(O&M) Ishrana And ORS v. Shamsher A Nd ORS
! " #$ ##
% &
'
('
! " #$ ##
% &
)%*+, -./
*% 01 )
-0-2 + * *345 64 7733 * 8945 64 7
,!6) "7:
;;;
3
77735<#3$#= (
7<:* 66#)3#" #<!3493 > #<!3.4=<:*) 6 ( 3#$
"66#=#7 $
#3 773=<! "35$ 6 7#33:<!64"=6 !6!<86 33 8!?67# !5##6#
'
(
43#$ :=#5#$" 6:63 9<#3 = 7#33# # @ : 6 %"< 6 #$4#" 6:63=#<:3:$3#$3:#56 <#$$## /,/,'
' !3 66#4 3#!"!3#73#8!#3 #3# 9<#3=3 #8!# #66#
= 763#"7## ! 6# AA * #63 64
> 6. = #3 <: 3$3 7#5 63##8!9<#3
#<!346 ##$5#6=#4 =!" 44 B, 3$37#5 6 3#3 $=## C7!" 63#"7## #3<:#8!9<#34!" A4(B,==3 $=## C7!"
# 773 < #3 <: 3$3 7#5 63# 6" 6 "7#
536 !3 7#7! 77,< D
6 !3 7733$!6=
: $#" 66# #<!3= $3:
773#"!3#73# -!$! " !< =!6 5# 3
6 !3 7
E!6) "7:
5"3: 77 6" 6 "7# -!<"# #6 "<: #<!3#3: #$#4 4 "!3#73# #8!## " ! !3<= !6 5# 3
6 # #<:36 !3 7733 5 6676 #<!3 " 3: #6 " 6 4B,!6#$B 66 ! #3 ?74!376:<#54 B,A?
/:773:#$"!3#73# 43 76:<636!3 ?F 44 B, !$
5 <#7!4:#< !<"#D7#$#5#=$ 64"!3#73# == $3:773#
#! "!3#73#<6#<:- .<37? ) !#
=##<3#6 : 37 43 76:= !3<636!3<:773:#$ "!3#73# ( 5#= # 6## 4 773:#$ "!3#73# (4 6 "7# 66 ! 3 76:#,636!3 ?( F A4B,
,, @# $ =#$ 6 "7# ! 6 5# 34
!" #
!
" #
$%
&'(() *(((() " $
++ $
"%&
"
!! !"# $%$ # '*,-. " '((() "
$
!" *((((() "
"
&#' ( ) " *# + * '
!
'
&(*/ & 00 1,23 &(*/ 4 0 5$6 056 **&3&(*/ '
578/,9&'((() " $ *((((() "
"
() () &(*4 4 00
,', *,(# &(*4 4 0 5$ 6 056 2'9# &(*4 9 '/ *1 - " " *((((()
"
,& "#() " & () &(*4 4 00 1*, 3&(*4 / 0 5$6 056 42/3 &(*4 9
*22-
'(((() "
"
"
( " - . . !
/ &(*4 / 00 ,&93&(*4 ' 0 5$6 056 '*23 &(*4 *& 5784&/
( %
% )
&
* "* * %
* (" &
+
6##6= : $#" 66# -=!5#5<:=# = 3" #"#3:
!<6! !#"3: 3# =#3 6 "7# 4" 3 : !$ "#3:3 < 97#$#5#=3=3# =<:- .<37?) ! 6"# < 54 63#"=6 "7# !6 5# 3
,A,
6 # 6 "7# !6 5# 3 # $ " ! = <: #<!3 3 76:#67 33 =#$<3+ - =<:
#<!3 = =<:#6 !
76:
44 B, A4B,
6 #!"
'4B,
3 5 6# '4B,
'4B, !3?7 '4B,
3 44 B, 4(A4B, 5#= < 54=(
#" ## ?" ! 44 B,=<: #<!3# 6 4(A4B,
773333<#3 6" ! 6 "7# 3 $=## AC7!" " #3#$ 63#"7## #333## " !
'
('
#773<#3<:3$37#5 9<#3 6" 6 "7#
536 !3 7#7! 77,< D
6 !3 7733$!& #8:2!7 7 < #<!39<#3!G!#73$#=#6!
,(, #3 6# !5#63#? 5!5#635 -= 7#3# " " 6 !3!$!!#$76: 63#"7## 49<#33 #3#<6! #8!#!# 66# 66! '
(
-<=6 "7# 3:
"#63?74 " !<= 76!#: ,76!#:"$ 66 ! #8!#!#66#
6 !3 7
E!6) "7:
$!77335#3 7 59<#3#<6! #8!#!#66# -6 6" 6 "7# #G!#
6 # #<:36 !3 7733 56676 !$#": 5<7 5#8!# !<:9<#3#66#7 534<!# <#7! #8! "# 7#3# " " !6!6#$#!5#63#?5 !66#6!"64 7 " =#$ 6 "7# "#63 ?74 #<!3 !356 #=#$ 6 "7# !5# ! 76!#: ,76!#:"$ - .<37?) !#
!
"
#$
))''43!+ ..#33=6 "7# #7 3#8!: 6 !3<"#! 33 =#$+ 6!#:"$ 76#3"$ # ?73#$ "4 7#3## 4 "#6#47 # 4 !##$
"#633 !?7#!
## #$ $#4=#6 #8!= !35" <#8!4 6 "7##$+ #$!#$7# "H < !!#$ 66 ! 7"#<#3#:
###!!"#63?7
,76!#:"$23"$ #5&"$ 7#4!#$!" 6 G!6 #8!#
5 "##B 3 7 76 "#$
5# ?76# 3# #$ "33 $5#:
!#7 3#8!:646 "7# =#33< = 3:!#4###5 # 3:# # !6 #8!:4=#76##6"#63 5#66 < #$5# 63#"4 6 "7# =#33<$!: ## <4###455#3#$ 3 !!#$ 66 ! 7"#<#3#:4!!"#63?74 3 "##B 3 7 76 "#$ 3 ?76# 3# ..
7!3 < 56## =#6 7 3 #8!:76!#:"$76#3"$ !3<$#5!5# ! =!3 ,76!#:"$ !33 < 6 "7 #6#764#8!#!#$76:
,, 63#"7## 4 4##"77 7#D7#$# 5#=!#$ 7#3## #8!6 ##$6 !3#"3:466#!3# #$ #3#?766:4 # =#$" !!5# !46 3#!"
36#= 63#"
5#= < 54=(
#" ## ?7733=!"
364 5 < 5" !3:=<: #<!3 7733 33 < #3 6 " ! 6 "7# 3 $=## AC7!" " #3#$ 63#"7## #333## " !
77373:33 =4# #"
#$ %&' () 8
-&.
/
0 /