Balbir Kaur v. State Of Punjab And Others


 


    

 




   
;
<
=


"( 
!!  $

























!!!!


  








































. 


"
*

/ 01
!
23451
   

 

 
  !













!!! '" 
 36 7


*
'!

!
+


%
"8( %


!
  )

+*
* * %
69%


!
     -
) "

*
' 
'


: *+
*
"# 
"
$!$!  %
&
>%
,* -
(

)

*
'
 
()'


'')
, ,
("%

"

*
 (
* 
*


) +*%
,*(*
 
"
"(""
-
*


CWP-2218- -2017, Amarjit Kaur vs. St tate of Punjab, decided on 17.01.2020, , after taking a holistic view of the object of the policy, declared Cl ause (c) of Note-I of Scheme for r compassionate appointments2002 as ult tra vires of Articles 14 & 15 of f the Constitution of India and struck it off f, which was upheld by the Divi ision Bench in LPA-462-2021, vide judgm ment dated 25.01.2023 and has a attained finality up to Hon'ble the Suprem me Court wherein SLP No. 935 56-2023, challenging the same was dismiss sed on 18.10.2023, relevant para as whereof read thus:

  ?>!


'


*

8
'

+-

'  %
,*
,


'')

()'

"'"
)) 

* 98)
)'

-%
,*
,*
*
"'"
 -
)


*
"'"

"
)

"'"
"

+*



) )
*

+ +
 "

*

:

"
-
A) 

 

*


(("% + "

*
) 

  !



 

"

+* 
) +*
 -!
!

4*

"
''  (
) 

*
'  * '+
* "

*
 -%
,*   ",!
4*
)%
* )
 8 

* 
*-  %
,*(*
*-

 ( ' %
,*
'8""
*)
*

)

*
88

!
4 ,*
+ "


' 
+

'')

()'



*
 -!
4*

 

 -


*
, -!
 '8""
(*
 %
)

 

* #*
 -%

'')

'(

(



3) *
) 
+'

* 
*
 (

()'

 -


"( "
)'

  (

( 
"


'8



"
)  
 !

!

( 


*
  :

 )

)


( ("


*

-
* 
*
 
"

* '  #( +

+)

*
( 
8

" () ,) 
) -

*


 *
) 

  !
4*
 -



"'8"
'')
 +*


"( "

@
; =
, "
*,
* 
*






( " 
+"
( "

 -

*
"( "

*  !

5
"

) %
,*(*
( "
%
"
"

+*
( "+
+*!
4*

''


(*)

*
,"
A"

+*A
"A!
5
) """
*
* %
*


:


,*


( 
) "

8


(("%


 ("


*
(*)%
,*(*

*

'%


'8"+
*
*



""%
 
*
%


8
(*

 -
( 
"
8
*
&)
+
 

*
" *

*

"
"
*
)))

(
4* %
*
") 8
 (
+




( " 



+" %

*
 (

%


+
'8""
 -
" 8+
( 
* 

,*%

' %
) %
 
*
"
' 

!

*
/


')

/
( 
; ' =
* "
 8"


'')





*
-

"
8
*
""
8"
)'

-)


* 
" *


)'

-



5"
+8
+*

()  (
*

'8 +
)' "!
4* 
"

) 8
*
',

(

-+


''  !
,8%
 "
* 

+  

*
&%
,*(*
, "
( "
 
,*-
*
'
* "
*
(*)

* 
*

"
+8)
8 %
,*

@ "
*

) "

*



  %
*
(

)
, 

" () %
,* 
  !



%

-  

 %
,*(*

 (* 
*+
*
'  )"!
.



+" 8



( 
%
$ + "


(C


(*8"
 
*

: ,) 

"'8"

*
* * *




( "  
+

,) %
 '(


*
) %
, )
 +"
"-!
5
*
,"

 

&%

) 
* ( " 
8

,)
*
(

"+ + "
"
*
  

')"

( 

@!

4*


( 
" (


( 8"

"
*
 ,*

'' 
* 
*
* +*
)
*
" +8)
8 

*


*
*

"



,
( 4*


"
'

,+

*
)  +%
( 


'


*

) 


*  '(8

*
) 

  (

* 8
* 


 
"'%
*-
( 

"

 

*
) 

  "
%

"'"
 )'

-%





( ()'


+" %
,*-
,


 "

*
)
 ) :)

+
"'" 8 

*
)

* #*
" !

D)
*

"
''

,
 )"%
,* 



&  ( %

*
"'"(





"

+*

* 
*,
"

) E

" +*

) "

)

"


*
%
" '
*
"
* 8

( ""!
5
*

( 


)"B
-%
*


"
'
 



*
8 (-

,*(*
*
)
* 

:

-
, )

$
"


 

5" !
1:

-
( 

''


!
5
* -
"+

)  

*
) 

-
,*
*
)



" () 

*



" %

( "
* 
)
'

+*

 

) 

  %
,*(*
*
:

'(


,

 (
 *

 !
4*

,"


'' "!
(%
,*(*
'' 

* 8

(*)
;&
 =%
-
*
( ( -
)"


 -


"( )'
* 
*

"'"
 :
'
*
)  +!
)'
*
"

+*%
'



*
 -

*
 *!
*+*%

"

"

+*
 !
5
*

"
*
"

+*
 %
,*(*
*-
 

*

"'8"

(*
 
)  %
) +
* -
* 

'

"( "
98)
" 

'')

, "
*
) +*

)
'8""
*


*


*
"( "
+8)
) !
' 

*

' (-%
,*(*
& )"

)
*
*
*
 -
)) 
,**

"( "
+8)
8 %
(


,**
*



"B
4*

(
 

*

 "'"(


 -
)) 8 

*
)

* #* +*
(


*
!
*
"
 $!

5
"'"(-
*


( " 

'') ,*(*

*



" 
( " 
*

(

"
"

+*%
"'"
8 %
, "
8


(  '(

-
,*
*
 ( "'"

*
"( "
+8 F!

5%
*%
( 
*

(*)
,*(*
"'8 "'"
'
*
"( "


" () "
+  

*
) 

  %
,*(*
+  '(

-
,*

) "
 *
"!
4*
)
 "
 ;( "+
"'"
=G%
, ?) "
"

+*
;( " (  


?) "
"

A"'"
 -
)) A%
( 
%
$%
F
"


* H!

4*
8
*

, E+
",
*
,"
I) 5
-

"+
%

"



  %

"'8"
 ( " 

'') "
*

(*)%
'8"

"
",
*!
J!

4*
68 
(*
 E* /
( 
; ' =%
,* 
" "
!! %
,*(*
'( +*


& 8() (( %
*
*


,



*
"( "
+8)

") %
 '(

-
,*
*
+*
" '
*
+

 
*
 "


 *'!

*
') -
 -
( )

()'


+" %


( "+
*
+'
%
,*(*
&( "

*
"( "
+8)


"
$

*
 %

"

&( "

) "

8)
8 !

"
* 

5

'

@
; =

8

) +*%
,*

"
+8)
8 %
*

*
 
"

*





"'"
'
*
&%

*


&( ""
)



 
;

=


5

? 
,*



 
;(=%


+
"'"
"

+*=G!
4*
+*G

*
"

* %
, 
8

8

*
 !
,*

 8
( :(

"/




 
;(=


+*
)  

*

*
( 

+*



()'


+"
""
*


*
*
( 
*


2 


+
,*


 
;=

' (-

-
'8""
*
) 

 "


"'"


?H!

4*


:"


& )"

*
 !
4* ((+
(

  8
* 
( 

"

 "
 

 (
"
  (

(*8+
'((
"

) 

 -%

"
'8 

*
' (-

"

*
8

( 



 

( 



,

 "!
5



 "
(

+





(



'  %

-
*
 

*
'' 

!
,8%
*
(

(

"
8 8
;
 

$ 
 
+

8!
, H$=!
5
) 

, -
 
" (
+

   (
+*







,+
,
("


""


 " + *
' 
+*
)
*
 "
) 
* 8
+*

(*8"
- J!
4*
"

"
*
 " (
*+ !
* 



&
,
*
 (

*
' (-
,* 
 -
,*
*


*


) 
"( >!

5
*
 "
(



1& 8()
, (

8 *"

(

"'"


1&
 (( 
)

() +*
* 
&( 8

-




(


*

"
"

+*  (

*
( 
 "'"
(



-
"(
,** ())
 (

"'"
(


*
( 
"
,*(*
'

'" 

!
4*%


)

+8+

" ( +*
,*

,*

8 *"
-
"'8+
(

  
 *

*
) "
 
()!
4*
+)  )
)"


+"
* 
*

"' 
:
-
" *
( 

"'"


)' "
* 
*
, , 
 
 E %
5
>$

'
)


"
 

"
 






*

(*8"
-
*
+

!
 


) 

*
 
;=
4*
(


) 



"
,*(*

*+
* 
+'"



*
+'K
"
; =
4*






*
 (
-
*
(!
,*(*

*



*
 (

*
' (-

,
( -

* 
*
) 



(

"
*
(*
) E
*
(

!
5


 




+

E+
(*

"
" () -!

 
;=

*
' (-%
) ,*
"

* 8
"'"
 ""





 "
8() "
 

(*
)'
*-
,* ""
)
*
!
4*


(
8 
 (
*

*
)!
5
())

)'

-)

(E

()
*

"

) E





"

+*!
4*

+
I)

(E


8 *"/

' 

*

*

*)

*
)
, "
"
( 

) -
 )

) 

"'"
(

*

"'"
(( 

*


+"

(* "

*

,*
"'"
(
)

 -
*
"

*
) "
"

+*

*
"

*
*

"%
, ( "  
8

"


("
* ,
) 


 +!
4*

F )'* 

)


8 *"%

 
,* 

) +* 
*  

(

8
)") 
*
"
(( 

"
,
*
"

+*
 +*



* , "
* 8
* "
*
 !

5
8,

*

,"!
4*
"+
*,



(

"(

*
 
"
*



"'"
(

*(*
, 
' 

*


,

!
4*%
,
* 8
+
*
 "
+)!
)
"

"
$!F! $%
(
F

(%
>$F%
* 
)""


('

(
* 8
*
)
*
('

( -
''-

*

!

8%
*
  
'



(

 
;=

*
' (-

"
 
8

( 



 
;=
*


" "'"


8()
,*
"

* 8
(

8 *"
,


"
(( G


"("

 
"'"


*
"

+*%
 (


-
*!
?;=

+*

1& "'"




"'"

4*
 '"

(( 

*
' 

+
*
(" >!

4*

8
 

* 

''



*
( "+)

*
3 E* "

3"* )
+*
+ 
6 (
; ' =
,


''

-
,  
8 8"

*
' 
( !

4*
,"
I) "/



'

@

*

( ( 

"
$

*
 
)
*
"
' (-
 ( 4*
"
(

 
, "
,


?415
A6'"
D

=
LLL
LLL
LLL

=
LLL
LLL
LLL


(=
6 +*
;( "+
"'"

"=
LLL
LLL
LLLG
!

5
*
+*

*

8

'')
"
*
 ;&
@=!
!

'+

8,
* ;&
 =

*
6' 56%
4 
4 %
,*(*


()#''-
 )


68 
(*
"+)



* "!
4*
D

(*
+*


*
( 

' 8

E
0"!A
( *


(

*
 (
!



 
;(=

5%
  (*)

"(

"
 
8

 
"%
*%
(E
( !



, 

) A
)  "
6 +*=K

%
'

* "





(*)
"

"
!! 
*
'
"

"
 !F! 
-
'"

 (%

"

*
8( 

*
 *
)*

*
'%

H ,*
,
*
''


 ) - *
'%
,*

*
( '

+
,*
*
*

*
)*/
* 

.

"'"
'
*
' 

*

"
 




(


"

*
 *
 -

  +
 

 

 *+
*
 (
* 
*
'

"
'

8-



+
"'"
'
*
"(

'')

()'

 @!

5
*
+*

*

8

,"!
5)'+"
"
"

"


* -
: *"!

 "
*

(*)
"

"
!

6(

   (%


 '"
!

*
'

( " 
)*
)
*
"



( -
)!
2


 %

* 


)"
* 
*

"
(* "

 "+

+

+*
+*


%


-


*
"( *)
+*!
*
*
 -

(

()
&('
*


,*
+ 
"( -%
* %
( -
' 

*
)*
"
* %


*
(

( "
 *
 +
*


+" !
8%
*
' 
,
'

"
$!! $
;&
=

* "




'')
!! 
;&
@=!
"

*
6(
9




 
'')



*
(

)
,*

'"

('

('-

*
"!


!
0 "
 
( 
" ' 
*
 

* 




(8
+ "
*
 (

' 
"
" ,

-
" (8

'(

*
)"
 "+)

(
-
( -

,!

@!
5
, E

*

8%
*
'  
'

" ' "


)

Am marjit Kaur(supra).
!!  $



    








 
8
E) **
' E+# "

7
#
 **
'

7
#