High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33902/2018allowed

Sucha Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2018-10-01Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal5 pages

! "#$%"&'()*+,-)#*'-)%#.#,

" # $%&&'()("&* " $" + '( ) "'( % +, $"-.& ()""* / #*'-)%#.#,/*0"#(1 &* % 0! &"1 ' "%" &, '"2%& 3 // !

5"3"% "

- 004(/ /(/ 6( 0! 05& '7"&"8& 89( '- ': &%&" (".*%"&' 06 !

5 "3" % " - / ;(/ /(/ 0( 0!( 05 ' - ': &%&" ( " .*%"&' '' '

3" 3&""1( &,1*"1 0

<"" !

!(&*":""**"

,"&"'%"=''2$3"("3 3&"1 ""> &3 % &1*"1 1*' &"("*"%'

$3" '( -%' *%" ?&

!( & , ")( :&" (&, &&1*"1""),: &*" 3 % ()'% "@(:&% @" "% % '% &""1 * 33 &1 &%'11(,+) 3''3'@1" ' &' '?:"2%" '@ %"&**' &)3& :&&&"+%*"&""3&*"*"@("3&' ',"@

&""3&%"&1,@&'3'@1&)'*%"& ',: :*"(&) 3'")" "&'""('

&"1 @"&@%& ,'%"13) &*" ' &" *% ,@ 1*"1( %"( 1 3 :& " '3'

:'':)"(&"1 '*% "'@"" &1') '@:*"&*% "1&"*( &"1 ' &" ) %*

&@'"3&""(&':*"",*% &1 ()"*% &1 &A"1*% &1 ( '% 3&* '@""1 ' :)"1" &)'*%" "B ' : *" " "1 &1') "1 ' * &""( & '3'

@1*'@1*""')& ',: :*">:&& C %" 3 & & )" 1* *% 2% @ '"3 1 1D%''&""')& ',: :,@ *% 3"&""() &"1 '':"2%"3)%"3" &:&&*"*% 3 D 3&*" *' '@(&

'3'-@1'*")""3 D 3&1*"1,: : "1 '*%- "

A*"*") &"3"& '@ *") " 1*% 3 %" 3 & "'( ,% *"1 1*% 3) **''"") '3:)",@)"@ %" *( - / "

, & ' "*"@> :&" & 1*"1 ,: & *" &)> "'@> , & "' '@& *"",% "&

'&""'1" *"",% ) & A & :1 ""111(1C &A 3 ,'3&""" 3 ) :1'*" " , 3 "3 ): & '3' ) 1 &

"2%"& "'C 3,@ - "

&1*"1,: &*"*%%1 @&*"%"*"",""1 '"'>&"'%"

, *"1")',@ &**"",% "&*"%" &

" )C 3- 0! "

,@&3&%" %(,"),)(&:& '@*"&"1 *%:%' ':@,% "1 "1 '"' ):& * (' "%,'>&" %:%'&)'2%&@ '"3&""& 11,@*" )') 3)"

1 " " 2%" 3 ' *:" " :&' A" 3 *:"

,*"1,1*"1?C:() & )') '@ : *") *" ( ,% "' 3 *")@ &"" " )') % '''"% ''*"*"@,@A 11 &"''>

,*"1,1*"1A* &,)1 3") (&")"@" &''&" &%',*"1,1*"1,@&%"- &*" ,"&%"(3 :%' )')& %&*"*%( &""&%" *"1&1,1*"1& &*" :%' *'@"C%* &%" %"&2%'%,@ %,)" 3&1 " "1 '+% )" & " 1 " "1 '+%"&D '"

*&"C 3 ,*'@%* %"%,)"&+%@1-:%' ':@, & "+%'>&&1*"1,: &*" "3 D &D "1 1" 11& ' &@11 " +%('(2%& (:&&& "@ *"1,1*"1 8,'&-%*"1%"&1*'@'"&'3'*

D 31*"1 & - 3&<- % +, &"(

709 7"1 '960/( &,")% "#B E64&* &1"3"1&,)% , %11"&%#&*:"&3&%" 2%& 3"1 3" "1*' A" &" +%"

" "1&*:"3) "1 '%""

1*% 3& % & &" *:":*' %:& %"@'1 ,%& ,A" ":&&3%' 3" %&*:"

)D>79%"& +%"79*") ,%& *" @%" :&*:"2%&&"1 3 " 1*' " 1@ , A" :&" & " )1&)'&"*%:%'* "%1 & 3"@ , *"",:)"(,"A"%&*:"(&3&%" 1%&)%"3"& %" 3")@&"1 % "% 1 '*")@" 'C1%""( "*(@(

, 3'@2%&) &%3&&)1 ")181'@ & "&)'&*%-%& " *") %" &)"%1* @ -1'"'@( @ 1*"1 ,: & )1 "

"' & % "*'%'C ") ""%* "& 11,@*%,'") :&' :"C 3 & *@ >

*") " @ , "

2%& 3 "1 ' *" 3 )') 3 %& % & "1 ' &) 3 )":&'1 3'@ *"1 3'@ )'

')%" " 3 " &*%"* 2%& 3( *"%'"'@ & " 3 "1 11"'( '( 1" '()'(*" "&*"%&'C" "& " 3 % 1"1 @ "' 3 :"@( " & 1'@ *%:&"&:" 3,''@*")"*" ' %" &*"&)"')&" "*% &3"@ (3&%"1@2%&"1 '*" 3 ):( ,%&1*"1,: & " )1(& *,'@ ) "1 ,'C %

"1 ':%'*%%3"**" *"+% A"1 +%:%',%&1,@ 2%& 3& "1 '*%'' 1*''1 1*"1 :& & )1 &" :"( & 3& %" 1% "

:&&":%',% "" ""@& "+% %:&&"1 '*" 3" % &"1 3:%' 1% ,%*"':* '1 1*"1,: &)1 :" 3" :&&"%"& +%(**"*"&"1 *% & :"&,)2% 79

"1)(&3&%"&'',:'':& +%" 2%&&"1 '*" 3F &*" '' @ &A* )3 ,) ( ):&"*"%'$3"'(-%' *%"

!1 *%"% &"" !

!* ,@&%"(&%"'& %%'*%"*:%',"),@C* &*" 3'):'', & "+%(&'1 "& ,: &*"* " 3'@( & *" * '': // !

5"3"% 004(/ /(/ 6( 0! 05&

'7"&"8& 89( '- ': &%&" (" .*%"&' 06 !

5 "3" % " - / ;(/ /(/ 0( 0!( 05 '- ': &%&" (" .*%"&'' 3:&'' '*" 3" 3&""1&",@ 2%&2%&*" * " 0#*'-)%#.#,1 *+45)

G&&"*C 3=" # G&&" *",'#