Preet Mohinder Singh v. State Of Punjab
"#$%$&'(')* +
,$$#-')%$,.')/- $#'#')$, 0$,(1( .#"#$1)2"3")%#-$,( $(4)%$)#(
* 56 . 7 6. ,$($)#* ,"(8"'9.')/-,",:%;&"#$:,#-$4$#'#')$, ,. '99:(('(#")# 1)2"3 )$,,$(4)%$)#(#
<-$#-$,#-$ $4,#$,(9&"9)$=(4"4$,8">3$"99=$%# ($$#-$21%/8$)#?
3$,$$,,$%##-$ $4,#$,,)# <-$#-$,#-$21%/8$)#(-19%3$,$4,#$%')#-$%'/$(#? 6.
6!
-$4$#'#')$,-"('9$%#-'(4$#'#')1)%$,.$&#') @
, ,A1"(-')/ B :%"#$%
:,$/'(#$,$%1)%$, .$&#') "#9'&$.#"#')6$-,":'(#,'&#.")/,1,))$C1,$ ! -$3,'$"&#(:=-'&-",$,$A1',$%#3$)#'&$%,#-$ 41,4($ %'(4("9 #-$ 4,$($)# 4$#'#') ",$ #-"# "( 4$, #-$ "99$/"#')( 8"%$ ') #-$ : .1,')%$, -")&849"')")# )= %$&$"($%")%,$4,$($)#$%3>-'(9$/"9-$',(!-"%#=3,#-$,(:
)"8$9>:",;')718",")% "2')%$,718", #'("99$/$%#-"##-$> -"%($#14"-"%$; '&$'99(')0'99"/$-"'7''(-,$:')=-'&- )$ 19%1 "8 6"83",%", ="( -";')/
D (-",$ ")% ,$$# -')%$,.')/-:,8$,.",4")&-#-$;'99"/$:="(-";')/ (-",$ # '( (#"#$% #-"#0'E"( 718",() ,";')718", ="( 8"')#"')')/#-$"&&1)#(#-$("'%(-$99$,.'C8)#-(3$,$#-$ %"#$&,'8$'$
:,$$#-')%$,.')/-'("99$/$%#-";$ ')#'8'%"#$%")%#-,$"#$)$%#E'99-'8-"%(&",$%"=">0'E"(718", )$4-$= #-$&849"')")#!,8 #-$ ("'%(-$99$, ")%#E #-$ &-",/$"99#-$"&&1)#(("'%(-$99$,')-'(-")%")%%'%)# "99=#-$&849"')")#")%%$&$"($% "2')%$,718",#$)#$,#-$ (-$99$, "2')%$, 718", ="( (#,$(($% ")%%$(4'#$ -'( ,$4$"#$% %$8")%(:#-$4,$($)#4$#'#')$,,$$#-')%$,.')/-%'%)#($##9$ #-$"&&1)#(#'(1,#-$,"99$/$%#-"#)B
:=-$) "2')%$, 718", ,$A1$(#$% ,$$# -')%$, .')/- 4$#'#')$,! # ($##9$ #-$ "&&1)#(: -$"31($%-'8 )
: "2')%$,718",&"8$ 3"&E"#$,%1(#')/-'((-4")%#9%#-$&849"')")##-"#-$3$')/ "//,'$;$%3>#-$&)%1&# ,$$#-')%$.')/--"%&)(18$% &$94-(#"39$#($="('88$%'"#$9>,$8;$%#-(4'#"9=-$,$-$ %'$% -";$-$",%#-$9$",)$%&1)($9,#-$4$#'#')$,:#-$ 9$",)$%.#"#$&1)($9")%-";$"9(&",$199>/)$#-,1/-#-$'9$ -$9$",)$%&1)($9,#-$4$#'#')$,&)#$)%(#-"##-$
&)#$)#(#-$ ')A1$(#')%)#8"E$")>$)&$"/"')(##-$ 4$#'#')$, # '( 1,#-$, 4')#$% 1# #-"# #-$ 9$/"9 -$',( #-$ &849"')")#=$,$8"%$4",#>")%#-$>-"%8"%$(#"#$8$)#(#-"# #-$>-"%&84,8'($% =$;$,:'#'()#&9"'8$%#-"##-$9$/"9 -$',( %$&$"($% "2')%$, 718", -"% 8"%$ (1&- (#"#$8$)#( 1,#-$,:'#'((#"#$%#-"#)B
:#-$4"%%>(#&E="(&-$&E$% 3>#-$#$&-)'&"9'&$,1)2"3.#"#$<",$-1(')/ ,4,"#'):
.")/,1,:')#-$4,$($)&$ "2')%$,718",%$&$"($%!")%(8$ (-,#"/$="(1)%")%#-"# "2')%$,718",-"%"9($C$&1#$%"
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
:
-$="("31($%3>#-$4$#'#')$, #='99&8$1#)9>,8#-$ $;'%$)&$:"(#=-"#E')%"31($(=$,$/';$)")%=-$#-$,#-$($
=$,$ (1'&'$)# # "3$# #-$ %$&$"($% "2')%$, 718", # &88'# (1'&'%$ )#-$($&',&18(#")&$(:=-$)#-$');$(#'/"#')'("9,$"%> &849$#$")%#-$&-"99")'(4,$($)#$%3$,$#-$9=$, 1,#:#-'(
1,#%$()#')%'#'##4,$21%/$#-$&"($")%A1"(-#-$ ') A1$(#') 6$##-$8"##$,3$%$&'%$%)8$,'#(3>#-$#,'"9 1,# $)&$:#-$4,$($)#4$#'#')'(%'(8'(($% 6. !
+
(2E(