High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3526/1999dismissed

Gurbachan Singh v. Kabil Singh

2023-02-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!!"

# $$ % ! "& $'$(&" $

$&( "$

% ! "& $'$

& $ # $$ (&" $

$&( "$ )" &*) &+ ,

# ## $ "+ ) # -. (/&" 0 " 1$-.(/&"

*&" !!"

( *& $&( "2&

3 $ " .(/&"

*&" "

( *& $&( "2&

## $# 56" $&( .7$!!( $&$ &*

* ! ( 6 !!"8 (

* ! (& !*&* "

& 8% ! ( ("& $'$

5 *!6$"" (.*"$&*" $ ""! **

$&&* . $ ( "&*/ !! 5

.1 $ !9" (.

) $" ":

$ &09" ( $$ " ) $" "(& "$ $"( * ("$% ! $&&* . $ ( "&*/ !!

5$ . -! ( ;3 (& .&" $ ( "$&* !! 5

$&*&-( * ("$

7 " $ ( $ ". " ! ** ( $& " ( *& - " 3"

& $" ( * ("2& *&- " * &$$ $$ & &/ !"! !( %$ 2& < == = < .

< . = >"&"!!(- $ <?!$,-!.$ "" ("

!! 5

.1 $ !9" ( *" * ("&$" $ "!(

$ " $ &*" ! **.&*&-( * ("$2& ( &0 $&*" $ "!(0 " 6(! $ (&""&" ! ** *" / $"

0 "&0

* % * >> " *&-&*" ""

@ !!& =(" A" ! **$ &&*" $ "!( "" "6 / $ ($&" / " ($&*A" 0 &"$ &*( * ("$2& ( &"?&0A( * ("2& (& ( 3( - "(( (" ( >

! "2& ,&*

"! ( B% ! # $$;3 " B6- $&* - $&"

&A" 3( - "(( (" ( >

0$$$ ( "" !$ "( -""

& 2& > 0$ $"

& ( & ,

& " $ $ &* $ ( 3( - "((

&( "& " ! **. " 3( - " ( ( $& & (6( * ("2& (-""

&$"

& (&" $ $" &* !!

!. !! ( /& (A ( * (" 2& " " ( "& " * &$$ $$ & &* " ! ** ( "& ( $&$$ $$ - *&- " $ "!(

!!6(*& !6&" $ $&*""3( - "(( .&"6

6 ("&" C $"$&*" ! **"&( $ $"*&-(&$& 9 !

/ (." ! **(& "" $ " C $"

.&!6( * ("2& - *&0("&&** &" $"

: * ! (0 "" $"" - " ?

- 6 &3 "

&$ "" " $ " 0$ $" !0 ( *"$. $ $ 0$ &"

- " ! " $ "*&-A " " ! **(6!&$$"(

"&* ! " $ "&6$ &*"

& $ "& -"&(&$&A" ! ** 0$ $"& (6 $&0"(&("A" ! **($ $$ (" -" !*"$*&-" &"A$-"" &**"( * ("2& $&0

&&*" $ "!(&" $ $&* D ( " $ " - &*" ! ** " / &( *"!!60& /

- !" (6! ** &!!$ &0 " / &** !$ - "$." $0 ( * ("&" ( (""&*&-( * ("$2& ( 0 &0 $ &$$ $$ & &* " $ " !(. 0 " 6 ( D ( 0 " ( * (" 2& ( "" D 0$ ** - ( 3( - "(( (" ( >

$$ ( ! "2& ,&*

"! (% ! # $$;3 " A" &*&-( * ("$ 2& ((" ""$ "(/&!" !6$** ( 3( - " ( ( (" ( >

A " 0$ & $$ "6 &*

-! ( " $ "! ** ""$ "A" 3( - "(( $$ ( ""$ "0$!

!(/!

($&0$" -""

&$"

& (&

"$$ $A" ! **( / !"

/" (" $ "!(A" *& " &C $"

&&* $ ( $&$$ $$ (" *&- !!

!!6(*& !6

( * ("6 (*&( $- $$!&*" $

) * ("$ 2& ( ( * ! ( "& " ( $ " $ / 606&*-( .$$" 60 & ( ( $"

1 ! **(* ! ( !

&"&" 0 "" $"" - "&* ( * ("2& &"&/ "

" !!

&$ " 0 "" $"" - "

0 $ " "

" / - "$ " !

" ! ( $ &* " "

$. *&!!&0 $$ $ 0 *- (+

@ " " ! ** $ &&*$ "!(( $ ( " (&" &*!"$" ""@ !!& =(" $!!

@ " " 3( - "(( (" ( >

$$ ( !

,&*

"! (% ! # $$;3 "

!!!(/& ($!!

@ " " ! ** $ "

"! ("&" !

*&* - " 3"

& $" ( * ("$*&- " * "&&$$ $$ &&*! ** &/ $ "!(( $ ( " (&" &*! "E

< @ " " $ " $&"- " ! " $ "*&-E )

@ " " ! **$&$ &*"

&"&* ! " $ "$ "E

)

@ " " ! ** $ $"& (*&-* !

" $ "$ "6 &0"(&("E )

@ " " ! **$&!&$$"( "&* ! " $ "$ "E

)

> @ " " ! **$$ $$ (-" !*"$*&-" &"E

)

@ " " ( * ("2& $ "

"! ("&$ !&$"$=$&* " E )

, !

1& $"!

$ $$ ." ! ** &" D- ( $ !

""& 6-"

:3%$@ ( 0 $@( (( &"&"" " ( ( / ( (&- "$FD "&FD

" &" (." ( * ("2& $ D- ( $ !""& 6 0 $)@ ( ) $3."0 $ )@ $ ( $" ( " (&- "$

7 ""!" ! **&( ((&- "FD

*" ! (&$ !*&" "

$." " !&"

&* ((!

! G(

) / . 9" ( ( $- $$ ( " $ " &* " ! **0 "&$"$ 7(( &.$ !&$"&*$ ,,=0$0( ("& ( * ("2& .6! 6" ! ** 1 $0$$&(& / ( 3( - "

(( (" (

9 !

/ ( 6 " $ ( 3( - " ( ( . " ! **(* ! ( ! " &"&*) $" "G( .:

$.0 0$$$

("&(( &!) $" "G( .:

$.0&/ ( 3( - "( ( (" ( >

( $- $$ (" !

) $$"

$* (0 "" 3( - "$(( $$$ (6" &"$ !&0." ! **$?&? ("" (&&&*" $&"606&* * !

!$ &( !6 """ $- " (."

- (3( - "$(( $$$ (6" &"$ !&0 $ "$ ( (" $ "* ! (6 - ( (

2&"

&* " ! 0$ $$ ( "& " $&( "$ (

$&( "2& $" "& &$ !

@ $$ / &* $&( "$2& (.0& &*&-( * ("$0$( $ $ ( "

7/ (! (&$ !*&" "

$ $ ( $ &

"& " &($(7* (""" $& ! - "&*- " " !$ &( !

1 " !&"&( ("&& !6$ $&*" / ( & "& &(6" &" $"

$. !

"&*" ! ( $( $ ""! (!

!&$ &$ ( * """ ! **$* ! ( "&&/ "" $ &&*" $ "!($" ""@ !!

1 - $&$*& "" $&!$ & $*&!!&0$+

1& " ! ** " $ " * ! ( 6 - ( !!

( ""

&*&-( * ("$2& ((&"" " ! "2& ,&*

* ! (6( * ("2& $"" -( ( * ("2& (& (" ( 6- $ $ ""

&( *("" " ! **(* ! ("& & &(& "( &/ / ( "" ( 1 &!6 / ( (( (0$

" *&-&*$"" - "&*@ :3%0 * (""& 6 &*! **"""0$ "" (6)@ 0 . !

""& 6 &* ( * (" 2&

1 *& . " ! ** * ! ( "& $"!

$""" 3( - "(( (" ( >

$$ ( ! "2& ,&*

"! (B% ! # $$;3 " B0$ !!

!.!!(/& ( -""

&( $"

& (& " $ $&*""3( - "(( */&&*( * ("2& " / &((/!

"! "&" $ "!( &""$* (

$*/&

$ " $ &* " ! **. ( !"

&$$ $$ & &* " $ " !($" " "@ !!& =( " $ *! " ( " / &("" D "*&" "6 " / &(." ! **(&"! (6 / ( $"&0 0$ (" ( " $ "!($" "A"&0&- ( 6

" "

1 ?$

(0 $*/&( ( "&"*&!!&0 $ (& ( 1 &! / ( (( ( 6" ! **"" $ &&*" $ "!(0$ &"*&("& & "(&/ *&" $&""@ :3%.""& 6&*! **((- "" ( &$$ D- "

&"" $(( & "&;(" *" $ 0$ &&*" $ "!( @ :3%(@ 0 ((- "" (""" $ "!(0$&"! "&" " $ @ :3%((- "" ("" "0$&" ( 6! ** $ @ 0 $"" ("" ( (&"?&00 " ! **(:3% ( ( "&&"

@ :3%(@ 0 ((- "" (""" 6( (&"66 ""&6&

1 " !&"*" "&&?&" &*" *"""

( -$ !* $&"!"

" $ "!(

/F/ "& ?$

(0 *&-? * >>"&

" ! ** 0$ &( ("& &&* " $ "!($" ""@ !!& =(" *&-? * >>"

> " $ ?$

(0 0 ( */&&*" ! ** *&- ? * >> / ( &" 2& (" ( ,

>>"""0$&"$ & ( $ (( ! $ 1 *& . " $ ?$

(0 */& &* " ! ** &!(&" "? "&/ -( $ ! $(" "&$ !!

!.!!(/& (

$ $!"&*!!"&$ *"$$ " ! **0$&"&/ ( "& &&*" $ "!($" ""@ !!& =(" . 0$ &" "

"! ("& !

*&* - " 3"

&(" $ "* ! (6 -&"

&!6( $- $$ (0 "&$"$"0 "$ !&$"$

1 $ ( 3( - " ( ( 0 ** - ( 6 ! ( (( &! ) $" "G( . :

$ 1 3( - " $$ ( 6(( &!

) $" "G( .:

$ !$& (& $ &" "& $** *&-6

"6& * - "6

- " 3"

&( !"0 "6 "

&>&*" * !

*".

$( $ "

&6 C "! !

*.0 $"& " ( 6" &"?

/ 0" *"$( -$" $&*" $

!( " &("&*" "

$(& $&! -" $ !

*$ -"" &*

9&!6 $ $*& "&* - " 3"

&. $&& " &"-$"(&$&0 "! ($( $!&$ !!

" -" !*"$( * &$ " $"&& !6-" !*"*&- " &"." $ !

* $&""& " ( !$

&* "

&< &* " * !

*"&/ ( $"" 3"

&&" " (0 " &("&*" ! **& $ "$$ $$"&( $ "

"! -

"&" $$ $" &*" &"

9" -& ." ! ** " $$ $$"

"06* ! ( $ "*& "&* - " 3"

&0 "&"!!

" 3( - "

(( $ ("&/ $** (6&*&-( * ("$2& (

*/&&*( * ("2& (-""

&$"

& (& "$$ $(" $ ?

( *& - " 3"

&$&$ C "

! !

$ ($ " 3( - "$

! "

#$ % " & ' % ( #

) ( # " *

( ,- ."(/(

% ,.

0 * ("&6! (&$ !*&" !!" $&"&* $&" "

&."&$ &"!

! "&" $ "$ ( "&( ** "

*"$( -$" $(" &" D" 0 $&$ /"

&$( -(

@ "" & "* ( $ &( (6" &"$ !&0 "0 7(&&"$ 6 $&"&( $ (0 "&$$""

C $"

&&*!0 $ $."

$&("& ( $- $$ (

7" $&( (&( !6

" - ! !$"($( $- $$ (." $""$ C&&( (" (

$"($/" (

7/ 0&*" ( " ! (( $$$ &&/ . -6&$ ( ( 0&*" "

& $ C ("& "? 0 " ("&" $&" -"

, & 1 $- $"($( $&$ (&*&( !6

" - !$ &( !$"($( $- $$ (( &" -" "

&$"($( $&$ (&*." - $ !! &$!

& $. * 6. ( " $- $"(( $&$ (&*&( !6

, ##

5 %&'(&'))'*+,-'./+0'*12-3 '+/, %&'(&'))'0,)(*45'

'+/,