High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2081/2025dismissed

Bikram Singh v. Mohinder Pal

2025-09-09Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

!" # $ %

"& #' (& #

)!&" "'*+&,* "(

!"*+&,*'!-""

(&( ." / , ( ! " &&0(&12"+((''+%" 2*#" * &! " ((' '& ! " , && (&12" *#" ." (&'&' &

"& #'*%& ( %& 3 " 4 #%51 6 1 +* 0* ! , " (

!" "(

&7+ 4/"('

%''2 & 1& " , (* %& '

('8* "& 2&*#" "

& 7" && ( / ." %( - " "

(&'&' & - - '&' & " &&

92] ( *1!- " '

('8:- ,

&"''""(%&"&('8"&1 %%''2 ( & 12 " - '2 (

,& ; : " & (* " && ( "& '' " 8'%, " " (& &+( " (&'&' &*&%"

! &"&1!,"( 3 : - ,

& " " &&( "& 1 12 " ( < = ( " 3 -" > " 8! ( & , 2 "

2 ." 2 & 0."( -&1

; 3; %' -""* " ,(-'& 0 : " - * ( ' 2 15

! &! 1'2*

& ' ' * - & * - && 12 " ( ""-"&&( * ",! " % & ?% ,&

&& 0 @* "-, * && "

'"( '&' & & 1- " & "

(&'&' &." ( && ; - & 1 ''!'* %'' & ,& +, ! & (2 - &&:-,

&"2 -(&*"- &2(2" " ('&! " ( * " ''-! %- &12"

93] B C"" '"( '&' & & 81-"( D #+ :%E( ,&*-"" (& '1'15& "&&( D #+ 3 C"" " 5 ((' 1'D # 0 C"" (('"'&" ' "% D # 'F G # '&" (,,& ; $& && * " ''-& " , ( "'&! " " '"( & & "& 1 ( ,& : - % " "'& " " '"("&1&&12"( * " - !"( ,' & " & '"( "& 1 ( ,& & "& 1 %& " " ( -

* % " (( %2 & ,& 1 !

& (2 "

."(('(

&!"& ,*- &&,& &&0(&12"+(('' +%" 2*'&!"'!" ,( :"," &' &%' "( I &%' "( "%1&" 1"% ",!

,'2

&''-!",( ."' !% &""( -''! (2 " & " %& " %* " % "%'& ", (& " I & %'* -"'

!"(%!& *"%1&"" %1' : %(( " * ' & %' " ( " ('& ' %( "

94] 5%&! ""& "&" $J, &" 2&" * 0 3GK"?% $# #' * 0G 3G K " C&"- $ = )!&1 :&% ' ( * 00K '5 !" $ % "& !" - & " *

30K + 5 !" & " $ +'5 !" * 0;K#%51 A& % ( , I& "&! " $

%&" , & " *0 0 ,'0; # * ' & %' " (& & " %1& " " ''!'2 " (%!& " %1 " " '"( &&"&1&&*" -2 !( ,' &% " *" - !,!2(( %2 (2 :%(( " * " " ('& ' %( " 5%&!

= "( )-'' $ 5& #' J%(*

K# $ " !"&" *

3;K % " %&" $$" &*0 G & " 5%&! " @/1' %( % ,"2 & 12 I $ # ,"

& " *

; G 3 & +" J%( $ $ ?% *

3 ;3 : ", & &" %1 & 12 ' & %' "(

&, !" "*-%'&1 (( "'!'(

95] 3 :-'''&"" '"('&' & & &&* " -%'& 1 ( ,' " 5%&! "C&"- %( :% " -'''&" &' %" '"(* " '"( '&' & & ( ,&&"%&1

* % " (( %2 &1!

& (2

& '2 , -%'& ''- "

! & 1 & " 5%&! & " "%

!" #$% & '( 0 * -" * -"'

! " " 5%&! ,L

) )*% "%+,("( )()'% 3 ;3 K "%

! ()'% " (- & .

, 0 ;* '*("% ()'% " % ) !

0 0* " & "* & " & ( '- & "'&%& B; * " '"( '&'&2 & "1&&*" *"( "& ! " !" '' %( " " & !

(( %2(2"

$ 2 !"'2* ' &% "&"'&1%" 1%& 1'!"( ,'

* &2! " '"( '&'&2&* (, !"* & &" *''1 %("

$#"% *% / ) , '*

96] )*."+,( !, , +()*1221345 3 #)+5647 C" ( &&(%"'% & - "("'&' &&" %(* &" '"("'&' &&* %"** (,('

%' & C"" * %" -%'&1'&( 3" +* ( &12"@/1' %( %

$#"% *% / )8" %( * " 1 - & % % 5%&! '

& "

) )* % "%+,( 9" ( ) ()'% 3 ;3 & "

',1 ,*&" * ''- B: ", "%!"%''2 & & " %1&12"' &%' "( &",-" " &,& ." %1 " " ( - '& 12 " "'-'&&- 12" %( % " " C&"- %( -%'& 2 &'& & 1% -" "&(%" '"( &&8(&" ( & !"(2" : %" * 8 1 12 " -%'& 1 %' & -%'&

" ! 2"&"( + '' ! %' 12 " " , 2 " % ( %" , * , "

97] ( %" & " " & &2! "

'"(""1 &(2 " : -%'& ' 1 %5% " " -%'& ! " &! %1! '"( & " &( "

%"% -%'&'1% & %5%"'&' & (&." * : ", " 5! " !% &12"' &%'M ' '2* - "'& N" #' !" $ $52 ?% * 0 ;* E & !" $ 15 !"* G

G & )!&" !" $ " I'* 0 0* -"" ' %& ' %&

# , " !" & " * 3 3G* &&& ;F 0 , ! " " ( * "%!" &% ! " % !%* ' & %' " ( & !% ! & " &! H% "

'"('&' &&*:&(( ( ! "'2( 5%&" !""( ." (&'&' & ('& ' %( " '2( &&; 48"1+*( -""*" &&( "&''"" E 48"1+0 & + - ' ( &%& "- " " (& & "& ''&%("( (2 " ."( *&&"2&" =( "*1%&""-%& % & ?% & %& "& #' " (&

98] &A% " * % & ?% (( &+C&&(& 1% " '2 ( ",! (' 6& " %* - !"'2 "'& 12 " % " "

'"('&' &&&%'2&( ,&E1'2* " '"(-( ,&"1"% ! &

*1%12-2" ,&'&" &" *

&1, G

* " '"( '&' & & - ( ,&&" -'( ,&*- !"'2"'& " '%%'&1& &" "& 1 8%& 1- % & ?% & " ( & " - % ! & ." * '2 " && -& &&-%&"" ( -

*" '"( '&&"&1&&12"( & -%''2( ,&"" - '"('&' & &1-"( &% " "( -%&1

*" &-""

" '-

& " ( &! ( !

("* (( %2 & !" - &1!, ;

" % * " * & ''!'2

!%' 2''-!",(4," -* -'''&" ,'5% &* ! "%

&! &*"&! %& 1( , *'!-""%"&! 1&% 1& : ", ! "

%!" " 5%&! '& %( 12 ' & %' " ( : " "&

99]

"/ %( * " %(& " & ( "8( 2'."2- "'&1 12"'&!, &% &*" * H% %& G " .

# ( 2 +* -

& 1 %& " : - ' "'& " % ! & ' && %'& 1 &1' '' ' (% (*1% '&&- '' '(% ( ." &(% " '- '& &- " & 5%&!@-, *"-%'&"&" ( " "& 1 & " 1 " " ' &&* 1% " 1 " &"( ." 5%&! " " ?% %( * -%'&'"&"( " ( * " '"( '&' & & - &&* " * " 5%&! " " C&"- %( *-%'&1(('1': '5 !"/ %( *

"& 1 & 12 " *-"'!"( ,' + &

" " % * " * & " " +((''+%" 2*-""&

*&& 8."5%&!-%'&'"& "( *1!''2& A " *"" 5%&!-%'&'1(('1' "*(''2,-"'&'- "%15&%&"( &!( !

910] : ,- " 1,* " , ( %& 1 &,& & " * &!'2* && ." % &(& " ! 2 12 " ( (' " && 00 1

%&&"( *( %' #&! ((' * 2* "'' ' & &(& : ; & C"" ( != &N=E C"" ( 1'N=E