High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32928/2017allowed

Joginder Pal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-03-03Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary8 pages

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 1

!"#$%& !'

#( )(* &+$+",#-!

/ #( ( $01.0(234$5(0/( ( 678/(.24$$#*39 $7(36*(4$5( 0 &874$5(07/8 +0/(/098*(&: (#( ;*0<, !

(<(# & =4&<(*(4 ( &<(*( *( & :

4 4 : # 88 ;*8 /(<(<0((78*<(( >

:4$@*( #4520040/(28(/(87/( %(*800, ;*4(<( < 0 /( 0 9(0( !(( #84 7/8 3*(= 20 A0<(0(<0007/82(9* 0 /(4 208 0 9(0( <(5* 3*(= 0 0 0 7/8 20 A +0 /( 2 8( *(< 5< 0 0 8 ( $*(8

'25(4 0 GAURI SHANKER 2023.03.04 10:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 2 /( 2 *77 *( & (# 5 ((

9=0(8*(49*28(/(87/(40*<0 20* 7/8=< 20 0 /(5 *( & B ( 20 &

?( # '9(0(2;*00(<8588< 0753*<7

?420007/8***88= 088<//802753*<7

>9= 0 $//88 *( +0 * 0 /(< < 0 /(2*899*82 '(83*<7/9=0 *(

!"# $ %

&'( () * + ,

(8 :? '&"

)$ "-. &' ( () * + ,

(.)$

%(*8(0&28807/805 9 98 /(* = 7(8 (5( 0 ( *97 7 9= 8( *8 ( 0 /( (<( 0 /(*( 05< 9 7/8 20 9( 8(< 0 /( /(87/(((5(000*4202 (9=0(8*(40/(*8/(5<07 0075<0/(40(9< (0 5 5898 '25(40= //0/(=( 0 <(* 00/(098(/(87/(/(=(0 780/(/ '(0*9708(*8(0/( /(*08 $78=40/(4200*<0270, 4 28(*(<5<1/8*7! 0

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 3 8(/(08(9( //88*(& (# 4 0 0 2 *77 '25(4 0( 9< 7(8 9(*<0((020(52*/0/(20 2 (< $*(84 7/8 9= 0 /(5 & B (20&

( #4(8(<07/(87/( *(<0((<*7409(0(0/(4202* 0 , 4 (8 2 ;* 0 0(< 9= 0 (8 *(4 (7 9= 0 $//88 *( 0 7 8= +0788<5@<0/( +0<0$//88*(2087<0//8 89=07/8088<<03*<7;*84(0* +0/(*807/*<3*<7(580 0 8( (8 *( 0 985 0 5 #D .82(6*(#D?

&*102(&<0 $( << 0(*<0 0 < 0 8( (8 *( 288 0 5 8 9( 4 7=8 <(72007 00/(* 0@/(8*<*!((/8&<00 1#D?&*102(&<002.82( 6*( +0/(0*3*(=0/( &*102( &<0 288 .82( 6*( ! 7 8<8 @7 .

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 4 0 0/8 *9*8 4 0( 0*9 2 82003*(=200(/<2/4 2*8059*(8(0(10(0*9 0 0/8 +0 % "@ #D:B. (58 0 0 3*(2100/89=09(0(%109( &<042009@79=0/(*

+0 3*( 2 7 8<88= @7 0 0/8 /

0 88< *((01/8

49*0( 70*(3*(0% ' 07*(<0(@700 70/(998*(3*(0% ' *(0(00/0(8588 07 0 @ 7 3*( +0 7< *( 3*( 0 ( *9 (<(< 0 (*0*8 0 /(* +0 , 0 2 (<(

:? /

4 9* /= 0 , 4 200 "@ # 2 (5 9= 0 *( $8 0 *8 <(4 &<(*(4

+0 8= <0/=0, 08(<(0 ( *9 0 /(* //(0 , 2((

4*20040( 8=2=</=0, 0 8(<( #D?&*102(&<00( @7000/887 0 0/8 (( 0 7 ( 2 = +0 /( 0 (@7 /(5 0 0 7 "@ #$ 0 9 200 , 2 (<(4 2 ((

4 9* 2 ((

+0 7= 9 0 ( ( <0/=0, 08(<(

+0 0 8 * 0 /(*(=

28880;*840( *9/(*7/5*(0* 0$//88*(09(*8(*E< 05(( $(<<0(*<005 8 9( 0 (8 *(4 0 0 <*8 0 * /(5 9= 02 (98 *9087/89(*8*0 +0( /* 92 0 0( 0 7/8 0 0( 0 * D $3 &<0400(0*40/(5((0 3*<758*(4200"@ 5200* ( (5(= 8 9= 07 < *10( &<04 0 0( 0 7/84 2 7 ' 0 8 8//8<03*<74/=00

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 5 0//8"@ 057/=< 0//8"@ '0887/8"@ ?

< 7/8 &*102( &<04 0 9(0( %109( &<04 0 0( *10( &<00(*/((9*<* !((/8 &<0

( (/< 00**<3*(0/(0 78= 779( >

+0 /(5*8< 92 0 /(4 20 2( (< 0 7 88= 7= 9 ( ( 8 7/8 0 * 0 9(0( <(/8 &<0 * /( +0 88 /8 0 *

<(/8 &<0 *(< 5< +0 88< 7 9= 0 7/8 (<(< 0 <8 00 2 28 * 9 8 +0 2/*770(728(5( *(<5< +0880/(* +0 3< / 2 (7 0 /8 *(( 8 8 0 4 /(5 0 0 88< *(( 1 /8 9( = 8<0 7= /( 2( 5898 0(4 20 *8 05 9 3 0 5< +0 /242070(/(*( &

( # '(/(6*(089 @7 *(< (8 +0 98 80 0 3*(2(1/8/

> 520*7954 70 (/00/(*0998 /(5 0 <*8 0 * 9= 02 (98*9 +0(70/(*4 200 05 9 * 954 ( ;* 7(8 7=8<(72003*<7;*8 / 9= 0 8( (8 *( $(<8=4 0 7/*<3*<7*/080//8(( 97 &*77((9(*((020 8<20/=03*<7 F 2*8 9 /(98 71 (( 0 3*<7 ((9= 5 .0 0 *( 0

*/(20(*(03*0/(<2(;*04 0<(*005(=7*98598*(*2(0=5 92000*4200(82(;*4**8 /*(/ 288 9 (5 5 /( 0 9< * 2

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 6 /(*(0(8072*8*878=80(;*8 2*87*9*0/(0*( 0

$ ))/ 0 $ &' ( () * + ,

(.)$4 :>

420(0/(2(<9( 28(/(87(0*420(8 2(;*40*(9=882<03*<70

*/(4 ;*0 0 , 288 0 (( 8(< 0 /(/(87( +0/(9((8=090 75*2000*2(;*0( 9</(/0<54080'<0*( 0" 01 $&'( ()2 : (8 > 49=9(5< 02*892<058*980*(*0(8 0*/(0*897*(<0(8(84 0(<0* +0 , 2 ;*0 0 $/$))( "-. "

' 0."

)$&'( () * + , ?

(8 420(78( (*74 0 /(4 20 2 0(< ( *( &:0+((((*/5$5 #(5$4

?42884& B: #40*4202((( ;* 9= 0 (8 *( 2 08 0 20( 0 5 74*/(<00/(2*8(*8 2*(G7*(=@/*(&@0;*(

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 7 +0*(0 '&"

)$"-. */(0800 /(9</(87(4288702=;*0< 0, 4090788<5< 0740*;*0*4;*00, +0 9 //8 9= *( ( < 200( @/0(3*/(7/(**4 9= 1< ( = /8 *( 200 //( /(*8(00*(5(88</(79800 20( 0 / 0 *( 0 5 ( 21**8/*(/818=9(59=882<0(78 /(*9*40*(;*00/(<42(0 9(5 'H98 +0 &*/(7 *( 0

"# +"

&' 1,.

+"$

-$)2

?>?

+0 80 '<0 *( 0(< 0 /( 0 (8 *(098507=&7 7(00(2 208 ;*< 88 0( * 0 0 88< < 0047*07&7 7(4((<((00 < 0 /( /(4 0 $1"

)&" &' .) ( () 4 *) ."5

(8 :>4;*78(8=0/( 2884088<<09(0(0/(2(05< 8 A 982 0 0 0 7/8 0 9 ;*9=8((8*(42080/(2(9* 9824200(*10<((<0007/8

CRM-M-32928-2017 (O&M) 8 ,(77/88<7<0/(/(4202 8( *(< 5<4 0 9(0(4 /( 7*<0705920040 9(0(2;*49</(9859842*8/ 0(/985 2*80*93** 0 /(< < 0 /(4 8= (788= 7/8 0 /(*(/(*08*4200(*87//( 2*887*0(2</(*3*87 52095*40*(/(*/ 0/(<<0/(4@(0/2((( *( & : (# (<8=4 , !

(<( # & =4 &<(*(4 ( &<(*( 88 ;*8 /(< (< 0((7 8*< 0 (( >

: ( 0(9=;*0 #882 4 5 67678687 67(B<5 D00(/1<B( IB! D00((/(98 IB!