← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1052/2023allowed

Manjit Singh Uppal v. State Of Punjab

2025-03-17Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti14 pages



   



 !" #$% &  %  % '%(( ) *+ + ,  



   

       

  !    

        *



"

#   

     -  .

 #$      

    

% ,  

&!

    

     / ,-

'()   

     * *

*)!$   

     .  ,

 )    

       ,

)    

    

+    ,-

$ ) ,-!!     

        ,.

     

     0) 1$2 0+#  0#$   . / ( 0

 

* ! /( 0  

0 * /( 0

# /( 0

 1 2345%5%+ 345%%5%+

!- / ( 0

 

6##) * /( 0

 1 23478%5%+/357+%5%+ 3579%5%+

!



/ ( 0

 

$

# 

/( 0/

 ! /( 0

$#/( 0

 1 234%:%5%+/34%9%5%+/ 34%4%5%+34:%%5%+

#

 '

/ ( 0





/( 0  



$

#/( 0



 * )/( 0

 357%%5%+

8

# '/( 0

 3578%5%+ 

$ ) /*  

 $

/ ( 0

 

;) /( 0

 $ /( 0

 0 ! <<<< 0#$ 3#+ 4    as referred above  )

 0 !!

 => are taken up together  0 

0



  %    

/     !/ 

 "

# /  # $    / &!

/ ' ( )   *)!$ (   ) ! )  %55+%5%+ 

    

 - )/ ! /

 /     )  /  )  / $  )  , -!!        (     )  ! )   5?58%5%+ 

    

- )/ ! /

 0

0

  

!     !

 =>&  5577545+%5%+ 0 +5?

>3 /9?51

@>3A20 +

0 3   0 " 1( 

 0 20/49401

@3B"0A2)   0  C

 / 0 03 !!

/!  +     0

 0 /  0 !   ! $!

  !



 0  (0! ))  

7 )  !

  )



''* !

>  

0 00   /  !    

# !

  %5:6 )   )6

0 '() /3*)$ /

!/ #/3 &!

/$ ) /

/6D* 

 /0

) / /-!!  

 !# !!  !)  0  

   

 0 !   

 "

 

               0 !   0 3 ! )    " !3 0 ! 0

 0 )   ( !

       #   0 0

! 10 !2

0  )          /   )  !  ( 

 

    

   

0  0    ) 6  )      )  0

      / 

/



 0! 03 )/!  !  

0 

!



 







)  

 )  ))

!0)   !6

  3

    

0

)  

  ) 

       !    0 3 ! )    !   )   0 ! 0 !!

0

  # 

 

E  )  => )  8 F0

1 2 ) 

   !3&

4545%

%5%+   

#

?

  ( 0 !! 

0      !0    => 0      

 0 !!

0 

 ))    "

   

0   > 0/ 0          !

   !



!

/%5%%"

 /

 0 !!

0    

/

 



  !

 *  ! 

 >  

0 00   /  ! 3  



''  G %> 0/0  )))  !  

  

  

) )) !0! !



0 0 

 0    G  +   

B0 (0!/

 )

00





)!

  ())  )

0

 (  )!

 

) 0 >

  

    ! 

0 !!)

0/ 0  

0 

!!

0))0 !/  

   

 0 (0!  ''  >C   !!     !   !0    !

0 (0!    0  

C   )  !  G 8&

0 0 +

3B"0 !

(   /   )!  3

 '0  (   %75:%5%+   

0

!/   ( 

:  !

) ! /

  !  ) 



*   D

0 * 0  )      %55?  #   

 

   * !

>  

000 /! 

!  %5:0 (0!  (

 

    0 00 0  0

 

   

  0

 ) 



0

75      )0   !   >  



  )! 3

'0 ( %75:%5%+00 ) /

  (  7 F 0



   )    3 57%%5%+)    06  03 0  *  ! 

 >  

0 00   /  !  0& (!

/%5%%    00 0   "



/   

 

 )

!0 !!



0 0 (0!3 ! () ) !

  /0   

 > 0/     

(/ 0    )))   ! 

! ! 

D 

 0    G  % F 0

  )    !) ! )) ! 

0 !!)

0 ! 

0 (0! 

#!

  %5:   ) )

 ) 

(  /



9

 0 !)) 

! 0  !#

              ))   3B" 0)  )  )"

   00 

   00

  

  !)  0 B0 !!

  )) 

  0   '' =    / C   0 !!     !  !0    C  0 !!1G 82>

0/0 )

 ))  0 

0 

  )(!  



0 

)

 

0 G G 4&

0 0 +5?

>3 0 +

3B"0 !

  ) !  3

'0 ( %75:%5%+ 

0

!/ 

 (  ? F0



 

"

# / #$   /&!

*)!$ 3&

4%:/4%9/4%4  4:%

 %5%+  0(   ! ) !      

( )) !

0 (0!



  

 

/

     &    =>  )  ) 1 2 )   0 )    

* !

>  

000 /! D !

 0 / C     0 0  '



 3 !!

0 /  

 0 !!/ !

 0 0    G 7> 0  /   0 0 

     &

0     0 ( E

 0)

0 

 / 0 0    ) 0

4   

 "

# /  # $    / &!

  *)!$  )!  3

'0 (

%75:%5%+00 ) /   ( (        !

0  !

 3

 : F 0



  $  )  , -!!   3578%5%+ )         !        *  ! 

 >  

0 00   /! & 0 0  

 !&

0 !

 C  !  0  +5?

 >3     (

3B"06  0

    00  0  0  (0!   #   "

   

0   E

0 

0

0 /0 0      )  0 ( ! )   5?58%5%+      ) !    3

 '0  (  %75:%5%+   (  9 F 0



   ' ( ) /  )   3&

478/57+579

%5%+ 0(  !) !   

(>  

   ' ( )      "

   0 0 ) )  3 

=>  0    

0 

0 (0!

    

!    

0( > 0

0 !

 0  +

 3B" 0 "

    )  0  

          !  0 !!



0

5 0 (0!    

0  ))   )       

    6

!

* 0  ) * ! 

 >  

0 00   /  !  0! ! !

0 

  

0 (0!/ 0 !

   !

  ( )  ) 0/ /0   

!!



 '   ) ! ) !/  0

  

     6

!

' !   * !

>  

000 /!  "

 0 00) )  F

 )



 0 !   

 ) !  3

 '0  (   %75:%5%+

0

!/   (

 (  "

     C 

     

 "

 0 0    )  0 

   0 

0 00 !

0

 0  4 

     0(   0  G0  3 &

 45%/4%9/4%4/4:%/578579

%5%+ 

   

0 345%5%+  C 

0  F0

 )  

  5+5%5%8/ 00 )  0  !   C   

 !!



 0/ /! 

!  & 9:4 7  %?5+%5%8     D

0

 3 !!



  0/ ! 



        G0  *)! $   

!$ / 00

 

  0   )  0#

 ( 

3 !!



 0/  / ! 



 (    &  8497 %?5?%5%8  ! )   )  0#

  (             3 !!



 01>( 2/! >=>(   )&  ?+%7%%54%5%8/  )    00 !

 (0

   0    

  )           0

( 

 )            0 

 (0   

   0  

0      0 !!

0  

         3 !!



  0 13 +2/ ! 0 !)

 )/ 

/00    0 !! F 0

  )  0 !  00    

! ))     5%5%5%7> 0 !  B00

   ( 000   

!/ 

/    !

C 

( 

 0  5 F 0

  ) 0 !  )  

 #)0   (

0  +5?

 >3  0  +

 3B" 0 F 0

  ) ! 

  0  /    

  5857%5%+ 

! 

)    #)

0 0  ) 0

/

  )

%

  (0! !





(0! 0 (

! 

!=

  

%55:0 %7) )()

0 0     0 3 ) 6 )

0  (0!   )  0 ! ! =  0 00 F

 1=F2/  &)/     )   0

 ( /

!  !

0 !$!

  

0   0

0 0  !   B00

   



 0  (0!     

  /    0 0 ) )  B00

    )  

 > 0  

 / 0 0   

 0

  

 =F   

 G  G  "

 /     0 )    >( )) )0  D 

 C    /  

 000   



!  0  0 !  )(  0 !  0G G

)

   > 0/0 (0!  0  

! 

) 

3B"0)    !

/

 

0   ))   !0) 3 ) )( 

0/ 0  0   

   )  0    !

 ( !

  > ( 0    ) !   ( )  

)   0 0

  =>  )  0 !

$!



   !



 0  (0! ! / 0  (0!

+  !



''  ) 

   *  ! 

>  

0 00   /  !  "

  ) 

  



!0 )/

)

3B" 0)  >( )) )0  )  0

(  0  / !

 

 / )   )

 0 (0!E)  ) 0 !    )   

=F%?58%5%+1G 2))  

  54%5%+> 0

 

(0!



! 

 (# ))!  

!

0 (0!) ! /     

 

!

  0 (0!/)) 0 C   !!  0  !  

(C    5?5%59 G 8 0 > !

0    

    5857%5%+/ 

    54%5%+/ 0

    )  

  / 



 5+5%5%8/00 ) 0 

C    /00   

!

 3

 0  )

 45+%5%7 F 0

  ) 0 ! 0   0 !    0(  0    0 3 !             00  >0 )    

(  ) !   

  !    (  0 00  

!/ 

/  C 

 ( 3 ) 

 0 

 / 

8

    )  !

0 30     0  3

0 0 !  >( 



 0 

 /  

 (

)      

  ! (     ( "



/! ) %55+%5%+

)  B00

  

/     !/ 

 "

# /  # $    / &!

/ ' ( )   *)! $   ! )   5?58%5%+ 

 )  B00

   )  /  )  / $  )  , -!!       /  00 )      

( /00 ) /!

 ) (

   (   %75:%5%+   0 !/

0   !

  0     0 8+91%2

33 % )! 0

0 1 2/  /0 /  

00 )    +  

 

    0   

 0 0 0 ! 

( :5+%5%7 0#$    # %

  #)B

. ; B&    . ; B&