High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32967/2017dismissed

Anoop Singh Kahlon v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-09-12Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa9 pages

!" #$%&'"($)' *+"(+ ",-+.*+/+$0$)'

"".-1232 +**"+ 4+

-**+"( 56/7"*2+ ."7+*

!" #$%8"($)' 9*-12 +**"+ 4+

-**+"( 56/7"*2+ ."7+*

!" ###8"($)'

.++*-12:

+**"+ 4+

-**+"( 56/7"*2+ ."7+*

;

!" ##;"($)' 4*-12: +**"+ 4+

-**+"( 56/7"*2+ ."7+*

!" ##;&"($)' //-12 +**"+ 4+

-**+"( 56/7"*2+ ."7+*

+ +*, 7++.=>074"*+0("*2+.+**"+?

@ ! !

? @ 2 "7+

7 ."

+ "(

#$%&'0 #$%80###80##;##;&"($)'0

( +757+-+*";8$"( 0 ++>1* (+"(4+ *1*""(?@ " ;<7*+7)# )# $)# 57+-+*" 80$0$$0$<!0$'0$'!0$%0&08<"(*2+ -*A $<B<;B<%!"(*2+ *7;$)0;&<0;&'0;&80;'0$)0$)!"( 0+1 *++7* +-**" *+212-2/A?@ " ;$7*+7 $$ )# $)#+1 *++757+-+*" $$0$<"(*2+ -** +

-**" -270 ** *+212 -2/0 7 ?@ " &% 7*+7 )8 )# $)#0 +1 *++7 57+ -+*" $B$$B&B8< "( - * 7 -+*"#"( ** - 7"/7120 ** *+212 -2/0 *" *2+ +* 5+5 "( 4+ *1*" 0 "71 *" *2+ .+**"+ 0*2+(5*2+4+ *1*"+7"5*/C*2+-.+ 4+ *1*" +?-@"( 56/ +09229 " **5*+7/C*2 "5*47+ "7+7*+7)' ) $)<9 "*" "+9*2*2+7+*" "*+7 *2+ 7"7+ $ 2"512*2+

+1*" 7(* 922 +7*"*2++1 **" "(/"4+!+*"+7

+ *"1+*2+7((++*0+4+*2+

*2++ "" *C*"*2++D*+**2*

*2+*2++

.+**"*2+("5

E751 E922*2+ 56/ + *"24+5+*2+7*"+D."

+*2+ "

!/"7+

*751*7+ # +"(*2+.+**"+?

.++*-12:

@7+ "*2+ .+* ..+2+7+7 /C 56/ + 27 + + ( +7 *2+ + .+*4+ +**" BF*!

+**" 0 ++>17+* + +( "(* (+"(4+ *1*""(*2+/"4+!+*"+7*2++

"19*2 *9""+

0*"*2++* 5+5"(4+ *1*" *2+C77"*+D.+* C(4+ *1*"/C*2+ 56/ + 2 "5** "7+7*+7 )' ) $)<.

+7 !""!#$%&'()*+ + ),,,-./00 /!# *1 2!

,/0@*"">"*+"(*2+

+1*" 1 **2+ "

+." #87#%"(*2+ 7"7+*2+("

"919"7 ,!

G ?#8@ 74+*1*"*2+

+1*" +4+ +7/C*2+ .+**"+ 1 **2+ " ."

+0*C/+ ++*2**2+

+"!"

*"((+5 +7"((

*1"+"( *2+?

.++*-12:

@ **+7 C*2+ >"(E-+"-5.+*+7+*"( +E +2 +*2+ /+++7".

+7+7 .*C+ ."7+* 2+

"*2+."

+"((+ (1 5 *" +"+- *2++ .+*" 7 "+ -5/ .+*" 0 92" + 7+*

C."

*+7 - "(*2+."

+ **" 92++

5/6+*

24+/+++1 *++77B"++/+ "( -.+ 4+ *1*1+ 2+ +7+"( 56/ -**+". "+*2<) - ((+ "5*"(92" * + *&< ((+ +*2+> "( 0

+* * 9"5 7 /+ *"" 5(0 7 565 *(+7 *"

.+ 5+*2*"+"(*2+ + +""((+ /"4+!/"7 "*2*+2"+2 55/+7*" "+277+.+

5+ 922*2+.+**"+ 24+ +/ C( +7*"7

?#%@ *"(*2+.+**"+ ++ "5+(5 .+

C "( *2+ + (( 5+* +*+.++5 92" 24+ ( "5 21 /5 +

0 7+7 .".+*+ 7 2"

7((++*."**."

*" 2++ "+ */ 2+7" /+ +4/ +2 *"C"(. *"

*C/+*9++*2+7 *2+."

+"((

4+ *1*1*2+ + ; (*+" 7+1*2+4 "*+*" *2 "5*."++7+7*"

57+ ("

"9 ,!

G ?&%@4+9"(*2+/"4+7

"0* 2+ 7*2* +4+ 55 *4++((+*"(

*2+"*+*" +7 "*2+/+2 (0*2+.+**"+ 24+( +7*">+"5* +9*2*2"

++D+.*" 5 *+ 92++*2

"5*+*2+0+D+ +"(* 9*65 7*"57+ * +$$&"(*2+" **5*""2++*."9+ 57+ -+*";8$ 0+*5 **2+ +**+ ("(+ 2" +!4+ *1*" *" " C "*2+ 1+C 2+ .+**" ++ ** C7

+77*2+*+"7+

*C1*2+* "5*."++71 +4*+77*2+ -.+ "5* +7+*+7*"."++79*2*2+ "7+9*2 9 5/6+**"*2++((+*"(7+*"

5+72++(*+ H

< 2 "5*0 "+!*2+!

0 "*+7 "+ 7+(++ *2+ 4+ *1*"."+

7 5I+7*2+." ?'@ C1*2*,!

G ?'@412+ 7*2*09+"*+("5 4+

(""/ +41*2**2"512*2+.+**"+ 24+( +7*"

>+"5* +("(+ 2"+!

+ *1*"+7"5*/C*2+ 56/ +

> +*(+*2"7"

"1C""7+*+2J5+

C*" *2+."(+

>+751

"7 ?@2++2 /++..+* >"("*+*0 7+ /+*+""*2+9 +0 +51.+2/ +" .+/ ++47++"(7+.+7+**5+A ?@2+++ "+ "".2"

71.

092+*2+ +(* 7+ /+*+ C""*2+9 +A ?4@2++..+ *"/+7((++*7 > *+ ***57+"*2+.*"( +"."

+"((+ 92"

12* /+ ".*4+ C 9+

!4+ +7 9*2 *2+

++ "( "* 751 " .

C2"*".

5/ *+ +* A ?4@ 2++ 5+D.

+7 ++"*2++(("* 0( C07+ (*+ *2+ C+ $)#!;0 *" / *2+ "1I+7751*((>++ ?4@ " +4 5*" "( +1 0 "1 7 "1!

>1+/+*9++"+ +*""*2+/C9C"( +7/ +"7

/ ++47++..+ *"24+ /++7+ H & 2++(*+0*2 "5*" 57+7 ("

"9 ,!

G ?'$@ 7 .5*/ + *2* ++ /" *1 "( +"4+C"5+*21*2+751!/5 +

9"*25.++

*2"5 7 "+"/71"+"*2+"*2+5 +7

*2+>1. +*2+*2+( *"*2+ * *2+

"(( "( *2 ++ 2+ 212 > ."

+ "((+ .+(+/ C9*2 .+ I+7*1 "512**"24+*>+ *2+

"" *2+( * +9 7+*+*+7 2++"5 /+ /+**+ ""7*" "* " C /+*9++ *!7 ** ."

+/5*9*2*2+1++ "(+12/"51-**+

-+*2+ 2724+/++14+ "52 .5/ *C (

*751 9"5 7+4+ 5(+*2+ -**+"( 56/0* *2+75*C"( +7 **"*"

+ 5+*2*+4+C + *>+*"* "1 " " -"+*C2 (57+* 2512**" 4+(++(" 751 2+ ( 5+ "( *2+ ."

+5*" 1+C *" +7 +7/ ++47++ " *"/1*2+15 *2"++4+C +9"5 7 +7*""

*1"I17 .."*+*7 (5 **" .++ "41*I+ 2+5..++2+

*2+ +*25 ++7*"+7*2+ 4+ "(*2+ 75*+ *2+ **+ +"( 97"7+2+C ?'#@-+

*2+".."*5*+ 24+"*1"+"5*"( 277++

C 5+ *

/+(

+7*2"512

5..

++*C+."* 07(

+5 *" ?(C@ /+7"..+709+7+**2+-**+"( 56/0*2+*++ * "(".

+*+65 *+0*" " **5*+-5.+4 "C+ ". 1*2+("

"91*2++ - ((+ 92"

9*2 "(*2+++.*"(".C"(*2 "7+*>+

*"> "( *2+ *5*" 7 +D+ *2+ 21+!

2++*

+7C( +7+2"(*2+ 5/6+*

?@-2 9-120 !5!+*"0-**+"* 5+5A ?@-* = ++60 -0 !5!+*"0=1 + 5+50 56/A ?@-2 1+ 9 "0 -0 + 2+*+

+!4 **2+

**4+ C."*+7 "5*.!'"(*2 "7+7 *>+*2+++

C ++7 *+.

?';@2+ ** +"*2+4+ *1*1 ((+

+ *+7*"*2+ - 922+*2+ 5/6+*!**+

"(*2+ +."++71 0+7+*+7*"."75+".

+*+ +"7 /+("+ *2+ ("+ 7 *+0 922

*2+ 7+*(C*2+

1 > 0 >"(.""("*2++47++ 922"5 7/++7/ +/5*2 "*/++"

+*+7" 7+.*"(*2++"7(" "+"/4"5 + (*2+ -5.+4 "C+(7 C*+ 922C

* *2+ -.+ "5* *" 4+ * 65 * 7+ "0 *2+ -5.+4 "C +0

/+ * /+*C *" 5/*

5..

++*C +."* ."

*4+ C /C # * ++/+0 $)< *2 ."+

"(+!+D*"0+" 7+*" "(5*2+4+ *1*"0(*2+-5.+4 "C+ (5

* (+7*2*"*+4+

+ 7+"5* 1 *C"(*2+ .+* 1 *92"21+!

2++* +/++ 5/**+70*

/+(++*"14+ 52 "." *2+ 5..

++*C +."* 7+*+7 /"4+ H ' * **+"(+"7*2**2+-". 1*2++ +" "((+ *2+>"( .+*"++ "( +0 " **5*+747+. " '#"(*2+"7+7*+7)' ) $)<(5*2+4+ *1*+7

*2+

*2+ 751 + *+7 72 5/**+7 5..

++*C2

" **+"(+"7*2*(+9 0-77"*(7C"1+*.""("( 4"

4++*"(*2+ .+* 72 +"+7+7*2+7 21+ "

* "(*2+ 02"9+4+0*2+-2 5/**+7 5..

++*C2

8 2+ .+**"+ + "1 * *2"

+ 1 * 92" - 2

5/**+7 5..

++*C2

2+1+4+ *2**2+-2 ( +7 *"" 7+72 *2+"4+!

"">+7*2+*+ .++"(+47++ + *"(922*2+C+/+1("+7 *"(+*2+."**+7* 2+ .+**"+ *25 "*+7*2*7+ "((4+ *1*" 7+ "(*2+ (57+* 12**" (+7 /+*C15*++757+* +$"(*2+ " **5*"

% F+ 24+ ."7++7 "4+ *2+ 5/

" 7+ /C ++7 "5 ("*2+.+**"+ 92"2+4 C+ + 5."*2+.+4"5 7+ ""( *2 "5* 7*+7 )' ) $)< )*+ + ), ,,- 0 30/ (045 92++57+*2+-9 " **5*+7 * 51+7*2**2+4+C.5."

+"(*

**5*" *7 7+(+*+792+*2+-2 ( +7*"" 7+*2+1 1

5+*2+."

+5*" ) * 02"9+4+0( C7**+7*2**2+* 1 *"

*"(*2+ .+**"+ "9**2+ *1+"(."

+5*"+47++7"

*"(*2+ 9*+

.+*2+"1 2

24+/++ +7C+D+70+D+.**2+ 77*" 9*+

0(C0*"/++D+7.5 5**"*2+ 5..

++*C

5/**+7 /C *2+ - 2+ J5+ *" 922 *25 (

(" 7+*" 92+*2+*2 "5***2 65*5+ 2"5 717+* +4+ *1*""(5*2+4+ *1*""(*2+ /C*2+-7B"C "*2+1+CK2+ 9+*"*2 J5+ *"0"5" 7++74+902 /++ +((+*4+ C14+/C*2 "5**2+ "7+7*+7)' ) $)<.

+7 16*-1222 +?

5.@ *9"5 7/+5 +(5 *"+(+*".!&8"( *2*"7+922+7 57+,!

G ?&8@* *5+*2**2+( 1"(21+!

2++*57+ -+*" '# "(1"(21+ "+9

"* 74+ * " **5*" "5* (" 7+*1 +!

4+ *1*"/C"*2+1+C 2 "5*02"9+4+0 "* "4+ ""> *2+ (* *2* " ".

+*" "( 4+ *1*"0*2+."

+2 +7C 5/**+721+!

2++*

*2+ 5/6+**"C 5..

++*C+."* 922C/+ 5/**+757+-+*"'#?8@

"+"(*2+ 0."

+5*"2 +7C **+7*

+47++ *2+ / ++ "( C +D+.*"

5 *+ 92++*2 "5*5 **+4++77"

+*+65 *+09++ * (+7*2* *2+..".*+

+"5 +**2 *1+ *"("

"9*2+7*5?@ 7?@

5.@72"

7*2**2+ ."9+ *" +(+ + (" (5*2+ 4+ *1*" *" 7+.+7+*1+C >+0"512*"**"/+4">+7 (*+( 1"(*2+21+!

2++*/C*2+ " ."

+ H 2+* *2+ + 2 (*"

+7C *1+ (*+*2+ "7+7*+7)' ) $)<9 .

+7 7

+7/"4+06"*C"(*2+ 9*+

.+*2+"1 2

24+/+++D+7 F+ ++"

+ "*"7+*(5*2+4+ *1*""(*2+ **2 *1++ .+

92+ *2+ .+**"+ 9

1+* +((+*4+ ".."*5*C *" +7 7+(++ +47++92++*2+C9+

."4+92**2+C24+

+*+7*2+ +.+**"

*1"+ 9*2"5* C1*2**2+7+(+++47++*"/+ +7/C*2+.+**"+

/+ 7 .

"*+ C " 7++7 /C *2+ * "5* 9*2"5* /+1 ( 5++7/C*2+"/ +4*" 7+/C*2 "5**2+.+4"5 "*2

"7+ $ 2+**+/+4+9+7("C+*"*2+1 +

" 2+ D+*C"(*2+.+**"+ *" +5++D"+*" 57+ *7/ + 5* 52 +D.+**" +*2+ +1**+"* "*2+ *2+9*212**" ++> +.+*+7B(+ 2B(5*2+4+ *1*"*

52*+*2+4+ *1*11+C 7"+ "*2"

7*2+"+*7+"+7*2+7 21+ ( 52 +"5 +

"9+7*"/+7".*+70*9"5 7"5**" >1*2+-*"

5+*2+"

+"(-.+ 571+57+*2+ -*7.""5+*2+ 4+7*"*2+.+**"+ E (!.++4+7"++ 2* "**2+ ".+"( (+ 24+ *1*"57+-+*"'#?8@"*2+2++*."9+ "(*2

"5* 57+ -+*" ;8$ "( +7 9*2 * + $$& "( *2+ " **5*" # *2+ 12*"(*2+/"4+7

"0+79*2*2+7+* +7

1+716*-1222 +?

5.@0"5.

+79*2*2+(* *2** *2+ ** +".

+*"7

">++.14+9*2+ 4 / *C"(+((+*4+++7C*"*2+.+**"+ **2+*+"( +71*2+ 7+(+++47++09++ * (+7*2*" +"(+!4+ *1*""(5*2+ 4+ *1*" 7+"5* 2+ +.+**" +*25 7

+7 ; 2+"/ +4*" 7+2++!/"4++" C("*2+.5."

"(7+71*2+ +.+**" 7

24+"/+1"*2++* "(*2+ .+71*

!" ##;"($)'?4*-12: 4+ -**+"( 56/7"*2+ @0 /+*C 1*+7*"*2+.+**"+*"

+1+*2+"7+7*+7$< )< $)'/C9C"( +.*+7..".*+ ."++71 & 7++7"71 6 7 8 -+.*+/+$0$)'

6 8