " " +  '* ( C"  !+   ! #"5)B0)=9 :,0

4 49 943& ' 0+ !

   5    

"5 

     



!   !#B  

    #  #B  

       5  # 

! #  '-  48)?!4897, ) 

)& -' 0 3 C"  !+     

 " +  # 8   

   5B

  #    #!

#

#   !!

#  #  !

 #   #     A

   5B

 # + "    



#

5   /)   4)= /)=9 /)?) 7,  0  !G 

 ) & -' 0++3 8+    

J"               !  "  1   1  

   #   # ; 4  (     /- !"      

          4 #4 

  

-   !*  (    (                ( 4 ( !*  (  -     #   !"              #     ( (!J /'

  ##       "  "  !  

  /*)0/)// &

 

 ' + + 

  

#=



!

         +  ,1)6*0  #  /)//      67089)459 4:,094) 5) 94  B)) ;3

+   5"  #   5  " #

3

" ; 5"   # !  #  5  5 

+  ! #  "!

  

    +      !   #   "!

       #        #   

      !##"5      "

!



+ 

//  # "#5   

 # # !  #B    # #

   # 53 "  ## !

+  /6  # !       !!

     )'>" /)'* #   !      )2  5         # 

##    ; "5

##   #

"#  

+ =   !  #   5   #

"#  +  !    "#  

+ "5 !

!(  !   "#  

+ "5 

! /2)1/)//   ! # 

5 

   -2$'% 

 0$/%# +     ,!5$ 

%

     )1)*/)//     +:(    @

 

    #     E       +    @"  #

 5    #     

   '6*#    ""5 "5 

+  /1 ( &

 

 '++ 

;

+

!

 

  )-)//)/6( 5  

## !

+ "  #



$    

 "# 

+ (      5 

!   !

"   #         "    "  

          

   # !#!

#  /2  # "

  #

!

                      "    "

!



+  /. @ !

 

+,-, +  &,0,01 2 '

!

   "   ;A 

G; D   "  G;