← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/733/2024allowed

Pardeep Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil15 pages

  



 

 

  

 

    

 

 



 

 !""

" 

 

"

 

#$ 

" "

$  





     

  

   "

$%  &$'

!

"     #   

  $ 

 %&!

$  $ '(   ' ( ))         *+ &* *&*% '# (

 ,+- .%/ 0

 !123  4 ) ( ((  # (('   *5 &* *&*%   ( #(  #   # (  0 &32%  ,& &2 *&*,

 *& 0

 !123   (  $ ('(

*   (( #  $  # ' ))           





         *5 &* *&*%     ( #( '( '' 

  ((   *+ &* *&*% ' (# (( ) #    , "    

  $  ' (    

     '  ( #  ( #(

 !+5.*/ $  $ "   ()   ( #      #('- 

        

   !"# $$%&' ! (# &)'! (*+   # $)  , !-. , */+ / + /

 ,(  0  

/ /     !     0       ,   . /  " 1203    ( *45 675%'/ /  ,   +

, 

 /  (-

 # $%' (+     +   ,       ,    (    + , /  ( 8  ,

( 6'      

    /    /      

   '   ( *+  #$)

( , 0   # (-' // # $%/0/+ ' 

,      # $%/.

(

'0/+ '  (-'/ (

 /  " 1203

  .      , 9

+     '

+ 

 ($5 $:  (/ (- /  ,   ( / '*45675% 



  ' /

///  '+   

+  

 ,  - ( /   / 7*45

 675%   / 

    (    (   

 +   - , 

/ 

+ '

+ ,+

  ! ;+'

  /  "

      ,  ;+' 

  /  + , 7  # -   "-

  1* 3  



 , 

  

 ' /<  '

/"-    "-

  1*  / 



  

 8  

= +  + '    - :#.0 (



 /

, +,

,,>//     ,

         +     

  ,+    

,     6> //  ,  ,  /

+  

      &/#.0         .  ",

  "

  0    .

. 7<#     /#.0 ! ( *+  #$)( ?  ,

 /    (  ( %:@&$&   (  ( )&$%)$)'/  ,/ ( '

 ,

 (*+     

  + (8  ,

 9 ,

     ' / +(, /   

+  

    -/  9  (,  -' / (/  ,+ 9,+   (-    (,  ,

, 

' ,/(, ( $ /(-,' , /(, (  -,' ,/(, (  @-, , ' ,/(, ( & -,:, '

 ,/ #: -,$, ' ,/ # @ -,,  ,/ #) $%-, $, 9  , $%-,%:, '

      (  



. ",

 ( 

 '      !"  ( $$%&.",

 (



  + ',+  +    (+ -7

A    + 

, /  

  ,

 (   (+  

  

  @$:

#.0 !( ,

,/$%-,%:,

/,+ 



' 

( ,  , ! (#&)"

( /  ,/ 

    /  ( (   

 + /  ,

//  

( $/ /  + , ',  ' /// 

'      /  4# . 7

0A

+ # $%.B5 2 C 2"

*  !

//0. % $$:0"  / 4   / , ,

   (+  ,

    

  5@$5:  #.0  !        !!#  (  '  

D  !&)E

( ,  + /0  ,

  //  $

( , 0 ! ( #&)  *- !

//0/ /   F %   (  (   #)   !2&   #

 ,+-

0

 4 *+ &* *&*%  '  ,& &2 *&*, (  (    ( #( '  #    )  # ( '     -        # )( '  (  

 !+5.*/ $  $ )( #)  4  ( 

  )(  ( ((  #(      -  # ( #(    ( # 7

 :(   ('

;  





    

   

 

 !"" 

!#$

 #

 '  )  ' -  (  (   ( #(   #( #   ' 4    ./  #- .*/ !+5 $  $  -  (  (  #(  (   #( #     # (  -   (  #(     $      (    )  #(       ) 7  ( #  #( -    ( ,+-

0

 !123     #(   '    (     #   !2&       *5 &* *&*%  # ( ,+- .%/ 0



+ 0 ) <  $    

  

     #( - ' #)  '  ,& &2 *&*,  4 !2&   (#( ' 7

   (  4 ) '  ' ((' # 4 ,&   ) (   *+ &* *&*% #

(  =  ('(

 ( )       ( #(  )#(    -   )(       (

7 ' ( #   '  

 !+5.*/ $  $ 

- 13  ",

           

 

/   

  '   

  

           '  /         

 /   

",

 - / '/  8 ,/ /  G / 

             /  

'    



 /   

'    ( /        ",

  + ,   

   B0 +     513H    ",

   

 / 

'

  / '(

/ / / ' /



/ ?,  8

/   ,  '  (    ",

    

    / 

   

 , / 

8 ,'5H( (

&:/$%)' $'/  , 131/$5 $5$%)3I1 3  '  + ,  

//

( '

 /  /

 /  /



8 '  + ,    //''8

/ 

/   '

8 '   ('  

 (  (  /

     /

  ( '   +  

     (   

(5   ( (      +

 /! JJJ

/  

/! GI

 1(3H    ",

    

     /      /  

 

 

 (/  

/ /

 ( ?+      

    /   ' ( ",

  8/          /   

  ,   /     +    -,IH(   (    !  / !

0  1  3 '1:/%3'

 $&131 3'/ !1(30

 (  '! 1(3     5H1(3   ",

   

    

 

  

 (/  GII 13   ",

  /      

'            

 (/  (    ,  ! '   

   / F :   (  ,+-

 (( #- .%/ 0

   ' ( # ) (   #('- 1&3      /  

     /    // 

(  $%  &  )

 /  // ++ ,       ?   

/  (5  13/  $@)/!/ !

0  '$%)1/$%)&3' /K   K'  ' (  /  K  , KB0 + ' / 



(  + ,     

/  , ' ! 8 

   /   0(   0    ,     ,

 /  

+ ,   /   /  /  ( 

/  , F

!& 7  )      #(   '   ) ' ( (      ( ' )( ( #  #(      -  #  !2&   !!

,+.

/.%/ 0

   ' ((    )( 4 (  (('

   #

    

 (   ') ( " ((  4   )  # )( '

) )  #  '  #)  

) ) )  )(    )  #) (    #(      ) #                

 #(    )  

)  # 

  $)(     7

      "  #(   4 ( (  ) 9  7  # #)     4 ) ' '

#(   )(  "    4 )  #(      (  ) 9    9  )   $      (

 

       #(   )(  )   9  7 < ( '  9   (

(  ) )  (      (  ) '  '       ) )(  

!* "  )    *5 &* *&*% (

 )  ,+

.%/ 0

 #    $  #('

 (       #(  # ( #(    (   ( (( ' # )   4  (  # 

    #  4 #(  # )(

(  $   '

  !+5 .*/ $  $  #(   #      ' ( ( )(   

 ((  )  ' ('

  #(

 !+5 .*/ $  $  #(  (( ))  $ > 

!,

   ' ( '

 (  (    ( #( ) 4  !2&   #   (   ( #( #) )( 7  ))  $)( $        ( #   (    ( '( #    (  (  (  # )   ( #( 4   # )   4 )4) )  !2&    ( #( #  #(   

   !+5 .*/

 )  # 

  !% '  ( (#   

   )   ) ( "   ( #(  # ( #

)

4 $  '((  $   (   

   !+5 .*/ $ #     #( # ('



( *!

$  7    )(       # ( #(     !+5.*/   ((( !3 "   ( #(  # )     ( ) # ?#(  ) $  ;% &' (' 

 &' '  

!)$)*  !* 

)  ((@      '      )( '  ( ) #

 !+5.*/ $  $ " (  ) ' ( 

-

$      /   

'         

  / B5 $2 (5  13/ $@)'",

 (/   

   

+ , , //

      ",

 - / /   8 ,$:    2     +

    /   (5    13  /  $@)'",

 

 /  

 / /    

    8 ,  %       

+ ,       //  

(    

 /  /

 /  /

  

$

'@   + , 

  //  8

/ 

/%  @ '

  (' /

(

, /+  /      /  ( ,      (    //( + , , ,      /    + ,         

 

( 

 (   ( ' /

  /

( '

 (",

 &9  / ( 

/ ( / /    /  

/

( 

,  ,    +   

/+ // /   + , ,  ,        /  

+ ,          /   

'   ",

E!  

 / /  '( ,



/  /  ( /  

/%  @ '  /  ,5

 (/ ( + , , ,     /",

E!   (  /

(/

   ,

 +   /    ( ,

 ( // /  + , , ,   , + ,   

  : / 

(/

( '

( ",

'   ,/D8 

   +

    (5    13  /     $@)'         /       +  (  

 /   

     ,   13       ( 

'' / ' /

,



+ , 

  , 

/    5 /

( 

, /     

8 ,



  @8

 / + / (

!  +,  - ! (

   /    

 // ( ( ,

    '

8

/

  /   , 13/ +

 (5  13/ $@) /  /    / ( //

 /

 ( ( ,

'  (   + /

/

(

,+, !  

    

  

  /( '   /

  

 '   /.

 '/0

  1  

 !  23  1

  45)  "&  &6 $74 )8

 

   0

'      (   B5 $&   '  / 8



,( + , , //  (    /0( 0   +

, +

 (  1&3/ @ /#.0 /   0( 0   

, ( /,''  + - ,

 

 ,  ' 

/ ( ,

/

+ ,    / 8

/    + , A  '    

      ,

 /  + ,    

    

/  

  /  (

?

  /  , /     /  ,           /  /     /         

   +   /  

! '  E  / (     /  ?

  +

, 0 +

 @1&3/#.0   /(

    / - ,8

/ 

 ,( 

/ ? / + , ,

//      /  -/ ( ,AC  

,

//

$  $@*   +  , 

3-



/ //     /  @1&3/#.0  ( / 



 ' +

   

/

(

,(  (    /    /  /          /       

(  /  -



  /

( ( 

(  " + '8

(, -           (     

(  

 8( + , ( 

  (+'(/ 8



, '   ( 

+

  (((, /8

 $)

,   $@)13!

0!'$%)   

/

(

,  

'/ =/=( + , ,,   /  + ,    8  

 

( 8'   (' -  / 

 (  

/ 

   /

     (      +

  13  /     $@)13 !

0!'  $%) 

 ,          K  55 /K 

, ///     + , /     

(



 ?/   ' / 8

/$ / /



(   ( 

 + / ///  

 , '

   /  , 

      /    + ,    '    

  

  +  / 

 ! '        $@)13 !

0!$%) /

(

,( ,(  /+ / ' / /     + , ,      $)!

0!'

$%) (

, '  '

  ! '   /   8

  /   8   

 

,  (-  '    ? / /    

  ( ,   

   

 /  /

,/( ,   ( (  -    (/

,

 (+ (  ( 9+  0 &' ' ##* !

"



"

- 5

'  - ,/  

' =(  !  /

     " :  .

  ;   <  '

 0      

         

   + '

("## 4'  B5 K 

,    (        $@)13   +

  13  

(  

,

 +   =

   / + , ,,/  /   ,5 (/ 8

/%E%@ '  ('    (   ( 7 ,' 

/  ( 8 # /' ,

    

( 

/%E%@    

  /(   

  /

 ?

( (K !+   #(     @ #)    $  ' ( (  (  A-    #(    )    !2&    4 # ( $  

    *+ &* *&*%   (   !2&    4    ( # B ( #(?

 !+5.*/ $  $ !5 7   ) (    ' (   #'  ' (  ) #  '    -  -    

    -  ' ( ( # ( 

 ( #( (( #   ' ) # ) # '((   #   (    *5 &* *&*%  #

(  =  ('( #     ((' !2

(    # (  ( #( #     9  #(A  #  ( $ A( =  .  / !1 '  ) (  # ) # ((   # )  &"

$'

 

 0 #, 9 - ,E   ; E# 9  ( ; E#