Harshdeep Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"
"#$ %
&
"$ ' ( )#* +!
*
& +" * +, +-* "#$* ) & * ++-* "#$
. $ , $0 " +,
1
"
3*
,'
,, ) ,
! " # $$%&$&'
( &!
) *
#
!
+ ) ,&$&&$&-
( .!
(
# "
" #
(
/ 0
(
"
/ 1# "2 $-$,&$&- ! (
3 ,.4&,4-,4%
%% 3 + *
5 ! /# # / #
!7(
&$&' 7 8
" 3 ,.4&,4-,4%
%%
" #
# 9:81 ; 0 # 9
*4
# 4 )
7(
)
# &$&', $$%&$&'
( &! 5 0 #
(
"
" &<
#
//78 7(
&$&' #
6
" ((( ((( ((( ((( (((=
$
* ! $ ,
*
4 "#$ "$, ! '' 5 6 '' 67 !
"#$ !, ! 589"! ( 7 ,,
5, 2
* ! "'
7 $
,, $
"#$ !, ! '$ '
! 89' *
* ! !' 4
.
.
5+9" 7 /
, "" !' " , 0
,'0 9' " 2.
/ ",
,'0 9' $ , $0
4 .
.
) "
':
0 .
': /
' 9' $ ", '
. ;
.
;
<", .
. '
, ! ! 0 ) , , $,
' 9' %
4 '$
"0
"
, "0 "
5=,71 $ >
5-337 )
'9'"' ,'
)
0 ) '9'"'
,'
2 0 . .
" ; ': ,'0 9' '
! .
5+9" 7
4
"
,
,0* : !) $ "
,'
0 3 " , " "
) ! <"
,'0 9' >
! *
,0 $0 )0
!
# * * 0* "#$ "$, ! '' * ,* "#$* $ ,
4 $
,* )
,, ) $ : 0 (
# (
/# #>
7(
4
#>
(
/#
# / / # 7(
! 1 &$$%
$$,&$,.
) , #
4 # 5 4 / 4+ *"
/
7(
8 7(
0
*
,
* 0 /# # 7(#!1
*
? ?
# >
" )
* 8 7(
> #
# #" #
,&$&&$&- /
( .! .0
#? :
; 8 # 7(
>
8 7(
" 5 4 / 4 + *"
/
?
#" '0
7(
* (
"
> /#
#/ / #7(
&$&'4
* 8 7(
> #"0
" 8 7(
4
#
#
> #">
> #" " #
? ! >
4 ?
#
! / 0
8
> #" "
" " " # # >
"
6 &&$@&$&,A B/ /# -%' &$&,
+ "
#
:0
/ : *
/
(1,!0 1 *
#
C
!
(
# 846 -0 /
(
$@,&&$&'4
4
"* $<,&&$&'" /
B
" 0
" " 6
"*
# $<,&&$&'
"# $<,&&$&' ,&,&&$&'
1#
(
$<,&&$&' B/ D E&/
#
6 0 6 " (0
4 #" * /
0/
" "
"
( " " ) 4
# (
/
B > 4 ) " "
4
" # " $&!
*
, 5 !
"
&'!
*
& / 0!
#
")
E @ 0 #4# 6
" 2# /
"
4 6 #
" " 24" 6( #? >
#? 6(41#?;
"2"
# ,$$,&$&-
>5
>> / 0 /
B " > A B/
6
" * " <,&&$&' ,&,&&$&'>
A B/ ) " ) ,.4&,4
-,4%
%% 3 + * 5 !
(
6 " ) 0 1#?;
" *
6 ) ,.4 &,4-,4%
%% 3 + * 5
!>
" 6 " 6 "
6
&<$'&$,%A B/ /# &.'<& &$,<F
+
:#
/ : * /
( 1&! 0 )
"*
# = ; ? ",
"0 "
, "0 "
=,1 $ >
5-337
'
, '
! " 8 89'
'$ )
)
$0 " 9,"
'
' 9' $
" ) :0
'
' "
"$, ,) > * , ", ! ',0
$0 , ",
"$' , $,
' 9' "
!
: ) #"
"
" "$'
, $ " ) !
!' 89 , ) ",0 " $0 '' $# ) ,0
! , ",
" 2 " " ; ': ,'0 9'
' ,
$# ) :0 , $0 '' 9' $# $0 ) ''$
89 , , ) ',* '' , ! ) :0 $
! ) :0* "
) " .
", ) " .
.
', <" $ $0 ! (
"
!
"#! $
%&
' ( )
* ) 0 ) '
<" , ) :0
! " 1
<"
,'0 9'
"#$ !, ! 5=", ( 7* ) ) , "" !'
* #" '
6$, "
' " #" * !
( ' +', )')
'!$- ."
'/0 123$ 45, %$ +'
'!$
*
'/103$ 647& )$!
) --
! 89''9
'/1 3$64*$
' ! 5' $ +'
' / 0 :5 1$"- 3 0 4 7& )$!
) --
!$
7
'( !
"" 666
1 +
$;13 0
0347 +'
" ' +'5+ . ! ' $ '
89'%
'/13$6 ! ( #" '
" 0
< ='
!$
7
' ( )
2* )
, " &.> " 6
"
() "
"* #7(/
( 6 &&- / > 0A 9
/ #" * !
( ' +' , ) ')
' , $- ."
'( 0 123$ 4 # D ,-GG *
"
# "
"
>
" 4 4
"# 6" GGG= &'0A 9 / 5, %$ +'
',$
*
'103$ 64 " ") #
" D $0 " 6 4)
" "
0 D !> 41 1 #
(
#
"
"
4 (
H !> 41 1 #
(
#
"
! /
#
# 4 "
=
(
H !0/ # I
"
J 7(
H #!0 / *
"
#!> # 4 (
= (( (( (( (( , :
"
#
" >
(
4
0 (
#
# 6 #
)
"
) 4
"
0 / "
"
J(
) & >
# / 4 " # #4 / (
0 (
# "
4
#
(
( "
(
4 # (
)
(
0 * #
4/
*
(
"
" # (
(
0 (
) "
(
#
(
#
"
" (
J " # H "" # # / H""
K # H
"" 0
" *
9 #
" 0 #
= &->
/
6 "4 (
6 4#
4 6 >
# + A/ 0
( )
2(
<='
, $
7
'4" "
(
A/ +
!7(
&$&$&, /# # !/
"* 6 A 9
/ 7& )$!
) --
, 89''9
'(1 3$64"
6 "4 / " " 7(
&@ 0 A 9 / "
4 *$
' , 5' $ +'
'( 0 :5 1$"- 30 D ,&0 ""
*
"
*"
) " *
" " 0 /
/ (
*
"=
&< 6 4 7(
# 1 /
# :
1 7(
L 6 4" # 7(
" 1
A #
7(/
4
1 /
4
"
#
4" * "
4 (
6 &&- /
> > #
(4"
# # ) &%
"
7( /
1 7(
? A 9 / 7& )$!
) --
,$
7
'( !
"" 666
1 +
$;13 0
03> 4A
#/
4 * ,
5 / !4 "
6#) "
"
" )
",$$) >"
,$$) 4
"
"*7(
"
4" ) # # ) L ) ) "
4
# + 4" "
(
(4
7(/
4 ""
6
A 9
/ 7& )$!
) --
> ) ! 0 A 9 /
6 # + "
4 "
* #"
"
7(/
4" " $
) ,
7(
" ) , /
"
1
,$&&$&0 4 ) ,"
1 /
) 4 " *
4" " " # * 8 (
4 #
" ) A "#4" #" # ,@$&&$& 1 /
" 3 ,"
"
* ' 6 "" #
"* ) ,> " #
# )
"
7(
* 1
"
A 9 / 5, %$ +'1$"34 #
4 # (
(
) "
,0A 9 / 7 +'
"
' +'5+ . , '$ '
89'%
'(13$64 *
"
(
"
" >
# 4 "/ 4" ( "
"
(
(
" & > " # 7(
1 /
>
4 # (
7(
1
"
"* = ',
#" '
! (
" ? %$ +'!$
7
'/ 77 02* ) , $ , "
", 9 " '
", $ ,"
, ,,
) :0 %,0*
(
" , " ', "
-@ !
'!$
7
'/ 77 * ) , * )
) "
<" , ) :0 5!7 , $0
'' *
+
5 ,, 7 !'
;* 9 )
. " <" ) !
,! 3 , * . " <" ) 9' $0 ) '' )
, "* $ , " '>
#
0 ) ,$$<&$&'4 /
# 6
" * " "
,,$<&$&' 0 6 #"
"
6(" "
#4
" * "
? # &$<&$&'
"
" ? 6 4
* (
6 4
" 6 ( 0
(H " " "
4
"
0 6 " (
(9 #4 #
"*"
$<$%&$&'4 " ) -0/
"#" * 6(
(
4
( 0
0/
6 6(4
"* "
0/ 6 #
" !
( * H
* " *( 4
#
4 # ( 64" #(
6 4
(
* "
?#
"* 0= .
',
#" '
" 620
0
-% #
'!$
%&
'( )
2 .. 9 !
",
,'0 89' * )
$ ,* ) <" $ , )
3 * @
"0 "
, "0
"
=,1 $ >
5-3,7
A * ,* )
$ :* '9'"' ,' 0
4 . ) *
4 * ' $ !* '9'"' ,' 2 0
. .
$,0
"0 "
, "0 "
=,1 $ >
5-337* "'$
, , $,
& 89' '0 '0 $ .
. ' !
0 / '
* "* 0 , .
. ' , !* ) ", $ , '0 "'$
$ ,
* )
! <",
& 89' * ' ,'0 89'
", ! , ) '
", ,,
,, "'$
'
" ", ,, ) <" ,,
& 89' 9
.
. ' , ! > $* ,, $
$0 9
.
. ' , "'$
! $ ,,
) ' 9'
,, .
0
" , "'$
)
5=,7 )
"#$ !, ! 589"! ( 7* / ,
$ !
0 ' 3 "
$0 0 " 0 %", / * ) ) $ "
$ ) $0 * ',0 $ "
"
,'
4 . 6 0 ) *
4 *
2 0 ' "'
1 5=,7 *
0, 9' !) .
$ "
#" "' , * $
" $ "
,
& 89' ,
0, !) 0*
)
, -, 5&,7 .; , .
) ! $
,
& 89' "
) * ! "1'$ "
" <" B" 4 .;* .* .* . ,0* ! ) :0 ) ,
.
,'0 89' ", )* * , .
.
* )
" "9 , ,0
'
)
'
) & 89' ,0 ", $ ,
. ;
.
;
/ , 0 $#
) :0 ) ", '
.
.
.
/ !
" ),, ' $0 , ! " " .
5C$
D
"#$ 7 * ) ', " ) !
,! ) ) 1! "1'$ "
" <" ! ,'0 89' " ' D ,, *
#$ E!0*
:
' $0 9 '' + )
"'$
" $, , !
: 9 0 ) #"
" / ,'
$, $ #" "
'
"' $ ! . C !) $ !* ", '9 , ,)* "
)
, $0 '* ) ! $ ' ,0
% : 1 F14
%
$, F14