High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21031/2021allowed

Sukhdev Singh v. State Of Punjab

2021-06-15Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!88$$ %&$'()$(%*($+,-.'$,/$0-&123$2&4$(2.52&2$2'$ $ $ $ $ +(2&4%*2.($ $ $ +.6767!8";8$<=$!"!8$>,$?$6@$ 42')$,/$4)+%A%,&$B$8CD"ED!"!8$ $ AIZ[VNR$APQ\[$ $ $ $ $ $ M0NOPOP<QNK$ RNKSIS$ $ AOFON$<=$0IQGF^$ $ $ $ $ $ M.NSU<QVNQO$ $ +,.26$B$ (,&W3X)$6.D$1-A'%+)$2.-&$6,&*2$ $ !"#$#%&'('

)"*'+$25B';-"-3'+,456/&#3'

75"'&2#'8#&-&-5%#"*'

)"*'+@-&')#2&/3'0"*'9+;3'!:%U/=*'

>0KNSNQYN$JFKZNV$O[K<I\[$RPVN<$Y<Q=NKNQYN@D$ !"#$%&'$(!)%*+%,'"!-.% % A2#' 8#&-&-5%#"' -$' $##B-%1' "#1:?/"' =/-?' -%' CDE' F5*IMK' ,/&#,'' OG*JM*IJGH'"#1-$&#"#,':%,#"'0#6&-5%$'IG'b'II'57'F9!0'+6&3''/&'!5?-6#'0&/&-5%' 052/%/3'9-$&"-6&'0+0'F/1/"*'''

I*'

!#"'CDE3'5%'OG*JM*IJGH',:"-%1'F/B/=/%,-3'8#&-&-5%#"'>/$'75:%,'-%' 85$$#$$-5%'57'GJ'1"/@$'57'-%&5^-6/&-%1'85>,#"3'>2#"#/$'65R/66:$#,';:"8"##&' 0-%12' >/$' 75:%,' -%' 85$$#$$-5%' 57' KJ' 1"/@$' 57' -%&5^-6/&-%1' 85>,#"' /%,' KJ' -%U#6&-5%$'57'S:8"#%5"82-%#'/%,'!/"4##%'[/&/'>/$'75:%,'-%'85$$#$$-5%'57'OJ' 1"/@$'57'-%&5^-6/&-%1'85>,#"'/%,'IJ'-%U#6&-5%$'57'S:8"#%5"82-%#3'>-&25:&'/%.' 8#"@-&'5"'?-6#%6#*'

O*'''

A2#'8#&-&-5%#"'/%,'65'/66:$#,'>#"#'/""#$&#,*'!#&-&-5%#"'-$'$&/&#,' &5'=#'-%'6:$&5,.'$-%6#'OG*JM*IJGH*''

L*'''

[#/"%#,' 65:%$#?' 75"' 8#&-&-5%#"' 65%&#%,$' &2/&' &2#' /??#1#,' "#654#".' 57' GJ' 1"/@$' 57' -%&5^-6/&-%1' 85>,#"' X2#"5-%Y' /77#6&#,' 7"5@' &2#' 8#&-&-5%#"' 7/??$' >-&2-%' &2#' %5%R65@@#"6-/?' `:/%&-&.*' A2#' T5:"&' =#?5>' 2/$'

>"5%1?.'-%45B#,'&2#'8"54-$-5%$'57'0#6&-5%'OP'57'&2#'+6&*'<#'7:"&2#"'$:=@-&$' &2/&'&2#"#'2/$'/?$5'=##%'4-5?/&-5%'57'@/%,/&5".'8"54-$-5%$'57'F9!0'+6&*'A2#' 65@8?/-%/%&' 2-@$#?7' -$' &2#' -%4#$&-1/&-%1' 577-6#"' 57' &2#' 6/$#3' >2-62' -$' %5&' 8#"@-$$-=?#'/$'8#"'?/>*'

K*'

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

!#"' 65%&"/3' ?#/"%#,' 0&/&#' 65:%$#?' 5885$#$' &2#' =/-?' 8?#/*' <#' $:=@-&$' &2/&' &2#' >25?#' `:/%&-&.' 57' &2#' 65%&"/=/%,' 2/$' &5' =#' 65??#6&-4#?.' &/B#%' -%&5' /665:%&*' A5&/?' `:/%&-&.' =#-%1' GQJ' 1"/@$' 57' S:8"#%5"82-%#' -%U#6&-5%$3' 7/??$' >-&2-%' &2#' 65@@#"6-/?' `:/%&-&.*' +??' &2#' /66:$#,' >#"#' &51#&2#"'/&'&2#'&-@#'>2#%'"#654#".'>/$'#77#6&#,'7"5@'&2#@*'+665",-%1'&5' 2-@3' "-15"$' 57' 0#6&-5%' OP' 57' F9!0' +6&' >5:?,' /&&"/6&' &5' &2#' 6/$#' 57' 8#&-&-5%#"3'>2-62'8"52-=-&$'1"/%&'57'=/-?'-%'6/$#'57'"#654#".'57'65@@#"6-/?' `:/%&-&.*''

P*'

A2#' 65%&#%&-5%$' 57' ?#/"%#,' 65:%$#?' 75"' 8#&-&-5%#"$3' /$' %5&#,' /75"#$/-,3'@/.'2/4#'$:=$&/%6#'=:&'$/@#'6/%'5%?.'=#'/,U:,1#,'/&'&2#'&"-/?*' 0-%6#'-%4#$&-1/&-5%'-$'/?"#/,.'54#"'/%,'62/"1#$'2/4#'=##%'7"/@#,3'&2#'6/$#' =#75"#'&2#'&"-/?'65:"&'-$'%5>'7-^#,'75"'8"5$#6:&-5%'#4-,#%6#*'A2#'&"-/?'-$'%5&'

?-B#?.'&5'65%6?:,#'$55%'-%'4-#>'57'&2#'6:""#%&'$-&:/&-5%'&2/&'2/$'/"-$#%',:#'&5' 8/%,#@-6*''

M*'

D'2/4#'2#/",'&2#'"-4/?'65%&#%&-5%$'57'&2#'"#$8#6&-4#'?#/"%#,'65:%$#?$*' GJ*''

'D%4#$&-1/&-5%'-$'54#"'/%,'62/??/%'2/$'=##%'7-?#,*'A2#'8#&-&-5%#"''-$'%5' @5"#'"#`:-"#,'75"'/%.'7:"&2#"'6:$&5,-/?'-%&#""51/&-5%*'A"-/?'57'&2#'6/$#'>-??' &/B#' ?5%1' &-@#' -%' 4-#>' 57' ,#?/.$' =#-%1' 6/:$#,' =.' 6:""#%&' 8/%,#@-6*' A2#"#75"#3'%5':$#7:?'8:"85$#'>5:?,'=#'$#"4#,'=.'B##8-%1'&2#'8#&-&-5%#"'-%' 7:"&2#"'8"#4#%&-4#'6:$&5,.*''

GG*'+??'&2#'8"5$#6:&-5%'>-&%#$$#$'/"#'85?-6#'577-6-/?$*'A2#"#3'&2:$3'$##@$'%5' /88"#2#%$-5%'&2/&'8#&-&-5%#"'>5:?,'-%7?:#%6#'5"'8"#$$:"-c#'&2#'>-&%#$$#$*'' 'GI*' ' </4-%1' 8#":$#,' &2#' 5",#"' ,/&#,' GP*JM*IJIJ' 8/$$#,' =.' /' 65R5",-%/&#' S#%62'57'&2-$'T5:"&3'5%'&2#'1"5:%,'57'8/"-&.'/?$53'&2#'8#&-&-5%#"'-$'#%&-&?#,'&5' 1"/%&'57'65%6#$$-5%'57'"#1:?/"'=/-?*''

GO*''' T5%$-,#"-%1'&2#'54#"/??'$6#%/"-53'>-&25:&'65@@#%&-%1'5%'&2#'@#"-&$' 57'&2#'6/$#3'&2#'-%$&/%&'8#&-&-5%'-$'/??5>#,*'A2#'8#&-&-5%#"'$2/??'=#'"#?#/$#,'5%' =/-?' 5%' 2-$' 7:"%-$2-%1' =/-?' =5%,$' /%,' $:"#&.' =5%,$' &5' &2#' $/&-$7/6&-5%' 57' 65%6#"%#,'T2-#7'\:,-6-/?')/1-$&"/&#N9:&.')/1-$&"/&#3'/$'&2#'6/$#'@/.'=#*'' GL*''

D&'-$3'25>#4#"3'@/,#'6?#/"'&2/&'-%'6/$#'&2#'8#&-&-5%#"'-$'75:%,' -%45?4#,'-%'/%.'5&2#"'6/$#'57'$-@-?/"'%/&:"#'>2-?#'5%'=/-?3'&2#'8"5$#6:&-5%' $2/??'=#'/&'?-=#"&.'&5'$##B'6/%6#??/&-5%'57'2-$'=/-?*'' 1-&)$8C]$!"!8$$ $ $ $ $ >2.-&$6,&*2@$ 02/?-%-'

1-4*)$ _2#&2#"'$8#/B-%1N"#/$5%#,'('

a#$NF5'

_2#&2#"'"#85"&/=?#'('

a#$NF5!