← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21182/2021allowed

Simerjit Kaur v. State Of Punjab And Others

2022-04-18Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl23 pages



   



   

!"!

# $ %&% % 

   

  

 % '''&



   

  

  

  

    

    !

" #$     %%&''(&%&)&'

 *  +     %%&,,,-%&)&'

 "

.



* +

 

   /                 -(&

  0    0   12  '3   '4 )& &)&&' 0    &'

 &5     * 0 #     

'5(, 7  86* 

9:

       *       #

   # #   0 # "  $    # 

0 #

/   

%%&''(&%&)&'     # 

     0 ; +# 7

  12  '3   '4 )& &)&':

     

%%&,,,-%&)&'    # 

   <  0 7

  12  '3   '4 )& &)&':

=       

%%&''(&%&)&'

 #  0     "            "  2                 #        12 

         0    "      0 ; +#  ', )- &))&

       0         

 >//    + > #   *

$ "



*  /  /  #    "0             0   2                  6   #          

   '- )& &)&'

             $ ! ?        #     0 0      0 0      

  '4 )& &)&'

        

        "        

         0    =    /  *  /  /

   

 #

"0           #            0        0 

        0     0  #         0            2    

(        @                           A         =                   0

    

      2         #  0   0 0    B        0  #

             0  =   5   0  #            "0 @   00 B     #       0 #        

 #              /    @ 

          0  (                '4 )& &)&'

 (')             "0   $

     0  +  0  <  0 7       %%&,,,-%&)&':

2     

0       !

    #   0 20 0 ?    0 7  (:

2  2 0 7  C:

       7  5:

      0 #          <  0    "0    $     2

                2   

   +  0     0  

  0 ; +#  <  0        2

 #            "   B    "0              

&             0 0  

$%-3%

%(4()    2

     

       #                 

/       "0    $  



             ), )4 &)&'   #    .

0    

     #     0 ; +#         B

B  %4     2                   2          0 ; +#  <  0   #       12      0     #  4)) 0            #     ')4)      *   /  !"   !

" 0 

 2             0 ;

+#   0       )3 ), &)&' 7 B  %,:

   &  -    <  0   0

    )4 )4 &)&'     

   0   & ,  %%&,,-%&)&'

0           2    0                0         0 0     3  5 2                   0  )& )C &)&'

  $                     'C4

        2             0 ; +#  <  0            

%%4)5)&%&)&'

%

'

%44&C4%&)&'

   -45

 0   0       12  @      0 

              2           0  0    #     0 

   #        )C )- &)&&    

               0 ; +#  <  0  0     2                                $         )& )4 &)&&       

/  0  @         'C )4 &)&&   'C )4 &)&&

       0   *    .

0

     

/  0           *    .

0

   

              &( )4 &)&&

 0                        0           #         2  

#  #    0     12    

#  0 #     

  $ 

 20 

           0   <D     2   

   ! "# $%& '( "

!&   )*+*+)  ),-            0  &C     0         8   0         0      9 2                @          #  0 

             

)   #    0                         0            0 0      #  12         2    0     #     !                   0  !             # #  #      0  0

 

     

 #   &3 )C &)&'                 0  (  ''   #   2           0  (       #     @ #      #       0 # 

   <  0  0            <  0  



   0                    #  0

/  0  #  0          0      12              

       #  0       0                <  0  %

   0 ; +# 2        $

         

 

 

 

   0 ; +#

 <  0      "0    $  

  

/  0      #               0  

*            

 

 

 #     !

 /  *  /  /                 

   

      C  5 # "        !

 /  *  /  /           #                  #      #   2  0  ''              0 ; +#   0     &( ), &)&) )5 )3 &)&'

 @ #           2         B  %&A/   @ #          

   <  0              12  @     0                 " #     

  2           @ #      #  0  0

       

 #   '3 )3 &)&':

!                

     12           0    0 !

  

0            2           0  0      #     

 "  #    0      12 0 #

  #        2        

     *    .

0

   &( )4 &)&&   

/                   2          0 ; +#  <  0      

%%4)5)&%&)&'

%% 44&C4%&)&'  #    -45

 0   0    

/   0     #           #  *    .

0

     

/  0       #  $     0       /       %  

            

                   

          



                 

       

              

     !!    

   

 " #

$ %  "  ! !            

     !!    

   

 &  &  '         

    $

    

      



            (  )    * %          %   +, -.

.-.+

             #

  /                   

      

       

     0    $

          

       ''% % 

      1              

  

         

    

        

   

+2 -.

.-.+  

 -34+- %(            

   $   # % 

              5 (      6    )7(8(822.928.-.+:

+   

  5    /  7   5 5    

 )     %  

    

  



            

        $ 



  # %    5

 )

      

           

       5 (  

 

      

     6  :       5

   

  )    %     $          5

               

%#8,;8')8323-     $  

  

                       

  

  5

                  



               ))!

 

   $   # %  '            -< -2 .-.+   

  

           



!      0  '0  %8, )  

                  -.

-2 .-..  

        

    

      

         =           6   : %   

            

      

  ..

-9 .-.+      

  

      

    

           2     

     

        



  $         

      >57  =            >57

           ++4,3 %(         >57          !   "

 !

  $  %  $   '   

 +-42- %(  

     

       



       >57       .- +- 7  ..

27?            -34+-

       $          $   -34+-    # %  

 5  

     

    >57                     

 

     

         

    

    

       >57                 

   

       

       $

           5                    

   

     

  ,.

  *"% '

 

       

    ,.

  *"% '

     

    

      

            $        

       >57  

    $            34+-  +-42- %(         

  ,.

  *"% '

    =   

     

 5        

           $               

      

   

        

   

   

              

         

       

       

  #     )

  .% '(!&  '/  0

..   ! "# 1'%    )*+)2  & '. )24,

   

      

   

        $       

 

     

                  

  

 2--            

   5      

          $       

 

 

 

     

           

    

  

  #    )



  -.

-3 .-.+   55--*65 )*)+     7 '

&0

'

&  !"#1'%

'(!& & 0 $"/    ! "# 1'%    )*)+8  & '. 82* 9&'  '/  0     ! "# 1'%    )*)+)  & '. 684  

 .3 -.

.-.-   556*)25)*)*     9 :

'(!& '/ 0 9   !"#1'%  

           

  

                             

        

     +2 -.

.-.+     

            

  $   $             @@ @ @

@

!  )

   

      @ @@

 @ 5                  

     5              

         

        !!    

   

 " #

$ %  "   ! !          !! !   

   

 &  &  '  >                           

      #

  /                 

                

          

          

     

 ! %  "   ! !  

   ''%  5           

 

        

            

     % 3     )7(8(82-A-.8.-.+        @

@ @ @

@  3:@ !@ @+2 @-.

.-.+@  @@

@3 +-@  @   @@@$ @ @#@% @

@   @)@ @ @@ @ @ @5@(   @@  @ @@@  @@ @@

@           $  '     ('  %

  

  5    /  7@  @ 5 @ 5 @  @   @% @@ @

@ 



      @ @ @      $ 



  #@% @ @@5

@) '   

       

      



     5 (   

 

'@@@  @@ @ @@@

 @ @ @ 5

@ )@ @ @ 

@  @ @  )  @  @ @% @ @ $@ @@0 

@@$ @@

@@ @ @@  @ @  @ @@@ @@ @ @@  @ @ @   @7  @*

%#8,;8')8323-@@

@ 5

@)@ @ @@  @@ @ @ @ @  @  @ @ @ 

@  '

  

    ))! ) 

   $ 

 # %  '                -< -2 .-.+     )

 '    

  

  

      '

     -< -2 .-.+@ @0@ @@'0 @%8, ?@ '  

  

 

      

       -34+- %(  +2 -.

.-.+        

        

           $ 

 # %  

        7 

%#8,;8')8323- 5    

    

  7   5    /  5 5       %         5

                     5

 5      

 )      %         

                 

     $           

    5

   $    0    $    

  

       

  5

 5               

   ))!  

   $   # % '0  %8,     -< -2 .-.+        

               

        ))! 

  !   

   

     ))! 

    # %  $         !

   

        

     

5 7   5  5       

( %                 +2 -.

.-.+  +, -.

.-.+    ..

-9 .-.+     )

 '  '

  #     )

    -.

-2 .-..        ))!

  

   )

  +9 -2 .-..

/ +9 -2 .-..@@

 @ @@48 %4@ ( @ @)@ @'

@  ( @"  @@'

@ @@  @  )77@*

++-,@ @.-.+@)7(8(8.++3.@ @.-.+ )7(8(82-A-.@ @.-.+

( @ $@  @'

@ @( @"

 @  '

@ @@  @ @)77@*

+-,9@ @ .-.+@)7(8(8.<<<,@ @.-.+@@)7(8(822.92@ .-.+

( @(  $@B @"'@% 

( @  @# @'

@ @( @ %  @ # @'

@ @#@% @) 

CCCC / -.

-2 .-.. 

  #     )

  @ @@@

 @ 48 !@@@@$@ @

@  @

 

 

           

 

    

      

        =           6   : %      

           (' 6   : 

@ @@

$@  @ /    

      

             

 +2 -.

.-.+  +- 2- % (   "

  $ 7  '   ))! 

  # %  ' 

      



  $  +2 -.

.-.+  3 +- % (    $ @



@ @#@% @'  @ !   ))! 

     !  )

  -< -2 .-.+    !      



@@@ @@

@ @ '

@ @+9 -2 .-..

@ ( @-.@.-..@ 6" %'&@5#':

B  @+@ BD" ?

5         

    # %   

  ))! 

   % " !        # %       

&

    B   )

 '   -< -2 .-.+ @ 5       

                  +2 -.

.-.+  +-42- % (   !8%  "

  $ 7  '   



  $  +2 -.

.-.+  -3 +- %(    $ 



  # %  '  5   

        $      

8       "      B  '  !

              "      B  '     

8  ))! 

  @  @ @ 48 6 :  7     )

      

    )7(8(82-A-.

 .-.+ E       

   %     )7(8(8.++3.8.-.+ E    &  

  %    

 8  /  "  F   B  '  ! 

    ..

-2 .-..

!

        )

    

  

   )

      

  

 

        

  

    "      B  '       

                "     @B @ @@@ @  G 6 : !       

            

          

     "      B  '  ., -2 .-..  ++4-- '

( ! 

    

                 7   5 )5'  '     %   )   )5'  '   5    5  )5'  ' 

      "      B  '   ., -2 .-..  ++4-- '

(

!       $     

8   @ @@ @G 6 :         # %  )  !

 '     % "     



    % "     "      B  ' @ @., -2 .-..@@++4--@'

(G@ :  "      B  '   =    @))!@

@ @., -2 .-..@ @@ @ @@  

'

          

  

     

     6 :  

                                

 

     $  +2 -.

.-..+  -34+- % (    $ 



  # %  '        ))!@

@

@ @ G : 5             "      B  '     ))! 

  ., -2 .-..   "     B      

        ))! 

     

  

                ))! 

      ! "      B  '   =    ))! 

      

8      2- -2 .-..             @@ @

@ @ @)

@  @-, -, .-..

@ '

  -, -, .-..         "  @ @B @' 

/ 1 7        

     

  "      B  '     

  @  

' 

           

 @ 

+4*8)*))    ;$ < 5             .3 -2 .-..       "      B  '  !            

 

48 5        ))! 



                % ( H$  '

            

   B   B  &$ '

  0

      '



    

    % #  '



 # %  '         '   % 

% 

     5  

  ))!

  +2 .-.+

 $ 



       $            I ))! 

      

 J/

) J $ 



  # %        @@@

@3 -3@% (@

@ @ @  @@@ @

@ @$@ @@$ 

    

    

          

 

    

    ))! 

       $      

   



      

)

  

                       

         $ 



  # %  '              

!@ @ 

@ 34++42A@ % (@ @ 

@  



@@@ @  @ @0 @  '               

  

                  

        

    

           $    ))! 

 D  

   

         $   $      

    $ 





 # %   > @ @ 

@ 3 +2@ % ( @   @  @  @  @

@  @ $  @ @   @ @@

@ @$@ @@$ @ @ @ @@ @ @ @ @   ' 

 

          !   ))!

       J%!HJ 6

:                 @ 

@ 3 .;

% ( @@

@ @@ @ @0 @  @!@

       

    

  

                

       >           

  



   

   

       @ @ $@@ @ @))!@



!       ))! 

               

 

     $  +2 .

.-.+  3 +- % (

   $ 



  # %  '    ))! 

 

     )

   "  & @   @ @ @#@% @'  ?

* '  

  

  

     



 ))! 

     $            

     

     

             $  +2 -.

.-.+  34+- %(                

 -34-3 %(   $ 



  # %  



          

   $   $   

                 

                     -34+- %(         $      

    

     5            34++42A %(  

          0     

         

                5



            

        0    >   

   

     

 34+2 %(        

   $           

  $   $                   ))! 

        .; % (   

         0   

 

                    

           

             

     $

  )    %            '



        

 

                             

      

       

   

( 

   

    

             

  +-42- %(         >57 6'0  %8+: 

 

2          34+- 

      

                               $     $   # %              

   



      )

          @

@@

@ @@)



 5            

 @ @@  @  @ @@

@ @ 

     

  ?   

    (   '  )     %

   )7(8(8.++3.8.-.+        

 

 

      2         2--       

  

  ?

!      @@2@ @@  @ @

@  "

    2--       

@   

        

    $ 

       

    

 

       

 6      :               +2 -.

.-.+@@5@7@  ?

5        

  # 

   )

      $         

         

 

    @@

@ ?

               0             0 ; +#

 <  0   #     #        0 ; +# 0          

 #    0            =   5  /  *  /  /       0         0 ; +#  <  0      "0   $     '4 )& &)&'

 (')       /                 #  *    .

0

         0  (   0      

%%4)5)&%&)&' 7        0      0  (    :

  

+         0

       

     0                 # 12@ 

/             0  (                0  (    

     &( )4 &)&&   #  *    .

0



             % : 2  0  (         '4 )& &)&'

  )( ') 

   0 ; +#      "0   $     

0  +  0   2 

 <  0    0    

2 &( )4 &)&&    0 

/  0  @     ( )( 

            " "0  $  

:2  0  (          20 0 ?    0

2  2 0   ;

          0 #   

   0 ; +#

 <  0  2

      &( )4 &)&&         (''45 

        00    B 

/               2

 :2  0  (              0 ; +#  <  0        2

<      ;

     "   B    "0     "                0 ; +#       2

2     &( )4 &)&&          ('4

         "     0       "    "0

  (&3 

      00    B  2               0  0    

    ;

          00    B                       0 ;+# <    0             0        )C )- &)&&

     

                  1    

                     0      3  5        0     12 /   0      0      * 

.

0  0 /     0     #         @ #  7 B  %&A/:        





   <  0     #      #               )3 ), &)&'

  0 # 

     0 ; +#   #            

   0 ; +#  <  0 #               

/  0  @     0 0            0  ''          

       0 #    

     0  ''   #  #   

  0 @                 B   #       #     

              0         # 

       

 

 #     @ 0      # 

   12                     #      0    #  

  

2     

  #  <D      

 7  :            

             9 2     0 # #0     0@                

     '

 .+            

   ?

2  

           

  $         )& )C &)&'         

   'C4

        ?

         0     / @            "0     

                     0 0 0        0 ; +# <  0  12  @       0   #   3  5

    0                   0 #  

  $ 

 20 

     00       /    0          0                

 <

0   #             

                                            

   0      12   '3   '4 )& &)&&' 0    &'

 &5 6* 

       *           

  $ 

 20  / 0 0       0 0    12         0    A      0 0 0 #  /

  $ 

 20      0 #             0    #     0      12       / *  

  $ 

 20     "   12   0 0    

  $ 

 20      0 0             0   

(  0 0    

  $ 

 20      #       0 0      12

   

,- ./ 

 23!4 5  " @&  = "0A  EA6 =  EA6