← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1809/2003allowed

Harvinder Singh v. Pb.St.

2019-07-03Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal16 pages

 

     

 !! "

#  ) !%!

**++

,%-

.-/0

*



 !! "

#  .

!% ,%-

.-/0 

* 



 !! "

#  .

!% ,%- ) !%!



*     

 .% "

% 2 *%! & 

**++

3  % 4 (-( & 

* !% 3



% -%!% .+ 4! !

!+ 1 .-/0 % .5/ +! & 

%*



3 

 

 

/-'8

%!!'

%8 88 /-'8

* +% !

!+ ! 9-'

(  :

4% 5 ;-(!  < 

(++  ! **++

%!8!+ **+$%&!% ) !%!

&!

-%

<

3! .+    

-%' !8*%!8

*%!

-% 7%

*7

= -+

*78

!

-%' %!'%- !8*%!8

*%!

(% 8 ( >(% ! %%

 ?-!

 4(

> %&!! (&

!+ '!

/-'8

 ?-!

!'

) -+-  

( 8

 >%

!'( 

-*

8*+!

8&  **+! 

!% 1%+

.+!

!%

! !+

.+!

*%

!'

%!

,!++'

(- 4(!+ 2(

%!

;-(! !'( **++

5 

8*+!

!'(

%8 (-

*% @

'

!'

;.1 ' 7+!% !++ 0-

!'(

% !

-%

(%

!++

!+!'

8*+!

% -

(!8 (&

!+

8

5>+'

8*+!

0

8+7 +'>!

-8 +!?-%

2(

 -

+

5 *+ >

(8 &%+ %?- 8

0

*%&! %8 !=>(%0-

(&

0% 7

%-!

! 

(7 (&

(%  !% ?- 

1-% (% !'( &% %!

!-

(!'(%

! % 

0!

%! 8*+! :3 %'! % !& !'  

8*+

!& !' !

!+ %*%

-% #

%. -08!

% '! % >(

88!

! !'

+% !

!+ ! 9-'

(  :

4% 5

%!+ 4(

- *%!8

 !

-%

< 3. '!

 -  - >% (%'

( 

>(! (

(7 *+

'-!+ +!8

%!+ .% - %%

*%& @8! .A

%!

 >( %'! %

%8+ :3 B@.= ( &% !& !'

3 (!% !'( .A

>(

- %!

% (

8!!'

07 !'( $

% %

8

    C 

%% !'( .A

3 9!

!'(  3& !' !'



! % *

-%!'

!& !' !

-%/!

!'( 5( >% >% % %

% -

!

7!+ *!

!& %-+

 4( 8

!8*% 

 ! !'( 8*+!

@8! .A -%/!

0%

@8! .AC

!'(**++

5

%8 (-

'

!'

* -*

;.1 7+!% 0

-8 +!?-%

2(

8 7

(7  -

+  ( (%

-% !

( $ @*% **%(!

8!'(

(& 8-%% 0

 - 4( %!

%%0% -%/!

!'( 

( >( >% @8! -%

%.

(7 ! (&!'

88!

+!8

(7 % !     8+7

A (!% 

%/ @8! 4(!

(% +% -+

*% !

+'

(!% 0+ !  '

(%-'(

/-'8

*

+% !

!+ ! 9-'

% %

&%

%'-8

+% -+

*% ! !

% %?-!%

!  *%*% *%* !&  *%

!

5 >7

%8 %!

*%

-%/!

*% @

!'(**++

'

* -*

;.1 7+!% < 

!'( 8

<  ! +

(

5 +!?-% < 

(7 ?-%%+  ( (%

+!8

C< 

C '

.+!

+'!'

:3 0-

*+!

!

5 7 ! :!%

 -8

 

 #   %!'

%!



**%

 %'! %

0!

" . #  >( 8*+!

+'>!

&%!- *% '

*+!

+'!'

%*%

%*%

) $**7 >

2( < 

%8 (8 )

!%!**++

(%! 4(7 +

(8

.

% 0-

 !

-%

) !%!

+ (!8

'

>

%8

 

;+(%!

: 5 2( ;+(%!

!+>7 %!'

8!

-8 +!?-% ! 0 8 %-5%

% !

 8*7 (!8



5> >(% ' 

 %!0!'

+ ( >(! ( >%!'

&%++ **% 



8

5>

'

:!D'%( ++  - >(  ?-!

 !+>

! %!+>

+*(

2( 0

(8 -8 +!?-%

8!+7 8!

7

(

>  - $

> (& -'( +& ) !%!

-+ 4(%

% @

**+!  -08!

!% 1%+

.+!     %-+ +'!'

:!%

%8 *%

< B@.=

**+!  !

) $**7

8!!'

07 '

 7% ++

%8 %!

-%

8!

( -8 +!?-%

2(



% 0+ %* +7 5 0

++

>(%0-

 0-

(7 (& *-

!'

4(7 (&

*%

%  %

(%  !% ?- 

%!

!- (!'(%

! !+ @

!8*% 

 -8

B@.: *7

**+!  -08!

$E0+ (!

!! % .-/0 *7

&%!-

! !+

**+!  ! *%

%8

5 >7 !'(

8!

( -8 +!?-%

2(



% 0+ 4

!8!+%

**+!  B@.1 %

*- 3* 1%+

.+!

 #    8%

8 % % >(! ( B@      % % -%!'

?-!%7 -*%! 

.+!

$ 2(

!%

!8 8 -* %7

5 >7

!++!'= * -*

;.1 ' 7+!% *%

%8

@

7 8

(-

+ (!8

(7 ++

(% -8 +!?-%

'

?-%%+  ( (% :3 %'! %    > +

- ! -

>(

# **% .A 

8!!'

07 8*+!

:3

%!

%

) !%!

8

(- $

5 >7   

*% @

'

!++

' 7+!%

%8

2( 0-

8!!'

07 &% -% >( ?-!% !

 %!+7 %*+7 0-

<  8

(!8

+ (!8

( -8 +!?-% < 

(7 ?-%%+  ( (%  C< 

(7 >

.+!

+'!'

:3 0-

*+!

!

5 7 ! %@8! !

8

(-

 . <   !+>

! %!+> &!++'

! 

=C 2

%8

&!++'

!'(

(7 ! +-!'

!'( >

4&%  *+

%!5!'

+!?-% >(% ++

(% -8 +!?-% :%

!%

!8 %@8! &!>

!8*-

8 !&

 -

 ?-%%+

> 8 ( *%!%

 -%% 0-

 '

% $

+ (!8

?-%%+

> 8 ( *%!%

 -%%  %

!8*%&8 8 (!8 %

&%!- 8*+! 8 (!8 ! 

*%&!- *%

/-'8

-

8 +

!8*%&8  +&

*%

@ % -%"                    



     

  

  

          

 

     

          

  !"

 #         $%&

    '

         

  

    

( )*&+,+-.-#       $%&

     '

    

         $%&  !

  

  

  

#    

 $  % 

           '

       

       $%   

            /0 1  /0 2   

$    

  !!

  ! 

                 ""!            

  3 

#     /0 %4

    '

 

     ""!      

              

    

   

    "

  

  

     /0 %4 !



   

"

 

  



$     

    

/0 %4      

$!    

!    

   #       /0 %4

    '

!'(

% >

*

) $**7 %!!'

(-

(+*!'

(!8 -+ !& ! $ !

-''

>%5!'

%!&% 8 %+ - + 4( '& -'' %

.%5( !'( B@ %* (

,!++'

  !'( -

++7 !8*+!  0 -

8+7  ((*+

!+ !&!+ -!

'!

.%5( B@ %* ( (% (+*!'

.%5( !'( B@ %* ( ;% -+

**++ >(!+ %>!'

&%!-

% -08!

!+

*%& 07 %0+ -0 $

-08!

-%

< 3.

8 -

% ++' !

!%

8*+!

5!**

5!++ 8-%% $  -08!

88!

 %%% &!

!'

**++ 

( +% -+

8*+!

>( %*% * !%

%&!! * ! -08!

% 

!++ 



%

8-

-8

!  ( 

(-+ %8!

0 5

%!+

%8!'

(%'

-%

3! .+  $ -**%

/-'8

%!+

%*

&!

!'( $

-08!

!-

! !

 >% >%'+7  ?-!

!'(  %+7!

&! 

**%

!+

*%& 07 %0+ -0

 -

++>!'

%" 

%8

++

(%

(8 -8 +!?-%

2(

?-%%+  ( (% $>&% !++ >(



 

 #  %'! %

!'(

8!+7 8!

% (&!'

' %+ !

+& >

(8

%!

%7 %'%

(&!'

5 >7

*% @

!++!'

;.1 7+!% 8!!' %

5!'

+!?-% ! 0 8 %-5%

% !

8 0 5 @

:3 >(%!

!%

!8

% %

( (&

*%

% !'

 %

(7 %

(% !'

**+!  +

%7

(&!'

5 +'

*% @

!++!'

7+!% '! 8!!'

**+!  !

-8

(&!'

8

! + 0-

-8*

+!?-% ++

(%

(8

?-%%+ 8'

(8 *! --+7 0 @

 -8

B@.:

+7 '!'

@

++ 

%8 %!

 &% 8 0 5 8!

++

(%

(8

5 +!?-%

2( 

% 0+ 4

8

**+!  B@.1    

!%

!8 ! +

5

%8 %!

2(

!++!'

' 7+!%

5!++  5*

 8>(% 4(-

**%

*'

!8 8*+!

8 !'!

! 

!8*%&8 

 >( **%

 8!

) $**7 %!!'

(-

(+*!'

(!8 -+ !& !

%%

( >(%

?-

(&!'

5 +'

%8

(-

>(%

?-

5!**!' !++

(%

**%

%8

 

!

!%

>(%! 7

+& >

8!+7



**%( 7 8! (!

*%

!'( 0

 -



8 &!

!'( 8!!'

07 -8 +!?-% < 

4&%

!+>7 %!' 2( +'>!

! *% &!!

4&%

&%!

(>&%

%8

%! *+ @8!

*%&

(%

(8 ! !'(

-8 +!?-%

?-%%+ 4( &! +

%'%

-8*

+!?-%

(%

(8 ?-%%+ 0 -* ++' %8 -**+!

*%&



  '

@

7!'

>

:!D'%( ! &!++'

>(% %! ++

0

(8

5 +!?-% $>&%

*%& +!'

7 &!  >(!+ **%!'

 

*%

 %%

%!0-

8 !&

 -

%!

%-

%7

?-%%+ >

> 8 ( *%!%

 -%%   ?-%%+ >

> 8 ( *%!%

 -%%  4(

(& ! +

!%

!8

!

*%

**+!  !

!+ %

-*%! 

.+!

  

% $

%'%

8 !& %%

0 -* %%

(

&%7 8- ( 5>+'

<  0-

&% (

! %*%

8*+!  4(% %

8*

+%+7 

(-'( > +

- + %'-8

+% -+

8*+! ;% -+ 

!

(%

%8 <  !  7% (& +*

% (-+ *%-8

 ( (-+

%!

8-%%

%'%

%

> %+&

*%&!! ! ! # 

3! B&!  # >(! ( % @ % -%" 

   

 



 

         6       

   ! 7  

    !    7   "



     " 

 

 

   

  



  

 

     

  

   ! 7 "

          



!  !!        !7   "



  !  " 

   % -+ %!'

! # 

3! B&! 

**%

>(

?- >( *% +!& 

(>

+!& (!

7%

0-%

*%&!'



*% >(

!%8 >%

*% >( ++'!'

8  %*

*% >( (%

 +!&

7%

*% >( %   %'% 

3! B&!  -0

*%

(%

*%!

# 7%

( >( >-+  -%++7 (%

(!8

+!&

0-%

*%&!'

+!& (!

*% >(

!%8

+!& $>&% ! # 

3! B&!  +7 + 0-%

*%

*%-8* ! !++

(% 8 

%!

-%

3! .+  ! 8-%% +7

%'

! # 

3! B&!  # 4( %'-8

+% -+

8*+!

*

>(++7 8!  !&

**%

*%

0 -* !% -8  !+ &! -'(

0+!(

5!**!'

+7

0!

+



!% &!>

!% -8  !+ &! +



+

+7 (7* (!

5!**!'

!'( 4( (!

&!



8*+

+& 8%

( +  ;!5 &! 8!!'

:!& '+ *%! !*+ >% -++ -

$E0+ -*%8

      

!"

#$ %&%  '

( ( )

(+

8  (+

'-!+



0!

!% -8  !+ &! 

8-

**+7

!& '+ %-+

%>  +-! 4(

!& '+ %-+ (& +! > *% C

%! /-'8 .% C

8 %*%-  -%" *+  ! !   !    !!

   !!!      

  !!! 8 #9'

:



 

  

  

!  !  

 !!!!       3    

 

 

;   !;  ; ;

!  :

  !

  !! !



  ; "

;    ! "

5  ! 3       )           

     !!

    8<33" 9=7"

>-?833#3 '

"

9-.?@ 3  !7"

  "

"!  

     !  !    

     !

 ; ; ;  ;    !

                



!

#&'

:

 !  !    !

   "   ! 

7 7  !  0"! !   " 

C 0 "  

 !7 #4'

:



 

 ! 

!    

7 #.'

:

 !0 ! "! " 0 "  "

7  #A'

:

 

 

  "!    !      ! 

        

!

     



 

   

 !!   "

!       

 4(- @8!!'

- (

(

!& '+ %-+

**%

+% !

!+ ! 9-'

!+

**+7

%!

!& *%! !*+ %-+ !'

>%'

 +-! :%

% 0&

**%

!+

0+!(

'-!+

07 %0+ -0  %!'

/-'8

*

+% !

!+ ! 9-'

**%

8 %!+ *

>% &%+5 4(

88!

%%% % %!'

!!'

!8*%&8

&%!-

&%!- ' % 8!%  -% ;% !

!+ ! 9-'

&%+5

8 !&

88!

!'

%!8

!%

!8 -'(

%-  *%&

>(!+ **%!'

'

!+

*%&

8 07 7 %0+ -0 ;% !

!+ ! 9-'

&%+5

8!

-

%!

(-

!'( &!>

(%

/-'8

* +% !

!+

< ! 9-'

(  :

4% 5 ;-(!  < 

%%

 

- ! 

%

! !+ 0 -08!

**++

! (%' %!8!+ **+ ++> ! 

-

!+

*%& 07 %0+ -0

%

8 %  ?-!

+

-*(+ (  

(++  !8! 

>(! ( *%7% 8

( 8

 %% %- -- &!>

!!' %%!&

 ?-!

!'

!'( $ 

 !

(

*-!(8  %!'+7 

!8!

!"





 

  #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0