← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/579/2024dismissed

Raman Bhatia v. Mamta Rani And Another

2024-04-25Mr. Justice Harpreet Singh Brar9 pages



         

 !

"#$%&'$()*)%+ ,

,

"-"+ ."#)"

,,,$#)#)%+$/ 0*, !"-#""+)"+'"+%#.$/ ,,,$*1%+'$+#*  ! 2 3!,4 4    

    

 

  4  5, 3

            !" !# $!$$  & & '  (&% ) ) ) *+  , & &  -

$"

) )& 

#./ 0  1)  ) 23 , &&,  * 4!!!56   



  

  , ,   $

  ,  



, &7 

# !

$!

 9  & :  ,&  & & &% 9

 ,  9,

&   , &  &  &  -

$"

)  )   * $"!!!56  

 & &%  &  

& (&% )    !" !# $!$$   &&, * 4!!!56      



  

         ) &   / ; &   

       <6 =     ,    && >        =  (>* &  

 6,  - 8#46 ?

8!@ >) *&      &  +  %  9  )    

     

 ! "# 9  & &      ,  &       & & "

+                %   &      + & &            ,   

)  =     ,&  & & &  



  -

$"

)  )     ,   %  & + , &  

 -

$"

)  ) ,     & +   , &  , & && , & , &

"0/3  & /# ) > @ 6'  A 92& - ) 



$

  % $

""  !!

&'    ' ( A   &&,



 



 !

"

 #

 

"



%&

# #'

 " )

#

(

(

"

( 

'  

* +

.

( ,6'  A 92& - )  $   ((    )

  "" # !! #&"    ' (7 B   &&,

 ,

'

*

%

#



 

  

%





 %&

'#

  &"

*

 



# " #'

 %(

'



*

 "



*

"%

"

 # %" #

 

 "



#

 

#

(

( 

* 



"

 *





#

 

   #





"





"





#

#



 

(

*



 "

 



 "  #+

 + & &         





&        &    5   &5&     &      &  #

  & %   , &%    &  &    &   % & & , <

& &  &&%     &       )   =  ,  +    & =

=   +& &     &   , <    &%  <     ,   & %

=%  &&,   %    & & & & 

!

C& & ,  

-  , '   92& - )  *+  ,+ ( +    !!

# & ,    =   &&,  .--- !

  ) ( . /   ) 0





%&

#

'

'





 (

"

 "

"

" #'

 

"

"



'



"



"

  & / " -'

0""  

*  1

* *" * ' *

"





"

 2

%



*





2 *



"



( 0" 2 *

  ( 

 "

*

" 

%





 #'

 

*

"

   *

 *

(





'

*



* * /'

"

'

"%



'

*

*

*

0"





(

" "

"

'

(



' /'



" %

(2

%

 '  * /'

* 

12 $

+. 3  0 1 (. + (  ( + ""& & !! & *)    3   3  3  

  !!  1 ) 3 4 # 5// 4 6 

1  "



 





  * *"



 *

'

0""  

5



  

 



"

*

"% * /

   

 " 

 "

 )  *

  

*

"



" "



"

" /







"



(

"

(

 "

 3 

 "

 " "2

"

" "

  

%  # " "'

 17 8





 

(

"%  "

%

-

  *  

 ( %

*

%'

 "

* %  ( *"

0"

/ 





#





0""  



"

" #

"

'



 #'

"%  *  

 '



 '

 #'

"%



  ( "

   %#

    "(   *



%

% 

"

 0"  *  3   .+  "

 !!

 

" &" %

"

* *



# 



  

   "

 

  "

 

 #'

 *

"

   !+

2+  3  4 5  !!

 1

 

" * "

%

 #



*

-

  

*

*

" 



- #' *

#

"% %

   " 

 '

 #

*

"

(

" 

0"" 

&"'



*

%



*

%

  

 

# " '"

*





'

0""  

"% 

 

 

#

*'

* (

/ 



:



 "

  

%

*

  



  #'

 (

&" 

 # #"

;

( (

#

"

( #

; *

'

( 

"

#

 

<=

#

 



'

''

 # * 



"

 0" 

%

 *

 #'

*

''

 # * *

"

   #

<  9' "

4+  6(. 3    6.( # & 78   *

*'



'

 

:



"

 



  %

*

 





(

 7

"%



 

   

" " 

 #

  (

 

&(

   >  

 ; %   ( 6 !

#



'  

"

    



  1 !(

(

 

  ?

'"

 * /

" " *

'

 

 * 

"

"

   

 



(

 ' 

" * "

 

!

&"%

'

" * " 7

+ #





"



%#

  *" 

#

'

0""  

(% + --- --- ---

- 9  0  ) # *

''

 " 

 ! @  =  &"'  *







*'





-

"

*

"



7

" ):

 -  ) 3 ::. 

(0  $ #

"

#



'

&"

  #

 '

'

 

'  

 "



 

'  

" (



* %(

A( "

<  "

3' 

"

 "'"

" ( ,



:

 *

"

#

  



%(

( "



" 

"

*"



6

 &" 

" *

#"

' *

'

*

( "

"

*

"% 0"

':

  



  

#"

'





"% 0"

'2  



#"

'

0"

(  

#   *"

0"





'

 ) -  0  $

5# < "

5  B%  -  C "

) )) )))  &"'   (

 % 

 %( %

   

' "'

'

'



A( "

 <  "

 3'  "

 



( "'"

" ( 0 !

  ) ( . + /   ) 0  A

'

0""  

(%



 

"

 /



"





"

 ! @ )))

&"'  7 $





* #

-"#



"

(

-

 





( 

 * (



#





"



 )  %+0+ 0   2 % ((  ,

/



 



 *

*



'

   

  ! @ )= %#

 ;) 0<;=0  )  (  ) 0 > A



 -

"

 

 



 

(



"

 15

9"

3

'

 ?>2

 >

<= 2

 1

! (

 %

 

(



 

#

"



#

!



 " (

   1 >

*

DD).

 

&     &&%  & &%       & ) &,  <6

     <   +

& A

  A ( &     & (&% )     ) &,  &%  & &     =  & + &   ,   , && &     &  &   ; &      &  % %     , ,   )  &%     ,&&  &   &% 8#@ %  &      %    7 4  8 $" !8 $!$8   #"

C  5  D5  C & 

D5