(O&M) Bhupiner Singh And ORS. v. M.C.Rampura Phul & ORS.
!"
#$#%&#' () *
%()(+),#' () *
#" $
%%%
!"
&'(
$
) **
%%%
++++
! -. ! / 0.
(, % , ' #
- .
/%01 2%
%% %3 #
- .
/%4%
% 5#
- 6
% #
- .
/%0%
%'%3% #
- % - #
- % " #
- .
/%8
%
++++ / 0.
1 0%
"" ) "
. .
"
.
9
:
! ".! $ !!$#( .
"
"
.
. % ("
-
- ;
() ) #
!!$
)
.
) ",% <%
= .
# .
(* "" ) "
.
" (2 #
93+45)'#% 5)63 5),# #,#7$#'" 3%(+63 5$ .$ 7)'
83#%$ &$ !+)5,5479 (::588##1 7:4+%7 7)' )(83#%:#"
-
,
- .% 5-
"
(
," # . (2
- . ) (
% 8%
(
) "
>?%><%0??@
' # #
3+45)'#% 5)63 7)'
83#%$ &$
!+)5,5479 (::588##1 7:4+%7 7)' )(83#% , "
) "
#
' .. "
.
(' #$ #6 "
.
A .. 5&59 +58 ( * (2 % 1% ..
.
6
9 "
3 /%B<1#
6
. " #
C
D # .
" "
""
" #(
),
( ." .
"" "" %
# (
. ,#
. . .
#6
,(
E
(,C D.
"" ,. %F
.
" - #
" ( .
-
. -
%
6
.
#" #
.
# , 6. #
#
% #
,
6
-
"
6
D
#
"* .. .
"
6 ,
,%
#
(,( 6
.
#
(
- .
(
.. "" ,%6
# - 6.
D 6
6. "#
6
"
* )
. .
.
- .
.
" -
,% :
4% 6
A
"
6 9
6. 6
. " 3 /%B<1#6(
,
E
(
%G
- , #
# -
,%
.
(" .
.
/%<
"
) #6 6.
, )
D(
;!
"%$
# !""
#H
E -
,
/%<D.
6
,.
"
# "
)
#-
#- 6 .
,
,
%
#
.
#
" (
#(
(,
6# , ) . !- # , "
( "
6%:
2%
A .. ( = , .
# 6 , =-
,
.. "
"
#6
.
,
, # -
#
.
.
# #
6 "
% .
;" . -
#
!
.
"
.
6 .
) 0% F
..
6
.
,I $$% <% F
" (
. "I$% 8% F
!- ) ,I$% 1% F
..
) ,
I$$ 4%
.% B% 6
..
"
,
.
- "%J .
.
. #
(' #$ # "
6%
* (,) "
#
.
' # #66 * 6 "
#
(, .. "
. # (
C
! "
# $ %&
"
&
"
&
%
'
D% @% !
"
) "
.
H
#
-
# 66 , "
%/ 6
# 6
#
. 6
6
=
,
(, ! % ?%
( = ,#
A
/%<#1# 4.
!!$ /%28<.<>01
#
6
. "
6
0<%>B%0???))#;+%#
(,!
/%@80.0??@%
-
6 " 9
# '( #
. " $ # " $ # #("
- 6
.
,-
0<%>B%0???
;
$0
(, D(
/%@80.0??@#
" = .
,%
3 /%B<1# 3 /%040>#
( # 6.
.
" # .
#
# . ( ,
6 # 6
. ""
%
.
" , !""
#
;
$< K $8#
6
, (,
" 6
5
6 # # 6
;
$1%
(
. . D
". #"*
(
"
! ".
! %:
0>% J . #
-
/%0 <.
6
,# (
/%0 <
#(
/%8 %
- .
.
(,
/%0 <
9#49< () =#3792 (2 %#$4()'#)8 ( 7>479 5)63 !7??7%1 ;#,+85() 225,#% (2 !+)5,5479 (::588##1 7:4+%7 3+9
" # ; .
, "
#
%
"
.
" 6
. D(
# " -
%
, 6.
,6
(,
#" $ #6
D "
- ,.
" .
(,.
" .6
6
#
;
0A06 6 *6
.
- ; (,5
6
# 6- D
%
.
6"
(
( "
%:
@ A#49< () =#3792 (2 %#$4()'#)8 ( 744< 7)$791 ;
%#$5'#)8 767% (+),591 7:4+%7 3+91 7)87 (9()<1 5$8%5,8 7835)'7
" # ; .
, "
#
,
%
"
.
, "
6
.! # " -
"
%
, 6.
,6
(, ! # " $ # 6
D "
- ,.
6 " .
(,.
%
" .6
6
.
.
,
7 ))#;+%# B
" 6 * 6
.
- ; (,5
6
#6 - ,!
%
-
#
D
(
#
"$
<0%>B%<>08
;
<A<# , !""
D
<4%>B%<>08%
,# 6"
(
(
"
%: 00% G-
#
(" -
.
,
;.
#
# . . (
6%
(
"
, ;"
- -
6
"
) "
..
.
" ,
. ",#
#
,6
0<%
. # 6
. 6 $ )( , #
(
10. $ )(! #0?0@
0>>!$!%
( "
) "
.
"
. 7)?7>7?$35 #7'" 83%(+63 .$ 7)' (83#%$ /B$ 37)'%5?7 7)' (83#%$1 "
*@#.
6
(, ) "
.C5%('5 $5),# '#,#7$#'" 83%(+63 35$ . /B$ 7:
7%?7$3 7)' (83#%$1 "
@ 7)' 78#)'#% 7)' (83#%$ /B$ 7%(> 7)' (83#%$1 " ,79# %
, 6 6 .
) "
# = . 6
=
( .
"
08%
= ,
"
,
(
6- .
-
, ,"6
#
,(,
- . $ )(
!"" #0?20
.
9 :% G 6
"
;
. #
# -
% 6 , #
"E
<-. ; ,
.
" , 6
"" (
.. -
"" , E
# #
"" %! = ,#( .
, .
(
E
#"( .. "-
, -
#(,
# 6
""
, E
-
.. -
% "
. 6 ".
# ,
;",
# #
.#)., .
%
6" -37:978 #3- (% ,37%7)' 5),9+'#$ 0
(
"
; L (
L% <
8
1
.. -
"" ,
# # , # #
* 6
#
6 (
% 4
08%<%
.
"
) "
.
H
"
.
%G6
.
,(
-
#" $ # ,
, (
%
#6
#.
<-. $ )(
!"" #0?20#
, ( .
,
.6
E
"" (
. -
"" ,%G ( .
#
" ."" 6
(
6 #
, , , -
08%8%
!"#$
% &' (
) * + ,-.
"
!"#$
/0.
1
2
3
3
/0$
"
5
/06
5
# 7
3 01%
# "
. .
"
-
# - ,
.
D("
. . (
6(
, .
,6
.
%G
.
# "
, .
.
/%<# &'( #
#"
=- " * 6
, * 6 9
(E :
6 3 /%B<1% " #(
#- ,# "(# ( -
( "
6% )
" # 6
# -
,
D
. ; - 6
-
,% 01%<% H
#
6 ! D
"
"
#6 , =-
,
.,
,. " .
9
(E :
6 3 /%B<1%
#6 ("
#
..
#
."
" #
,
" .
6%
#
# - .
,
(
"
,
(
.
,- .
( "
- , "
(,
01%8% G6.
D "
"
" .
"
"(
- 6.
6
(
%-
-
" #
,
.
"* 6 * 6
"
% " #( "
.."
)
# -
6(
"
.
% 01%1%
.
"
#6 ;"
. "
,
,
#
D "
,
" .
(E
6
, (
#( 6 .% 6
# #
.
, . "
, (
.-
.
#
D
.
(, -
, " -
(
01%4% G - 6 . .
# 6
.
' #
,. " .
(E "
3 /%B<1 -
!""
#" $ #
.
,).
#6
#
(,
,
%
D
#(
- ."
, ( , - .
#
"
04% .
- -
,# $ /%2.
"
6.
( )
%
* +, -, . / ! & )
! &
& ! 0 & 1
& 1
% "
%
3
%
& ! 0
*
" )
4, 2 4-5 " 6 % 1
7824(
1 "
2 " "
04%0% " -
"
. #
, - 6 ( . , . .
,
/%< #6 .
. ..
/%< %G
(
.
/%<# 6
#6 " ,() - .
.
.
/%<#6
- ,
"
D(
"
% 6
-
.%!""
#H
E #
02%00%0?@B M;%8# .
,
6
"
. " *
# " 6
. D(
"
! # 6
=
-
" . 6%
#.
( = , 04%>0%0?@@# $ /%2# .
,
E
.
/%<#
, " .
#6
(
% 04%<% H
#-
$ /%8.
, E
"" %
- .$ /%8
6.
- )
%
! 0 & "
! 0 & )
! & 04%8% G
6
.
, (
"-
,%
(
6-
,
E
. .. -
, . .
,%
H
! ,
,(
"" # "
.. $ /%8. %
,"
6
.
#" $ #.
"0?1?# ( "
. 5 "$ ,#6
. "
5 "$ ,-
.
,
$ /% @ . H
! D ) "
% 02% G
-
/#<#6.
. ..
/%< "
(
() 6(
6 6
.
,
M;%4%
.
"
"" ..
. "
,
*
! "
# (
,.
6 ) .
(,0?4># "* (
(, - . $ )(
!"" # 0?20
(
H
# . ..
( (
6 6 , . . # ;
/%<#66
( E
!""
! = ,# ( . , ,
.- .
( #
,-
#" $ 02%0% G .
-
#
# . .
6
! #
- .
( ,-
6
% #
.
# *"
,
(,C'5$:5$$#'D% " .. "
6
(
-
(
6
, # .
, ).
#
. , " .
% 0B% J
. ,.
#
;
(
( "
#
#" $ #
" -
, .
, - .
. ! % .
,
"
*
,
"
)
(,! %G ( . ,"
- .
"
(
- . D
#
!!$ (
%! = ,#-
*."
,. # !!$
(, C'5$:5$$#'D% " .. "
6 (
-
D #
#
" 6
(
(
) # .
6
% 0@% ! = . ) . "
#
"
#. ,#.
6 .
!!$#
(,
.
6
%/.
,#
.
6 .
0?%
,.) "
.
" #.
"
#
- ,.
.
% / 0."
* 7+%7& (%(8 Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No 8
9 : ;+