Banni Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab
! "
#
$%&'&( ))** +(, $ ,-. )/
0&&( )((**))(12.**3/&-,/%14 " .(((/& )(((4 ! 0&&(&-,/%1&,*/.()(/&%4
( 5( /(/&(6/761,,(6 (&))** 5 5-(&(,8,*6//* 6 ,-.6 (&()/ & )( ))* )(((/ .2 $%& 1 $(,)/ (,(&/%&-,/%17/ (/(// 9
" !)/.2&//*$,/%6 */&(6 3&(.2 ))** $%& 3 7/ ( ),&.*,/($! " 63&())** (,37/ ( ),&.* ,/( $ ! " (/ 3& $ !: 37(6.&&))**3(/,/(%*1)(1 / )2 # ;< & / /,* )21 ,/(%,(&((%(,1)(1(2( & )(, 3 1 & 1 5/=*., 1/.(&(&//61/$;$
"
$>($%&6 $ $&&> ? " "
63&(&/&) & 1 @A B6 5/ =*6 3& ((/ )( (1 )(7 )(16/&&2(7.(&(/&**(1((// (/)(*2 */(.(&( 16%/.,9#;992(63& ,//*.,(3(>6&7/3/,%&( **&1( 1((/ .(&( ,/ > *C,( **2 / & ? " "
.,: 563&&1.>7**%/(&/ ( ,(/3( 7**% ( /% & /1 3(> (1 7**% &,**(.2*6&3&$%& 1$(,)/ (, ( &/6 3& 3( * *.,(( / 11 /% & 3(> **%***C,(63(%())*%3&&.(&( 1(& &,63&(*.($%&(.$%&3((%&1 &13&*6$%&/&)&3 (,1/&.(&(
1**&%(,// (,,%&&*/&.&(163&( $%&3/&* &((6$%&/ (,( /(%%% 1(1(&&,.(,%&&1())*2% &((,(/3( (&(3% 1&(6.&&1( 32(1&)3&*2%&&2&7,%&* 16 &3/1%&13&,2((%(/%&(**%** *C,( ,(&(/&&/*.($%&>/ 1&3& &/&))/3&&&*/&&(*(,/>*C,((1 $%&/ (,//2*1>*C,((1&1 ,(&( / & 3&* 2% 6 1 // &((6 *.( $%& (1/*3/($%&6$()&&7**%63&(1/.,& ,(( & )* &(,%& *)& & . ,& 16(,C@A ;
B3& *$((%(
!
.,# :# 5 ()(,C6 @A ;"B3((//.2 $1(>$%& ( 1)*% & C, )(/% @A B6 & &//./2 1()1(1A1 *)()(/ (,%&)*A &)<1(1A1&//./2 1 3 /,/ .2 0<# ( &,)/( $%&6 7* )*6 >/( " "
63&,/&**3%-,( < D&(3.*,&,)(&*(*,(&(%&(< (1,))()(#1.*3&(%&&,*/(- 3 1A# 1 &(.*,&,3)(&*((1((/ 1/*)( 1.*3&*&,*/(-/&,3!1A : 1 &(A *,/% 3**6 (. / (*% 3( &*&2 *,% *(2A / ( *,/% )*,( 3( &*&2 )((/,1 3 &*&2 / &( 3 )* *,( / & (( ,( 3 &7%%(,2**3)&/&((23&(1./ =/ &&(31)2/(%&/3&7%.*/ .
(/>,** 3&*&2 1**6*(%6*7(6)*//>/23(( &1* *2 .*//( 3 1)2 / &*&2 / & * 3(3**//&(3.*/%&*/ .
! ( 3 */ % & )( ))** )(7 6 )( (1 A1% 0<# ( &,)/( $%&F 0< $ $,(/( $%& / 0< " $;$ $>( $%&6 3& /)/3&(%(/&7%((/,.2&13**&( 3 (1* ,(6 & )(, A1/ 0<? 5/ =*6
:
.(&( & // 16 3& ((/ & (*( 7( 1%7*/%&((/%& (*,)(,7/6&1.& &,/3(((//,/($!
( &23(),**& (1% (,1 ))(% % &1 & )(, 7/ &2//&)(,/)*//*1)* &( /6 & ,/ A1/ 0< *3/( $%& 8( $%& (%%&(,%&&7/((/6*(/(*,( (,(//%&&)(,&..*)(7&%,*& )( ))** .2/ 2 (.* /,. / (/%*2 7/ //&161/.7 ( & ,(6 *(/ ,* ( & ))** & 7&1*2(%,/&/)/2<3 0<:*.($%&& ,(/&*6&((6&(*21 0<?5/=*6.(&( &//63&&&.(*/,).
2&(*,(7& ))** (%,/&&1 0<?5/=*& (/3/&&)(&1,((/,.,* $**,(&(6)(&1/*()(6&(3.*/%F&((6& 1(,%/&.* ,(&((%,/& ,*).*&1/1,%1,(/(6.,3&(/& 3,// &,6.6),&.*,/( $! : &&(&/6*(/,*(&()/<$& (%,/ & & )( 0<? 5/ =* & 1 ,(( ,(*6&&/)/%()&**2.
#
$,&7/((.(/.2&1/*7//)/.2 0<#( &,)/($%& 5(&5/=*((*&//6 (/(/&16.,&112.(,G/ 3&**1(,&&1/)/3 * (%,/ & 0<: *.( $%& &,(/6 ., & & /1/ & (<A1&&&%71&)*/&&& 1)(1/3&&,/ &,6&&*.($%&&,(/ &*.,/%&)(, 7%&(/*(/,*(&)(*%&63/ /21(&)())* 0<?5/=*&&.(&( 1.,: 5 ? " "
/)/&,/ (, ,%& &*/ & .(&( (1 & (16 3&( $%& 3/ & * &((6.&&,//(%%/&.(&((1(& &,/&(3&1(&))*2%&((,(/3( & .,&11/.($;$ $>($%& ? " " 6 (,C3& *$((%( .,9 # 5 /& 3*/%/.,
5 5%&(.26&&( 1*63&&3((//3&3&,())(A1*2& /&6&(*&&))**&.*(*21/
0<:*.($%&3&*))(%&3<.A/1/ &1)*F&%,(A (7(2113 &))* / & & & 1)(1/ 3& & ,/ / & 5&/($%&6)(,(6&,*/&5,>&($%& $ ,-. * /1/ & 5&/( $%&6 3& & .(,%&&1&,(/2 73&/6&1 *.($%&&&(1/5/=*.,&,((63&&3
9
&16..*7/6/1/*2&&*/3&&,/ ,(&* &1 0<?5/=*6.(&(&//6 *( / %(* & & 3 .& & ))** / & (, 11.*G/&//63&($%&3/&* 0<# ( &,)/($%&&/,/)<1(1&//./2
1 " "
**26 & /)/ & & , /& 3** . %7((7%()(&&1*A1( ()()( &&1*A1(A 6&)/&&,/&3/, 77%*/(%&>(,*%,//(/(63&&3 ,,/&(/(2,(,( ,(&(/)/ &)3,/&7(&// *)(7/& )1(1()(A
/)/&&*3(3**/ /&(3.*/%&* &((6&)(, (26 /)/ .2 0<? 5/ =*6 .(&( & //6 / ((.(/.2&1/*7/%7.2 0<#( &,)/($%& (&(&&*3(3**3&&,*/.).**2 ,3%&1(/)/.2&3 0//21(&(%,1&&. .*/%6 & /& ,*/ . ,/ )( & )(, (2 3%* &&1*A1(&(,*/,/&.2) &(A(*-,(23&&,*/)(7,%-,(2.22&() ( .*, 3) & & * 3( 3** ((.( & 1 0?5/=*3&/)/&3/&* 3&* (,,%&&*/&(1 $,&(*12..(,&/ / *2 ( & ( & 0? 5/ =* .(&( & //
&(7/((/&3&5/=*31*3(/ &))** &)(5/=*&)*,(( ./,./& 3*/%/3&3&,(&**%/,(( &,%& 0:*.($%&//,))(&)(,&., /1/&(A1&%7%&)(7,1 / & & & / 1)(1 3& & ,/ &((6 0: *.($%&&,(/&*(&(&&3&2< 3.,(&(&&(/*13&&,/ &((6 3 / & & 1 %7 .2 *.( $%& & )* 3&&&)&/.%7/&&&&*/3&& ,/&3&&&.37(.
2&,/ 0*//21(&(%,1&&))** (*.*.7/(),&.*,/($! : &/&))**,//%&6.,/* &(1((//,/($!
!( &)(, 3 & . ,%%/ & & /& 3 ,// ( & %( &((6 & - ( .& & ))** (*2 11.*G% & // / ,.C,*2 >% & * .2 3% & *6/3((2(((),&.*,/( $! : 0/&&12 0<?5/=*6.(&(& // & (*.* / (,3(&2 36 3&& )( & //&.(%&*2>/(.2&*(/(* ,( 0//&&/%((//.2&*(/(*,( ,((12**%*2(((%,*(2 &(7/&.>
H
/((,(/%&&)(,&.,,* )(7%%&,/.2/2(.*/,. C,*26&)())*/1/ @5
B @=$==B
! "
# +1*; ,*