Krishan Kumar v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited And Others



  
 



!

 "

!  

!#$

!$%&'& () )  
 

    




  

 

 

*


 

    




  

 

 
 +( , - + )

.


.  .  





 

 !

"
 

# $%&'()
"
*&%+

,
- .

 !

"
 

# $/&*0)
"
*&**

 
 
 !

"
 



 !

!






.  . 

/

) 012* 
 

, 

1 
-

! 
"


"

 
!

 23 !
 

2
 

  




! 1








(
" 
"
 5
 
 1

 

2

 
 ""


2 

! 1

 ! 6
2 "
"!
"

 
!

 %$ 




  
 " 

2 "

 


 78

 

 


"
 !1

! 
"  5
  

3
5
5 
 5
,
55
" 2 
"
!. 
"
%( *
,1
"
%0&&
! 



1 1



9!
-
:.
" !
!


- ! 
(
-
 
 
 5
1 !.
2.
 


-
!



; .
*&%/

" 
-


4
(

 

2
 1

" 
 5
1 !.

!  .



# $%&'()
"
*&%+

2


" 
2.


 
 "

2


 
*&%+


,1
!!


"
  




(
:


 

2


!

 !
!


2 

.

1 <!


"
  # $/&*0)
"
*&**

2


" 
2.


 
 "

1

 
*&** ,1

 
.


"
!!


"






(
6
 

 

2

"
 ! 


!
 1
 !
!


-!

, 
!



.


*&%%
" 

 



2


 
2 

-  !!

" 

 !
!




"


-
 
" 
2.

 

"

2

 

# $%&'()
"
*&%+

!!

 
2


" 
" 

 .
"
=
.


"


"
!

1
"

 5
  


(


"

-
 
" 
2.


 

"

1
 

# $/&*0)
"
*&**
 !!

-
-
 

2

"

! 

 ! !




2


" 
" 
 .
"
 
1 
,  2.
2
 

 
  6
 

# $%&'()
"
*&%+

&* &) *&%+

, 
"



".

"! 


 1




2.
 

1
)
"

-
 
2.

-!

-
 




1
1
-
1
 1-




!
 2.





"
  
2.
  "  
-
, 
 1

- 

 -
, 

"
 1

&'

&% *&*/
2.

 
   1

2 "
"
 

2
 

 2 




"
2! 
 =  $%
-!

! 
-
2
! .

 
-
23 !
>.

1
 

!!
- 
 

2
1-
-
 5
2 
  1

 !.


 1

 
1-
 
 ! .
-

 !"!
"

"
 5
!. 
2 ! 
"
 
1-

2 
%
,
" 





! !1

2 
1-

 


!
2


"
!. 
" 


1-

! ?

.





!




,
 !. 
"
1-
2 ! 


 .


 ? 

" 
-
23 !
 
2.
2
 
"
 

 -
  
2.
 
 1

2 "
"



:-


 

" 
 1

 
"

 


2
"

23 !
"
 
"



 

!




 !




" 
  

 


 
"
3 !


-
, 
  2 
 
" 
1




 !

"


""!


"



- 



 !

"
 

2

! 




-

"=
@
-
"  
 ! 

 

 2 
1-

1
-
 1

 
- 23 !


6 "

 
"

!




2

 !

 
2.

 





"
 1
 
" 

 1



   
4


" 
.

23 !

 

  
"
 
 
-


! 



1 
 

2
 
23 ! 

"
 
 

  !



 $
A/

6

"
 !
-!
-

2
!

 
-
 A-

.
1$ 
!!
-
1
2
1-




!

.
1$ 
!!

-


 

1-
 
-


2 -


1-


1$ 
!!
-
@

 2 

1$ 
!!
-

1
2
1-

> 


6"


"
*C

 


!

"
''
"

<*& %%


"
2 .
-
"

1-

>
,
! 
"

:82
 
1 !!, 

&0 &% *&*/
-1

2

"!
 ! 
 -

 = 
$/
!.



3 (

6
 !
 !
-!
-

2
!

 
- 
A-


= 
2 -


 
 

1-

-


-
"


 1

 1-



- 





B
@
 1


 2 


= 
2 -








1-

*&&

 @

"  
 2 



-
 !
 

 
<-.<1 
 1


1- -
"

 !
<-.<1
 1

 1-
-!

1

!

=  .
%%
"

</ /C


-

-
"

 !
<-.
 1

1-
-!

 


1
1

!
 =  .
%(
"

<( *'


-

>  $ 


 2.
 2 

2
 -.<1 
 1


1-





D -

! 
!
.< 







.
2
 !2 


1


 1
 ! 
 -

 = 
$(
!.



1


2


! 
1-
 
6  

   
 
" 
2.



"

 "
23 !
 1

 = !

"
1$ 
- 

 1-

!!





1$ 
- 

1
2
1-
:-



"

*C

 


!

"
''
"

<*& %%


"
2 .

-
"

1-

1
 11



!  "

 !
23 !
 1


1 <
 1

 1-
" 


!!



2



  

 = 
2 -


 



1-

*&&



 6
-
, !
 

 
<-.<1 
 1

 1-
-
"

 !

 1


1-
-!
 1

!

=  .
%%
"

</ /C


-


-
"

 !

 1


1-
-!

 

  
"
 
1

=  .
%(
"

<( *'


-

>  



2



 


 

2
 -.<1 
 1


1-



 
2 
 -

! 
!
.< 






.
2
 !2 




 
 
 1

2 "
"
 

# $%&'()
"
*&%+


,
- .

 !  
 1

2 "
"
 

# $/&*0)
"
*&**
  2 


"!
 !!.
- 
2
1-


 




"



-   

1- 
"

 !
23 !

!!

.
 2 







,,<

 

 1


1-




! 




1
! 
 - .
 2 
 " 

-!

2




 

 
1-
 1
 

2 1


(



" 
 11
-!

 

2


,  .
"  
 2 




 
"
3 !
-

" 
2.

(
1
 5 !.
"


,1
1

1

 

"  
 "

 


 
"
 2! 
-!
.
-

 

!
-!
1 


  


"
 5
2  .
 "

 

 2$! 

E

"

 
'


 1 

"



  !


  $ A

FF 6

"


 .
 5
!. 
1 1-
 
2
"

.
!!

2
 1

- 

!



 

! !1

  2!

@
!
"
 

! !1


 2!



 
2
- 
2.

!<


"

" .

 " 


2 -


- 
! 
" 
@
!
"
- <!$- 
2.
" .

 
  !
"
 !
 

! 
  
"  ! " .



-
2 ? 

 6

 
2



!1  

"

"

  
- 
 

 


<91 <4
 

2
1
 1



6

"
! !
"
 5
1-
 



  
"
 
 .
2 
 !

#9<:1-.

  <6-

 .
1
9 


!

 
!  
 2 





 
 !
 
 


2! 
1 1

 5
2 
 


 .
 5
!. 
1
1-
 
2
"

.
!!

2  1

-  

!



!
"

 
 1


 2!




 
2
- 
2.
 !<


"

" .

 " 

 2$! 



!   


2
2 
"

 
" .


6 .
  2 



 
!



!

 
 

2



# "

1

  2$! 

 1

!!.
- .
 2 




 " 
 2$! 


-
1-


2
  
-

2 "

"

  
- 
 

 
 
- 

  
! !!.
- 

1


-

"

 2.





"
 2$! 


-  .

 2 





-!

2




"  
"

(

 
*&%/

2

2
?  


1 
"


"
 
-
! D

 

 
 
 
!   1

2 "
"
 %$
 2 





.
!  
"


23 ! 1

 !!
- 

!!



! 



- 
1
2 
1-


"

 = !

"

"


 

1-

!!


 

!

"
''
"


"
1-




! 






"!

"





"
 !
 1

!!
-
#
 1
-

 ! 23 !

1
 "

 




-  

2


 !"!.
 




2 
-
1 
-! 
 

 1


1-
" 


 "

1-
" 


=  .
*&&


-!

 
!

-
"

-



2



 








2


 
2.

! 




" 

!
2
 !2 

 1
 .



 


 !
23 !  
2.
 
"
 



 2

 -
"

 


:

"  
 2 

 !
!



 

 
*&%%


 5
2  -
 


(

 
*&%/

-

- 

2


" 

 
*&%+

*&**
-!


1.

 
1


2
 


2

2
  

1 
"
 .

! @

 
 
"

 


   
 
" 
2.





 1 6

-
 
  


 
!

>.

-
.
1$ 
!!
- 
1
 

2 1-
2 1


"
 2$! 

"
 
'

 !.

- 
 2$! 

"
 
'


2 1
 
2 ! 



!
 
"


"
 1


1
"

!!
- 

!!


  
"

 
"

! 


- 
-



2


 

! .
1- 1



1$ 
!!
- 
1
 1-
1
 1





2


! -
  = !

"

"


"
*C


"

''
"






"
 
"
 
 2$! 

"
  '


"


"
23 !
 1

1
 
!!

- 

!!


23 !
 
2.
 
!  
"
 


 2

 1

 !
23 !
 1

 2$! 

"

 
'

  !


2


  
"
 
 2$! 
-  -

 ? 






"

 
2
"

.
!!

2

  1

-  

!

:-


!

   
 
!

2


 
:-



  !


 .

 


 
! 1

1 1

23 !
"
 
" .


!

 
.


 
!

!
-!
 
 

 " 
! 

>.


1-
 
2
"

.
!!

2
 !.


 
2
!!

2
 1

-  

! 

  
"



1-
 1
- 
-


-
 

=  .
"

%%
"



%(
"





!
2



1-

 !!

2
" 

-!

 -


"
.
*&&

 
"


!
"

-  

!

 !!


!






 


!
2 ! 




  
"
 
! 
- 
- 


1


! 

-



 
2

 < ,,



!
2


 
! 
  




"
 !

"



"

 5
2 


"

2


 5
2 
- 

(
-
!



; .
*&%/
# $%&'()
"
*&%+
- " 
2.

 

"
2


 
*&%+
@
  !
!



-


!

 !
!


2 

  

2
.

1 <!






3 "!
"
 .
"

=
.



"1

 
 
"

 !



# $/&*0)
"
*&**

!!

-
" 

 
*&**
" 

"
 
 1
 
"

!

 

2


 "

! 




"
 !
!


-!
 

  *&%%
2 

 .
"
 

 = 


2
 


2

2
  


1 
"
 .

! " 
 1
 
"

 

  1



 
 




"

 
 , =.
- 
 
!
**'
"

 
"
@ "
 "

!


 

 
"




 2.

 

.  .  *

!

$41516 /
















  # 
 ,1  <4 # 
 2  <4