High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1028/2002dismissed

Kartar Singh v. Sulakhan Singh

2018-03-12Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma4 pages

!!"#$#%& '"() *' '#%+( ,,!--% .!'$/$ /-0(%#%+( !$,%1!%

!"#$%& '( $(')#

'!$!% &

'233)14" !) ' (!,,!--% %!' (!'!$,%1!% 55555 (')#*% ,,!--% 61!!%1% #$#% !+/-'!"%1,,!-+#%$ (!

3/1+7!% %11!"'!!1 !1)8(!'!9: (!,,!-,'!!''!19: (! '!$,%1!% 6,-#% # +#%$ (! 3/1+7!% %1 1!"'!! 1 !1 ;<<= 1#$7#$$#%+ (!$/# $!!0#%+'!"4!':)=;>6)($9!!%$! 6$#1!%1 (! $/# '!7!% #%!1(19!!%1!"'!!1

!$,%1!% 6,-#% # #%$ # / !1 (! $/# "-#7#%+ (! '!7!% #%!17/% % (!9$#$ (!,'% !? %1'!"!#, ? % (!,'!7#$! ( (!1!!%1% 9''8!1$/7 @);>6%1(1 +'!!1 ,:#% !'!$ AB,!'7% ()%=<<(!1!!%1% '!,#1 (!7/% )>6%1 (!'!7#%#%+7/% 8$,'7#$!1 9!,#1 % << C# ( (! "%$!% (! ,' #!$) % !%1'$!7!% 8$ !!" !1% (!'!4!'$! (!,'% !)8(#"(8$$#+%!1> (/797'0!19: (! ,' #!$!$,# !%/7!'/$'!D/!$ $) (!1!!%1% 1#1% ,: (!

7/% ) %!"!$$# #%+ (! '!$,%1!% 6,-#% # #-! (! $/# "-#7#%+ )=;>6)#!)@;>6$,'#%"#,-7/% %1E);>6$#% !'!$ (!,,!--% 61!!%1% 1#1% ,,!'1!$,# !$!'4#"! ('/+( 7/%1#%18$,'"!!1!1 (! '#-/' )4#1!3/1+7!% %11!"'!!1 !1;<<=) 1#$7#$$!1 (!$/# % (!+'/%1 ( (!,-#% #1#1% -!1%:!4#1!%"! ,'4!!%1'$!7!% 1 !1F<<%1<<%1) (!'!'!)(!-1 ( (!$/# #-!1%<<;#%'!$,!" ,'% !=<<)8$ #7!9''!1(!,,!-8$,'!!''!19!'! (!28!',,!-- !/' ) 8(#"(8$-$1#$7#$$!14#1!3/1+7!% %11!"'!!1 !1<<%1

!+/-'!"%1,,!-8$,'!!''!19!'! (#$/' %14#1!3/1+7!% 1 !1@;) (!7 !'8$'!7%1!1 (!28!',,!-- !/' 1#$,$! (!,,-#" #%#-!1/%1!' '1!'E /-!= (!28!'

,,!-- !/' --8!1 (!'!7!% #%!1,,-#" #%%1,!'7# !1 (! '!$,%1!% 6,-#% # ,'4! (!!%1'$!7!% (!9"0 (!,'% !9: !?7#%#%+ #'#%+($ !$ #%+8# %!$$

'233) -!'%!1 "/%$!- ' (! ,,!--% 61!!%1% $/97# !1 ( (!/' 9!-8(1!''%!/$-:--8!1 (!,,-#" #% /%1!' '1!'E /-!= (!$ !7!% #'#%+("/-1% ,'4!

(!!%1'$!7!% 1 !1F<<%1<<) (!'!'!) (!$/# #-!1 %<<;8$9''!19:-#7# #% (!!4#1!%"!,'1/"!19: (! '!$,%1!% 6,-#% #8$"% '1#" ': (!,-!1#%+$ (!,-#% %1 "% !% $ (!-!+-% #"!? F 8$--!+!1 ( 7/% )>6 8$'! /'%!1%<</-0(%#%+($ !1 ( (!(1'!"!#4!1 )>6%<<)9/ (!,'% !1!,#" !11#!'!% $ ': ( # 8$!?!"/ !1#%-#!/-1,'% !1 !1=<<-- (!$!" '$)#

-0!1#% #%"''!" ,!'$,!" #4!)8/-1% (4!'!$/- !1#% 1!"'! - (!$/# (!28!',,!-- !/' -$% ,,'!"# !1 (!" ( (! --!+!1 $#+% /'!$ 8!'! #' #%+( % ,'% ! %1 '!"!#, 1 !1 <<'% !4#1!%"!($9!!%,'1/"!1'"7,'#$% (! $#+% /'!$) (/$) /'+!1 (#$ /' ' $! #%+6$#1! (! #%1#%+$ /%1!' "(--!%+! (!'!$,%1!% 6,-#% #($-'!1:9!!%,'"!!1!1 4#1!'1!'1 !1)8(#"('!1$$/%1!'&6

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

(!'!$,%1!% 6,-#% #)') (!$ !7!% #'#%+(#%,'4#%+ ( (!!%1'$!7!% 8$71!%F<<($+%!/%6'!9/ !1(!'!4!'$! $#1! (!,'% !8$8# %!$$!19: #'#%+(%1 (/797'0!19:

/-0(%#%+(%1*' '#%+(!$,# !!? !%$#4!"'$$6!?7#% #%' $/++!$ #%$)% (#%+"% '':$/'"!1'9'#%+#%+ (!$/# / (!,!'#1 (!-#7# #% ,,!--% 61!!%1% #-!1 -!1%:!4#1!%"!1!$,# ! (!" ( ,,-#" #%/%1!' '1!'E /-!= 8$--8!1' (!!?,!'

"/-1 (4! 9!!% !?7#%!1 9!-#! (#$ $#+% /'!$) (!'!'!) 14!'$! #%!'!%"!($'#+( -:9!!%1'8%(!,'% !"''#!1,'!$/7, #% '/ ( $,!'!" #% (!!+ #9-!%$ '/7!% " (!'+/7!% '33#$% 9-! 9'#%+ (!"$!8# (#% (!,/'4#!88''% #%+#% !'!'!%"!#% (!3/1+7!% %11!"'!! (! 28!',,!-- !/' )9!#%+ (!-$ /' " %1-8

' (!'!$%$$ !194!)%+'/%1'#% !'!'!%"!#$ 71!/ )7/"(-!$$%:$/9$ % #-D/!$ #%-8'#$!$ !$/- % -:) (!

,,!-#$1#$7#$$!1 -* (')# ./- %&01$ )-2-/34 5/

6/5

)-2- 27 6/5