Balwinder Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
!
"# $!%&'&"() * +*
,-&($!.
/&(01 ($ " 1!.'
****! & &"(!.'
2!.'3'
/ !
"# 3(4 5 ($ (" 1!.
*****!'6"($!( '
) 78 * / 9/ 8
!
" # 9/ 8:
* 8
$ %&# ! !
'
((" #) #* +* #*++ ,#, ,#%+%&+%-.
!+&)* /." +,* #* +* #*++ 0 ( 1
23 +4 5 #6 *- #*+&
7 8
+ ! 1
,#,,#% +%-.! 55
9+* *6 #*## !
! !!
""#"#
!# !$
% # ! &%
!" ! !!
' (# ) *+
, -!. /
/
0 1
/0
2
0 % /0
30
# /
0 /
+
5 #)
0
! 6 8
#9/3 0#++:# 3/
/
- 9 9 #+4
/
/
% 9 ;
0 (
!<2 %9 ;
/0
/
,
(
0
=- !
0/
2 > 2 0
?
" > 0 #4
2 (
?
>
4 2
&%
? <
% 4 7
(0 24 0; 0
&% /
( 9-9-!$ - @ .
7 8
+ ! 1
2! 4 ! $
0
/2)
A/ )
=-
*!.
0/
2 +
% 4 7
# 4
2
*.
> 2 0
+
+0#
( 0
*". > 0 #4
2 (
?
0 4 / #
2
> *. >
4 2
&%
?
2 '( ;
9 4
&%
!" ! !!#
""#"# " # !$ % 0
B, 0#
4 2
&%
*<. (
% 4 7
(0 24 0; 0
&% +
% 4 7
#
0
;4 0
# /2/0
2 8 # 2 =+/ 4 */3
D. 59 ! ) E%
' " "F
5 5 55 7 $7
55
7 7 :
5 :
: " #
5
55
7 $ (( " #) #* +* #*++ 7" # ,#,,#%+%&+%-.
!+&)* /. " +,* #* +* #*++ 0 ( 1
23 +4 $ 8
+ ! 1
5 #6 *- #*+&
; F
0
; %0
&
%
!
'( "% %
2 - - "";!$% %
- - "";!$% %
- - 3 ";!$% %
2 - - "";!$% %
- - ""% %
- - "
";!$% %
2 - - "";!$% %
- - ""% %
- - : ";!$% %
2 - - ""% %
- -
; "";!$% %
- - < 9 ";!$% %
2 - - "";!$% %
- - ""% %
- - +
2
# 2
/2 #
/
/
4
2
30
/ 4
& /
0 0
= <$ ! *: .# 59 ! # ) E%
' " F
5 ( 7
55
. '
. '
55
: 55
5
! 0 !
<
5 %&#! !
/. '
'
5
55
: 5 #- *- #*#+1= 5! .
!! "
#$$ "
%&
' ($ "
) # * +
,
5 7
: '
7
$ !
$ 1= 5 ! .
($ "
#- 2 4
1 !
%&#! !
7 $
5 F
4
#
&% "
4 0/ #
+0/# 9 # 9
0
2 # +
/ 0 * 0
.+
!
4 8 0
( #(
2
+
8 / (
/ 2
0
+
( 00
$#"" " ( "
% #! * #G%H.
"
4
+ * / .+ #!$$E
2I 4 # 1 59 *&.#+0/#
+
$#"" " ( "%( 0,00
2
" ( "% ,,, ,,, ,,, ! ) #
#4
4 0/2
4 0( 2
0 # ,
(
# 4
0 / ) / /2 4
+
/ 2
/ 2
4 0 #
2# #
8 ( 2I 4 2
/3
0
0 3 2 0 !"%
0 4
-
(
0
2
4
# /
4
2 /
0
) 0
0
4 3 0
2 ( 4 2(2/3
( ,
% ( 2 # ( 0 8
# )
,
( # 8 4 ( 0
#
( 0 / 4 # (
#/
#/
, , 2 (
( /
3 /
(
)
/
3 + 4
(
02
3 #( 4 0
#02
4 3 7
# (
4 / 4
#
/
/ ,
# 2 / 4 /2
J74
3/J7 1,0 2
*.
,,, ,,, ,,, !$ > 0-
" ( 2 /2 0 /
G 0 / H(
2 0 ( 8# , 2 (
)
4 + !
# / 8 / 2
0 /
"
#( (
( 0
/ , 2
,
0 #/ 0 =*.
2K*.
32# 2K*.L
2
0 / 4 0KJ*4.
#
;
4
@
5 3 7 1 !
%&#! !
> 75 ,#*! !
.
7 5
5 5 $ 55 > 1 ! 3 > 5 ! 0 ! - .
/ $ 0 %&#! !
5 $
5 <2
&%
<# <*+
, -!.
""#"#<#< #! !$%*/
2
" "" %.#
( # - ( #
/
0 !<*+
, -.
/
0 30
#/
< $ !" /2 +
5 # ' #( /2 -
# (
,,,M,,,M,,,
N
&%
0 30
< $ !" /2
+
5 # ' #
/
0 !<*+
, -.#
/ 2
/
,,,--,,,M,,,
!(
,
2/%0 /!! "0
0
/ 4
4 (
/
0 # )
4 (
0 2
3
/ 4 =- !<
8 (
" # ( 4 #
/ ) 0
(
0
3 ! + / , /2 5 (
(
0
0
/
0
/ / 8 4 / 2
/2 #(
3 #*!
"
. *
,
) #5 /0 /!! "0 & /0 &%#
0 0
(
*/ . /
$+%
!0
A0
( /
+ , 0 8 4 ( 0
3 / 4 F
0 ( / /
(F /2 8 ( + !
)
2 ( 8
+ !
#
/
4 4 ) ( 8 (
!6 0
3
, / /2 )
0 ( 4 (
4
/
(
3 # ( 4 # (
(
2
0 /
( /
" 0 / ( #
4 (# , / 2 4
, / 8
( 23
0
! ,,, ,,, !$ ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ! %
0 (
2 / 4 *
- -(
.4 0/
0
#(
4 (
0 ( 0
I
0
0
020 0/ ( 4
3
02
0 (
0 3 ( 4 2
3 4 22 0
2 0/ 8
(
0
/2 2
#
/
8
3
8 /3
2
- #(
3 0
! " $ 0
<-!
+
5 9 # )#
/
0 !!4 / 0 -0
*0 0 4.(;
30
2+ 2 2# 0 0
/2
0
/
/ 4 - 0
2# /2
/ 4 -0
! " $ ( /
/ /2 +
)@ 02#
4 ("
!(
%/20 /!! "0 5 ( /2 (
" % (
0
2 #
0 2
( 2
30
7 "
, & / 0 /!! "0 2
!(
&&/0 /!! "0 2& ( 0
" % (
/ 4
( /
0
/ #
/ 0 ,,,M,,,M,,, + 2#&%
<# <*+
, -!.
""#"#<#< #! !$%*/
2
" "" %.#
( # - ( /
0#
# #
/
0 !<*+
, -.#/3
20
<# ;-#
/ ( 3/
1 4 + 2#
2# 30
#/
< $ !" /2 +
5 # ' # /3
20
@ ! 0 ! 5 *- *, #*+? ! ,-*#*+? '8 "
$ !( * !
,
< /
8
",
3*!
* $! 85 /0 /!! "0 & 3
* ,
"
"5 #9 /0 & 4
3
) 0
!( / /
3 / 4
0 #/
0
0
( 4 4
4
( / 4 /2 4
, ( /
(
!6
/ % 0
+ 3
* ,
"
"5 #9 /0 &# ( / 2
0
(
/
/ ( 4
% 4 (
#0 30
!$ ! !6 /2+
5 #98 /4 (
( 4
( /3
!<O
0
3
- .
/ $
1 4 + 2# ( ( /
2
(@
5
51= 5! 3
- / $
! 5
55 $55
55 51= 5! .
($ "
) #- 2 4 5
7
5 7 ! / 7 @ 7 ; 7
3
55 7 55 '
>
$ 7
78
. ! / 755 7 5
7 7
.! 1
/ 7 > 7 #*++ 7
> 5 37
5 75 5
5 ; '
$ >
5 ((" #) #* +* #*++ ,#,,#%+%&+%-.
!+&)* /." +,* #* +* #*++ 0 ( 1
23 +4 '
5 5 #6 *- #*+& 78
+ ! 1
;'
'
9/ 8
3,< :
> A ; > B C A B "